Facebook PixelAlltrue: Fall 2021 Box Full Spoilers | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Alltrue Spring Welcome Box 2024 – Spoilers

Alltrue: Fall 2021 Box Full Spoilers

ByMSAAug 31, 2021 | 39 comments

alltrue box along with mug, hand cream, dryer balls, tote bag, and other lifestyle items

3.3 overall rating
244 Ratings | 82 Reviews

We've now got the full spoilers for the Alltrue Fall 2021 Box!

First Impressions

The Alltrue spoilers for the Fall 2021 have been focused on making things easier for you at home. The first customization option offers dryer balls, measuring spoons and a moisturizing cream. The second option gives subscribers five possible choices including stackable pantry containers, a vegan leather everyday tote, a smart heated mug, a sea-based skincare bundle and a portable speaker. The third option? A hair towel wrap and gold eye masks. The fourth customization offers a layered necklace set, a set of knotted hairbands and a vegan mascara. The fifth customization includes a candle, diffuser and welcome mat. The last spoiler, which will be in each box, is a skin balm.

Check out all the options below.

Customization #1

Silicone & Beechwood Measuring Spoon Set

Silicone & Beechwood Measuring Spoon Set

This set of measuring spoons from Kitchen Innovations is dishwasher-safe and reinforced with a rigid steel core and are heat resistant.

Natural Wool Dryer Balls

Molly’s Suds dryer ballsFrom brand Molly’s Suds, these dryer balls come as a set of three and are made from 100% pure New Zealand wool.

Hydra Repair Day Cream

Grown Alchemist hydra day cream

Made by Grown Alchemist, the moisturizing cream retails for $49 on the brand’s site but is just $11 as an extra pick for the Alltrue box!

Customization #2

Set of 5 Stackable Pantry Containers from Small:Hours

five plastic pantry containers filled with pretzels, dog treats, goldfish, and other pantry staples

If you’ve caught the Home Edit bug so many of us picked up during The Home Edit, this option may just get you up off the couch and into your pantry for some serious reorganizing.

Henny + Lev Vegan Leather 2-in-1 Everyday Tote

Henny + Lev Vegan Leather 2-in-1 Everyday Tote

Henny & Lev totes retail for $79 and up, so picking this tote along could cover the entire cost of your Alltrue fall box … and then some. Even better? Since the leather is vegan, you can feel good about popping it over your shoulder to hit the farmers’ market.

Tease Smart Heated Mug

Black smart mug with a lid and stirring stick sticking out

Coffee and tea fans, have you tried a smart mug yet? Designed to keep your warm drinks warm, these are a serious gamechanger if you tend to pour a cup and then get too busy to drink it (guilty!). Retail values for these genius gadgets vary, but with some costing in the near $100 range, this is another pick that shows the real value of the Alltrue box.

Earth Harbor Seas the Day Luxury Skincare Bundle

Seas the Day Luxury Skincare Bundle with two spray bottle and one jar

Earth Harbor is all about sea-based skincare products that are cruelty-free and vegan, and that’s a huge draw. It’s also what makes a set like this a great pick if you’re looking to get the very most out of your Alltrue box. The Glow Juice hydrating mask included in this kit alone would set you back $42 if you were buying it straight from the retailer

LSTN Wanderlust Portable Speaker

portable speaker with grey top and white bottom, plus a grey strap

The final pick in this round of Alltrue fall box customizations is a speaker that is actually rather pretty — definitely less techy looking than your average speaker. It comes from LSTN, a pretty cool company in and of itself. When people buy from LSTN, a portion of the proceeds go to help provided hearing aids to people who need them!

Customization #3

Bemakai: Manta Hair Towel Wrap

Photo of woman wrapping her hair inside the Bemakai Manta Hair Towel Wrap

Bemakai: Manta Hair Towel Wrap

For those still tossing their wet hair in a big bath towel when they emerge from the shower, we have a better idea: say hello to the hair towel wrap!
Made with 40% bamboo and 60% recycled polyester, its super-soft, extra absorbent material hugs your hair to absorb the excess moisture quickly, leaving curls, waves, and straight hair alike with less breakage and a frizz-free finish.

