Facebook PixelThe 16 Best Subscription Box Loyalty Programs & Perks – 2019 Readers’ Choice | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The 16 Best Subscription Box Loyalty Programs & Perks – 2019 Readers’ Choice

ByMSAOct 1, 2020 | 1 comment

Voting for our 4th annual readers’ choice awards is now closed. Stay tuned: our updated list of winners will be announced in January 2020!

Updated 10/1 to reflect updated pricing for Allure Beauty Box. Lean more here!

We asked our readers to name the subscription boxes with the best loyalty programs and perks of 2019, and these are the results! Check out all of the awesome results here, or read on to see which subscriptions our community says have the best member benefits.

Subscription boxes are known for delivering great value to their members, and that value only gets better when the box has loyalty, refer-a-friend, and other benefit programs in place! See how you can save on top-notch beauty, home, style, and wellness products with these reader favorites.

Want more? Check out our full list of great monthly subscription boxes here!

1. FabFitFun

The Cost: $49.99 per quarter. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Save $10 off your first box with code MSA10

What Our Readers Say:

"Their member sales where things are like 50-70% off are AWESOME. One of the best perks of being subscribed." - aalexaurora

"Offers early shopping, customization and add ons to box with most selection of items at great prices." - Taradesigns4u

About the Perks: Every FabFitFun box comes packed with an awesome assortment of full-size beauty and body care products, accessories, and other trend-savvy gifts. But as a member, you also get exclusive discounts on top brands, including brands featured in current and past boxes, plus other products they're loving!

Check out our FabFitFun reviews or read this FabFitFun info to subscribe. Ships to US and Canada.


2. Ipsy

all contents

The Cost: $10 per month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

"You get points for each month you receive the bag, plus more points for reviews. They add up fast and the reward items from your points are always great." - KarenLRK

"Really great benefits for subscribers like extra discounts, first access to bags, and super discounted add ons to your bag! Really great perks." - Katelyn

About the Perks: Ipsy is one of our readers' favorite monthly beauty subscription boxes, not just because of their assortment of amazing samples, but because of Ipsy's point system. Members can earn points through Ipsy's referral program, following Ipsy's creators on social media, and reviewing what you got. Use your points to nab unique beauty products and tools from beloved and up-and-coming brands. You can also shop Ipsy Offers—exciting deals on top cosmetics, skincare products, and accessories.

Check out our Ipsy reviews or read this Ipsy info to subscribe. Ships to US and Canada.


3. Birchbox

The Cost: $15.00 per month. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Check out our Birchbox Coupon List for the most up-to-date deal!

What Our Readers Say:

"I love getting points for my purchases." - Shell F

"As an ace you get 1.3% cash back towards future purchases. You also get a sample pack for $30+ and free deluxe/full size products for $30+. Also free shipping on purchases and bonus perks/discounts throughout the year." - August D

About the Perks: Birchbox is one of the first beauty subscription boxes that we and our readers fell in love with. In addition to sending you a monthly selection of personalized or Birchbox-curated surprises in handy sample sizes, Birchbox offers a loyalty program that rewards you for shopping, gifting, and reviewing their products. While you can't put your points towards your re-billable subscription, you can use them to nab top-rated brand-name items in the Birchbox shop.

Check out our Birchbox reviews or read this Birchbox info to subscribe. Ships to US, France, Spain, and the UK.


4. BoxyCharm

boxycharm box with all the included items displayed around it

The Cost: $21.00 per month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

"I love that you can review products and refer new people to receive 'charms' which you can use in their 'charm room' to redeem for other beauty products. I also love that once in a while they have offers where they send you a full size product when you refer a new subscriber." - Dida

"I think if you comment on every item you receive you can build a nice amount of charms and be able to buy big items!" - Lesly

About the Perks: BoxyCharm's mix of full, sample, and deluxe-size beauty goodies make it easy to stay on top of the hottest makeup and skincare trends. And with every review you give or friend you refer using your special BoxyCharm code, you'll earn Charms points to put towards an ever-rotating collection of top brand products!

Check out our Boxycharm reviews or read this Boxycharm info to subscribe. Ships to US.


5. Play! by Sephora

all included items

UPDATE: As of April 2020, PLAY! by Sephora has ended. Find out more in our post here

The Cost: $10.00 per box. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

"Overall Sephora has a great loyalty program and the extra points that come with the Play! box are great." - slappe

About the Perks: Love earning VIB points at Sephora? Every Play! by Sephora box includes a pass that you can redeem in-store or online for 50 bonus points, plus tips, tricks, and, oh yeah, a personalized collection of sample-sized beauty goodies from the hottest brands! It's an effortless way to score points and learn about the new products your skin, hair, and makeup kit can't live without.

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews or read this Play! by Sephora info to subscribe. Ships to US.


6. POPSUGAR Must-Have Box

The Cost: $75 per quarter. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Get $20 off your first box with code MSA20

What Our Readers Say:

"I get $20 credit for each referral." - Lee

"They take care of their customers and offer good sales." - Jeanette H.

About the Perks: This box has a great refer-a-friend program that lets you earn $20 in credit while giving your loved ones $20 off of their new subscriptions! You can use your credit on Must Have add-ons, or apply it to your next POPSUGAR Must Have Box charge. POPSUGAR boxes connect you with over $250 of the hottest beauty, wellness, style, and home products of the season, curated by the trend-savvy editors at POPSUGAR.com. Take advantage of the referral program and get even more amazing value!

Check out our POPSUGAR Must-Have Box reviews or read this POPSUGAR Must-Have Box info to subscribe. Ships to US and Canada.



all included items

The Cost: $21 per quarter. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use coupon code HEART to save 20% off any length subscription!

What Our Readers Say:

"I find it easy to fill in the questionnaires and can use the credit for limited edition boxes." - Claire B

"Points to use for limited edition boxes and reduced prices for limited edition boxes as well." - Shannon S

About the Perks: This beauty box gives members GLOSSYCredits for easy actions like reviewing products, referring friends, and even just completing your beauty profile. GLOSSYCredits can be used on lookfantastic or GLOSSYBOX, so you can try premium beauty products from top brands for even less!

Check out our GLOSSYBOX reviews or read this GLOSSYBOX info to subscribe. Ships to US and Canada.


8. BeautyFIX

all box contents

The Cost: $24.95 per month. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

"Love their rewards system. Points for purchases and reviews translates to $10 off anything in store." - Heathers1211

About the Perks: BeautyFIX is the official subscription box of Dermstore.com, the online skincare aficionados. Sign up for the Dermstore Rewards program, and you'll earn credit to use on future purchases, plus access to special deals. All you have to do is share your purchases or product reviews on social to start collecting credits. As if the skin-nourishing samples and deluxe-sized beauty must-haves in each monthly box weren't enough, you can use your Dermstore Rewards to re-up on the new products you've discovered and loved!

Check out our BeautyFIX reviews or read this BeautyFIX info to subscribe. Ships to US.


9. Fabletics

my fabletics polka dot shorts and bra

The Cost: Make a purchase or choose to skip the month (and not be charged) at the beginning of the month, or have $49.95 saved as store credit to your account. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

"Fabletics is pretty cool because every time you buy stuff you earn points in which you can then use to redeem products!"  - Jessica

About the Perks: Fabletics is a super-popular source for figure-loving fitness and athleisure apparel, and with their BeneFits Rewards Program, you can earn points towards discounts on orders, accessories, and clothing, too! All you have to do is shop, review products, or earn bonus points during the occasional special promotion. As you accumulate points, you'll unlock additional benefits, like birthday gifts, exclusive partner discounts, magazine subscriptions, and more.

Check out our Fabletics reviews or read this Fabletics info to subscribe. Ships to US.


10. Petit Vour

The Cost: $18.00 per month. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Use coupon code MSAPETIT to save 25% off of your first box!

What Our Readers Say:

"Offers points for members, when you submit reviews, earn vouchers for discounts on future orders." - Raquel S.

About the Perks: Fans of cruelty-free, plant-based cosmetics and skincare will swoon for this elegantly packaged, thoughtfully curated, and personalized beauty box. And by rating and reviewing the items in your Petit Vour subscription boxes, members can earn points to redeem for special discounts!

Check out our Petit Vour reviews or read this Petit Vour info to subscribe. Ships worldwide.


11. CURATEUR (Formerly Rachel Zoe Box of Style)

The Cost: $99.99 per quarter. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Use code SPRING25 to save $25 off your first box

What Our Readers Say:

"Best extra present for annual subscribers; Amazon Echolook!" - Modisabelle

About the Perks: This quarterly box from celeb stylist Rachel Zoe gives you access to chic new beauty products and accessories each season. Take advantage of their refer-a-friend program to save $25 on future renewals and add-ons, and enjoy seriously awesome loyalty perks once you've subscribed for over a year!

Check out our CURATEUR and Box of Style reviews or read this CURATEUR info to subscribe. Ships to US, Canada, the UK, and Australia.


12. Allure Beauty Box

all contents

The Cost: $23 per month. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Get $5 off your first box when you use this link!

What Our Readers Say:

"Allure throws in surprises for subscribers randomly."

About the Perks: This beauty box brings the fun of Allure Magazine to your doorstep! Allure Beauty Box treats its long-time subscribers right, with bonus surprises like accessories and special beauty gifts. They also have a great referral program—for every referral, you'll earn extra samples from top-notch brands like Sunday Riley!

Check out our Allure Beauty Box reviews or read this Allure Beauty Box info to subscribe. Ships to US.


13. YogaClub

Yoga Club

The Cost: $79/month plus $6.95 shipping. Subscribe here!

COUPON: Save $20 off the Guru Box for the lifetime of your subscription! No coupon required—just use this link!

What Our Readers Say:

"If you refer friends, you end up to pay 19$ per box!!!!!" - Valerie

About the Perks: When you refer a friend to this fitness apparel subscription, you get $10 off and so does your friend! You can keep referring friends until you've shaved your monthly box cost to $19—that's three premium fitness pieces from high-quality brands for under $20. You'll also start earning Lotus Bucks with your membership, which you can put towards perks like free shipping!

Check out our YogaClub reviews or read this YogaClub info to subscribe. Ships to US and Canada.


14. Loved + Blessed

Loved + Blessed best subscription boxes for great loyalty programs and member perks readers' choice 2019

The Cost: $19.99 per month. Subscribe here!

Coupon: Use code MSALOVE to save $4 off your 3, 6, and 12-month subscriptions!

What Our Readers Say:

"We get discounts and sometimes, a free box too. They also have great offers periodically." - Chioma

"They offer monthly drawings for special gifts." - Cindy D.

About the Perks: Filled with faith-based gifts and self-care surprises, Loved + Blessed is a fantastic, feel-good way to treat yourself each month. Members get special deals and offers, plus access to the Loved + Blessed Facebook group.

Check out our Loved + Blessed reviews or read this Loved + Blessed info to subscribe. Ships to US.


15. Breo Box

group of included items gathered around breo box

The Cost: $159 per quarter. Subscribe here!

About the Perks: The longer you subscribe to Breo Box, the less it costs each season! That means you can get their thoughtfully curated assortments of gadgets, home goods, kitchen tools, wellness products, and other top-quality items for up to $30 off!

Check out our Breo Box reviews or read this Breo Box info to subscribe. Ships worldwide.


16. kidpik

kidpik best subscription boxes for great loyalty programs and member perks readers' choice 2019

The Cost: Styling is free! Only pay for what you keep. Subscribe here!

What Our Readers Say:

"They offer customers great sales!!" - Tonya

"Besides receiving the cutest and most unique clothes, ever, every box comes with a FREE gift that your child can keep, rather they keep the box or return it! MAJOR PLUS!!!" - Darlababies

About the Perks: kidpik has a great refer-a-friend program that lets you earn $20 to use on your next box while also giving your loved ones $20 to use on their first kidpik order! kidpik is already a super convenient way to shop for trend-savvy, fun girls' clothing—use the refer-a-friend program, and you'll get a great deal, too!

Check out our kidpik reviews or read this kidpik info to subscribe. Ships to US.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

1 comment

Ellie F

I would argue that any one which only gives points or rewards for referrals or social media posting isn’t offering perks or a loyalty program. They’re paying you to do their advertising for you. That’s not a perk. That’s a really good financial deal for them.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike