5th Avenue Style Subscription Box Review – April 2018


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

5th Avenue Style is an accessories subscription box based out of New York City that specializes in luxury fashion items at a deep discount. Their motto is “Effortless Elegance” – and they boast that their company is made up of a team of highly professional stylists and fashion veterans. In the monthly subscription box, you are guaranteed 4-5 branded luxury accessories items with a minimum value of $250.

When you sign up for this box, or any of the variations (e.g. other subscription boxes, their membership club, or limited edition boxes) you will complete a short questionnaire indicating things like what colors you love, which you avoid, your preferred accessories, style, and metal color – and some sizing info where applicable (for instance, with rings).

There are several subscriptions available from 5th Avenue Style including:

  • SUBSCRIPTION BOXES ($98/month or 3 months for $279): Includes 4-5 luxury accessories items such as jewelry, scarves, bags, small leather goods, sunglasses with a minimum value of $250.
  • DELUXE SUBSCRIPTION BOXES ($159 or 3 months for $447): Features 4-5 branded luxury accessories items such as jewelry, scarves, bags, small leather goods, sunglasses with a minimum value of $350.
  • LIBERTY CAPSULE SUBSCRIPTION ($249 every 2 months): Liberty Capsule is a bi-monthly subscription that features 2-3 pieces of high-quality clothing and 1-2 accessory pieces.
  • QUARTERLY VIP SUBSCRIPTION BOX ($390 every 3 months): Features 4-5 items of brand name jewelry and accessories including popular European designers and seasonal items. This box has $900+ Retail Value.
  • QUARTERLY DRESS FOR SUCCESS BOX ($490 every 3 months): Features a branded handbag, 4-5 items of brand name jewelry and accessories along with upscale beauty and skin care products. This box has $950+ Retail Value.

Although the external packing isn’t much to look at – inside of the boring brown box the pieces are tenderly packaged and often beautifully wrapped.

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

This review is for the 5th Avenue Style Monthly Subscription, $98 a month, box.

About 5th Avenue Style

The Subscription Box: 5th Ave Style Monthly Subscription Box

The Cost: $98 + free US shipping

The Products: 4-5 branded luxury accessories items with a minimum value of $250

Ships to: Worldwide! “Anywhere where ladies desire upscale accessories.” Standard shipping is free in the contiguous 48 states. International shipping is $35.

Good to Know: 5th Avenue Style is notorious for slow shipping. For perspective, this box was ordered on March 14. They try to ship within 15 business days from the date of the order for their regular subscription box. This means my box should have shipped on or before April 4th, however it shipped on April 9th. Their quarterly boxes can be delayed by months, rather than weeks, but you do always get your box in the end!

5th Avenue Style April 2018 Review

5th Avenue Style has you fill out a survey when you subscribe to this box. You describe your metal preference, any colors you like or dislike, and your preferred accessories. There is also a section to leave a note to 5th Avenue. From what I have learned from the forum and people who have subscribed, the more details you give,  the better your chances of the box is just to your liking. Here is what I said in my note to 5th Avenue: I have very fat wrists that makes fitting bracelets difficult. I prefer necklaces I can throw over my head rather than clasping. I love dangly earrings. I prefer bags that can fit a wallet, an iPhone, and a makeup bag vs really small bags. I don’t use clutches (too scared of losing them!). I wear prescription glasses 90% of the time.

Now let’s see the box they put together based on all of that information!

Here is the invoice detailing the products I received. No prices are listed.

Cristina Sabatini Olivia Handbag in Pink

Cristina Sabatini Olivia Handbag in Pink – Retail Value $119 (provided by the bag company)

I legitimately squealed when I was opening this box and saw the gold chain intertwined with leather peek out. Then, after it was unwrapped in all of its glory, I was dumbfounded. This purse is everything. The gorgeous millennial pink/rose gold leather. The beautiful gold chain handle. The TASSEL. The combination of pink with gold is the perfect mix of fun color with elegant details, and I am in love with the tassel at the closure of the bag- and the spot right above the tassel is studded. The python leather is a design I have never owned before, but I think it goes with the style of the bag perfectly.

This purse fits my wallet, phone, and keys, so it fits the bare necessities for me. If I put my basics in a card case instead of my full wallet I would be able to fit a makeup bag in there too.The interior is lined with black and it has one inner pocket with no zipper. Honestly, I feel like when Cristina Sabatini designed this purse she did it with me in mind. In terms of how much this purse is worth, I could not find this purse anywhere on the internet, so I reached out to their customer service and they confirmed the $119 price. Similar-sized purses on the Cristina Sabatini website range from $175-$200. 

All of the jewelry came packaged in this sturdy white box.

Karine Sultan Liam Pendant Earrings – Retail Value $32

These 24k gold-plated dangle earrings had me swooning when I saw them. I mentioned in the notes that I love dangle earrings, so I was happy to see these! I thought they would be a bit bulky based on the way they look in their packaging, but when wearing them they look more delicate. They aren’t heavy, and these earrings are probably going to become my new go-to earrings. I couldn’t find them available for sale, so I reached out to Karine Sultan customer service! Margaux was very helpful and told me that these earrings are the Liam pendent earrings, the color is antique gold, and they retail for $32.

Here I am wearing the earrings and feeling very elegant.

ArtZen Oynx & 18K Gold Plated Sterling Silver Adjustable Ring

ArtZen Oynx & 18K Gold Plated Sterling Silver Adjustable Ring – Estimated Value $20

Right off the bat, I was impressed that I was sent a ring that matched the bracelet, and I was happy to find out that it fit! I have sausage fingers, so fitting rings are difficult. I mentioned this in my notes, and I am so happy to get an elegant ring that fits! Colette got the same ring with a different stone in her Deluxe box, and I was happy to get mine because when I read her review I thought it was really pretty. I reached out to ArtZen to try and find what they value their items at, but I have received no response yet, and I will update this review if I do hear back. In the meantime, I think my $20 estimation is on the low end, but I was doing my best with what I could find similar rings for.

Les Georgettes Wave Cuff Bracelet

Les Georgettes Wave Cuff Bracelet – Retail Value $79

Les Georgettes Iridescent Scales/ Soft Black Leather Band – Retail Value $17 (found here for $13.60)

When I saw the pretty pink box wrapped in a bow, I squealed again (a lot of squealing went on with this box). Les Georgettes is a brand I have seen in some other subscription boxes, and I am so stoked to have one of my very own. Plus— it fits! I mentioned in my notes that fitting bracelets are hard, but this one fits comfortably! Also, I didn’t even remember that the leather band was interchangeable until after I was done taking pictures. I actually like the iridescent scales side more than the black, because it has a bit of rainbow shift when the light hits it! In terms of quality, there is no question this French brand makes quality pieces. The bracelet is gold plated,

Here is the bracelet as I wore it today when the sun hit it just right. Stunning, right?

Here is the bracelet + ring being worn together. I love how they coordinate!

The Verdict: I am, quite simply, floored. Every single thing in this box feels like it was personal to my preferences, and I can tell attention was paid to the notes that I left. There is no doubt in my mind that each piece is of high quality, and opening this box gave me that same joy that I got the first time I got my first-ever subscription box. Even if some of the pieces are from past seasons, that doesn’t bring down the value in my mind — as long as what I receive is elegant, in style, and high quality I’m not hung up on if it isn’t the newest release. For $98 a month including free shipping, I got 4 amazing (and coordinating!) pieces for $24.50 a piece, and I think that is an amazing value for the high-quality items I received. While the shipping issues are a bit of an inconvenience, I do have hopes that 5th Avenue Style will improve their shipping in the future— just be aware of their history of slow shipping before you sign up.

The Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Because of the variation, it’s unlikely that you would get the same items that I’m showing here. The value should be similar and is promised to at least be $250.

Value Breakdown: At $98 for this box and an estimated value of $267, here’s what you are paying approximately per item:

  • Cristina Sabatini Handbag: $43.68
  • Karine Sultan Earrings: $11.75
  • ArtZen Ring: $7.34
  • Les Georgettes Bracelet w/ Leather Band: $35.24

Check out all of our 5th Avenue Style reviews and the Women’s Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of your subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of this month’s 5th Avenue StyleWill the moonstones help me see my future?

