Posted by on in Subscription Box News | Tags: | 64 comments

Subscriber Survey: What’s Your Favorite FabFitFun Box?

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Sunday Subscriber Survey time! I thought it would be fun to look back on all of the FabFitFun Boxes and ask, what was your favorite box of all time? And what was your favorite item?

Here is a refresh on every box:

FabFitFun Spring 2013 Review

FabFitFun Summer 2013 Review

FabFitFun Fall 2013 Review

FabFitFun Spring 2014 Review

FabFitFun Summer 2014 Review

FabFitFun Fall 2014 Review

FabFitFun Winter 2014 Review

FabFitFun Spring 2015 Review

FabFitFun Summer 2015 Review

FabFitFun Fall 2015 Review

FabFitFun Winter 2015 Review

FabFitFun Summer 2016 Review

FabFitFun Fall 2016 Review

FabFitFun Winter 2016 Box Review

FabFitFun Spring 2017 Box Review

What was your favorite box this past year? It’s the Fall 2016 FabFitFun box for me – so many great, high-value items, and the blanket scarf is so cozy!

And what was your favorite item? So tough to pick, but I’m going to go with the Marrakesh Hair Oil from the Spring 2016 box. It smells SO good and I love how soft it makes my hair feel!

If you are new to FabFitFun, it is a $49.95 a quarter lifestyle subscription box. Check out all of our FabFitFun reviews to see what’s been in past boxes. And check out our FabFitFun Spoilers to see what’s coming up in future boxes!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Definitely Fall 2016. Although Spring 2017 is a close second. 🙂

  2. Fall 2016 was my favorite box and my favorite item was the blanket scarf. For me that box spoiled me. I haven’t much care for the boxes after that one.

  3. Fall 2016 box…loved the eyeshadow and scarf..also coloring book!!!

  4. Fall 2016 box was my favorite with Winter 2016 being a close second. I love trying new hair and skin products so all of those things have been a hit with me, but I really enjoy getting the Spongelle exfoliating sponges because they smell amazing and last nearly a month!

  5. Winter 2016!!! Or the welcome box that I got as my first box.

    It was fun looking back over all the boxes! They definitely just keep keep getting better! Can’t wait to see what’s next!

  6. Winter 2016 & Spring 2017 #Best Ever!

  7. The fall & winter 2016 and spring 2017. Those are my favs.

  8. Both Spring 2017 and the original Editor’s Box (Winter 2016 was sold out so I got Editor’s box) I think both were phenomenal.

  9. Best box: Spring 2016
    Best Item: Spongelle from Fall 2016. It was my first Spongelle, loved the fragrance.

  10. Winter 2015 is probably my favorite box, even though i have really enjoyed them all. Its hard to pick 1 box. Fall and winter 2016 are also my favs, as well as the last one. I loved the George hair stuff, ORG fave mask, candles, and the bullet necklace. Its hard to pick just one!

  11. My fave box, well i’ll say the last 2 as they are the one’s that finally got me to jump on FFF! (not the current editor’s though). I loved the scarf and blanket the most out of it – I use bracelet quite a bit too! Loved near everything in it and actually use near half of the stuff!! 😀
    My fave items from them are always scarfs/roundie type stuff, colorful polish, eye shadows, and hair stuff! But I like the variety, I am always surprised at how I can use, learn to love most of the stuff. This is my 1st sub to FFF and it’s a year’s sub so I sure hope they can keep it up! 😀
    Can’t wait for spoilers(enough about add ons, I have no money left to spend!!) !!!

  12. Fall 2016! Beautifully curated. I loved the necklace, candle and Manhattan Beach lotion, moleskine journal, notecards, and the Mineral Peel Face.

  13. I like Spring 2017 box! I can use every item in the box.

  14. Fall 2016 is probably my favorite box followed by winter 2015. Loved the scarf and use the mug and earbuds regularly. I subscribed right after the first box and they’ve only gotten better. As for favorite item, probably the kai perfume. It smells divine and I usually hate perfume. Followed by the Dr. Brandt microdermabrasion and Marrakech hair oil. Also loved the dermasuri mitt.

  15. I would have to say Fall 2016 is my favorite to date, but I also really loved Spring 2017!

  16. Winter 2015. Love those fingerless gloves! This was a nice trip down memory lane!

  17. I have been subscribing since spring 2015, but I have to pick Winter 2017 as my Favorite box. I loved everything in it. My daughter and I usually schoolyard pick the contents and I really wish I had bought two boxes because it was a real fight over the candle, the tangerine cream, and the journal :). Though as I am picking my favorite items, Summer 2016 was a close second choice.

    But it is hard to pick favs: but I have rebought the Stemulation scrub twice because I adore it and the Juara body cream is to die for. The compeed blister covers seem basics, but it has got us through two walking vacations and I am a huge fan. The Osea lotion is a must have also.

  18. 1st place: Spring 2017
    2nd place: Fall 2016

    I started my subscription in Winter 2016 (my first box). Feeling bad I missed the fall 2016 box.

    Favourite items: Dr.Brandt and DL&Co candle.

  19. Fall 2016, although I only subscribed on Spring 2017. I started paying attention to this box after Fall 2016.

  20. Spring 2017 is my favorite box. They raised their game by letting us select color choices and the value of the beauty products was unmatched. My favorite item was the Dr Brandt.

  21. I have gotten them all and my favorite was Spring 2014. I love that turband! We actually have a sisterhood of the traveling turband with my girlfriends now. So fun.

  22. Winter 2014 an Fall 2016. I’m actually a new subscriber (past two boxes) so it was fun to go back and look at all the previous boxes.

  23. I regret not getting the fall 2016 box. I can’t see myself subscribing until one is on par with that, fall 2014 or winter 2017. Fall 2016 is easily the one that leaves me most upset with myself for missing out.

  24. My first box Winter 2016. Loved the Tangerine body cream.

  25. Fall 2016 but my fav item, that I keep buying is the bath bombs from spring 2016

  26. I think all of their boxes since the winter of 2015 have been particularly awesome. I feel like FFF is one of the rare subs that has actually gotten better with time!

    • I think so as well.

  27. Spring 2017 for sure! There was only one product in the whole box that I didn’t want and that was the Briogeo because I don’t use hair products at all. I just loved how substantial the whole box was and it was like it just kept coming as I was unboxing it!

    • I just used that hair product today, and I like it. I have curly/frizzy kind of hair so it tames it down for me. I was going to purchase more of it through the “add ons” but it says it is already out of stock. 🙁

  28. Winter 2015 – my first box – fingerless gloves, Dermalogica skincare, the Juara creme, gift cards – they definitely hooked me in! Still a member.

    • Yes!!!! That was my intro to Juara and I’ve never looked back.

      I also got a “to die for” Nanette Lepore trench coat that was offered at a crazy sale on shoptiques (under $100 thanks to that gift card!!) and it’s one of my absolute most favorite items in my entire wardrobe. It’s a compliments magnet!! In fact, I wore it today 🙂

  29. Fall 2016!!

  30. My favorite box, and first box, was Fall 2016. No box since has topped that. My favorite product is probably the ORG peel face. For someone with dry skin, it is amazing.

    • That face peel is everything. No other peel I’ve ever used works that well and that quickly. I’ll keep buying it after mine runs out.

  31. I’ve only gotten the first Editors box and the Spring 2017 box so it’s hard to pick because I’ve enjoyed them both. I’d have to say my favorite item is the blanket scarf. I get cold easily so I use it almost on a daily basis as a shawl.

  32. Triple F has introduced me to so many of my favorite items (Headspace, Compeed Blister Cushions, Marrakesh Hair Oil, Gold Radiance Luxury Facial Mask), but Fall 2016 was my favorite box of all! 🙂

  33. My favorite was their former Welcome Box. That had an amazing value!!

  34. Spring 2017! And my second favorite was Spring 2016! I still use the ISH 🙂

  35. Summer 2016. The bag and towel have gone on two vacations since then and will soon be going with me this summer for a third. I have received a lot of compliments on these items as well.

  36. Fall 2016. Loved that box and Spongelle is my favorite item, esp that fragrance!

  37. Fall 2015. I ended up getting all 4 bracelets. That has been my favorite item.

  38. Fall 2014.

  39. Spring 2017, easily. Loved everything. Before that, Summer 2016.

  40. Spring 2016 for the hair oil and for getting me into herb gardening.

  41. Either summer 2014 or fall 2014

  42. First place: Spring 2017
    Second place: Winter 2016

    I like jewelry, candles, & skincare

    i defiantly think they’re listening and moving in a great direction! Very happy with this subscription

    • Agreed! Spring 2017 was such an amazing box. Winter 2016 was also great. Love the value and variety mix of items.

    • Those are my two favorites too. Skincare, candles, and jewelry are the best!!! I also love those Spongelle add-ons.

  43. Summer 2016.

    • Me too!!

  44. Spring 2017

    • Me too! This latest box had so many brands I buy full price! The real world value is ridiculous!

  45. I still like the 1st editors box I received, which is Fall 2016. I used everything except the coloring stuff. I’m still planning that one for a rainy day. I wish I could make a box of my own from the above boxes. 😉

    • Same! I really enjoyed that box. I noticed at the beginning they had a lot of beauty items in the boxes, I am the opposite, I prefer less beauty. I also noticed they used to have the “fit” part of the box more often. My only 2 boxes didn’t have a “fit” product. I don’t consider online things a product.

  46. Fall 2016. My favorites were the Lavender body oil or spongelle.

  47. Spring 2016 and Spring 2017 are my absolute favorites. Used everything, loved everything.

    • My favorite items are the Marrakech hair oil, the ORG Peel, the ISH palette, the Karuna masks, and the roundie blanket. Especially the ORG peel. It’s amazing.

  48. Winter 2016!!! I missed that box and I was so bummed. The spring 2017 box was a real knockout too!

  49. My favorite FabFitFun box is actually their latest one, the Editor’s Box 2 that was just released. It has the best of the best to me and such a good value. The pallette in this one is so pretty.

  50. Ooh, Fall 2016! Loved and used almost every bit of it. What a showstopper!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!