MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Walmart Beauty Box “Winter Wonders” Review – Winter 2020

The Walmart Beauty Box is a quarterly beauty sample subscription box from Walmart. It features brands you will find at Walmart.

My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

About Walmart Beauty Box

The Box: Walmart Beauty Box

The Cost: Free – just pay the $5 flat shipping rate!

The Products: Beauty samples from brands carried by Walmart.

Ships to: The US only

Good to Know: Here is when each season starts shipping: Winter – January, Spring – March, Summer – July, Fall – October.

Walmart Beauty Box “Winter Wonders” Winter 2020 Review

 

When you sign up you will answer a series of questions such as your ethnicity, hair color, skin concerns, and a few other preferences. The answers are used to provide a more personalized experience so that they can tailor your box to you.

 

This little card highlights our theme of Winter Wonders, along with some info about reviewing the products and a link to a survey. My boxes have been a bit behind; I’m not sure if it’s dependent on when you sign up, but just note that you might not know when this box will arrive exactly!

 

Color Club Nail Lacquer in Take it or Leaf It – Retail Value $5.00

Our first item is a full-size nail polish which is a great way to start this box! I think that this nude color is a great winter to spring transitional color, too. This color is called “Take it or Leaf It” and while that’s what I linked to above, I think the color I received is much more similar to this color on the Walmart site. It definitely doesn’t look purple to me. I thought the consistency of this formula was pretty good. I could get a nice opaque coat with one thick stroke, although I think it held up a bit better on the nails that I did two thinner coats on.

Sorry, I have zero nails as of right now, but hopefully, you can get a sense of the color here! I didn’t use a base coat or top coat but I was happy with how well the polish held up!

 

Avena Hand and Body Lotion, 3.4 oz – Estimated Value $0.85 (Buy a full-size 17 oz. for $3.59 – this was currently out of stock at Walmart)

This lotion is a nice size at 3.4 ounces and the fragrance is fresh and maybe a bit floral? I wasn’t a huge fan of the scent, but it did fade some as it absorbed into my skin. It took a little while to absorb into my hands but definitely left them softer although I didn’t find the moisturizing effects to be as intense or long-lasting as I would like. This formula contains oatmeal and is recommended for all skin types.

 

Degree Women Ultraclear Dry Spray, 1 oz. – Estimated Value $1.31 (Buy a full size for $4.97)

This next item is a repeat from the fall box for me. I made the switch to natural deodorant awhile ago when I got pregnant with my first child and I am not someone who typically sweats much so I haven’t tested this one out. Since I don’t tend to need a strong deodorant, I don’t think my experience would be a great indicator of how well it would hold up for others. It does have some great reviews though! The smell is nice, very fresh and light and it says it offers 48-hour protection.

 

NYX Makeup Crew Soft Matte Lipsticks in California – Estimated Value $12.00 (based on a similar set found here)

This next item is a cool concept! There are two mini tubes of soft matte lipstick in the same shade, although one is metallic and one is plain matte. Both of these formulas were super silky and smooth and felt weightless on my lips after drying quickly. The matte finish was barely noticeable and while it wasn’t incredibly long-lasting, it wore down evenly.

Here they are swatched with the metallic shade at the bottom.

 

The matte color was nude with a hint of pink to it.

 

The metallic formula comes across a bit darker.

 

Here I have the matte with the metallic over top. It is a perfect balance of the two formulas and I like it better than either of the lippies by themselves!

 

Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelette, 1 wipe – Estimated Value $0.30 (Buy a pack of 25 for $4.97)

This last item is one I’m sure most have tried at some point. This is a single sample of Neutrogena’s makeup remover wipes. This will be a nice item to throw in my travel toiletry bag or my purse in case I need it! It works pretty well to remove makeup, although I feel like it’s not as gentle on the eyes as my Makeup Eraser, nor is it as environmentally friendly, of course. It will still do in a pinch, though!

Verdict: This was a pretty decent haul and a well-rounded mix of items this season! While the lotion and deodorant were misses for me, personally, and the Neutrogena wipe was just okay, I was happy to receive a set of two mini lipsticks and a full-size bottle of nail polish. Especially since they were all great colors and decent formulas! While I had a hard time estimating the value, I think this was a great deal for the $5.00 cost of shipping for this box!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? You may receive a different assortment of products based on your profile. From Walmart Beauty Box:

Sign up today for your first box. Each box is hand-selected with in-season products that fit your profile.

