Facebook Pixel26 Best Beauty Subscription Boxes - 2022 Winners | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The 26 Best Beauty Subscription Boxes – 2022 Readers’ Choice Awards

For beauty aficionados, buying every single product that comes out can be a little pricey especially if you're just wanting to try it. Well, that's where beauty subscription boxes come in. While they have been a great way to discover new brands and products without even needing to go out, there's no denying that there's an overwhelming amount of subscriptions out there and it might be hard to decide which one you want to splurge on. From skin care to makeup, there's an option for everything. But how exactly do you pick just one – or two?

Every year, we ask our readers to share their top recommended subscriptions of all types. Then we ask our experts to share what they know about each subscription to make it easy for you to know which subscription is right for you. Below, you’ll find our insights for shopping beauty subscription boxes, and see readers’ top choices for every need.

What To Look For When Shopping Beauty Subscriptions

The first step is deciding what you're looking for with your makeup subscription. These boxes range in price, delivery frequency, and product focus, but they all offer exceptional value (especially when paired with promo links and coupon codes, which we’ve provided wherever possible). See our notes at the end for information about our selection process and tips for getting more from your subscription.

There are a lot of boxes out there, so how do you know which is the right beauty subscription for you? Here’s what our readers focus on as they’re making a decision about which subscription service to join:

  • Do you only want makeup? Most beauty boxes will include some makeup. However, there are several subscriptions that include hair care, skincare, and even a few goodies. We’ve noted which boxes only have makeup in them and which offer other great items too.
  • How much variety do you want?  Some beauty boxes will send out products from one brand every month, while others send products from several. You may want a lipstick only box, or you might want a beauty box that gives you an entire face of makeup. In our list we’ve noted where brands keep surprising subscribers or whether members know what they can expect.
  • Quality: Generally the boxes that offer exclusive brands will cost a bit more. If you are concerned about the quality of the brands you’ll encounter in a box, you may want to stick with subscriptions that aren’t the cheapest in terms of price. Our list contains some luxury boxes, as well as community favorites that still have high standards.
  • Product Sizes: Some beauty boxes offer trial-size or sample-sizes. This might be great for you, especially if you’re looking to find new favorites or sample brands you haven’t tried before. However, you might be someone who prefers to get full-size items at a discounted price. Our list notes whether products are sample-sized, full-sized or a mix.
  • Customization: Some subscriptions allow you to choose one or two items in the box, while others give you the freedom to choose all of your products. In our list we note how much customization is possible.
  • Clean Options: If you’re looking for cruelty-free boxes, we’ve got them. And if you're interested in ethically sourced or dermatologist approved, we have those too.
  • Customer Service: Problems happen sometimes. You might get products you didn’t ask for or makeup that accidentally spilled inside the box. Good subscription services will respond quickly and settle your concerns without too much of a headache. We tried to only include those subscriptions that our readers describe as reliable and consistent with their approach to resolving customer problems and concerns.

The Most Popular Beauty Subscription Boxes

Read on for our reader’s recommendations for the best beauty subscription boxes currently available. If we missed anything, drop us a comment. If you’ve tried one of these services, be sure to leave a quick review (even if you had a poor experience — your review can help other readers avoid subscription remorse).

1. Ipsy Glam Bag Plus

The best beauty subscription box overall

Image from our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

This subscription is an upgrade option from the standard Ipsy Glam Bag (which costs $13/month), and our readers really loved it for a few reasons. For starters, you can expect makeup from brands such as tarte, Fenty, Murad, and Viseart. Being able to try these brands without paying retail price for each individual product? Our readers say yes, please!

Every box comes packed with a whopping 5 full-size products that are a mix of skincare and makeup. Even better than all those full-size beauty products for just $28 a month? Instead of the usual one, customers can now customize three of the products that they're going to get, so you can stock your box with what you'll know you'll love. For the rest of the items, your profile preferences are consulted, so you'll only be sent the creams, lip balms, cheek stains, palettes, and brushes the team at Ipsy knows you'll enjoy.

Who Is This Subscription Box For?

This is the Ipsy customer who wants a little more from their monthly bags. It's also great for the people who know just what they like and would like more control over the products they choose.

Is This Box Customizable?

Yes, you get to choose 3 of 5 products.

Pros

  • Gets more products than the regular Ipsy Glam Bag
  • Can customize the bag even more and choose up to three products

Cons

  • Might sometimes get products you don't care much for.
  • Will still get travel-sized products

What Readers Say:

"Has the most full-size items and most choice for picking in this price range. The algorithm really reads my preferences and feedback." - Jenn

"The products are top notch and they offer exceptional customization! Each box is well worth the price." - Ted

"After years of sub addiction, Ipsy Glam Bag Plus is one that I always come back to. The products are great! Even when the products miss the mark for me, the value is always there." - Rebecca

Shipping: Ipsy Glam Bag Plus only ships to the United States and its territories.

Starting at $28.00
Try Ipsy Glam Bag Plus
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Ipsy Glam Bag Plus reviews.

2. BoxyCharm

The best subscription for people who want full beauty products

BOXYCHARM December 2020 box with the sponge and glitter makeup lipstick mascara

Image from our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription?

BoxyCharm is a well-curated beauty box that manages to excite its subscribers month after month.

With your BoxyCharm subscription, you'll receive 5 full-sized beauty productions from high-end brands with a total retail value of over $100. If you're obsessed with makeup, BoxyCharm is the beauty subscription box for you. You can expect to receive amazing cosmetics like eyeshadow palettes, beautiful blushes, and a variety of lip colors to try, as well as skin care products, beauty tools, and other great beauty finds in every box.

Who Is This Subscription Good For?

This subscription is great for those who just want beauty products in their bags and would like to experience the full size. It's also super affordable compared to what you might spend per product regularly.

Is this Box Customizable?

Yes, you can choose 1 of 5 products if you're a Base Box member; you can choose two products if you're a Premium member.

Pros

  • You get full-sized products
  • Focus on beauty products mainly.
  • You can customize at least part of your box.

Cons

  • To get more than seven products, you have to pay more.

What Readers Say:

"Boxycharm is the best bang for your buck. You get tons of coveted high-end products at a serious discount." - Runner WHY

"Great overall variety. I've been a member for years and have a huge makeup and skincare collection now, all started with Boxy. Pop up sales and add ons make being a subscriber even better because you get products at a fraction of the cost." - Alice R.

"BoxyCharm was untouchable this year. The products were amazing, the brands were amazing, and I was thrilled with every single box I received!" - Kitkat04

Shipping: BoxyCharm currently ships to the United States for free, but Hawaii, Alaska, and all the US territories ship for $5 per box. BoxyCharm also ships to Canada as well as its territories, provinces and military locations for $5.

Starting at $27.99
Try Boxycharm
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our BoxyCharm reviews.

3. Ipsy Glam Bag

The best subscription for those who are on a budget

Full Contents for the Ipsy Glam Bag December 2020

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

One of the original beauty subscription boxes gets its spot on the list as number three for its affordable price point and quality curation. For just $13 a month, the Ipsy Glam Bag delivers incredible value with a mix of high-end and drugstore products. Inside a stylish beauty bag, you'll find makeup, skincare, and beauty tools.

Who Is This Subscription For?

If you're looking for the most bang for your buck, Ipsy Glam Bag is the beauty subscription box for you. It's also a great way to discover more indie beauty brands.

Is this Box Customizable?

Yes, you can choose 1 product in your box each month.

Pros

  • You get a cute makeup bag along with your order.
  • You can actually purchase products off the website.

Cons

  • You may get repeats from previous bags.
  • You usually get trial sizes.

What Readers Say:

"I love that we have a say. Every month we pick 1 item and we can add others to it. Great value and love the little pouches that come with it!" - Michelle

"Ipsy always seems to consistently provide the best value and the best delivery consistency." - Rachelsbeautyspot

"I always use my Ipsy products since they are all tailored for me!" - Jacqueline Frazier

Shipping: Ipsy Glam Bag ships to the United States and Mexico for free, and for $2.95 to Canada.

Starting at $13.00
Try Ipsy Glam Bag
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Ipsy reviews.

4. Allure Beauty Box

The best subscription for those who would love to try products from Allure magazine

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Subscribing to the Allure Beauty Box is like going behind the scenes at Allure magazine.

Inside this monthly beauty subscription box, you'll find premium samples and full-size products from the top brands the editors at this popular magazine love (and you will too). At $23 a month, this affordable price point makes the Allure Beauty Box an easy way to try the trending ingredients and current cosmetics you'll see featured in the pages of Allure.

Who is This Subscription Box For?

Perfect for the critical buyer, the Allure Beauty Box is especially apt for those who wish to sample the latest beauty releases before committing to the full-size purchase.

Is this Box Customizable?

No; products are curated by Allure editors.

Pros

  • Super cheap for full and deluxe-sized products.
  • Get a mixture of affordable and luxury brands.

Cons

  • Will depend on the products they sponsored in the magazine.

What Readers Say:

"Best value for the money. No repeated items. Wide variety of brands and types of products and no tiny sizes. Majority are extra deluxe samples and full sizes." - Sherri

"Allure always sends new products and that keeps me excited about the box. I also like their choice of brands because they tend to include well-known brands with newer ones." - Katrina

"Good balance of skincare and makeup. I've found some definite holy grails through this box." - EK1006

Shipping: Allure only ships to the United States.

Starting at $23.00
Try Allure Beauty Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Allure Beauty Box reviews.

5. Ipsy Glam Bag X

The best subscription for the ultimate Ipsy experience.

Image from our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box

Ipsy Glam Bag X is a quarterly upgrade for Ipsy members. It costs an additional $42/shipment for Glam Bag members and $27/shipment for Glam Bag Plus members. It replaces your usual monthly bag in February, May, August, and November. This bag "includes seven to eight full-size products specially curated by beauty’s biggest tastemakers and celebs" and allows subscribers to pick three items.

Who Is This Subscription Box For?

This is perfect for those who are loyal Ipsy subscribers who want to try everything the brand can offer. This is especially great for the people who are so over the trial sizes and want to commit to the big thing.

Is this Box Customizable?

Yes, you can choose 3 of 7-8 products.

Pros

  • Get seven to eight full-sized products
  • Let's you pick out three.

Cons

  • Only comes in certain months.
  • $42 more expensive than the regular Ipsy Glam Bag

What Readers Say:

"I loved my Glam Bag X when it arrived! I’ve been with Ipsy for years. I feel like they follow my profile well. The few items that are not for me, I have no problem gifting. I think keeping an open mind for products/brands received is the key to fully enjoy this subscription." - Bandaa

"I am really impressed for the launch. My box includes $329 in products excluding the addons, that's an 83% discount off of retail. I don't care about the Huda palette but I'll try it. I also got the Pat McGrath mascara, the Complex Culture tool, the Patrick Ta blush in pink, About Face matte lip in Take Aim, Beautystat Vit C serum, Tula Skincare eye balm, and the scrunchies. I added on Patrick Ta brow wax in dark brown, R+Co detox rinse, and Make Up Forever foundation. I think everyone got the mascara, the Huda palette, and either one of the Patrick Ta bushes or brow waxes. Complex Culture may be a house brand but so far I have loved every one of their items that I've received. I have no idea what a facial massager may do for me but I'll give it a try. I'm 52 so I'm fighting the good fight over the wrinkles." - Karen

Shipping: Ipsy Glam Bag X only ships to the United States and its territories.

Starting at $55.00
Try Ipsy Glam Bag X
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our IPSY Glam Bag x reviews.

6. Margot Elena Discovery Box

The best subscription for fans of Anthropologie

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?:

Margot Elena is the brand behind Lollia, TokyoMilk, and Library of Flowers. If you aren't familiar with this beloved brand, these luxury wares are carried in stores like Anthropologie and other upscale boutiques. Margot Elena's mission is simple: To help its subscribers discover "the world of all things beautiful" with their deliveries. Inside, you'll find over $200 worth of expertly-curated full-sized products brought to you by the discerning team at Margot Elena.

Aside from full-sized offerings from the aforementioned brands, subscribers can also expect to receive beautifully designed stationery, wearables, luxurious fragrances, and lifestyle gifts. You have to act quickly on signing up for this quarterly subscription, however; each season's box is curated in limited quantities, and tends to sell out fast!

Who Is This Subscription Box For?

This is perfect for fans of Anthropologie who love luxury bath and body goods, which not only smell incredible but look pretty on your vanity.

Is this Box Customizable?

No, the products in this box are curated by Margot Elena.

Pros

  • Get full-size products each time
  • Receive beautiful lifestyle items in addition to luxury bath products

Cons

  • May miss out if you don't sign up quickly

What Readers Say:

"Always a delight to unbox, and I've found some new favorites. Anything I don't need or want is easily repurposed as a gift that is always appreciated." - Lele

"Exquisitely packaged, opening this quarterly box is like Christmas morning." - Dawn

"ME is a beauty box completely different than the others. It's more for the senses than the others." - Mic Walker

Shipping: Subscription boxes are shipped via FedExGround Shipping at a flat rate of $6.95 per box and it is limited to the contiguous United States.

7. See New: The Skincare Box

The best subscription for those who want to try a single brand per shipment

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box

See New is a bi-monthly skincare subscription focused on highlighting both new brands and cult favorites. Each box features 4-5 full-size products from a single brand allowing for an immersive experience. Although See New offers two beauty subscription boxes, The Skincare Box contains 4-5 items for whole body care. Their beauty subscription boxes focus on a single brand for each month, such as Tbg, Dirty Lamb, and Aster Raine, and include beauty products like lip scrub, cleansing oil, toner, and serum.

Who Is This Subscription Box For?

See New Skincare is the ideal beauty subscription for people who are looking to clean up their beauty routine, and use more sustainably sourced products.

Is this Box Customizable?

No; See New Skincare selects all the products in the box.

Pros

  • You get to explore sustainable and clean products
  • Features 4-5 full-size products

Cons

  • Focuses on one brand per shipment

What Readers Say:

"Beautiful packaging, fast shipping, all full size from same brand, fantastic value, great ingredients...does anyone need more?" - Judy Barrow

"I canceled all my other subscriptions after trying See New. It is the best subscription box out there, period. So glad I found this one through MSA, it's been one of my favorite quarantine finds." - Eli

"Absolutely the best skincare box out there. They always have the highest quality for the best price. I love the handwritten notes they include. I have tried many boxes over the years. This box I will always keep. You can’t beat it!" - Stacy

Shipping: See New Skincare offers free shipping on all orders that exceed $40, as well for subscription boxes that are being shipped within the continental United States, Hawaii, and Alaska. Canadian shipping is a flat charge of $14.99, and international shipping has a flat charge of $25.

Starting at $47.00
See New: The Skincare Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our See New: The Skincare Box reviews.

8. Birchbox

The best subscription for those who want to earn points

Full Contents for Birchbox December 2020

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

There's a good reason Birchbox is synonymous with beauty subscription boxes. With its amazing assortment of high-end samples, Birchbox has been a reader favorite for years. Subscribe to Birchbox and every month, you'll receive a new mix of 5 beauty samples, such as makeup, skincare, haircare, and fragrance items.

Subscribers have the option to select from several expertly curated boxes of samples or choose a sample choice box, which entails hand-picking one of your samples and letting the rest be selected by Birchbox with your beauty needs in mind.

Who Is This Beauty Box For?

This box is a great way to try the brands and products you've been curious about, while also unboxing discovery with new ones, all from one budget-friendly assortment of monthly goodies.

Is this Box Customizable?

If you select a sample choice box, you are able to select one product in the box (of five).

Pros

  • You get four to five beauty finds every month
  • You can choose between a curated box or a customized one

Cons

  • You only get sample sizes

What Readers Say:

"So many of my favorite staple beauty products have been, and continue to be, discovered in Birchbox. I also love being able to purchase those items in the Birchbox shop, especially when there's a good sale! There are a few really great features about this box: easy to skip a month /swap for points or choose featured boxes, and earning points on purchases to spend on future purchases!" - Nervie

"They have an awesome rewards program and if you've got sample overload you can swap your box value for shop credit." - Arlena

"Birchbox always introduces me to new items. Some samples are very small, but usually new to me, I like that." - Jan

Shipping: BirchBox currently ships to the United States. For international orders, BirchBox also ships to France, Spain, and the UK and operates as Birchbox France, Birchbox Spain, and Birchbox UK.

Starting at $15.00
Birchbox
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Birchbox reviews.

9. FabFitFun

The best subscription for people who like a little bit of everything

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

FabFitFun is a lifestyle box full of wellness, style, and fitness goodies, hitting the Reader's Choice Awards for 2022 across several categories, and the love for its makeup and skincare inclusions are no exception to this year's all-stars of beauty.

Our readers can't get enough of FabFitFun for several reasons. This beloved beauty subscription offers new products alongside tried and true favorites. There's also the ability to customize your delivery, so there's truly something for everything. Subscribers love the full-size beauty products found inside this quarterly arrival, praising them for their quality and on-trend properties.

Highlighting everything from eye masks, ingredient-conscious makeup, nail care, hair products, and more, FabFitFun delivers a plentiful, diverse, and thoughtful seasonal box that stands out among beauty box contenders.

Who Is This Subscription Good For?

This subscription is great for people who are interested in more than just makeup and beauty products. It also includes plenty of lifestyle products like bags, bathrobes, notebooks, and pieces of clothing. It's also great for the people who aren't necessarily interested in getting their boxes every single month and would rather space them out.

Is this Box Customizable?

Yes. Seasonal members can typically select items in 4 of 6 categories, while annual members can select items in all possible categories.

Pros

  • You get full-sized products
  • Box includes more than just beauty products.

Cons

  • Only ships quarterly
  • One of the pricier options on the list

What Readers Say:

“Wonderful products I get to try before I buy... so worth the few dollars a quarter. I enjoy trying new products and have loved the ones I've gotten from this company. Shipping and delivery always exceptional. And there is always open communication between myself and customer service if I find I need them." - Kittykat45

"Although it is WAY more than a beauty box, my favorite beauty items have come from here." - Amy W.

Shipping: FabFitFun ships for free to the contiguous US. They also ship to Canada, Puerto Rico, Alaska, Hawaii for $8 USD and to the UK for $10.

Starting at $54.99
Try FabFitFun
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our FabFitFun reviews.

10. Walmart Beauty Box

The best subscription for affordable options

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Drugstore makeup gets a revamp with the Walmart Beauty Box. This quarterly makeup and beauty sample subscription delivers subscribers a shipment of samples at $5 a box. A great way to try new colors, brands, and options, the Walmart Beauty Box allows recipients to try the latest and greatest in trends at a bargain price.

When you sign up you will answer a series of questions such as your ethnicity, hair color, skin concerns, and a few other preferences. The answers are used to provide a more personalized experience so that they can tailor your box to you.

If you can't get enough of this try before you buy model, Walmart Beauty Box also offers themed seasonal limited edition boxes for $12.98.

Who Is This Box For?

This box is for those who only want to try affordable beauty and skincare without splurging on the full size.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Walmart curates the box for you.

Pros

  • Affordable beauty products
  • Only $5 per box

Cons

  • Only offers trial sizes of products

What Readers Say:

"This is a hidden gem of a box. Inexpensive but receive at least one full-size product along with samples and deluxe samples." - Rhonda Said

"Surprisingly fun and inexpensive. I have gotten great products from this box." - Megs

"Nothing beats the value for this box and I have been introduced to some great beauty products through this." - Emmi

Shipping: The Walmart Beauty Box only ships within the United States.

Starting at $6.98
Active Deal
Receive a bonus item when you subscriber to Walmart Beauty Box for the first time! This season, new subscribers
Use Coupon Code SPATTY2022
Walmart Beauty Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Walmart Beauty Box reviews.

11. GlossyBox

The best subscription for a mix of affordable and high-end beauty

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

GlossyBox is a beauty subscription box that sends five deluxe and full-size products to your door every month for $21 (with free shipping to the U.S.).

Each month, GlossyBox delivers a nourishing haul of amazing cosmetics, skincare, and other must-have items in full and deluxe sizes.

Filled with a fabulous combination of notable and under-the-radar brands, this box has proven itself to be the tried-and-true beauty box, beloved by subscribers worldwide for its quality, value, and variety.

Who Is This Subscription Box For?

This box is great for people who want a subscription that includes makeup, skincare, and some additional goodies.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Glossybox chooses all items for you, based on their monthly theme.

Pros

  • Good mix of high-end and affordable beauty
  • Full-sized products

Cons

  • Only delivers to the United States and Canada

What Readers Say:

"I have subscribed to just about every box on the list and have found that GlossyBox provides the best selection of products and manufacturers, as well provides products in sizes that are large enough to give a very good sense of how the product works for me." - DragonQueen

"Gorgeous packaging, and great products. This box feels like a gift each month." - Marina

Shipping: GlossyBos is available to ship worldwide, but it is only free in the United States.

Starting at $21.00
Try GlossyBox
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our GlossyBox reviews.

12. Macy's Beauty Box

The best subscription for fans of Macy's

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Macy's Beauty Box is one of our favorite beauty subscription boxes. This beauty subscription box is a well-curated way to bring the iconic department store's beauty counter to your doorstep.

For $15 a month and free shipping, the Macy’s Beauty Box really delivers. Inside this monthly beauty subscription box, you'll find five deluxe beauty samples, one bonus item, a collectible cosmetics bag, and a $5 beauty coupon exclusively for Beauty Box subscribers, available for use online and in-store.

Subscribers will be thrilled to snag that exclusive coupon which can be used on their next beauty purchase over $20.

Who Is This Box For?

This box is for fans of Macy's who don't really want to be constantly going up to a counter and exploring new beauty products. It's also perfect for people who just want to save some money.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Macy’s chooses items for you.

Pros

  • Includes beauty samples, bonus item, cosmetics bag, and a coupon
  • Super affordable

Cons

  • Doesn't include any full-sized products

What Readers Say:

"The best value for department store beauty." - misti

"Loved that they added in additional items, such as a makeup mirror compact." - FaithAbdel

"Macy's always has great name brand items." - Shelby

Shipping: Macy's Beauty Box only ships to the continental US.

Starting at $15.00
Try Macy's Beauty Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Macy's Beauty Box reviews.

13. NewBeauty TestTube

The best subscription for high-quality products on a budget

 

Image via our review.

What's In This Beauty Subscription Box?

NewBeauty TestTube is one of our community's favorite subscriptions for trying out new brands and ingredients.

That could be because the NewBeauty TestTube began all the way back in 2006. Created so that readers could try the products that were featured in the pages of NewBeauty magazine, NewBeauty TestTube is a collection of luxury samples designed for discovery and access to the most innovative, must-have beauty solutions.

Subscribers can expect to receive a mix of well-known products and new high-quality brands that you'll definitely want to try. To round out the experience, each membership comes with a free NewBeauty magazine subscription, so you're an expert in your beauty domain from the first box.

Who Is This Box For?

This is a great box for people who just want to try new brands and clean ingredients while getting access to innovative beauty solutions.

Is this Box Customizable?

No; NewBeauty selects the items in each box.

Pros

  • Each tube comes with over nine products
  • Comes with a free subscription to the magazine

Cons

  • The majority of the products are travel size

What Readers Say:

"I love the high-quality items they put in the tube. I can't wait to try each one." - Meaghan A.

"I love this box because it introduces me to new products and is more focused on skincare." - Damianscloud9

"NewBeauty Testtube is consistently worth the cost and filled with unique things I can actually use. Whether it's a less expensive item or a special product I never would have bought myself, there's a lot of thought put into curation, especially since many of us have now sampled many products from beauty boxes and are hard to surprise.." - Kristy

Shipping: New Beauty Testtube only ships to the continental US.

Starting at $59.00
Try NewBeauty Testtube
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our NewBeauty TestTube reviews.

14. BeautyFIX

The best subscription to discover your new favorites

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

BeautyFIX by Dermstore.com is known for its incredible-quality and aesthetician-approved skincare items, but it's good for the occasional makeup surprise as well.

Curated by skin care experts, each monthly BeautyFIX includes six or more products adding up to a total value of $100+ (which is about four times more than what you’ll pay for it). In each beauty subscription box, you can expect to see a healthy mix of full-size and deluxe-travel-size products—including skincare, hair care, and cosmetics handpicked by beauty experts and delivered right to your door. You'll be excited to receive premium products like hydrating serums, nourishing haircare products, anti-aging skincare solutions, and more.

Who Is This Box For?

This subscription box is great for people who love to shop at Dermstore.com and would love to explore every single one of their products without breaking the bank.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Dermstore’s skincare experts choose the contents of the box.

Pros

  • You will receive a wide variety of high-end products.
  • It includes more than just makeup

Cons

  • Only ships to the United States

What Readers Say:

"BeautyFIX offers an incredible array of high-end products every month. The value of the box is always many times higher than the subscription price. I have discovered so many new favorites!" - Amanda P.

"I love that this box delivers amazing beauty products, many in full size, AND beauty tools. Lots of boxes give makeup brushes, this one gives hair brushes, accessory bags, mirrors, etc." - Katie

"High-quality, useful products. New discoveries every month. Dependable delivery. Great customer service, and great $ value." - Bernie

Shipping: BeautyFix ships only to the United States.

Starting at $24.95
Try BeautyFix
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Dermstore Beauty Fix reviews.

15. Beauty Heroes

The best subscription for those who don' want to be overwhelmed by the amount of products

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Beauty Heroes packs a small but mighty punch into its premium monthly box.

Beauty Heroes is a clean beauty subscription box that focuses on non-toxic ingredients for $58.95/month. Here's how it works: Each month they send you one new full-size “hero” product in the face, body, hair, or sun care category accompanied by a “deluxe sidekick" or two. Once you get familiar with the quality of products that come with your Beauty Heroes subscription you'll see why our reviewers are totally obsessed.

Typically, the hero and sidekick (or sidekicks) will be from the same brand. With a steadfast commitment to extraneous quality (another reason this beauty subscription is so popular with our readers), you'll discover new brands with every delivery.

Who Is This Box For?

This one is for the people who want to focus on just a few products a month. This is also great for the people who are only interested in clean beauty.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; you’ll get two (at times, three) products chosen by Beauty Heroes.

Pros

  • Quality, clean products
  • Comes with a full-sized item

Cons

  • Pretty expensive for the number of products received
  • Only sends two products a month

What Readers Say:

"The value and quality of products for the subscription price is unbelievable. I have never been disappointed with this box and am always excited each month. It has never gotten boring." - Erin Gallagher

Shipping: They ship worldwide. Shipping is free in the United States. Canadian orders under $75.00 from their online healthy beauty shop have a flat $11.95 shipping fee. All International subscription orders and beauty store orders under $200 enjoy $18.95 flat rate shipping.

Starting at $58.95
Active Deal
Get 10% off any subscription!
Use Coupon Code MSABH10
Try Beauty Heroes
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Beauty Heroes reviews.

16. Kinder Beauty Box

The best subscription for vegan products and eco-friendly packaging

Image from our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Curated with 100% vegan products and eco-friendly packaging, the Kinder Beauty Box is a beauty subscription box that's all about supplying subscribers with cruelty-free skincare, haircare, makeup, and other accessories.

Each monthly box contains at least three full-sized beauty products in addition to an assortment of samples, and compassion is at the forefront, as a portion of its sales benefits animal rights and environmental causes.

Who Is This Box For?

This subscription box is great for people who prefer vegan products and eco-friendly packaging.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Kinder curates the products for you.

Pros

  • Great to discover vegan and eco-friendly products
  • Get a mix of full-size and sample products

Cons

  • There are more sample sizes than full-sizes

What Readers Say:

"While I have tried numerous subscription services for beauty products, Kinder Beauty Box has given me products that I have fallen in love with, and I've seen dramatic improvement in my skin's appearance with their vegan and cruelty-free products. I also really enjoy how many full-sized products come in this box each month, and I love their add-on and holiday shops!" - Jocie ran

"Great selection of natural beauty and skincare!" - Dani

Shipping: Kinder Beauty Box ships to Antigua and Barbuda, Argentina, Australia, Austria, Bahamas, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, El Salvador, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hong Kong, Iceland, India, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, Lithuania, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Peru, Poland, Portugal, Singapore, Slovakia, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Taiwan, Thailand, Turkey, United Kingdom, United States, Romania, and Uruguay.

Starting at $26.00
Try Kinder Beauty Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Kinder Beauty Box reviews.

17. Boxwalla Beauty

The best subscription for the indie beauty lovers

Image from our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

This bi-monthly beauty subscription box features full-sized and deluxe travel samples containing cruelty-free, nutrient-rich beauty products. Crafted by artisans around the world, each box is themed around a different aspect of what Boxwalla Beauty calls "the beauty ritual."

Boxwalla also curates boxes for three other categories, including books, film, and food, so you can shake things up and switch between genres from your second box for the most well-rounded experience.

Who's This Box For?

This box is great for people who love discovering new indie beauty brands and are interested in products that complement one another.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Boxwalla chooses the products for each month well in advance according to their themes.

Pros

  • You get full-sized and deluxe products in every box
  • Products build from box to box, so you'll get a full routine over the year

Cons

  • Only 2-3 products every other month might not be enough for some customers

What Readers Say:

"You can tell that they spend time curating these boxes because what's inside is so thoughtful and generous. Plus, I love the fact that it's every other month so you don't get bogged down in product." - Jen Carnegie

"Out of all the boxes I've subbed to, Boxwalla is the only box that has consistently offered high-quality products that I'm happy to receive month after month (every other, but still). The curation is beautiful, and the reusable boxes are the prettiest, most durable, and nicest to display." - Elaine Kaiser

Shipping: Shipping within the U.S is free, but it is $11.95 to Canada.

