My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The 16 Best Makeup Subscription Boxes – 2021 Readers’ Choice

Erin Pullmann
ByErin PullmannJul 13, 2021 | 135 comments

Every year we ask you, our readers, to tell us your favorite subscription boxes. The results of the 2021 Readers’ Choice Awards are in! This list features our fellow subscription fanatics’ top choices for their makeup subscription boxes.

Are you a subscription box addict like us? Beauty and makeup subscription boxes give you the chance to expand your regimen without spending too much money. There’s really no better way to try new items from a variety of brands — particularly if you’re looking to upgrade your beauty game with all-natural, vegan, and cruelty-free products.

We asked our readers to select their favorite makeup subscription services for 2021. These boxes range in price, delivery frequency, and product focus, but they all offer exceptional value (especially when paired with promo links and coupon codes, which we’ve provided wherever possible). See our notes at the end for information about our selection process and tips for getting more from your subscription.

 

The 16 Makeup Subscription Boxes Our Readers Recommend Most

Here are the makeup subscription boxes that rank the highest among real subscribers:

1. BoxyCharm – Best Makeup Subscription Box For High-End Brands

Image from our review.

The Cost: $25.00 per month. Save with longer subscriptions. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use code SOFISHSTICATED, SEASTHEDAY or VITAMINSEA to get a free gift (up to $55 value!) and $10 online store credit .

What Our Readers Say:

Boxycharm is consistent for the best value in makeup products.” – Alice R

With a total of 5 full-sized products in each of their base boxes, BoxyCharm holds the crown as the best subscription box for makeup! If you fill out your profile just right, then you’ll be swimming in makeup products buy next year’s end!” – Kathleen Dougherty

I feel like they have a really good mix of brands that everyone has heard of but also new ones to me. Great inexpensive way to build a collection fast!” – Nikkiaust17

About the Box: BoxyCharm is our readers’ top pick for makeup subscription boxes of 2021. This subscription box is filled with high-end brands and at least 5 full-size products, valuing at $175 per box. Each delivery includes amazing cosmetics like eye shadow palettes, lip colors, and eyeliners, along with skincare products and beauty tools. 

Members also gain access to exclusive product deals and giveaways along with redeemable points that can be used in the Charm Shop. You can also discover creative ways to use products through the BoxyCharm social media community. That’s not a minor point — the welcoming community is a big part of the draw.

Is It Customizable? Through a program launched in late 2019, BoxyCharm subscribers get to choose one item in their upcoming box; the rest are customized based on your preferences (not all subscribers receive the same box).

Check out all of our BoxyCharm reviews and info to learn more. Shipping to the contiguous U.S. is free. Shipping to U.S. territories, Hawaii, Alaska, and Canada is $5.00.

 

2. Ipsy Glam Bag – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Value

Full Contents for the Ipsy Glam Bag December 2020

Image via our review.

The Cost: $12.00 per month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

I believe Ipsy sends out a good variety of makeup brands (sometimes full-size). In addition the retail value is always there for me!” – Shelly111

Ipsy gives great samples of products I’ve loved!” – Emily

I am a huge fan of the mixed, diverse products that ipsy provides!” – May

About the Box: The IPSY Glam Bag makeup subscription box boasts a satisfying haul at a gloriously low price point. This monthly sub delivers 5 deluxe samples of high-end and drugstore products. You’ll receive a combo of makeup and skincare selections along with bonus beauty tools based on your requests. 

That’s right: You choose exactly what type of products you’re interested in, then wait for your bag to be delivered right to your door. Start by filling out the IPSY beauty quiz, which collects basic information about your skin tone, beauty preferences, hair color, eye color, and current favorite brands. It’s a stress-free way to explore.

Is It Customizable? Ipsy Glam Bag allows subscribers to choose one item each month.

Check out our Ipsy reviews and Ipsy spoilers to learn more! Ships to the US and Canada.

 

3. Ipsy Glam Bag Plus – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Full-Size Products

Image from our review.

The Cost: $25.00 per month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

Ipsy Glam Bag Plus rocks in that you get to pick three of your items. I usually end up with makeup colors/tones that actually work for me.” – Katrina

“Ipsy Glam Bag Plus has probably hit most of my makeup likes” – TnT07

Ipsy and Ipsy Glam Bag are unbeatable in terms of value, variety and overall subscription quality. Amazing products, tons of customization without being overwhelming and outstanding customer service on every level whether it be making sure your bags meet your account preferences or always being on time each month or having great support teams to assist you immediately for any inquiry. This is a must-have subscription for makeup.” – Erin Alysse

About the Box: IPSY subscribers who want to punch up their collection of cosmetics can subscribe to the Glam Bag Plus. This next-tier makeup subscription box comes with 5 full-size products from well-known and up-and-coming brands — members get to handpick 3 of the items they receive. 

The IPSY Glam Bag Plus offers an even greater variety of palettes, lipsticks, brushes, and skincare selections. It also arrives in a stylish draw-string bag (chic!). Members also have the option to add-on up to 8 additional exclusive products per shipment. 

Is It Customizable? Yes, IPSY Glam Bag allows subscribers to choose three items each month.

Check out our IPSY reviews and IPSY spoilers to learn more! Ships to the U.S. and Canada.

 

4. Allure Beauty Box – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Great Selection

Allure Beauty box with makeup and skincare items

Image from our review.