Mintbiology Seaweed Collagen Gold Eye Masks

Photo of woman wearing hair wrap and https://www.facebook.com/alltrue/photos/pcb.4643745705656586/4643745648989925/

To answer your first question: yes, they’re really made with gold!
The luxe eye treatments in the Fall Box are made with pure nano-active 24K gold particles that work together with skin-loving nutrients like seaweed collagen, hyaluronic acid, and vitamin C to hydrate, brighten, tighten, protect, and soothe to reverse the signs of aging and fatigue around the eyes.

Customization #4

Headbands of Hope: Set of 2 Knotted Headbands

Two Headbands of Hope, one mustard colored, one blue

Gossip girl isn’t the only thing that’s back — channel your inner Blair Waldorf with these playful, vintage-inspired headbands! For many of us, the return to life on-the-go also means the return to dry shampoo and messy buns thrown up on a busy morning. Enter: headbands.
Made with a polyester fabric blend sourced from recycled plastic bottles and extra padding behind the ears to help reduce that headband headache, we fit-tested across a range of hair types and head shapes to find a sizing that works for most. For each set of headbands included in the Fall Box, a child with cancer receives a headband.

EACH Jewels: Layering Necklace Set

Photo of a woman wearing EACH Jewels Layering Necklace Set

This minimalist and delicate set of necklaces is everything we look for and then some! Bold enough to wear individually, complementary enough to wear together, reserved enough to mix and match with the rest of your jewelry box, and dainty enough to effortless pair with your wear-everywhere classic pendant, each necklace is made from 14k gold plated steel with an adjustable length for layering.
When you choose one of ‘EACH,’ you’re choosing to live in a win-win world where the jewelers who make your accessories are just as valuable as the people who buy them. Made by a women-led artisan team in Vietnam, this project helped employ 96 female jewelers, 10 of which hold senior management positions.

Aloette Cosmetics Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Photo of Aloette Cosmetics Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Whether you favor that bare-faced look or love to experiment with the bright and bold, a good mascara is a must-have in any make-up bag — and this Aloette mascara is one of our favorites!
We took one of Aloette’s most-loved mascaras and tweaked it juuuust a little for Alltrue, making the formula fully vegan. A blend of nourishing Argan Oil, rice, and orange peel waxes works like your classic conditioner — but for your eyelashes, moisturizing and strengthening each lash without any clumping.

Customization #5

Botanica Speckled Ceramic Candle

Falling leaves, cozy sweaters, your favorite book, and this warm, comforting scent! 
This Speckled Ceramic Candle is about to become your new fall favorite. Made with 100% soy wax, a cotton wick, 35-45 hours of burn time, and an “Autumn Sunset” scent, it features bright notes of persimmon, red currant + koba, and mandarin.
Better still, the custom ceramic vessel can be repurposed into the winter months! Once burned down, clean it out with warm water and give it a new life as a coffee mug, pencil holder, or home to a potted plant.

Accompany Jute Welcome Mat

Photo of Accompany Jute
Welcome back your much-missed family and friends (and elevate the doorstep arrival experience of your Alltrue Box!) with this handwoven homeware, perfect for indoor or outdoor covered use. This message of community was crafted with care in Banskho, Rajasthan, using 100% natural jute fibers sourced in Calcutta, and embroidered with black nylon lettering in Jaipur.
This Jute Welcome Mat project sustainably employed 227 artisans at the Craft Boat Artisan Collective in Jaipur, India, a cooperative with a focus on gender equity and women’s empowerment, providing consistent employment through India’s second wave of COVID-19.

Serene House Ion Fan Diffuser & Inspire Essential Oil


This little diffuser is compact, battery operated, and entirely water free — perfect for scenting small spaces! Keep it in your laundry room, bathroom, car, or take it with you for a sense of familiarity as you make your way back out into the world of hotels, airbnb’s, and childhood bedrooms.
Formulated to help you find your creative spark, the Inspire Essential Oil Blend included combines six vibrant scents: lemon, blood orange, orange, lime, geranium, and eucalyptus. Simply pour this blend (or one of your choice!) onto the paper pad, pop it into the device, and turn it on to trigger the fan inside for an instantly refreshed space.

Final Spoiler

The final spoiler, which will appear in every box is:

Huna Vegan Nourish Skin Nutrition Balm

An everyone-gets-one option in the Fall Box, this award-winning body balm from Huna offers year-round moisture and protection from the elements. Made with nourishing, healing, and natural ingredients like calendula, organic mango butter, pomegranate, avocado, carrot, broccoli, and chia seed oil, it works to soothe dry, damaged, dehydrated skin and protect healthy skin (looking at you, cracked, cold-weather lips!).

This version of the Nourish Skin Balm is also fully vegan, customized for the Alltrue community to swap out beeswax for candelilla wax.

Other Things You Should Know

How much is an Alltrue Subscription? An annual subscription is $49.95 with a value of more than $250.

When does customization open? It is now open for Annual Members and will open for quarterly members on 9/4.

Sign up for a MSA account and put Alltrue on your MSA wishlist so you can get notification alerts for new spoilers and deals!

What will you choose for your own Alltrue Fall 2021 Box?

Starting at $64.95
Subscribe Now

Alltrue (formerly CAUSEBOX) is a seasonal lifestyle membership that unites a community of individuals who stand for good, seek truth, and take action. Every season, Alltrue members receive a curation of carefully vetted socially-conscious lifestyle products (from fashion and homewares to skincare... read more.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Comically poor quality. I bought an extra of the heated mug and I actually laughed when using it the first time. Comes beautifully packaged in the lowest quality packaging that’s perfect for a photo but feels like false advertisement. The cup’s base is wobbly and it’s not a defect. It’s due to poor design and I expect my second cup to do the same. I wouldn’t pay more than $8 for this mug at TJ Max or somewhere. I’m nervous to see how everything else in my box is. Which is soooo silly that I have JUST received my fall box while it’s snowing out and the winter spoilers are only just being revealed. BUYERS REMORSE. I LOVE subscription box and am pretty easy to please but dangggg. This company has the worst customer experience from all that I’ve tried. FabFitFun, while also gradually getting worse quality over the years, has spectacular customer service and community feel.

Honestly? Scratch both of them. Go get yourself a beautiful subscription to Curateur or Breo Box or something with quality or your just going to end up with a bunch of low quality breakable crap in the long run. It doesn’t feel like a special treat anymore. It feels like a let down. Curateur and Breo Box and home decor boxes give me all of the feels these days. If you’re a beauty products fan, go for Birchbox or organic bunny.

Reply ButtonReply


FWIW my mug isn’t wobbly at all and keeps my beverages nice and warm. It does, however, have an absurdly short cord, which is a real challenge. There’s basically a single place I can set my mug and have it reach an outlet.

Reply ButtonReply

Karen Robinson

Hi, Just wanted to check in. I have not yet received my fall box. I am guessing y’all may be short staffed or have supply issues like we are all experiencing, but just checking on when the fall box might arrive. I love your boxes. I know this has been a tough year for everyone. Do you think next year y’all will have staffing, etc to mail these boxes a little closer to the beginning or middle of each season? Just trying to decide if I ask for this again for 3rd year as Christmas gift that gives/surprises me all year long. I know you are working hard and I truly appreciate all you are doing. Blessings and thankful for you, Karen

Reply ButtonReply


I finally got my box just yesterday. Fortunately, I wasn’t really in a hurry for any of them, but it’s funny to get them mid November! I had all my products. Unfortunately, the balm has lavender in it so I’ll have to pass that on, but all my picks were fine. The candle is a lot tinier than I expected.

I still have fomo over not picking the headbands, but it’s doubtful I would have worn them, so I will get more use out of the necklaces. They are more dainty than I expected and will be great for layering.

Reply ButtonReply


I only received 3 items in my box today- not too pleased

Reply ButtonReply


Is it to late to pick my products for fall box❓

Reply ButtonReply


Good thing none of the items are really fall specific, because once again it looks like I’m due to get my box out season. I got my summer box in late Sept and this one looks like it will be here after Thanksgiving. I’m an annual but will definitely be renewing.

Reply ButtonReply


I signed up for an annual last winter so I could do customizations & I have not once gotten an email like I do from FabFitFun to customize. I just went in & my box is scheduled, for shipping. I didn’t even get to pick my products, fingers crossed I got good items, but I’m canceling after this, I don’t like their lack of communication.

Reply ButtonReply


When I subbed to this one, I had to go to the site to click on customizations in order to chose.

Reply ButtonReply


When will I get to choose my fall options

Reply ButtonReply

Cheryl !

If you go to the alltrue site.. log into your account and in the center you will see a photo of the measuring spoons and a link saying “Start Customizing now” Click on that.. then they will give you a choice to upgrade.. or add something else.. below that click on no thanks and it will take you to customize. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply


How do we track our package?
It’s been so frustrating to purchase and then have to wait 2 months or so to get the box. The intended season is almost over. Also not happy with the customization process. This next box will determine whether I drop the subscription.

Reply ButtonReply


Agreed!!! I’ll be keeping my box because I love all the products, but trying to keep in mind that the season will basically be over when I get my box and customize accordingly (I’m an annual member so I get to choose everything).
In May I ordered from the Summer add-on market and didn’t get my add-ons til the end of July… so useless. I had bought several things for the purpose of using it in the summer (like an aloe Vera spray). By the time I got I I didn’t need it anymore. SMH.

Reply ButtonReply


I have several monthly/quarterly subscriptions: Ipsy, BoxyCharm, AllTrue and Fab, Fit, Fun included. AllTrue is the BEST! I bought a few boxes and based on the very high quality of the products, I got an annual subscription so I can customize the whole thing. It’s miles ahead of the competitor, FFF. I won’t be receiving FFF anymore as it’s contents are so cheaply made. AllTrue has provided me with excellent customer service, high-end goods and great prices. I’m always really happy with this subscription!!

Reply ButtonReply


WARNING – FYI, You do not get to customize all of the options if you sign up on Quarterly plan. It’s sneaky because you are first forced to Place Order and provide credit card info, and only AFTER you are billed does the website inform you that in order to pick all options, you need to “Upgrade” to basically an annual plan.

Reply ButtonReply


It’s common knowledge that in order to customize any subscription box, you have to be an annual member. That’s the perk of doing so. Nothing sneaky about it really.

Reply ButtonReply


Thank you. I was considering coming back to get this box, but don’t want to commit to another year.

Reply ButtonReply


I didn’t even get an email that customizations were open. I’m beyond annoyed!

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa Lutz

Me too! I’m so done with this. No emails, no communication, no choice even though I paid for the annual plan. I miss the causebox days. This new brand marketing scheme was worthless and the service has completely gone downhill. Beyond annoyed is putting it lightly.

Reply ButtonReply


I agree with you, Melissa! Causebox always had products I liked. With AllTrue, however, I can’t even figure out what I got…the long “article” in the beginning shows all kinds of cool things, but I received non of them. I’m going to discontinue my subscription as well.


I agree. So now I hope don’t get stupid items

Reply ButtonReply


Same here. I have an annual subscription but keep missing the customization window because they don’t send notifications, and I end up with garbage that I can’t use. Am I just supposed to remember to check their website every couple of months? I have a busy life, that’s not happening. Also their shipping is slooooow. Waste of money, time to cancel.

Reply ButtonReply

Rhian Liberatore

I haven’t been receiving them either

Reply ButtonReply


I don’t get notifications either

Cheryl W

You can go back and customize any time.. Even if you change your mind, as long as the customize window is open, you can go back and redo it.. Just go to the alltrue site and on the top of the page, click on my box. It will then take you to a page that says Box Customization. Click on customize next to your name and address.. Then it will ask you if you want to upgrade or eco shipping upgrade.. Just go under that and click on no thanks, maybe later.. It will take you to pick your items.. I was disappointed that we are allowed to customize just the 2 categories that are not the more expensive items.. You just get to customize in category four and five. So I guess I am going to cross my fingers that I will get the one item I want in category 2.. I want the mug.. It seems unfair they give us choices in the least expensive categories.. but oh well..

Reply ButtonReply


MSA – can you please provide clear guidance on whether or not quarterly members get to customize any of the categories, and which ones if so.

Reply ButtonReply


I am wondering the same thing! I was only allowed to customized two customizations #4 and #5. Why these two and not customization #1 and #2 that make more sense. Before joining I had read that quarterly member would be able to select three customizations.

Reply ButtonReply


I’m so so done with this box. AllTrue promised the summer box would ship by August and then delayed my box until September. Since I was moving the first week of September, I went in to my profile and changed my shipping address (in August, BEFORE MY BOX SHIPPED) — and then STILL they sent it to my previous address. When I reached out to customer service, they literally sent me a cut and paste response with the directions to “include if domestic customer” in it because apparently the customer support person forgot to delete that part. I’m also still waiting (over a month now) for them to send me the replacement for a market order that arrived broken. Run, don’t walk, away from this company.

Reply ButtonReply


I could customize the first 2 categories, but the items in the categories on the Alltrue website were not the same as shown below on this website. I don’t care what I get from the ones I could choose from; I absolutely do care about the products as shown HERE as in Category 1 and Category 2, so that is extremely annoying.

Based on comments here, it could be an Alltrue issue. If some quarterly members can customize, some can’t, and some can, but not all the same, this is just stupid. I don’t know if MSA messed up what products are in each category or not because I can only see what was available for me. Still, good deal for the items, although we will surely mot receive anything until around Christmas time. 🙄

Reply ButtonReply


MSA, can you please confirm for Alltrue Quarterly if we get to customize anything? We need the feedback.

Reply ButtonReply


I was just able to finally customize something. It let me do categories 4 + 5. Seemed weird but I was happy since those categories had the most things I didn’t want to get.

Reply ButtonReply


When I went to sign up the annual subscription was $199. The seasonal membership is $49.95.

Reply ButtonReply


I would love to renew my annual but I am so worried this company will not last a full year. I wish someone could assure me they will be.

Reply ButtonReply


Im not renewing my annual subscription because I’m afraid they won’t be around in a year. Many of the items for the last few boxes are things they’ve been trying to get rid of in the market for at least a year. They can’t ship anything in a timely manner. Customers have had enough. They had a really bad facebook response to the criticism they were getting. It doesn’t seem they’re ready to accept responsibility and make improvements. Sad, it’s been my favorite sub.

Reply ButtonReply


Did I miss an announcement about which categories quarterly members will be able to select? Or is just getting in later?

The Alltrue FAQ still says Quarterly can’t customize…

Reply ButtonReply


Everyone gets to choose customization 2 this time

Reply ButtonReply


I’m a quarterly subscriber and didn’t get a choice on 2. I only got to customize the crappy ones 4 and 5. I’m cancelling as well.


Why would they let everyone choose number 2 that’s the best category. If they are opening choice to everyone then the winter box will be my last I only paid for a full year so I could choose because right before you check out it warns you that you can only choose if you pay for a year in advance. I had to pay for a year to choose my items. Doesn’t make since choice 2 out of all choices would be open to everyone, esp considering the purse sold out I was able to snag it but the people who pay for the full year should have a chance to get the purse before people that pay by month. I’ve never paid for more then a month at a time on any sub service but this one I currently have sub boxes from 4 different services and pretty sure I’ve tried them all but fff.


Not true—I signed up for the quarterly box an hour ago and all customizations required a $$ upgrade. It’s not even clear what I’m getting in the box so I already canceled my subscription. Super frustrating!