Shipping to the rest of the world could vary from country to country. To most countries, shipping will be $18.95

Starting at $49.95
Try Boxwalla Beauty
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Boxwalla Beauty reviews.

18. FaceTory Lux Plus

The best subscription for skincare

10 items gathered around the Facetory Lux Plus box

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Keeping your visage glowing and hydrated can be serious business. Good thing there's the quarterly FaceTory Lux Plus to make it fun. Sheet masks could be the easiest way to ensure your face is moisturized, so FaceTory Lux Plus makes sure you've got lots of options in your pursuit of good skin. With each quarterly delivery of this beauty subscription, subscribers receive 10 to 12 items inside this colorful box, ranging from sheet masks to specialty items and full-size beauty products.

No matter what products you receive, sophisticated ingredients are the default. It runs $49.95/box with free shipping and has a new curation by the FaceTory team every season. Every season's box comes with a helpful companion guide that's filled with beauty tips and tricks to aid in creating your optimal skincare routine.

Who's This Box For?

This box is for people who want to mainly focus on discovering good skincare with yummy ingredients.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; FaceTory sends you a wide variety of pre-selected skincare items.

Pros

  • An affordable option for just skincare products
  • Each box comes with 10 to 12 products each time

Cons

  • Mainly focuses on skincare
  • Only ships quarterly

What Readers Say:

"Facetory is by far the best value for luxury products I wouldn't be able to find on my own. It is exactly why I got into subscription boxes - new products at a great price. Exactly what I didn't know I needed." - Ray w

"A consistently good box that's always well-curated! A great way to discover Korean skincare." - Paula C.

Shipping: Free U.S. shipping for orders of $35+ but international shipping prices vary by country and start at $9.95.

Starting at $49.95
Active Deal
Save 20% off your first box!
Use Coupon Code MSA20
Try FaceTory Lux Plus
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our FaceTory Lux Plus reviews.

19. Scentbird

The best subscription for finding your new fragrance

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Let's face it, trying to nail your signature scent can be difficult. Gone are the days of relying on samples in fashion magazines or being misted by an eager beauty department staffer. Committing to an entire bottle of one perfume also feels like too much of a stretch when you're searching for something seasonal.

Enter Scentbird, a subscription that takes the guesswork out of finding your signature scent. You'll choose one scented item a month and you’ll receive a free atomizer and the scent, which you load up to get your sprays. Once you sign up for a subscription, you'll take a quiz to help determine your preferences. In turn, the experts at Scentbird will create a list of custom recommendations for you to try. You can also browse and rate the rest of their selections to make your suggestions even more accurate.

Subscribers love the flexibility found in either building a queue of fragrances they find intriguing or trying their hand at a monthly surprise.

Who's This Box For?

This is the perfect subscription for people who just love to try new perfumes each time without having to pay hundreds of dollars at Sephora or Macy's.

Is This Box Customizable?

Yes; you select a fragrance each month.

Pros

  • Helps you discover your signature fragrance
  • Super affordable option

Cons

  • Might not be the best option for people with sensitivity to smells
  • No returns available

What Readers Say:

"I like it, I've had it for quite a while now, great perfumes and cases and good customer service that gets right back to u within a day." -Mmiller1118

"Scentbird is a great subscription service. I am a perfume addict and I like picking my own scents out for my queue. The bottles last quite long, more than one month per scent, and I put perfume on s couple of times a day. I have discovered in over a year at least 3 scents that are must-haves for me. Their customer service is good, I have never had any issues. The value of the product you get is great if you love perfume. Definitely subscribe if you're on the fence!" -MSA user

Shipping: The Scentbird subscription service ships to the US and Canada for free. This includes US territories and PO boxes.

Starting at $16.95
Try Scentbird
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Scentbird reviews.

20. Tribe Beauty Box

The best subscription for supporting women of color

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Absolutely obsessed with makeup? Then Tribe Beauty Box might be the best beauty subscription box for you.

This bi-monthly beauty subscription box is owned by women of color that feature 4-5 full or deluxe-sized products from indie beauty brands. Your delivery will include one product specifically for face, one tool, one product specifically for eyes, one lip product and/or one lip prep product.

Who's This Box For?

This is great for beauty lovers who want to support women and people of color in their journey as business owners. It's especially great for discovering indie products of great quality.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; products are curated by Tribe Beauty Box.

Pros

  • Four to five full-sized products included in each box
  • Every box promises variety

Cons

  • Made up of only indie brands, which could be hard to buy in person if you love the product

What Readers Say:

"Such an incredible box, with a great variety and high-quality products - it makes my day!" - Sophiaj

"Best make-up box out there! Best customer service! Works directly with brands. What you see for spoilers is actually what you get!" - askluna

Shipping: The Tribe Beauty Box ships worldwide, but it's only free within the United States. International shipping depends on location.

Starting at $39.99
Active Deal
Save 10% off your first box!
Use Coupon Code MSA
Try Tribe Beauty Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Tribe Beauty Box reviews.

21. LOOKFANTASTIC

The best subscription for those who need a little guidance

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box

Started in the UK, LOOKFANTASTIC now has a US site that delivers a monthly beauty subscription curated around a theme.

Subscribers can expect to receive at least 6 skincare, haircare, makeup, and body products with each delivery. Aside from products galore, you'll also receive a copy of the UK version of Elle Magazine, a great guide for keeping you in the know of international trends from a number of global beauty brands. In addition, there's a handy booklet to walk you through every item inside your box.

Who's This Box For?

LOOKFANTASTIC is great for people who just love a good theme each time with their boxes and who might need a little help with the products they get. Beauty isn't always super intuitive and this box really helps you navigate it.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; the experts at LOOKFANTASTIC select all products.

Pros

  • Comes with an Elle magazine copy
  • You get at least six products each time

Cons

  • Contents of box remain a mystery until you get it

What Readers Say:

“Always a good deal and consistently a good mix of makeup, skincare and hair care products.” – Phoebe

“I feel that the items are a tad more luxurious and definitely more unique than other boxes around the same price.” – MSA reader

Shipping: Ships to the United States and Canada.

Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Lookfantastic Beauty Box reviews.

22. Cocotique

The best subscription for self-care fans

Full Contents for Cocotique December 2020

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Cocotique is a monthly subscription box delivering beauty and lifestyle products specifically created for women of color and diverse ethnicities.

Each month, subscribers receive a curated box of 5-8 full-size and travel deluxe sample products ranging from hair care, skincare, nails, fragrance, and makeup, to lifestyle products, and more. You'll also receive a canvas tote bag with a powerful message printed on it to better carry all your beauty scores.

Find something you love? Cocotique has the full-size versions for sale in their shop, streamlining the discovery process as you unbox your latest fav!

Who's This Box For?

This box is for women of color specifically, who feel like other boxes are usually exclusive of their skin color or hair needs.

Is This Box Customizable?

No; Cocotique chooses the products for you.

Pros

  • Offers a variety of products for subscribers such as body care, hair care, skincare, and nails
  • Specifically targets women of color

Cons

  • Need to buy separately if you like a sample size product

What Readers Say:

"I love that their products are for me. All products aren't made the same especially for women of color. We have different textures of hair and skin types." - Stacy

Shipping: This box ships to the United States only.

Starting at $30.99
Try Cocotique
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our COCOTIQUE reviews.