The Cost: $23.00 per month. Save with a longer subscription. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Get a Free Mega Bundle when you sign up for a 12-month subscription! No coupon needed - just use this link.

What Our Readers Say:

I’ve tried a bunch of boxes but I keep coming back to Allure for the great product selection and the premium products.” – MSA Reader

Allure has some nice makeup items, even an eyeliner that wasn’t black and a red liquid lipstick that didn’t turn orange on me.” – SharonDK

They contain great products I use on the daily.” – Debra

About the Box: The Allure Beauty Box is a monthly beauty subscription offering a selection of deluxe samples and full-size products from well-known brands. Each box comes with at least 6 Allure-approved makeup and skincare products (3 samples and 3 full-sized), valued at over $100. 

The Allure Beauty Box is a great way to try the latest and greatest cosmetics, face masks, and skincare products at a great price. Members receive a newsletter with tips and tricks. You’ll even get access to exclusive limited-edition boxes, members-only virtual events, and product promo codes — this box has an incredible list of add-on perks, so if you’re serious about beauty, you’ll find plenty to love.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out all of our Allure Beauty Box reviews and info to learn more. Ships to the U.S. and Puerto Rico for free.

 

5. Birchbox – Best Makeup Subscription Box to Discover New Products

Full Contents for Birchbox December 2020

Image from our review

The Cost: $15.00 a month with free U.S. shipping. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

Still #1!!!” – WordHermit3t

Birchbox was my go-to on trying new products & expanding my knowledge base. I appreciate being able to set my profile to my specific interests & thereby, being able to curate the boxes to my preferences, areas of concern, etc. It makes the box much more personal.” – CaliGirlKatie

I have been with BIRCHBOX several years now and I honestly feel it has the best price and usually the products are a mix of sample size, deluxe size and full size. BIRCHBOX has something for everyone. If you set your profile up correctly then you will get products usually on your selections! The customer service team at BIRCHBOX is awesome!” – Michele H

About the Box: Love samples? So do we.

Each Birchbox delivery is packed with an amazing variety of samples, and that’s why this beauty box has been a reader favorite for years. This makeup subscription box is customizable, so you only receive products you’re interested in. Simply set your personal preferences in your beauty profile, and Birchbox will send 4-6 deluxe samples right to your door. 

This box contains a selection of haircare, makeup, bodycare, skincare, and fragrance products, along with tips on how to use and enjoy each item. When you find a sample you love, you can purchase the full-size product from the Birchbox store.

Is It Customizable? Birchbox customizes what you’ll receive each month based on your user profile, and beginning with your second box, you can choose one of your samples each month.

Check out all of our Birchbox reviews and info to learn more. Ships to the U.S., France, Spain, and the U.K.

 

6. The Box by Fashionsta – Best Makeup Subscription Box For More Than Makeup

Image from our review.

The Cost: $24.99 a month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

Amazing products curated , ABSOLUTELY AWESOME customer service. I Highly recommend to try it!” – Grace Leb

They always send unique items I haven’t seen before,” – DragonQueen

Love the variety and that they include a palette sometimes two every month! Very wearable colors especially of lippies,” – Bethany L

About the Box: The Box by Fashionsta is a monthly product exploration box with a positive mission. Each shipment comes with 5-7 full-size makeup and skincare products, valued at $120-$180 per box.

This makeup subscription box only offers the highest quality lipsticks, face masks, palettes, moisturizers, serums, and skincare products, with a firm focus on vegan and cruelty-free selections. Plus, each makeup box purchased helps an Los Angeles-based non-profit, so you can feel good while looking your best.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out all of our The Box by Fashionista reviews and info to learn more. Ships free worldwide.

 

7. GlossyBox – Best Makeup Subscription Box For a Mix of Brands

Image from our review.

The Cost: $21.00 per month. Save with an annual subscription. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use code PARADISE16 to get your first box for $16!

What Our Readers Say:

“Great products and great sizes,” – MSA Reader

About the Box: GlossyBox is a perfect makeup subscription box for anyone who loves all things beauty. Each delivery includes 5 curated products valued at $60 and comes hand-wrapped in the iconic bright pink box. You can expect to receive some of the absolute best makeup, skincare, fragrance, and haircare samples in every shipment, handpicked by GlossyBox beauty experts.

Members also collect GlossyCredit (usable for full-product orders) and gain access to limited-edition boxes, competitions, tutorials, and product guides.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out all of our GlossyBox reviews and info to learn more. Ships free to the U.S. and to Canada for $5.00.

 

8. Kinder Beauty – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Vegan Beauty

Image from our review.

The Cost: $25.00 per month with free shipping in the U.S. Save with a longer subscription. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use code MSA5 to get $5 off your subscription!

About the Box: The Kinder Beauty Box is a vegan makeup subscription box that lives up to its name. You’ll get curated monthly boxes (in eco-friendly packaging, of course) filled with at least $85 in cruelty-free makeup, skincare, haircare, and other beauty essentials.

None of the products contain talc, parabens, sulfates, EDTA, siloxanes, or anything else you can’t pronounce — and nothing you wouldn’t want to put on your body. The company also donates a portion of their proceeds to charities, so you can enjoy the excitement of a monthly makeup subscription while supporting some great causes.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out our Kinder Beauty reviews and Kinder Beauty spoilers to learn more. Ships to the U.S. and most countries around the world.

 

9. Tribe Beauty Box – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Aspiring Makeup Artists

Image via our review.

The Cost: $34.99 per box (sent every other month) + shipping. Save with a longer subscription. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use code MSA to save 10% off your first box!

What Our Readers Say:

Nothing better!” – MSA Reader

I love the indie brands that Tribe beauty box brings to its subscribers. It’s primarily makeup, which is what I desire in a beauty box.” – Sherry FL

About the Box: If you’re addicted to YouTube makeup tutorials (and really, who isn’t?) the Tribe Beauty Box is an excellent choice. Each bi-monthly option provides enough products to hone your skills — and since the curation focuses on indie and female-owned makeup brands, you’ll discover incredible new items over time. 

The box includes 4-5 full or deluxe size products, and unlike some of the other boxes on the list, you’ll know exactly what you’re getting: 1 face product, 1 tool, 1 eye product, 1 lip product and/or 1 skin prep product. You’ll still find plenty of surprises, of course, but Tribe Beauty Box always delivers everything you need to get to work.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out our Tribe Beauty Box reviews and Tribe Beauty Box spoilers to learn more about this subscription box! Ships to the US & worldwide.

 

10. NewBeauty TestTube – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Well-Curated Mix

Image from our review.

The Cost: $29.95 per box, plus $8.95 shipping. Ships every other month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

I love the variety I receive in these boxes,” – Joiseygirl

About the Box: Looking for a makeup subscription box that doesn’t skimp on the full-size products? You’ll want to check out NewBeauty TestTube. It’s one of our community’s favorites, and for good reason: Each bi-monthly box contains an editorially curated selection of beauty products from both well-known and indie brands. You’ll also get a NewBeauty Magazine subscription, which will help you stay informed about the latest industry trends.

The perks don’t stop there. Members receive exclusive offers with discounts on their favorites, and if you’re not sure whether TestTube is right for you, the company offers “legacy tubes” (boxes from previous months) for individual purchase.

Overall, this is an excellent way to explore beauty products without overspending. The every-other-month delivery schedule keeps your makeup kit stocked without overwhelming you with options.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out all of our NewBeauty TestTube reviews and details to learn more. Ships to the U.S.

11. Vegancuts Beauty Box – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Cruelty-Free Must-Haves

Image from our review.

The Cost: $24.95 a month. Save with a longer subscription. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use code MSA to save $5 off your first box!

About the Box: Here’s another great box for filling your makeup bag with clean, cruelty-free products. Each monthly Vegancuts box contains a mix of 4-7 full and deluxe sample-size beauty selections ranging from cosmetics to skincare to haircare. All items are free from toxic ingredients and animal byproducts

Vegancuts’ curators highlight indie brands, and each box is valued at $60-$100. With easy subscription management and stellar curation, this beauty subscription is well worth your attention. We’re also fans of the company’s Snack Box, which offers vegan-friendly foods at a great price.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out our Vegancuts Beauty Box reviews and info to learn more about this subscription box! Ships to the U.S. for free, to Canada for $6.95, and worldwide for $14.95.

 

12. Petit Vour – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Mix of All-Natural Products

Image from our review.

The Cost: $18.00 per month for the Petit Vour box or $25.00 per month for Petit Vour Plus for U.S. subscriptions. Shipping is free. Subscribe here!

About the Box: Petit Vour’s vegan beauty box has a simple goal: to bring cruelty-free products to a wide audience. When you sign up, you’ll answer some quick questions about your cosmetic preferences, which allows the service’s curators to find products that you’ll actually use. You’ll receive an assortment of 4 beauty products with a total value of over $50. In addition to cosmetics, Petit Vour’s makeup subscription box includes occasional body, haircare, and skincare products.

The price is fair — and you can get $4 in store credit every month for reviewing each box. It’s a simple way to find the best plant-based, cruelty-free products in the industry, and the rewards program allows you to order your favorites at a low rate.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out all of our Petit Vour reviews to learn more about this subscription box! Ships free worldwide. Subscription prices vary based on international location.

 

13. Look Fantastic Beauty Box – Best Makeup Subscription Box for Theme Lovers

Image via our review.

The Cost: $19.00 per month. Save with a longer subscription. Subscribe here!

About the Box: LookFantastic’s makeup subscription box — wait for it — looks fantastic. This U.K. company regularly teams up with top European brands to create boxes that celebrate a different theme each month. 

Members receive 6 handpicked items; cosmetics are regularly included, but LookFantastic also sends out haircare, skincare, and body products. You’ll also get an issue of Elle UK magazine. We appreciate how the company posts the retail value of each selection on their site; this makeup subscription offers an incredible overall value, and they’re not afraid to show off. It’s like a spa trip to the U.K. without ever leaving home (though you’ll have to make the fish and chips yourself). 

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication.

Check out our Look Fantastic Beauty Box reviews and info to learn more about this subscription box! Ships free to the U.S., U.K., Canada, and Australia. 

