Facebook PixelOur Subscription Box Favorites for April! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Our Subscription Box Favorites for April!

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanMay 14, 2018 | 19 comments

We've started a new monthly post highlighting our favorite discoveries from subscription boxes! Here are our favorite items from the past month:

Haley's Favorite:

The Item: Marc Jacobs Twinkle Pop Eye Stick, in Honey Bunny

The Cost: $28

From: Marc Jacobs Beauty Makeup Mischief Mystery Bag

Why I love it: I have loved these Twinkle Pop Shadow Sticks for a couple years now. The pigment and shimmers are bold and opaque, and the formula feels cooling and refreshing! They dry down and stay all day for me, they blend easily and wear well under other eyeshadow like a crease and outer corner color, too. I especially love these for Summer because they are so cooling, quick, and wearing them by themselves is enough for a pretty, simple look (which works especially well when paired with a bright lipstick, which I tend to wear most days for Summer!).

Read more reviews by Haley!

Anna's Favorite:

hot sauce

The Item: Hank Sauce Cilanktro Hot Sauce, 8 fl. oz. 

The Cost: $14.00

From: Robb Vices

Why I love it: There are people in the world who are SUPER into hot sauce, and I've certainly never considered myself one of them. But here I am telling everyone I know about this mouthwateringly good hot sauce! I don't find the cilantro taste to be all that strong, though I can tell it's adding an herby freshness to the flavor. To me, the garlic is the star of the show, and there's no better way to get me onboard with a food than adding oodles of garlic to it! I'm putting this on every omelet, taco, and sandwich I make this summer!

Read more reviews by Anna!

Nicole's Favorite:

The Item: Denim Body-Con Dress by Rebel Wilson X Angels Size 22W

The Cost: $129.00

From: Trunk Club

Why I love it: THIS DRESS IS EVERYTHING! I love versatile pieces like this one because you get a real bang for your buck. Sure, it is a bit pricey, but it seems reasonable when you imagine the infinite ensembles you will be able to style from this staple piece. It can be worn alone for a cute coquettish look or with a shirt underneath for an effortlessly cool outfit.  The adorable get-ups are infinite with this number! In addition, this dress is immensely comfortable to wear due to the flattering cut and the stretchy fabric. I had to pass on this one, sadly, but I sense I will make it mine! Someday!

Read more reviews by Nicole!

Jess's Favorite:

Plated March 2018

Plated March 2018

Plated March 2018

The Meal: Leek and Gruyere Galette with Dijon, Shallot, and Pine Nuts

The Cost: $13.50 a meal

From: Plated (Coupon: Save 25% off your first 4 weeks of Plated with any subscription plan (up to a $159.20 value))

Why I love it: A galette is not something I would normally attempt to make, so I love that Plated pushed me out of my comfort zone with this recipe! The end result was savory, flaky, and satisfying. The onions and leeks had a somewhat sweet, caramelized flavor that was really nicely balanced with the spicy crunch of the radish and nuttiness of the toasted pine nuts. So delicious.

Read more reviews by Jess!

Andy's Favorite:

The Item: Sierra Designs DriDown 650 Pillow

The Cost: $29.95

From: Cairn (Coupon: Use code TRAILHEAD to get the Trailhead welcome box your first month! Check out our review of the Trailhead Welcome Box to see what will be included.)

Why I love it: I ended up taking this with me on a 2-night kayak camping trip in West Virginia and it was a great addition to my sleeping kit. It tucked easily into the hood of my mummy bag and provided a nice amount of cushion to keep my head elevated while I slept in my hammock. The compressed pillow is so light that I plan on using it regularly in the coming months during backpacking and hiking trips as well - I'm ok with giving up the pack space for the added comfort since it's so lightweight.

Read more reviews by Andy!

Ragan's Favorite:

The Item: Black Tulip by Nest Fragrances

The Cost: Buy an 8 mL Rollerball for $27

From: Scentbird for Women (Coupon: Buy one month, get your second month free!, no coupon required, just use this link)

Why I Love It: Scentbird's “scent of the month” selections are hit or miss for me, and while I don’t normally like floral fragrances, I *do* normally like fragrances with “black” or “dark” or “noir” in the name.  This one has notes of patchouli, plum, violet, and pink pepper, and I think the patchouli and pink pepper moderate the violet enough, while the plum provides a little sweetness, to make this perfect for my tastes.

Read more reviews by Ragan!

Marne's Favorite:

info sheet for celestite

Celestite Crystal

The Item: Celestite Crystal

From: Enchanted Crystal

Why I love it: Gazing upon this pale grey-blue crystal instantly calms me and I love the many facets of its natural beauty!

Read more reviews by Marne!

 

Lacey's Favorite:

Letterboard

Letterboard

Photo on letterboard

The Item: 10" x 10" Letterboard

From: Parabo Box (Coupon: Use referral code MYSUBADDICT to get a free bonus item in your first box!)

Why I love it: This is a simple case of "I've almost bought one of these for myself so many times, I was so happy to get one in a box and not have spent twice as much money on it!" 🙂 But seriously, felt letterboards have been Instagram-cool for awhile now, so I'm surprised we've actually not seen one in a box until now. And it *is* a really cool way to display a photo, which I'd never have thought of without this example! After this particular box, Parabo Box did raise their price from $29.99 to $39.99 every other month, so I hope we continue to see them send unique and modern home items with the great value they are known for going forward.

Read more reviews by Lacey!

Rob's Favorite:

Sprezzabox

Sprezzabox

Sprezzabox

The Item: Original Penguin Tie 

The Cost: Listed Value $55

From: SprezzaBox (Coupon: Save 25% off your first month! with coupon code MSABOX25)

Why I love it: I absolutely love this tie - I’ve received plenty of ties from many subscriptions boxes over the years, but this is by far my favorite! The print is a classic and will pair with so many different colored button-ups! The quality is top-notch and the value of this tie is about double of the total cost to receive the box!

Read more reviews by Rob!

Jessica Hapak's Favorites:

5th Avenue Style April 2018 Review

The Item: April's 5th Avenue Style Monthly Subscription

The Cost: $98 a month

Why I love it: I think it may technically be cheating to choose an entire box as my favorite, but this box deserves the honor. Opening this box from 5th Avenue gave me that new subscription box feeling that we all got when we first started subscribing, and I hadn't felt that joy and excitement in a while. Everything in this box matches my style perfectly, only I feel like it is my style taken up a notch. This is the style of the Jessica I aspire to be. I can’t wait to build up a collection of stylish things and be one of the sharpest dressed law-students-soon-to-be-lawyers around.

Read more reviews by Jessica!

Christen's Favorite:

Nosejoy April 2018 therapy dough

Nosejoy April 2018 puddy

The Item: Pinch Me Therapy Dough, Spa Scent, 3 oz.

The Cost: $24.99

From: Nosejoy (Coupon: Use code MSA5 to save $5 off your first box!)

Why I love it: This is such a unique product! It’s stress-relief puddy that was developed by a clinical hypnotherapist to reduce stress. Not only does the squeezing motion relieve tension a la stress ball, but this product’s calming color (which is a little more purple-y in person) and lavender scent were both thoughtfully incorporated to aid in the endeavor of stress reduction. I love the scent it leaves on my hands after using it!

Read more reviews by Christen!

Laine's Favorite:

Helvetica Book Titles Premium Tee

The Item: Helvetica Book Titles Premium Tee

The Cost: Listed Value $25

From: Accio! Box (Coupon: Use code NEWSUBSCRIBER to save 10% off your first box!)

Why I love it: Not every Accio! Box comes with a tee inside, but when they are included, they are usually one of my favorite items from the whole month. They offer a really premium tee that is buttery-soft, and the fit is relaxed without being sloppy. This is the second month in a row that my favorite item has come from an Accio! Box, which isn’t a surprise to me - the boxes are so well-curated that the items are usually incredibly beloved in my house! This piece is an instant fan hit that anyone who knows the series well will instantly understand - I anticipate many compliments when I wear this out and about!

Read more reviews from Laine!

Brandi's Favorite:

The Item: Cocokind My Matcha All-Over Moisture Stick (0.5 oz)

The Cost: $8.99

From: NaturAli Trimester 4 Pregnancy Box (Coupon: Use code MSA15 to save 15% off your first box!)

Why I love it: This stick is awesome and can be used pretty much anywhere that you need a moisture boost- lips, under your eyes and it even says it can reduce dark circles. I use it nightly on my lips and it makes them feel super smooth. I’ve also used it on dry patches on my face and it clears them up overnight. It’s made from coconut oil, beeswax and matcha tea powder and has a slight tea scent, but is very mild. It feels incredibly moisturizing and I love that the stick is a bit oversized which means there is a bit more product and it’s easy to locate if you throw it in your purse.

Read more reviews by Brandi!

Kim's Favorite:

The Item: Peripeti Candles Bamboo Linen Room Spray 

The Cost: $5.00

From: The PMS Package (Coupon: Use code PMS25 to save 25% off your first box!)

Why I love it: This room spray is absolutely heavenly! The scent reminds me of a fancy combination of rain forests, laundry, and a fresh spring day. Not only have I used it to freshen drapes and couches, but I'm guilty of using it on my clothes, too. 

Read more reviews by Kim!

Colette's Favorite:

The Item: Obscura Rosé 2016 (California, USA) 

The Cost: Estimated Value $15

From: Bright Cellars (Coupon: Get 50% off your first month!, no coupon required, just use this link)

Why I love it: With the warm weather finally here - I officially proclaim it Rosé season in my home. And, in my opinion, this is an amazingly delicious Rosé. I found it to be refreshing, light, and full of character. The citrus flavors were the perfect complement and added the needed acidity to the sweet fruit notes. I plan on ordering a case of this to keep on hand all summer long! 

Read more reviews by Colette!

Buckle's Favorite:

The Item: Clam Overboard!

The Cost: $12

From: BarkBox (Coupon: Get a free extra month when you sign up for a 6 or 12 month subscription (SUBADDICTION) or $10 Barkshop credit (ADDICTION) any new BarkBox Subscription. Barkshop credit code emailed 3-5 business days after purchase.)

Why I love it: (busy playing)

Read more reviews by Buckles!

Eric's Favorite:

The Item: Krumm Sweater 

The Cost: Estimated Value $25-30?

From: The Nick Box

Why I love it: I thought that this was the best item from The Nick Box ever. It's just a fun a smart way to incorporate the character into an item!

Read more reviews by Eric!

 

What do you think of our favorites for April? And what were your favorite discoveries?

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

19 comments

TK

I’m pretty sure the tie you got in the Sprezzabox is the exact same tie my son got in the GQ box and he likes it too. I don’t know if I could pick only one item. PSMH did a great job with their first quarterly box.

Reply ButtonReply

PudgeKat

I love the pusheen throw and the lipgloss from psmh that smells and tastes like marshmallows!

Reply ButtonReply

Sam

Pusheen Box slippers!

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

Cutest slippers EVER 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Sharon in SE TX

My favorite was the Weleda Skin Food Travel Size – 0.34 oz from April’s Target Beauty Box. I had a some dry skin around my mouth due to a bad reaction from another skin care product and after a few days of using Skin Food, the peeling was gone. I’m using the tube now on my elbows.

Reply ButtonReply

Luna

I recently started to use this for the first time as a hand cream at night, and I absolutely love it! While on vacation a few weeks ago, the dry, hot air did a big number on my hands and completely dried them out. They’ve only now started to get back to normal, partly thanks to this cream. I love how it smells too!

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

That stuff is magic! I love the scent, too. I’m so glad I grabbed an extra box!

Reply ButtonReply

Ann

My favorite was the throw in the Pusheen box. My 3 year old sleeps with it every night. And we use the photo clips to hang the kids’ art under the mantle. We attached it with clear little command hooks. That is my new favorite box!

Reply ButtonReply

Kristin

Finally Buckles makes an appearance!

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

❤️

Reply ButtonReply

Mandy

My favorite item to receive in April is EVERYTHING in the Glossybox Mother’s Day box, actually.
The best item for me from the box is the Lancome Renergie’ Multi- Glow Rosy Skin Tone Reviving Cream. It doesn’t change my skin tone a bit, but it’s a great moisturizing cream and I love the light floral scent.

I bought 2 boxes just for this creme and the facial hydrating toner.
People may not always like GB but they have some fabulous Special edition boxes!

Reply ButtonReply

Luna

Yay, we got to see Buckle’s favorite! 😀

I’m not familiar with the character Eric’s sweater is supposed to depict, but you gotta love the hairy armpits. ha! I would totally get that for someone I know who would wear it proudly.

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

Glad you liked the picks from Eric + Buckles! I’ve never seen Eric more enthusiastic over a subscription box item 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Luna

No joke… if I had received that in a sub box, I think that would be by far one of my most favorite sub box items I’ve ever received!! 😀

Margie

Jessica Hapak, I’ll say it again- you are just too cute! But of course in a sophisticated, soon to be southern lawyer, kind of way.

Reply ButtonReply

judy

………we are missing Liz’s favorite!? 🙂 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

Liz Cadman

Ahh! Oops! It’s the Tammy Fender from the April Beauty Fix! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

judy

🙂 ….thank you!!! 🙂