How do subscribers rate 5th Avenue Style?

68 subscribers rated this subscription
3.2
out of 5 stars
Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to 5th Avenue Style? Add your rating now!


Written by Jessica Hapak

Jessica Hapak

I am a staunch believer that pineapple doesn’t go on pizza and when I’m not studying for law school I’m relaxing at home with my cat. I’m a sucker for anything labeled a mystery box and I’ve never met a bath bomb I didn’t like!

Posted in 5th Avenue Style Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, UK Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: 5th avenue style | 24 comments

24 Comments

  1. It seems like they don’t ship until customer inquires about it. At least that had been my experiences. The value of the box is hit or miss – first one was disappointing, next one was good, then third one was just a bunch of Karine Sultan jewelry with no bag or clutch. I cancelled immediately after receiving the first box. Also, I have deluxe sub, which is $159/box but I received just about same stuff as this review of the $98/box. I will never sub again unless they offer some SIGNIFICANT discount or coupons.

  2. Slow shipping is an understatement . I am ready to demand a refund

    • It seems like they don’t ship unless customer inquired about the box.
      Once I send inquiry, I get reply in a few days with shipping date. 5th always apologize and send an extra gift for apology.

      • Ridiculous, and exactly my experience! One of the reasons why I won’t order anything more from them.

  3. If I could get the same items that you did I would order right now. Gold tone is my color of choice but might have to take links out of the earrings as I have short hair and cannot stand the movement of dangly earrings. See they were so good with this box they even sent earrings that could be adjusted for me. The pocketbook is really too small for all my stuff but I would just have to accept it. It is so pretty.

    • It is really beautiful, isn’t it? Sometimes I just look at it because I love it so much.

    • If you subscribe, you can send them a detailed email, really telling them your preferences. If you make a request, you just might get the exact thing, if they have it in stock. The more specific you are, the better chance you’ll like what you receive.

  4. This was a truly great review to read!! Thank you. And WOW – the box they sent you was stunning.

    I would sub if I was more convinced that I’d get something so well curated, fitting my style. But I think I’ve been burned too many times by other companies that promise but don’t do that that I’m reluctant to pull the trigger on a $95/mo box.

    • I can understand that, Beth! If you ever do decide to give 5th Ave a shot just make sure to be as detailed as possible in your survey.

  5. You seem like such a sweet person. I love reading your reviews, because they give detail and show enthusiasm. You got an awesome box, dying for that purse and the jewelry looks fab!

    Wasnt Karine Sultan also in an Emma & Chloe box? Or I’m getting confused lol…

  6. I’m having a hard time telling the difference between the lower priced box ($98/mo) and the deluxe box ($159/mo)? Is it just the total value of the items? A lot of the items seem similar between the boxes.

    • Hi AAC! I do believe the only difference is the promised retail value between the two boxes.

      • Thanks Jessica! I’m still waiting on the Deluxe box I purchased 2 months ago. So I guess I’ll wait to see if I should subscribe based on what I receive. 5th Ave said that it should be shipping this week, so looking forward to receiving it!

        • I am waiting on Spring Box ordered in Febuary They claim to be waiting on Paris bags .IMO
          I am getting tried of waiting just send me another bag if it isn’t high enough value send other items to make up for it.

    • Same here.. I sub Deluxe box and i received a clutch, earrings, necklace, and bracelet. All of my jewelry were from Karine Sultan brand. 5th Ave LOVES Karine Sultan.

  7. That purse is gorgeous! Love your reviews btw!

    • Thanks for reading, JSo!

  8. You are just the cutest! The reviews you do are so honest and candid. I find myself laughing out loud at some of your remarks. As long as you are reviewing I’ll keep reading! Thanks so much.

    • Awh shucks Margie! Thank you!

  9. Box is totally not my style no interest…..
    BUT….. can we take a minute to about your fantastic nails?

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

*