 

15. FabFitFun – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Variety

Image from our review

The Cost: $49.99 per box with free shipping. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

Great way to try new products that I wouldn’t otherwise choose to pay for unless I’ve tried it.” – Yvette Klotz

Still have to stick with my FabFitFun boxes. They are always the best.” – Joline Bradshaw

About the Box: FabFitFun is a lifestyle box that sends subscribers over $200 worth of full-size makeup and beauty products, accessories, and home decor items every season. Recent boxes have included makeup from brands like ILIA, Laura Geller, Phase Zero, Stila, Anastasia Beverly Hills and Beauty Bakerie.

The FabFitFun staff curates their boxes carefully, but they offer ample customization options, so you’ll never be disappointed. This subscription box ships seasonally, so you’ll receive a total of 4 boxes per year; we’d recommend trying a single box to make sure it’s your thing, then upgrading to the annual plan to save a bit of money. Subscribers also receive access to year-round flash sales, exclusive offers, and other perks.

Is It Customizable? Yes! Members get to select 3 or 5 items in each box depending on your subscription level, so you have the option to choose even more makeup items where possible if that’s what you’re looking for.

Check out all of our  FabFitFun reviews to learn more. Ships worldwide.

 

16. Cocotique – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Women of Color

Full Contents for Cocotique December 2020

Image from our review.

The Cost: $25.00 per month with free shipping. Subscribe here!

About the Box: Your makeup subscription box should suit your body, and that’s the appeal of Cocotique’s self-care box.  Each monthly shipment includes 5-8 beauty and lifestyle products for women of color.

Selections include both full-size and deluxe travel-size items. You’ll find a versatile assortment of makeup, hair care, skincare, fragrances, and nail care products, all of which are available in Cocotique’s store.

You’ll also receive a free reusable tote with each month’s box. At only $25 per month, it’s a bargain, and long-term subscriptions cut the cost further. Cocotique also operates a social responsibility program that highlights a different woman every month; the goal is to support women, promote self-care, and encourage people to “pay it forward.” Check out their site for more information.

Is It Customizable? No, not at the time of publication. However, full-size products are available through Cocotique’s web store, so subscription addicts can easily order more of their favorite selections.

Check out all of our Cocotique reviews and info to learn more. Ships free to the U.S.

 

17. Nourish Beauty Box – Best Makeup Subscription Box For Discovering Independent Clean Beauty Brands

Image from our review.

The Cost: $29.95 per month with free shipping. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use code NOURISHADDICT15 to get 15% off your purchase!

About the Box: Nourish Beauty Box is a natural beauty subscription box, and their emphasis on sustainable, skin-loving products provides plenty of value at an affordable rate. The site also allows shoppers to build their own boxes — ideal for giving a personalized gift or treating yourself to a few of your favorites.

The Nourish subscription beauty box includes 4 full-size vegan products per month. All selections are cruelty-free, and you won’t find any parabens or other potentially harmful additives in the ingredient list. The goal here is to deliver “toxin-free beauty,” and Nourish delivers.

We love that the company carefully curates each box, and their website includes detailed information about each brand to help shoppers make informed decisions. The modest monthly price makes this a great option for expanding your skincare regimen, and discounted rates are available for long-term orders.

Is It Customizable? The monthly box isn’t customizable, but shoppers can select a one-time customizable box. Choose from a selection of over 90 products, then enjoy luxurious skincare with total peace of mind.

Check out all of our Nourish Beauty Box reviews to learn more. Ships free to the U.S.


Factors We Considered When Reviewing These Makeup Subscription Services

We asked our readers to select the makeup and beauty boxes above, but to provide the best possible list, we evaluated each selection carefully. Our goal is to give our readers an accurate description of every service, and in addition to real reviews from actual subscribers, here’s what we considered:

  • Price and Value: Beauty boxes often advertise the overall value of the products in each box. We prioritized services that provided accurate descriptions of that value. We also looked for subscriptions that provided clear information about what was included in each box — including information about whether the products were full or sample sizes.
  • Packaging: While most subscription boxes maintain a low carbon footprint compared with alternatives, we tried to find beauty subscriptions with recyclable packaging and sustainably sourced products. This list contains a large number of vegan and cruelty-free makeup subscriptions, which reflects our readers’ preference for eco-friendly choices.
  • Variety and Selection: Most of the cosmetic subscription boxes we’ve covered offer products from a variety of brands. When a box focuses on a single brand, we’ve tried to make sure that they offer a decent selection — in other words, members won’t receive the same products repeatedly during longer subscriptions.
  • Additional Perks: We’ve listed information about discounts, add-on gifts, and other perks that make each makeup subscription worthwhile. After all, those perks can add up!


Finally, we looked for makeup subscription companies with strong reputations. We wanted to make sure that members could change, pause, or cancel their subscriptions at any time. Our goal is to help you start living the subscription lifestyle without worrying about unexpected charges or long-term obligations.

Tips for Getting the Most From Your Makeup Subscription

You’ve found a makeup subscription box that fits your lifestyle, and you’re ready to order. Go ahead and jump in! — but if you’d like a few more tips, here’s our advice:

  • Start with a monthly or bi-monthly box. Annual subscriptions can dramatically cut your costs, but by starting with a single box, you can determine whether the service is a good fit for your beauty needs and lifestyle. Wherever possible, we’ve included coupons and promo codes to keep costs low. You can always come back and try other alternatives next month!
  • Read the ingredient lists carefully. For all beauty products, it’s a good idea to test a small amount on your skin before applying a larger amount. If you have special preferences, email the subscription provider; even if they don’t offer customization, they may be able to make accommodations. 
  • If your service offers personal curation, fill out your profile. Curators use profile information to send you products you’ll love. Whether you’re declaring your preference for a certain lip color or marking down allergies and skin sensitivities, your profile will help you enjoy each new delivery.
  • Leave reviews after receiving your products. Some subscription services offer discounts for active reviewers, but even if your box doesn’t offer this perk, you’ll be able to provide your fellow subscribers with valuable information about the products. We also encourage our readers to review makeup subscription boxes on our site —- a quick review can help someone find their new obsession.

 

We love a high-quality makeup subscription box, and we’re excited about our reader’s selections. Be sure to leave a comment if you’ve tried any of the services listed above (or if you’d like to see another service included in our next list). Which boxes do you think you’ll try this year?

Erin Pullmann
Erin Pullmann
When Erin finds a new box she loves, she wants the world to share her joy, especially if it includes something sparkly. Her non-subscription addictions include knitting, reading, baking, running and dancing with her husband and daughter.

Erin Pullmann
Erin Pullmann
When Erin finds a new box she loves, she wants the world to share her joy, especially if it includes something sparkly. Her non-subscription addictions include knitting, reading, baking, running and dancing with her husband and daughter.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

135 comments

Amara

Do any offer fragrance? Like full size? I never got it from ipsy or boxycharm yet. I wasn’t with birch long so idk about them either.

Shurie Gallup

I believe Scent Bird carries fragrances that get sent to your home.

Nora

Didn’t get Ipsy 2 months in a row.
They said I’d changed my address.
I’ve lived here over 10 years!
Ipsy was a disappointment.
Looking for a new service.

Tamalyn

I used to belong to IPSY but rejoined a couple of months ago and super disappointed. I cancelled.

Tiff

I actually just cancelled ipsy glam bag plus subscription. It takes a month before your bag is considered delivered late. You only have 45 to ask for a replacement but can’t ask until the first of the following month. When they do replace your bag they are out of the items you pick and send you leftovers from previous months. And only way to get them to refund you is using the better business bureau. I’ve read lots of reviews on ipsy and this seems to be an ongoing issue causing many people to cancel.

Jenifer

Ipsy was upping my subscription without my permission, adding product and then charging my account… It is ridiculous that they do not have a live person to speak to. It took 3 weeks for them to get back to me about an unauthorized charge and in that time additional charges were added. It’s been 2 weeks and I still haven’t received my refund.

Erica

I just cancelled Ipsy today! I joined Ipsy at the end of May. Since then, I’ve had nothing but problems! The first few bonus items I purchased I didn’t receive. They don’t have a live person to talk to so I had to go through my email. I ordered a blush & highlighter set, 2 Eye shadow sets and a set of 2 brushes. I received duplicates of the blush and highlighter set along with 3 brushes. (2 of the same)The Ipsy customer service representative told me “W re out of stalk” referring to the eyeshadow duos. He offered a partial refund. The next and biggest problem I’ve had with Ipsy is they started shipping products and extra bags to my billing address not my shipping address! I had ordered over $300 in products in a month and a half! I changed my shipping address back to what is was twice. To make a long story short, I emailed Ipsy letting them know that they keep sending everything to my billing address. Ipsy sent me an email back telling me all six orders I placed would be replaced with a duplicate. I was so happy because it was their error, not mine. I felt that was fair. I emailed Ipsy after two weeks of not receiving a shipping confirmation for the replacement items. Ipsy to ok four days to get back to me. I received an email today telling me “They were sorry but it was a glitch in their system” and they eould NOT be replacing the items they shipped! Ipsy told me it was my fault because after products leave the werehouse, there is nothing they can do. I sent an email back explaining that Ipsy kept changing my shipping address to my billing address and it was not my fault. I also attached the original email from them telling me their sending out duplicate orders of everything. I received an email back this evening telling me they were “sorry” and all they could do is refund $31.33 and give me 1200 points to redeem for a free item. Are you joking? I spent almost $300 for nothing and all you can refund is $31.33? What? I dont have access to my billing address which is a PO Box, that’s why there is a “shipping address!” Duh!
The third thing that happened is I ordered nail stickers and face primer. Four days ago, I received the nail stickers but no face primer. Once again, I had to email them telling them I didn’t receive my primer. Ipsy wanted a screenshot of what I ordered which I provided. I was told “Im sorry were out of stalk!” How are you out of stalk but had it when I ordered it. This is absolutely crazy! I just upgraded two days ago to the Glam Bag Plus.
Ipsy also signed me up for “refreshments” without my consent or knowledge. I plan on disputing the charges on my card because Ipsy shipped everything to my billing address. Im going to show my bank the email I received from them telling me that there going to send replacements.
Ipsy has been nothing but a headache! My time is valuable too and it is a hassle to constantly email them. Ipsy customer service is HORRIBLE! When Are first emailed them regarding the missing eye shadow, I rated their response the worst I could give. The customer service guy (I totally forgot his name) confronted me about me rating him badly! He asked me why I wasn’t happy with his response! I was shocked that he emailed me because of my bad rating. He was incredibly rude to me in his second email. Is he even supposed to do that? Confront a person?? I thought that stuff was confidential!
They REALLY NEED a customer service phone number were people can call and talk with a live person! I mean people are busy nowadays and a lot of people don’t feel or have the time to write an email!
I have never done business like this before. Their shipping is free but it’s SO SLOW!! I would rather pay and not wait 2-3 weeks! Seriously.
Now Im totally disgusted with Ipsy. I’m upset because a few of my friends use Ipsy and have never had a problem. I don’t know where to go from here. I cancelled right after hearing “there was a glitch in the system.” That is BS. Maybe I will give BoxyCharm a try?? Any suggestions?!?

Debra

I went through the exact same thing. They never refunded my money either. I canceled.

Lorraine

Yeah, I stopped my subscription. They get the first box right and it’s as if the don’t look at your profile anymore. I told them that I don’t wear black eyeliner and the sent it in all my boxes. It wasn’t worth the money.

Alex

Interesting that you say this because I actually WANT black eyeliner every month and all I get are browns and golds! Maybe we should make a trade? LOL I think their beauty quiz could use a few more questions, honestly. I have found some great products, but I’ve had to massage my beauty preferences a few times to get more stuff that I’m interested in.

Danielle

I was surprised that ipsy made it on the list. They are not terrible I found 2 products I will stick to but that’s over many months. Its not for everyone for sure. Ipsy is the reason I came across this article..to find a new monthly makeup box. I want most or all of the products to be purly makeup. Personally I dont like using multiple different things in my face and had no use for much of it. I stick to a few to avoid more breakouts.

Beccaox

How is this “2021 readers choice” when there are comments from 2 years ago already on this post????

Also there are different boxy Variations so if Ipsy is making the list several times then boxy should have too IMO (personally been loving my diff boxys more than my diff Ipsys)

Jennifer

I think they update the lists every year, but use the old post? It’s kind of neat to see all the old comments.

Dagny

The Ipsy glam bag plus does NOT ship to canada!!!!!

Pam

Yes it does because I live in Ontario Canada and I get it delivered every month

Trudy

Straight from the IPSY site:
“Are Glam Bag Plus and Glam Bag X available for Ipsters in Canada?
LAST UPDATE:NOV 11 2020 12:16AM
No, Glam Bag Plus and Glam Bag X are only available to the U.S. and its territories. We aren’t sure if or when IPSY will be able to expand Glam Bag Plus and Glam Bag X shipments beyond our current scope, but we’re listening to member feedback to make our new option an even better experience.”

I’d love to know where you ordered it from because when I chose to sign up on the Ipsy site, it only allows me to choose the standard Ipsy bag.

Nicole Buttery

Me and my fiance just canceled boxy charm because the past 3 months we’ve felt like we just gotten whatever leftovers they could throw together. At first we shared an account, then she set me up my own but I was never able to customize it. We tried several times and they just kept saying they couldn’t find my account because some how it wasn’t under my email address. I sent the payment info and the account number on the boxes and they still acted like my account didn’t exist but I was definitely charged every month for it and recieved a box. Except for December, I dont know what happened there but I was charged just never recieved it. We both tried to reach out to boxy so that I could either recieve a box or a refund but they never did either of those. So I refuse to keep paying for something that is going to make a huge haste out of trying to fix an issue. We were both treated like we were lying and was told without the email that was linked to the account they couldn’t even pull up my info. Like I said before I gave them all the billing info, the card number that paid for the box and the account number that came from a previous box and they still said they couldn’t look anything up bc it wasn’t linked to any email that I own. Im here looking for a new subscription type of box but im afraid that bc these aren’t personalized im not going to be ae to find one.

Penny

I love my Boxycharm. I also get Ipsy every other month. Another box I fell in love with is the FabFitFun box. You get a huge box every new season (4 times a year). You pay 49.99 every quarter. You get a box of various objects – full size makeup, skin products; and even blankets or kitchen items. My first box had this beautiful, weighted, blanket. It also included cutting boards, full size eye cream, a glow bottle (I won’t use, but I can find someone who will), eye shadow pallet, and a few other items. Now I have to try Test Tube!!!

Lisa

I think there are some tricks to the Ipsy personalization process. I don’t think that it’s personalized in the way would all wish it were. I’m sure they are using algorithms and stock levels to build the bags, however one thing I heard which I have not yet tried is that if you review a product and give it 1 star, you will not receive that product type again. For example, if you do not ever use bronzer and you get one, you can give it a one star review and you will not likely ever receive a bronzer again.

I have been changing my preferences every month to see if it makes a difference. I haven’t received by January plus bag yet, but we shall see.

Crider

If you want to step across the pond, try Beauty Pie. They’ve a complete offering of skin, hair, & complexion care + fragrance, tools and of course make-up. The membership can be modest if you want and yet you will chose to receive lab developed pure head to toe care. I could go on and on. You should just go here:[email protected]

Lisa

I would say I’m pretty happy with Glam Bag Plus. I used to have the regular Glam Bag a few years ago but cancelled because I kept getting products I didn’t care for. December 2020 I signed back up and opted for Plus which was not an option back when I had the regular GB. Currently they do let you pick 3 of your bag items which I think is awesome, however that does not mean you won’t be disappointed. Some products are just crap shoots and may seem great but not actually be right for you when you try it. I also do like the inexpensive add-ons and offers which lets you try out other products on the cheap.

What I would like to get more of in my bag is fragrance. I think I got a Kensie fragrance one time in my old Glam Bag, but haven’t received a fragrance since even though my preferences are set to “often” and all scent profiles have been selected. Anyone know of a fragrance-only sub?

Misty Hicks

Scentbird is great and is $14.95 a month.

Angela L Franklin

What do you guys think about lashybox?? It’s not mentioned at all here, and I was just looking at gifting this to my daughter, the XL box for 24.99 but then remembered Boxycharm, I want one or the other, too …. Hmmmm…

Tamara

I really do miss Sephora Play. I love getting sample sized items because it keeps me from becoming overwhelmed with products. I wish there were more options in the $10-$15 range.

Catherine Ward

I’ve had Ipsy for a little over 3 years now and need to change it up. I want a monthly box that is primarily makeup BUT all really wild stuff. I want purple blush, grey eyebrow and orange mascaras, etc. Who has this? Ipsy used to have out-there items periodically but its been a long time.

Alex

YES SAME!!

G

Medusa’s makeup monthly box is less than boxycharm and has some wild colours in every box! They do 4-5 items and only include one skincare product in each box so you know you’re mostly getting makeup and they guarantee a wild coloured product like neon etc.

Deirdre

IPSY has killed Glam Bag Ultimate, in favor of a glam bag plus with every third month featuring an Ultimate type bag.
I’m super disappointed 😞 I liked my Ultimate

Cecily

Same here

Dorothy Montgomery

Me too I loved the Ultimate too.

GABRIELLE N GILBERT

Where!!lots of comments here ;)))) I got Boxy last Christmas and have loved every month. But I’m to the point of having just soooo much that I need to use what I’ve got, especially when we’re all home everyday. Buuuut, I’m looking at Petit Bout. Same price, or actually, they have an $18 & $25 and it’s all vegan. . .so, we shall see😍😍😘. 🐞

Lisa Rey

I read through all the reviews because I love trying new makup…My sister is always giving me samples even full size items she gets in all her makeup bags she gets monthly. I can not decided which one to pick that I will be happy with because there are so many negative reviews from them all….

Bridget Humphries

The Box by Fashionsta is by far my favorite out of all of them. I’ve had almost every box on this list at one time or another. When covid19 hit and I had to cut back, Fashionsta is the only sub box subscription that I kept. They have a mix of skincare and makeup each month. You get 5 to 6 products each month and they are all full size. They don’t do a lot of mainstream brands like tarte, too faced, Anastasia Beverley Hills, but more small companies that you don’t hear about all the time but definitely should. I’ve found so many amazing products and brands that I never would have known about without getting them in the box. The products are much better quality than any of the other sub boxes out there.

Karen

Beauty TestTube is by far the best value out of all of them… they do all full sized products. I subscribe to 9 so I guess you could say I kind of know what they offer😀
It only comes every other month and I believe it is $29?
But it is not all makeup. Lots of skincare.
Best way to decide is to go on each box’s website and look at past boxes.
You are the only one that knows what you like-want-need.
Out of the monthly boxes, allure gives you a lot of products for a small amount of money, but they are all sample sized.

Grisel

Boxycharm should be on the bottom of this list. Their products are good but if you ever have an issue with your monthly box or an order you placed, good look trying to reach them. They dont have customer support so good look trying to reach them.

Leslie Smith

For real! When I finally got through to someone they couldn’t find my account and said they couldn’t help me. 5 weeks later I received my box only to be let down. The products were all cheap.

hamoda

No comm

Shanna k

Well,

By the sound of almost EVERYONE. They pretty much ALL stink when it comes to NOT getting what you can actually use AND in customer service solving any problems.

So….the makeup addict i am. BUT…i have decided AGAINST ANY of the mentioned subscriptions. And sticking to what ive done successfully for many years, Which is purchasing large lots of various samples. And, always buying whenever a GWP is available..
Thank you all for helping me decide.

Des

Does ANYONE know of ANY beauty subscription that has the option to choose what countries they would/wouldn’t like to receive products from?????

OR a subscription that is only USA products??

Linn

For people of color try Cocotique. Has full sized hair products plus cosmetics and skincare, nail polish..$25 per month.

Tawney

Thanks, Linn. I was reading to see if there would be any mention of Cocotique and how good/bad their services are. Has anyone here tried Cocotique and what was your experience with them?

Jade

Have had a subscription to them for a couples months, the last month I didn’t like it but the haircare was just not for me. Well worth the money in my opinion arrives without issues.

Lila Williams

I’m with you on that one! I don’t like Huda Beauty either and don’t understand their popularity. With all the glitter in them they make me look like the painted woman in the James Bond Golden Girl movie. when I saw a picture of the founder I understood why I don’t like Huda Beauty. she looks desire with all that strange makeup on. She doesn’t wear the makeup. The makeup wears her!

And I also like tarte! Great products in good packaging very cute.

Lila Williams

I meant she looks bizarre.

Lisa

Totally. Sometimes too much is too much. I really dislike the shimmery glittery makeup products and have so far been able to avoid Huda Beauty in my sub. I understand that the founder is a makeup artist, but methinks that term is being used loosely.

Errmmm

Agreed – she’s bizarre looking and I’m far from jealous. Her makeup is totally made for Instagram use and it’s more like immediate gratification makeup. None of it is long-lasting, kind of like how MAC was originally made for runway use, and not really intended for long-wear and standard use.

HUDA is for Instagram pictures and not high-quality. Her face always looks like there’s an inch of thick/shiny product on top of her skin.

Sandra

Wow, umm..she’s gorgeous. Jelly much?

Lila Williams

I absolutely agree! I was very sad that two days ago I had to cancel Ipsy. 3 months in a row every single product was on my rarely list. I did not receive one product that was on my often list or my sometimes list. Except for the one product that I picked.

They Allow you to pick one product to opt out of so you won’t get it in your glam bag. I opted out of eyeliner. This third month, in addition to receiving everything on my rarely list. I also received an eyeliner but I had opted out of.

They had the gall to tell me that the box I got with everything on my rarely list and the product that I had opted out of most closely matched my profile!

Sometimes I actually wonder if they give you everything on your rarely list so that you will buy the full-size product for $18 as an add-on.

Raquel

I’ve seen a couple of new boxes on Facebook; Top Off Beauty and Glam Addict. Anyone heard of or tried these yet?

Joanne moore

Ive been very dedicatited to being an ipster . I have on my bank statement i paid them 140.00 as i understand it Im coverd for a full year. .Of glam gwn gags. Am I correcet or do i call solve at 7. Idk. Im hopeing ipsy gets back to me. . As my phone ìs out of order. This is a phone ipsy may reply me on. And Thànk You 💕❤👍💘🔜

Fiorella Vengoechea

I had boxy charm for like four years and this year it went totally downhill. I filled out a beauty quiz specifying that I don’t want mascara or any red lipstick only nude lip colors and eyeshadows. After receiving red lipsticks glosses and RED EYSHADOWS and of course mascara for about six months straight and seeing friends get the same products that I got in nude colors and other things besides the mascara I had to cancel. Their customer service is literally non existent… I sent them about 20 emails and even dms on their Instagram and never got even one response. It’s pretty sad because I did love this subscription before all of these issues started. They have no issues sending me emails every single day telling me to resubscribe but couldn’t answer one single email. Terrible company.

WJN

I had the same problem with Boxy Charm. Alot of makeup that I could not use because they were in no way suited to my skin tone. Eye shadow palettes with wild colors and after about 8 months, I started seeing duplicates of the same things I had gotten a few months prior. It gave me the impression that they were buying up bulk things that didnt sell and putting them in the boxes each month.

Cindy Lipknit

I too had nothing but problems with BoxyCharm. They even ILLEGALLY charged my credit card without my authorization or knowledge and sent me another box, after my account was “supposedly” cancelled! I even have the email from them from the month before confirming the cancellation!!!
If their CEO would spend more time developing an actual Customer Service Department instead of making his videos every 5 minutes, telling everyone about the stuff the influencers are going to get, but you aren’t, then 3/4 of his subscribers wouldn’t be so aggravated all the time! Sure, the products overall are good-great, but 50% of what you get are colors you can’t use. Or how many eye pencils, mascaras and full-on glittery lip glosses do you need? How many eye shadow pallets all in the same Sunset shades do you need? BoxyCharm if you don’t or aren’t able to customize (nor have you ever been, which Joe admitted in one of his videos), get your deceiving questionnaire off your website!!!!!!! I could go on, but I won’t. I’ve moved on now to greener pastures, as they say!

Robin L Kiely

I agree. I just cancelled my Boxy Charm subscription. They have horrible customer service. No phone number to call. Only email. It took about 3 days to get an email reply and it was unsatisfactory.
However, I really like the products.

Lila Williams

I had the identical problem with Ipsy! I couldn’t have been happier for 8 months straight. Then, for the next three months, everything I got was on my rarely list. In spite of the fact that they have plenty of stuff that was on my often and sometimes list.

They had the gall to tell me that the package with everything on my rarely list most closely matched my beauty profile!

Lisa

I agree 100%. I had Boxy Charm since the 2nd or 3rd box they sent. It has been going downhill for a while. My last BoxyLuxe was so lackluster, it actually pushed me to cancel the subscription.

Amanda

Cancelled my Ipsy after repeatedly getting same shade family of eyeshadows/blushes/lipsticks that didn’t go with a fair complexion at all. Plus same 3-4 out of 5 products monthly. Contacted customer service to ask what I needed to do to get variety in my products and to quit getting shades I couldn’t used and was told My products were chosen by their computer system. So much for that personalization! I asked what the point of filling out a beauty profile if it didn’t really matter.

Lila Williams

I think Ipsy going downhill, too. After being with them for a year, and receiving the last boxes with everything inside on my rarely list, I canceled. Too bad because I really love the products that they show you may be in your glam bag. Problem is they weren’t.

You Might Also Like

BeautyFix – Addressing CX Issues
BeautyFix – Addressing CX Issues
July 16, 2021
Macy’s Beauty Box August 2021 Spoilers!
Macy’s Beauty Box August 2021 Spoilers!
July 23, 2021
Allure Beauty Box August 2021 – Spoiler #1
Allure Beauty Box August 2021 – Spoiler #1
July 19, 2021
FabFitFun Shares First Look at Fall 2021 Box, Announces Fall Access Dates for Annual and Seasonal Members
FabFitFun Shares First Look at Fall 2021 Box, Announces Fall Access Dates for Annual and Seasonal Members
July 19, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.