Posted by on in Subscription Box News | Tags: | 145 comments

Subscriber Survey: What’s Your Favorite 2017 POPSUGAR Box?

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.


Sunday Subscriber Survey time! I thought it would be fun to look back on a year of POPSUGAR Boxes and ask, what was your favorite box this past year? And what was your favorite item?

Here is a refresh on every month:

January 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

February 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

March 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

April 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

May 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

June 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

July 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

August 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

September 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

October 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

November 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

December 2017 POPSUGAR Must Have Review

What was your favorite box or boxes this past year? My favorites: December, February, and October.

And what was your favorite item? (It’s tough to pick, but I’m going to go with the Turkish Towel from July!)

If you are new to POPSUGAR Must Have, it is a $39.95 a month lifestyle subscription box. Check out all of our POPSUGAR reviews to see what’s been in past boxes. And check out our POPSUGAR Spoilers to see what’s coming up in future boxes!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. December for sure. My other 2 favorite items are the Turkish towel and the yoga towel. I use the yoga towel and the Hawaii waterproof bag when I hit the sauna and they are super nice!

  2. October

  3. October

  4. Feb, May, Oct, Dec

  5. October and I’m sure once it arrives, December too. Every month had something special but October and December were extra special!

  6. Feb and aug

    • Same here!!

  7. October and December

  8. February!

  9. My faves were Jan, Mar, and Sept.

  10. September and October. The pink clutch fit my iPhone Plus perfectly. I use it every day. The throw and pillow set was my favorite for car and plane travel.
    Popsugar never fails to amaze me with the useful items in the curation. Love the food selections too. The value is definitely there even if everything is not exactly my taste.

  11. February and June ( yes, I said June). I would say December as well but I didn’t receive that one since I cancelled some months ago: (

  12. December, October, May and April!

    • CORRECTION, OCTOBER, DECEMBER, APRIL & JUNE! *September looked like the worst. I didn’t get that one.

  13. December and February for sure. I will say that Mother’s Day mystery box was amazing also.

    • The Mother’s Day box really was amazing!

  14. AUGUST! the tray and all items were so valuable. Least favorite are November and December. October was amazing too btw, close second.

  15. ***December*** is my fave of the year. I love the scarf and coasters, and would expect to see items of this type in the LE Holiday box.’

    In looking back, I TRULY ADORED every box except March and November. 🙂
    I think this was a GREAT PSMH year!!

    I can hardly wait until 2018. It may not be the ” fanciest” box or the “trendiest” box but I love that of all my sub boxes, I USE more of my PSMH products than any other box with some practical items.
    And, sometimes, the freebies are my favorites in the boxes.

    I adore the really pretty quality ” Free Spirit” rose gold journal from Jeep Wrangler, and the December candle so much!! My scent is Champagne, very pretty.

    • I love my champagne scented candle so much too!

  16. Loved September, October and December! Yes, I know September was very light but I have used all items, so that is a win for me.

  17. Just started the box in October. I think Dec. will be my favorite (please come tomorrow). I loved October and ordered Sept. with special pricing and really liked everything. Nov….Do I even need to comment on it?
    My favorite item so far is the wallet from Sept.

  18. Hands down: October. 2nd Place: August. Worst PSMH of All Time: Sept 2017 (I’ve been subbing for 4 years now.)

  19. September-loved the throw and pillow set!

  20. August, October, and December

  21. close, but february was definitely my winner.

  22. April and December

  23. September, October and I haven’t received December yet, but based on what I’ve seen and read, I’ll include it too.

  24. October & December! 💗

  25. I would say Aug, Oct and Dec. I really liked the Cheers tray and the Figs face primer.

  26. The only box I wanted and purchased is December. It has the best combo, a candle, a couple of nice accessories and a body care item. Perfect way to celebrate your customers this holiday season, Popsugar!

  27. In order, December, September, October, May, and February. I even paid full price for the first time ever, for a second December box to split up as gifts. I am gifting the necklace, scrub, scarf, and candle. I swapped both coaster sets. They’re very pretty but don’t work with my decor. I use the September items a lot.

  28. Not a subscriber but January and September/October looked most appealing to me. I really wish I loved spoilers enough to justify subscribing. The interesting items look incredible but I would just horde (and ultimately drown) in the unused items.

  29. April and December boxes. I love the Goldfaden and FAB mask. I also love the Aloha pouch from June. I thought I was going to hate it, but I’ve traveled with it a lot since I got it. It fits so much!

  30. I haven’t received Dec yet, but it’s probably a toss-up between May and Dec. I didn’t hey it, but October looked awesome, too. I liked every single thing in the May box and that’s such a rarity for me! Dec will depend on whether I like the items in person, but it looks fantastic!

  31. As I scrolled down I said “January was my favorite, no February was my favorite, no March was my favorite”. I realized I’ve loved every box this year except for November. No wonder this is my favorite sub.

  32. December and August

    • Agree!

    • Those were my favorites too!

  33. My favorite box / October & December.

    September was so close to be my favorite as well.

    My favorite item / eye mask from perpetual shade (October box) ,
    Sugar scrub ( December box).

  34. I would have loved April, but I missed out on it and I guess it never went on sale. So I guess December will be my fave when I receive it.

  35. August, February and December!!

  36. February and September.

  37. October.

  38. I think December will be my favorite…if it ever gets here! As a long-time subscriber, I am peeved that my box may not arrive before Christmas.

  39. October and December for sure. I loved May too. I pretty much liked every box with the exception of November. I didn’t care for it at all.

  40. December and April !!

  41. February, July, October and December. The turkish towel in the July box may be my favorite item, but it is so hard to decide! I also really loved the Tribe Alive clutch in the February box.

  42. October – coffee, body wash, and a travel blanket/pillow set!

  43. December and August!

    Couldn’t pick an individual item, but I always love getting home items.

  44. February, May, and June. Maybe in that order, though May and June are probably tied for second. I used and enjoyed everything in February’s box.

  45. December. I love that scarf a lot now that I have it, and wouldn’t have picked it for myself. I was a big fan of April when it came out, too.

  46. Favorite months were February and December. Favorite items were the habanero corn nuts from April and the Supergoop sunscreen mousse from July.

  47. December and January!

    • Ditto for me! And my favorite items are the clutch from February and the scarf from December.

  48. October and December, hands down.

    • Although, the Goldfaden from January was one of my favorite items!

  49. My favorite boxes were October and December ❤️

  50. July and October 😍

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!