23. BeautyBox by Bombay & Cedar

The best subscription for essential oil fans

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Bombay & Cedar is a luxury beauty subscription box for women that features cruelty-free full-size and deluxe-size beauty products. For $34.95 per quarter, you receive 5-6 full-size products with a retail value of over $120. You'll also get a mix of well-known brands and indie ones, helping you explore past what's in stores.

Who's This Box For?

This box is great for people who want to explore indie brands while also getting products from their favorite mainstream ones.

Is This Box Customizable?

Unlike other Bombay & Cedar boxes, the beauty box isn’t customizable.

Pros

  • Offers a wide range of products
  • Features cruelty-free products

Cons

  • Reviews don't support it as much as other brands

What Readers Say:

"One of the best vegan boxes out there. Super unique box! Loved everything I’ve gotten so far. 10/10 would recommend!" - Naomi

Shipping: This box ships worldwide. It's free for the United States. But you must pay $10.95 for it to ship to Canada. For the rest of the world, shipping is $17.95 per box.

Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our The Beauty Box by Bombay & Cedar reviews.

24. Petit Vour

The best subscription for getting reward points

Image via our review.

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box

Interested in vegan beauty? Petit Vour is a beauty subscription box that showcases a range of cruelty-free products.

Petit Vour's monthly box contains a mix of sample products and full-size items from unique, high-quality, standard progressive brands. Consider Petit Vour an easy way to elevate or recreate your beauty routine with a truly luxurious curation.

Each month subscribers will receive 4 products (always valued over $50) of non-toxic and plant-based beauty, curated to your beauty profile for as low as $15/box. Plus, get $4 back each month in-store credit for reviewing your box. You'll be excited to try products from brands like French Girl, Kani Botanicals, Leahlani, OSEA, Rahua, and Suntegrity to name a few.

Who's This Box For?

This box is great for those who want to discover ingredient-conscious alternatives to the products they use most, in vast beauty categories from skincare solutions to cosmetics essentials.

Is This Box Customizable?

No, but the box is curated according to preferences you set in your profile.

Pros

  • Luxury products in every single box
  • Vegan and clean beauty

Cons

  • Might be brands you've never heard of before

What Readers Say:

"Petit Vour is the best value for a cruelty-free beauty box out there. You get the chance to try everything from drugstore to luxury, and you earn point rewards for reviewing products in your box each month." - Sherry

Shipping: This box ships to the United States for free, to Canada for $10.99, and to other countries starting at $19.99.

Starting at $18.00
Try Petit Vour
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Petit Vour reviews.

25. Nourish Beauty Box

The best subscription for those want super glowy skin

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Nourish Beauty Box is a plant-based, skin-focused subscription that sends subscribers 4 full-sized beauty products every month that are crafted mindfully and sustainably. They also have a Build-Your-Own-Box option–which is not a subscription–that allows you to choose four products to try. If you want to try Nourish items but aren’t ready for a subscription, that may work for you.

Who's This Box For?

This box is for the people who are interested in discovering new brands that stick by a straight clean and vegan criteria.

Is This Box Customizable?

The monthly subscription box is not customizable; the Build-a-Box option is.

Pros

  • Plant-based products
  • Can customize your boxes

Cons

  • Will include brands you might not know
  • Not a lot of reviews

What Readers Say:

"Fun box, a lot of new items I've never seen before. Very clean ingredients. Each shipment comes with a small tote that is cute, but I have no use for a new one each month. Canceling was a breeze, fast customer service." - MSA reader

Shipping: Ships to the United States for free but for $27.95 internationally.

Starting at $29.95
Active Deal
Sign up for emails to get 15% off your first box
Try Nourish Beauty Box
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Nourish Beauty Box reviews.

26. Function of Beauty

The best subscription for customized beauty

What’s In This Beauty Subscription Box?

Function of Beauty is the world leader in customizable beauty, with hair, skin, and body care products made specifically for your individual needs. Each product is formulated using the latest science and technology to craft products that address dryness, sensitivity and other issues you may be having with your skin or hair. Unlike the other subscriptions in this list, this is not necessarily a box that will introduce you to new brands but rather one you customize as desired; you’ll then receive items depending on the frequency you choose.

Who's This Subscription For?

This box is great for the people who are so over trying to guess what beauty products work best for them. If you want to customize your products to your liking, this is the place to be.

Is This Box Customizable?

Yes! You can choose the color and fragrances of the products you want. You can also edit your profile to change your products for new issues or changes in your skin or hair.

Pros

  • Customizable haircare brand
  • Can edit your customization whenever you need it

Cons

  • Non-refundable products

What Readers Say:

"I love the customization that comes with Function of Beauty. With so many choices out there, it’s nice to see a company that caters to all of my hair needs." - Valeria Kramer

"I purchased a shampoo, conditioner, body wash, and body lotion from Function of Beauty, and couldn't be happier with my purchase. The shampoo and conditioner are absolute perfection for my hair, and the scent is fabulous--spot on with what I chose, not too heavy or too light. The body wash is sudsy and fragrant, and always leaves me feeling clean without any residue. The body lotion is my favorite item in this purchase. The lotion is rich and smooth, without being too thick or greasy, and the fragrance (rose) is delightful. My coworkers often ask me what scent I'm wearing after I apply this and they're shocked to learn that it's from a fragranced lotion. Function of Beauty is one of my best discoveries of 2021!" -Kari Roberts Carruolo

Shipping: Function of Beauty ships worldwide: the United States (including Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands), Australia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia, the EU, Great Britain, Hong Kong, Iceland, Israel, Japan, South Korea, Mslexico, New Zealand, Norway, Singapore, Taiwan, and the United Arab Emirates.

Starting at $49.99
Active Deal
Get 20% off your first large hair set
Try Function of Beauty
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Function of Beauty reviews.

How to Get The Most Out of Your Beauty Subscription Once You’ve Picked

So now that you’ve chosen a beauty subscription, what’s next? We’ve got some general tips to help make sure you make the most of your new subscription:

  • Start with a monthly or bi-monthly box. Annual subscriptions can dramatically cut your costs, but it’s a big commitment. Unless you’re sure that you’ll love everything you get, it often makes sense to start smaller. By starting with a single box, you can then determine whether the service is a good fit for your beauty needs and lifestyle.
  • Use coupons and discount codes. Wherever possible, we’ve included coupons and promo codes to keep costs low. You can always come back and try other alternatives next month!
  • If your service offers personal curation, fill out your profile. Curators use profile information to send you products you’ll love. Whether you’re declaring your preference for a certain lip color or marking down allergies and skin sensitivities, your profile will help you enjoy each new delivery.
  • Make a plan for extras. As your beauty subscription gets underway, you may find yourself with some products you just don’t open because you don’t need them, or a new box may arrive and you’re not done using other products. You’ll need a plan for what to do with the products you never open, haven’t opened or have only used once. Do you have friends or relatives who want to try new beauty products? Will you set aside a drawer for all your goodies and just stack extras until you need them? Plan for that as you wait for your first box to come in.
  • Read the ingredient lists carefully. For all beauty products, it’s a good idea to test a small amount on your skin before applying a larger amount. If you have special preferences, email the subscription provider; even if they don’t offer customization, they may be able to make accommodations.
  • Leave reviews after receiving your products. Some subscription services offer discounts for active reviewers, but even if your box doesn’t offer this perk, you’ll be able to provide your fellow subscribers with valuable information about the products. We also encourage our readers to review makeup subscription boxes on our site —- a quick review can help someone find their new obsession.
  • Try other subscriptions. Even if you like a beauty box, there might be others out there that catch your interest. If you sign up for a service that only gives you samples, for instance, think about trying a box that offers only full-sizes. This will keep things exciting and you’ll get a bigger mix of different products that you can add to your collection.

Factors We Considered When Reviewing These Beauty Subscriptions

This list features our fellow subscription fanatics’ top choices, and we can confidently recommend the subscriptions above since we’ve researched and reviewed them all. Factors we considered when reviewing these subscriptions include:

  • Price and Value: Beauty boxes often advertise the overall value of the products in each box. We prioritized services that provided accurate descriptions of that value. We sought out subscriptions that provided clear information about what was included in each box — including information about whether the products were full or sample sizes. We also considered whether they offer luxury brands, drugstore brands or both. Brands offering luxury products will often cost a bit more.
  • Packaging: While most subscription boxes maintain a low carbon footprint compared with alternatives, we tried to find beauty subscriptions with recyclable packaging and sustainably sourced products. This list contains a large number of vegan and cruelty-free makeup subscriptions, which reflects our readers' preference for eco-friendly choices.
  • Variety and Selection: Most of the cosmetic subscription boxes we’ve covered offer products from a variety of brands. When a box focuses on a single brand, we’ve tried to make sure that they offer a decent selection — in other words, members won’t receive the same products repeatedly during longer subscriptions.
  • Additional Perks: We’ve listed information about discounts, add-on gifts, and other perks that make each makeup subscription worthwhile. After all, those perks can add up!

Finally, we looked for beauty subscription companies with strong reputations. We wanted to make sure that members could change, pause, or cancel their subscriptions at any time. Our goal is to help you start living the subscription lifestyle without worrying about unexpected charges or long-term obligations.

We love a high-quality beauty subscription box, and we’re excited about our reader’s selections. Be sure to leave a comment if you’ve tried any of the services listed above (or if you’d like to see another service included in our next list).

That wraps up our list of the best beauty subscription boxes! Which ones are your favorites?

Sophia Caraballo
Sophia Caraballo
Sophia Melissa Caraballo is a Puerto Rican native living in New York City, writing about everything from beauty and food to celebrities and lifestyle for a living. She graduated from the University of Puerto Rico-Mayaguez with an English bachelor's and pursued a master's in journalism from Syracuse University.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

540 comments

Mallorynyx

While I agree that this article was very poorly written, this is to clarify someone’s earlier comment which stated that the publication had incorrectly used the term “bimonthly”; straight from Merriam-Webster:
Bimonthly- adjective
bi·​month·​ly | (ˌ)bī-ˈmən(t)th-lē
Definition of bimonthly:
1: occurring every two months
2: occurring twice a month

So the word itself is very ambiguous as both ways of using it (to mean twice a month *or* once every two months) are equally correct .

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Lautie

I can’t believe that Laurel & Reed didn’t make the list. It comes through with wonderful skincare products month after month. I have yet to get a blah box from them. Glad to see that Beauty Heroes & Boxwalla made the list. They too come through every month with a great box. New Beauty has become a disappointment and I finally let it go.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Joanne

Found See New from this article last week and decided to purchase after seeing some reviews. I have to say, after trying my box last night I am over the moon about my new subscription! Thank you for the introduction MSA.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Vicky

Anyone else confused how Ipsy and Boxycharm are the top 2, yet all the comments on all their posts are horrible?? Doesn’t add up

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Laurie

So tired of all of the garish pallets from Boxy. I stay subbed to the premium to get more skincare and access to the drop shop.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Melissa

Yeah, well also look at how stupid the categories are: “The best subscription for the ultimate Ipsy experience.” Geez, let me guess, is it one of the Ipsy variations? “Best subscription for fans of Macy’s” Geez, could it be the Macy’s subscription? There was absolutely no thought put into this. Plus, the fact of the matter is that people are probably more likely to post a comment on a post if they are unhappy with their box than if they are happy with it. But I totally get what you are saying.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Liz

How old is this article?? Clean Beauty Box went out of business April 2021, so almost a year ago!
Also, Boxwalla got voted as best beauty sub to get two boxes a month from. I’m sorry, but that’s not what bi-monthly means! 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️ Boxwalla sends a beauty box out ONCE EVERY OTHER MONTH! NOT 2 boxes a month! Oy……

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marie

Wow…these are some of the bigger blunders.

They even double-downed on the Boxwalla error listing a con being that twice monthly boxes are expensive.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Liz

Hahahah I didn’t even catch that but that’s really funny. Like, what is happening here!? 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Like This CommentLike

Allyson

Was very happy to see See New box on this list, one of my favorite discoveries this past year.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Meghan

SO FRUSTRATED WITH GLOSSYBOX AND DO NOT RECOMMEND!
GlossyBox continues to disappoint me. I did not receive the special box in October. Then I received an email saying I would get a free box in November as a thank you gift and apology for October. Then I did not receive that free box and customer service basically said “oops, we ran out and nothing for you”.
I ordered my advent calendar IN SEPTEMBER and it is December 1 and is has not even left the warehouse yet.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Tonya Hemms

I love shopping now and then I am married but still Care more family stuff use to be the shopping queen back in the day do you have any samples. Too

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Becky

Opinions on FabFitFun? I was a subscriber a yeqr ago but cancelled due to poor delivery and poor communication. A couple of times i didnt receive a box. I loved it when i started but it went down hill fast. I want to try it again but what your opinion. Thank you.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Adriana

Just start a new post. Some of the companies listed arent even in business lol.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kelly

True! This is dated about a month ago, but it’s just a reprint from last year. Clean Beauty is no more!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Binky Melnik

“With a steadfast commitment to extraneous quality”: Did you really mean to tell us that Beauty Heroes has a commitment to irrelevant quality (and therefore we should skip this one), or did you just use the wrong word? I was thinking I’d pick that box until I saw that; now I’m thinking you don’t really like the box but still want the commission that comes from our signing up for it. 😕 (Don’t get me wrong; I appreciate the honesty. I’m just double-checking. Thanks!)

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

L

Oh, come on, baby steps. Let them learn “bimonthly” first.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

custom box

I think this post proved that your are my best friend
Only this post proved that any body is not equal you and your level

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Lynn

Are the pictures provided an actual representation of what is in a single box?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Harmony

The Boxycharm box is accurate, but it’s usually more exciting than the box in the photo. My May box had a Tarte Shape Tape Glow Wand, a bottle of SkinFix “Daily Dose of Uplift” serum, a Kab Beauty palette, a brow pencil, and a pair of very sturdy tweezers – all full sized.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

SpeedAngel

Yeah but ipsy bought them out last year so it’s like a repeat of items.

Like This CommentLike

Frances Floyd

Idk about the others but Scentbird doesn’t send you a full sized perfume. You get a small travel sized ‘bottle’ with a case. Great perfumes but the representation is wrong for that picture.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Liz

How is Allure #4 and Birchbox #5 when anytime spoilers or reviews are posted, the majority of the comments are about how Allure’s price hike isn’t worth it and that the quality has gone down since then?? And the volume of comments about how much everyone hates BB because of the tiny samples makes me doubt how they could even make it onto a top 23 list let alone #5?!?
(Btw, I 100% agree with everyone on these points)

Oh and yea. There’s the fact that these comments were all posted from 1+ years ago that makes this “2021” survey 100% unbelievable! Lololol 😂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kristin

These comments date back 2 years how are these 2021 winners?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Mary L.

They update this post every year with the new winners rather than starting a new post.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

inkchick

Boxwalla is the only box that has never made me unhappy at ALL. The products are always stellar and their customer service is the platinum standard. I love them madly.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Liz

What about Beauty Heroes?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Tamara Courchene

I see all these comments and one i dont see is my favourite it is the Box from Fashionsta This one i will say will be on top 5 easy in next 3 years if not sooner they are not very old but they put all there heart in soul in this box and they have a great mans to .I watched as the got off the ground and i have been with them for about 15 very happy months this team is Amazing and humble they also give back to womens Mission if you want to try something new and this is skincare and makeup give this box a try good for all ages and no glitter you wont be sorry .❤❤

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Stephanie

Which box has the glitter I love it….. Also I wanted to ask which box picks there box based off your quiz questions/your preference because I don’t use blush I don’t use anything eye brow no foundation (no liquid) but powders, tinted moisturizer ECT…. Just needed some help here because I’ve been with ipsy over 7 years been using ipsy glam bag plus for about 3 now but lately they have sent wrong products, products Missing, not going off my quiz, sending the same stuff I’m beyond frustrated because I freaking loved them for so long…. Yes I’m a stay at home mom and that is my huge excitement for the whole month I’m absolutely devastated I don’t want to change but my husband hates them. There is no number to contact them also there is no refund even when they charge you for 2 13 dollar bags plus my original bag The glam bag plus…. So I’m totally open minded to any suggestions any options or opinion…. Anything please help if I won’t get anything I won’t have anything to look for coming in the mail for me. I know I’m a big loser for that is my high light of the month plzz don’t judge me but I need some information!!!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Cmaritaylor

I totally agree about The Box by Fashionsta! The are amazing and the value is always amazing for the price of the box!!! I love that you get a box filled with awesome indie brands that are so good for your skin!!!! My favorite gel moisture came from that box!!!! The Box is definitely my #2 favorite.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Denise

I 1000% agree with you, I LOVE my box from Fashionsta, The Box! They are my favorite box hands down, I get Ipsy, Boxycharm, ETC however my Box from Fashionsta is my favorite, they are always putting new to me products, Indie brands, brands I’ve fallen in love with since getting the box and I too have been getting it for well over a year now! I think I started getting it the 3rd month they opened it up! I use 100% of the products vs my other boxes that I might only use up to maybe 3 of the products, and I don’t plan to cancel anytime soon either! I LOVE it so much that they give back to the women’s shelter there! Some of them woman come there with just the clothes on there backs! They get a great start back into life bcuz of this wonderful program they have! I too used to donate all my gently used clothes and my children’s clothes to a local women’s shelter in my area! I just can’t say enough good things about The Box! I highly recommend this box too, I’ve never received the mens box but I can definitely vouch for the women’s box! Highly recommend!! ❤️❤️ Never disappointed EVER!! ❤️❤️

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Michele

I loved BoxyCharm. The monthly box was full size products that were fantastic. The eyeshadow kits were maybe a bit too young for me (almost 50) but I loved everything else, especially the skin care items.

My major disappointment was the popup shop. On 4 separate occasions I ordered from the Popup shop. I never once received my orders. BoxyCharm was quick to refund my money but I would have preferred receiving the items. This is a known complaint of many subscribers. It is apparently hit or miss. Unfortunately for me it was a miss every time.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

pili

I have IPSY, and it’s amazing, I pay 25$ per month but there are add ons, and I’ve received excellent products. I’ve paused my subscription and then come back, and there’s no penalty whatsoever. I recently upgraded to Glam Bag X and i’m truly happy with IPSY. there are skin care makeup hair care products, and it depends on your profile. But so far I would recommend it with my eyes close. A friend that tried many different boxes she told me ipsy was the best and I agree with her.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Natalie Abrahamian

Mintd Box will always be one of my favorites. Sad to see it’s not mentioned here. Their products are always amazing!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Cat

I hope I don’t regret subscribing to the See New Skincare box! It seems like it’s not mentioned a lot.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kelly

See New Skincare is amazing you’ll love it all their boxes have been pretty amazing.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Connie

I agree. See New Skincare is great. I just resubscribed after trying a few other boxes and missed this box. A good selection of quality products and customer service is excellent.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jordan

I was surprised to not see it on here as well! I’ve tried their most recent box and loved it so I’m sure you’ll enjoy it! tbh you get more products in their box for a way higher value which i think most people don’t realize

Like This CommentLike

Aarjullor

You won’t regret it, it’s great! It seem like when the company comes up in a tread, lots of people come out to praise it. I’m not sure why MSA doesn’t review it. It’s a fantastic sub.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Cynthia

I agree 100%✓
I was with ipsy for over a year & I enjoyed it even though it was samples but the cost was low.
I kept seeing ads for Boxycharm but kept putting off switching…always got busy, out it off…now after several months with Boxycharm & only paying like $12 more, I can’t even image the amount of product I would have had had I just changed to Boxycharm much sooner! Not to mention, I use almost every single item I’ve received!! I’m finding huge treasures in the add on products with sales at up to 93% off on products I would buy at full price for quality and effective skincare! Idc about the charms really but whether I use them or not, I’m getting a huge bargain every single month and finding great products that otherwise I’d not have known about!! If I would change anything at all, it would be that I could upgrade to the next price box as I don’t need 2 boxes per month but other than that, it’s a complete success, not one complaint from me at all bc I love pampering myself, I love pampering my skin, I love surprises and I get all that for a small fee of $25 a month 😃❤️
If we have to ever cut back on extras at my house, I would prefer some of my tv packages be downsized than to let my boxycharm go! Where were these when I was in my 20s, 30s & 40s as this year, I start my 50th year being alive and loving beauty and skincare ❤️🎇
Like the og poster said, just go ahead and do it! You won’t be disappointed!
PS I’m getting absolutely no kickback for my honest opinion either. I’ve actually just gotten my friend to join after an evening of discussing a good skincare regimen for her and I’m not even doing the refer a friend for the charms! When mine add up to a substantial amount, I will buy myself a little something extra but until then, if I never even use them, I’m saving tons of money and having fun doing it ❤️ thank you BC for such a great experience each month and off the chart products ❤️
🎉Happy New Year to all my fellow sublettes 🎉
Stay fabulous 💓

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Nicole Gens

Definitely FABFITFUN AND LOOKFANTASTIC!!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Linda

I have tried Boxycharnd the products are too young for me, glittery and dark purples and green eyeshadows for the young. I am a young 55 year old. What would be the best box for me. I love receiving the monthly boxes but I just need more age appropriate products. SUGGESTIONS PLEASE.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Patricia Sidor

I am 52 and I love my Macy’s beauty box. I’ve had it for over 2 years now. Lots of skin care and anti aging products.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

michelle

Linda, I’m your age and agree about Boxycharm. Allure is really great. I use so much of what I get. The cost has recently increased, but the January box was great and February is looking good too. Try Allure! If you’re looking for a budget box, Macy’s is pretty good, too, for $15.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Deb

Suggestions for boxes for ‘over 60’ age group
S?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

THE BOX by Fashionsta

Hey Deb, we have lot of awesome subscribers that are over 60 years old and enjoy our box. We try to have a nice mix of skincare, haircare and glam. Some of our palettes get a little colorful, but we always aim to keep things neutral for all age groups to enjoy! Check us out on IG and let us know if you have any questions. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Ashleigh

Journeebox

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

michelle

Allure or Macy’s.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jill

This is why I googled this as well. I had Birchbox for years and no matter what my profile, they continually send me pink or glitter for cheeks and eyes. I finally quit since I have a drawer of pink glossy lipstick/blusher.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike