Facebook PixelAlltrue Fall 2021 Box Spoiler #4: Customization Options | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Alltrue Spring Welcome Box 2024 – Spoilers

Alltrue Fall 2021 Box Spoiler #4: Customization Options

ByMSAAug 26, 2021 | 12 comments

alltrue box along with mug, hand cream, dryer balls, tote bag, and other lifestyle items

3.3 overall rating
244 Ratings | 82 Reviews

Since Alltrue dropped its their 2021 Fall Box schedule earlier this month, fans have been eagerly awaiting the chance to make their customizations for the quarterly lifestyle box. And we've got another batch of spoilers for you from the Alltrue box for Fall 2021.

First Impressions

The Alltrue spoilers for the Fall 2021 have been focused on making things easier for you at home. The first customization option offered dryer balls, measuring spoons and a moisturizing cream. The second option gave subscribers five possible choices including stackable pantry containers, a vegan leather everyday tote, a smart heated mug, a sea-based skincare bundle and a portable speaker. The third option? A hair towel wrap and gold eye masks.

What's in store for Spoiler #4?

What's Inside The Box

The fourth round of customizations features three products to choose from: two are pretty accessories, and one will give your lashes a beauty boost.

Headbands of Hope: Set of 2 Knotted Headbands


Photo of woman wearing two knotted Headbands of Hope, one mustard colored, one blue.

Headbands of Hope: Knotted Headbands

Two Headbands of Hope, one mustard colored, one blue

Headbands of Hope: Set of 2 Knotted Headbands

Gossip girl isn't the only thing that's back — channel your inner Blair Waldorf with these playful, vintage-inspired headbands! For many of us, the return to life on-the-go also means the return to dry shampoo and messy buns thrown up on a busy morning. Enter: headbands.
Not only do they add an element of ease to our increasingly busy lives, they're also an adorable addition to any outfit (and a staple in the wardrobe of our Head of Product!) Offered in two patterns — mustard antique floral and navy antique floral — we collaborated with Headbands of Hope to custom design this darling duo for the Alltrue community.
Made with a polyester fabric blend sourced from recycled plastic bottles and extra padding behind the ears to help reduce that headband headache, we fit-tested across a range of hair types and head shapes to find a sizing that works for most. For each set of headbands included in the Fall Box, a child with cancer receives a headband.

EACH Jewels: Layering Necklace Set

A photo of the EACH Jewels Layering Necklace Set

EACH Jewels: Layering Necklace Set

Photo of a woman wearing EACH Jewels Layering Necklace Set

EACH Jewels: Layering Necklace Set


This minimalist and delicate set of necklaces is everything we look for and then some! Bold enough to wear individually, complementary enough to wear together, reserved enough to mix and match with the rest of your jewelry box, and dainty enough to effortless pair with your wear-everywhere classic pendant, each necklace is made from 14k gold plated steel with an adjustable length for layering.
Hypoallergenic, lead, nickel, and cadmium free, this duo is perfect for everyday. EACH Jewels is an ethical, sustainable, female founded, and USA made accessory and jewelry brand.
When you choose one of 'EACH,' you’re choosing to live in a win-win world where the jewelers who make your accessories are just as valuable as the people who buy them. Made by a women-led artisan team in Vietnam, this project helped employ 96 female jewelers, 10 of which hold senior management positions.

Aloette Cosmetics Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Photo of Aloette Cosmetics Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Aloette Cosmetics: Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Photo of winking woman who is wearing Aloette Cosmetics Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Aloette Cosmetics: Winkable Lift & Lengthen Vegan Mascara

Whether you favor that bare-faced look or love to experiment with the bright and bold, a good mascara is a must-have in any make-up bag — and this Aloette mascara is one of our favorites!
We took one of Aloette's most-loved mascaras and tweaked it juuuust a little for Alltrue, making the formula fully vegan. A blend of nourishing Argan Oil, rice, and orange peel waxes works like your classic conditioner — but for your eyelashes, moisturizing and strengthening each lash without any clumping.

Other Things You Should Know

How much is an Alltrue subscription? An annual subscription is $49.95 with a value of more than $250.

When does customization open? While you can make choices now, the customization window officially opens for Annual Members on 8/29 and Quarterly Members on 9/4, according to Alltrue.

Will there be more spoilers? Alltrue will be dropping more spoilers during the month of August, and we'll be sharing them here on MSA.

Sign up for a MSA account and put Alltrue on your MSA wishlist so you can get notification alerts for new spoilers and deals!

Are you going to pick up the Alltrue Fall 2021 Box?
Starting at $69.95
Active Deal
$15 off of your first Alltrue box
Use Coupon Code MSA15OFF
Subscribe Now

Alltrue (formerly CAUSEBOX) is a seasonal lifestyle membership that unites a community of individuals who stand for good, seek truth, and take action. Every season, Alltrue members receive a curation of carefully vetted socially-conscious lifestyle products (from fashion and homewares to skincare... read more.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



This box seems to be lacking a “hero” item category, unless that’s what they consider the category with the tote. Not a fan at all of “vegan leather” so I hope that’s not it. Hopefully spoiler 5 will not disappoint.

Reply ButtonReply


I agree! I thought the same thing after the Category 5 spoilers came out. That’s it?? Would definitely not consider the category with the tote bag “hero items”. I hate fake leather and brown, so the tote is a big no. I’d skip the box altogether, but I have 2 annuals and I just want them to be over. I want off this ride.

Reply ButtonReply


I’m personally excited for the heated mug set! And I love Grown Alchemist products. Headbands aren’t my style but the necklaces are neutral enough to go with anything. Excited for this box.

Reply ButtonReply


Do you get to customize anything or add anything on if you are not annual? Thank you!

Reply ButtonReply


This box is just ridiculous. They actual think someone would part with $55 for these odds and ends?

Reply ButtonReply


Absolutely trash. I guess some people really like junk and garbage.

Reply ButtonReply


OMG – thank you – you made me gut laugh!!!


Totally agree!!! What a bunch of garbage! Especially those headbands and cheap-o necklaces!!!

Reply ButtonReply


The necklaces look EXACTLY like ones I ordered through a company called Paparazzi for $5.00, except the ones I ordered were shinier. The headbands can be bought for a few dollars – this is unreal – the only thing I have seen that is nice is the brown tote.


Ha, I’m actually looking forward to this box! They didn’t do themselves any favors by making their first set of spoilers the dryer balls/measuring spoons/cream, but I’ve found stuff in every category that I like and more importantly WILL ACTUALLY USE. It’s not as fun as FFF but I have found Causebox/Alltrue to ultimately be more practical than FFF.

Reply ButtonReply


Erinn, I agree! I signed up for an annual after a few too many cocktails one night, but I’m glad I did! No, it’s not as exciting as FFF but I am enjoying picking an item every few days as opposed to all at once. I’m finding items in each category that will be useful in my home. Just got my welcome box yesterday and I’m really happy with it!


One person’s odds and ends is another person’s (🙋🏻‍♀️) treasures.

Reply ButtonReply