Value Breakdown: At $5 shipping for this box and 5 items, you are paying approximately $1.00 per item.

Check out all of our Walmart Beauty Box reviews, the best beauty subscription boxes, and more boxes under $15!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the Winter 2020 Walmart Beauty Box?

Walmart Beauty Box

How do subscribers rate Walmart Beauty Box?

Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Price
$5.00
per quarter
Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about Walmart Beauty Box!

Enable notifications (On switch) to get the latest Walmart Beauty Box spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.


Written by Brandi Dowell

Brandi Dowell

Brandi has loved the idea of subscription boxes since joining Birchbox in 2013. Now that she’s a mother of 3, she loves finding unique boxes to educate and entertain her kids while enjoying some more pampering boxes for herself. Her favorites these days are Lillypost, KiwiCo boxes & Wicked Good Perfume!

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Cheap Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, Walmart Beauty Box Reviews| Tags: Walmart Beauty Box | 39 comments

Comments (39)

  1. I got mine today love it thks keep sending

  2. I received the NYX lippies, a Dove product which I really liked, an Optic White sample, a small lotion and the Lumify eye drops. Once I managed to open the eye drop cap, I LOVE 💕 this product! Just Wow! It really brightened my old eyes. This is worth my $5 every 3 months.

  3. Not impressed. I decided to renew bc of this review, but the only item I got that matched this review is the NYX lip colors. I wanted the lotion (good size!) and the nail polish. I got a sample size bottle of eye drops, sample size toothpaste, dry conditioner and a 1 oz tube of Curel lotion. : /

    • I received the same box. Was disappointed that I didn’t get the nail polish too. Seems like I always get Dove products (dry conditioner) and I’m not a fan. Also, it took almost one month to receive after my credit card was charged.

    • I also got the same box. Don’t know how many dry shampoo/conditioners and toothpaste I can stand. Rarely do I get the box pictured. There was one time last year that I got a few full size items not pictured in the review and they were better quality. Only $5.00 but same old, same old.

    • I got the same! And I just got my winter box a few days ago… Wonder if they are going to be doing a spring box?

  4. I was charged 3 weeks ago and I’m still waiting for the Winter box.

    • I reactivated and was charged about a month ago. I just logged into my account since I haven’t heard anything for awhile. It shipped Thursday and is due Monday! Try checking your account with them, maybe yours shipped too!

      • Mine arrives Monday as well! And I was charged back in March. Fingers crossed its a decent box.

      • I just checked my account again. It does say it’s been shipped now but the tracking number is still showing as “USPS Currently Awaiting Package”. I imagine it will show up next week. I still think that’s pretty late for a “Winter” box.

      • Just checked mine also, and that’s exactly what it says.

  5. Mine was awesome. Totally worth $5. I got the nail polish in dark blue, which I love. The lip glosses as well. But otherwise, mine was different. I got a travel size Jergens lotion with lavender. A sheet mask. And a travel size Colgate whitening toothpaste. I will happily use it all and that toothpaste may have converted me to buying a big one.

  6. I was charged for my box over three weeks ago and got an email today saying the box would be delayed because of the current crises. Which I totally understand. I haven’t been impressed with Brandshare in the past so fingers crossed it eventually ships!

  7. Still waiting for my Walmart Beauty Box 3/29/20. I have been a subscriber for over two years. I was charged 24 days ago and no tracking. I reached out to Brandshare( aka Walmart) to no avail. I had contact with a rep named Cristina. They can not provide tracking or any information. But they are “happy to help”.

    I know in the grand scheme this does not matter. I should just cancel and call it a day. Stay healthy folks. I just vented a little. Thanks.

    • I just received my Walmart Box ( Trendsetter) today 4/9 Here is what I received – Curel lotion, Degree, Optic White Toothpaste, Nail Polish – Navy Blue, NYX ( 2 lip glosses). Just giving an update.

      • Did you receive tracking number? This is my second box but I only see “Processing Shipment”

  8. My Trendsetter and Classic boxes had identical products 😞. I love the Avena lotion because I prefer a lighter texture and I’m partial to those softer European scents. Will be giving away the nail polishes and one of the lipstick sets.

  9. Why do a winter review when the Spring box is out now? I cancelled this long ago but this box would make me sign up again. I’m not risking it now for the spring box I know I will get a bunch of samples as usual. I know it’s only 5 bucks but still all those 5 bucks start to add up.

    • This is the winter box. Boxes ship the last month of the quarter. This is the winter quarter. The spring boxes will most likely ship in June, which is the last month of Spring.

      • Wow my box was very different… no lotion or neutrogena face wipe

    • Walmart beauty box shipping is wonky. MSA probably didn’t receive it until recently.

  10. My boxes were very different. I have 2 boxes, one of which is supposed to be Classic and the other of which is supposed to be Trendsetter. Both boxes were identical, which has never happened to be before. I received a bright pink/fuschia Color Club polish, the NYX lippies, the deodorant (ok, I guess my box wasn’t that different from yours – lol!), a whitening toothpaste, and Curel lotion.

    • I received my box with your same items in the mail the day after I received the shipping delay email. I didn’t receive a tracking email as I normally do. My color nail polish is the same as pictured above – the Take It or Leaf It. Worth my $5.

  11. Woo hoo! Time to resubscribe although I’ll cancel again after I receive the box. It seems to work better that way unless they iron out some issues.

  12. I received this exact same box. I liked this box because it was different from.all of the other boxes.

  13. Looks awesome too bad all I ever got was 1 use samples

    • Exactly!! Me too.. Thats why i finally got fed up and cancelled.. Their customer service sucks. And it was like they were charging me and I would get the Box 2 months later I got a fall box in like January with only one use samples and the spray deodorant that I’ve already gotten a million times before I tried to explain the customer service but all I got was a generic copy and paste email more than once and I’ve been getting this box for about the last five years and over the last year it’s been terrible and customer service doesn’t seem to care I’m finally cancelled I know it’s only $5 but my $5 would probably buy more travel-size fraud single-use card samples. I was pretty apparent that they didn’t care about their loyal customers

      • *products (not fraud.. lol talk text problems)

  14. I’m glad they sent the Nyx lip creams! I’ve tried Nyx lip products in the past for which I liked the color & performance, but couldn’t use due to the obnoxious fake vanilla scent of the product. These definitely are still fragranced, but the scent is perfectly tolerable to me. I’ll be on the lookout for more shades in this line.

    I got the variant with the polish shade in It’s Complicated (magenta), Herbal Essences foils, Curel lotion, & Colgate sample. DEFINITELY worth the $5 to me!

    • I got the same box as you, except I got a navy blue polish in the shade Made In The USA. I feel like this season’s box was better than last season’s box. For once I actually got lippies in shades that I can actually wear.

  15. I agree with you, the two lippies combined look better together 🙂

  16. The NYX lipsticks are full-size, I believe. I have several in that same style and they look full-sized.

    • Agreed! I looked them up on Ulta’s website and the same size is $6.50 each on there!! So $13 total🤗 I loved the California color I received too😊

  17. I have three accounts. I got the same nyx lippie in all. However one of the boxes contained two mattes and no metallic. I also recieved twonot quite navy blue nail polishes and one fuscia color. All three came with curel lotion. Two with Colgate toothpaste. A couple sample spray deodorants and all had some foil packs of herbal essences birch bark extract shampoo and conditioner. I always like my walmart boxes.

  18. Did I miss which version this is? I cannot find it. Was this the Classic or Trendsetter box? Thx!

    • Hi MzBev, I actually can’t find any information on their site about whether they do the trendsetter/ classic boxes anymore. I believe they use your survey answers to personalize your boxes now so there may be more variety between all boxes now!

      • They do. I reactivated, last week, after cancelling about a year ago. (after too many foil packets). The email confirmation I got from them states Classic box.
        I used to get both options, but only want one, for now.

      • Ah, I don’t receive the emails, but I’m sure mine would be the trendsetter box then! Thanks for the info! 🙂

  19. Well this is disappointing for me. I really like bold colors and I tend to get more subdued. I don’t mind subdued once in awhile but, my heart in love with dark reds, bright pinks, delicious purples..sigh

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.