My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Paper Source Subscription Box Review – Fall 2020

Paper Source Lifestyle Box
3.3 overall rating
6 Ratings | 3 Reviews

Paper Source has a quarterly lifestyle box that includes some of their favorite items from popular brands like Rifle Paper Co.,, Paddywax, and Lilly Pulitzer and runs $49.95 per season (with free shipping). Expect candles, stationery, and items for your home or office that coincide with each season. By the way, our readers voted this box as one of the Best Stationery Subscriptions of 2020!

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

About this Colorful Home and Lifestyle Box

The Subscription Box: Paper Source Subscription Box

The Cost: $49.95/quarter (A minimum one-year commitment paid in quarterly installments)

The Products: A mix of 10+ stationery and lifestyle items from Paper Source as well as popular home and lifestyle brands.

Ships to: The contiguous U.S. addresses only for free

Paper Source Fall 2020 Review

Updated 8/4/20 to add swatches of marker set. 


This is my first time reviewing the quarterly Paper Source box and man am I happy to be here. I am a for real-for real stationery enthusiast. Whereas my notebook hoarding tendencies have me quietly obsessing over my stash of unbroken bindings and blank pages for months (or years!) before I can well up the courage to write in one, my obsession with pens, greeting cards, and sticky notes manifests in a much healthier outcome: I actually use them! All the time! My friends get mail from me often, and it is my joy to send little notes through the post.

So, here I am gleefully reviewing the Fall 2020 Paper Source box, pleased that it came a bit earlier than I was expecting. Marne has mentioned in past Paper Source reviews that the info card included in each PS delivery tends to show inflated prices. I’m not surprised to hear this, as a quick gander at the price list shows values that all end in “.95” which smells like a round-up to me. Below, you’ll see I’ve provided a link to each item I could find online and noted a more accurate price.


Well-Kept Fitness Cleaning Towelettes, 26 count — Retail Value $12

I’m loving this take on the cleansing towelettes I often see in subscription boxes throughout the summer. Typically it’s face wipes with this trendy ingredient or that to differentiate it from the others. Don’t get me wrong, I find those types of things useful, it can just sometimes feel like everyone had the same idea—but these wipes are meant for exercise equipment or yoga mats, which is clever for this time when people are doing more home workouts. These wipes are vegan, cruelty-free, paraben- and sulfate-free, biodegradable, and made in the USA—yay to all of the above! They’re infused with eucalyptus and mint oils for their antibacterial properties, and, of course, smell very nice.


Soap & Paper Company Jasmine Petite Soap Bar, 3 oz – Retail Value $5

This little bar of soap is listed as costing $9.95 on the Paper Source info card, which I read and thought, “Wow, this must be a life-changing bar of soap!” In reality it costs $5, and even that seems like boutique pricing to me. It’s a nice bar of soap, sure, made in the USA without parabens, phthalates, petrochemicals, or animal testing. But even with its “notes of jasmine absolute, citrus, & tuberose,” it smells like a classic bar of shea butter soap. And it’s relatively small, more like a bar of hand soap that you’d place at your sink than something you’d keep in your shower, I think.


Maggie Holmes Heritage Boxed Cards — Retail Value $13

I’m freaking out! Guys, there are 40 greeting cards in this box! With 10 different designs! And they’re all so cute and so varied! Okay, can we talk about something? You know how sometimes you go out and buy a box of greeting cards, and maybe there are 12 or 18 cards in there, with 1-2 different designs. This is great and you send some to your friends to say hey, or to thank them for being lovely, or perhaps you pass one off as a birthday card. But then, realistically, there are only so many people in your life who you’re actually mailing notes to regularly, and you want to keep it interesting for them because that’s half the fun, so the last few cards in the pack end up lingering around for an eternity. Anyone else in this boat? They always end up being used eventually, and sometimes I even feel sentimental as I grab the last one to write in and send off. But what I’m trying to say here is I’m pretty giddy that not only did my first Paper Source box send me so gloriously many greeting cards to add to my collection, but also that there are only 4 repeats of each adorable design. This is good. I’m happy. I raise my can of sparkling water to this experience.


Detail Doodlers Felt-Tip Pens, 12 ct – Retail Value $10.21

Oh here we go again. I’m breathing into a metaphorical paper bag over these fine-tip markers. The nice case they come in! The triangular shape of the markers (so they don’t roll away)! The fun colors that represent the whole rainbow and more, and in sometimes unexpected ways! These are going to be awesome for envelope decorating.


Boxed Matches Set – Listed Value $4.95

These wooden stick matches are exactly the type I keep on hand to light candles around my house. Actually I had just run out and had it on my to-do list to stock back up, so these came with perfect timing. The tube container is really pleasant! I have these on my front porch, ready and waiting to light citronella candles the next time we sit out there in the evening.


Velvet Zipper Pouch – Listed Value $16.95

Oh, how funny—I actually have a scarf that looks so much like this pouch. It’s made from a light navy cotton, with coral tassels that match the tasseled zipper pull on this little bag perfectly. It was meant to be! I used to feel like I had so many zipper pouches that I didn’t know what to do with them. Then, in recent years, I realized they are the antidote to the reality that a physical mess follows me everywhere I go. I’ve since organized many-a-purse and our diaper bag with things like this. The navy one here (which is more corduroy than “velvet,” by the way) is a good size for tampons, or a lip balm collection, or perhaps for a few folded books of stamps if you want to keep with the stationery theme.


Draper James Manicure Set – Retail Value $25 (found on sale here for $17.50)

This is cute! I love this type of thing for travel—I often think I don’t need to pack nail clippers or tweezers, then wish I had when I get to my destination. Nobody wants a nagging hangnail on vacation. I can’t tell the difference between the two emory boards, but perhaps since that’s the type of thing that does lose its grit after a certain number of uses, they’re just providing us with a backup.


Mary Square Silk Scrunchie – Retail Value $7.95

I’ve been watching the return of the scrunchie from the sidelines, wondering if and when I might enter in but not wanting to make a move. The reason being that I have very fine hair that tends to become eclipsed by big hair accessories. Typically when a trend I’ve been unsure about trying enters my life through the magic of a subscription box, I relish the opportunity, but in this case the blush pink color of this one felt a little cutesy for my style. Alas, it caught my little daughter’s eye and she immediately put it on her wrist just as we were setting off for a walk. Right around the time that she was sweatily ripping it off her arm and handing over to me was when I was in need of an emergency hair tie, and up my hair went in a messy scrunchie situation. I was impressed with the secure hold (I had previously thought of something like this as purely decorative) and realized the pink isn’t so bad after all. It worked out in the end!


Colorblock Journal – Listed Value $14.95

This is a nice pocket notebook with a faux-leather cover, an elastic band to hold it closed, and gold foiled lettering on the front. Pretty straightforward. It’s a nice size for tossing into a bag if you’re the type of person who likes to jot down physical notes now and then. I’ll add it to my notebook stash and wait for the right time to use it!


TOPS Malibu Single Sparkle Wish Sparkler – Retail Value $2

This sparkler came at the exact right time for me, which is to say, a couple of days before my birthday! While I’ve never been one for pomp and circumstance to celebrate my birthday, I appreciate some fun little touches, and had a nice low-key dinner with my family complete with a delicious homemade cake. I figure in the age of covid, nobody (even my “pod”) wants someone blowing all over the cake they’re about to eat, so this mini sparkler was a festive alternative. I blanked on taking a photo of it in action, but it did its sparkly show for the exact length of time that it took for my family to sing “Happy Birthday.” On another note, it’s listed as costing $9.95 on the Paper Source info card—what the what? The actual cost of $2 feels much more appropriate for this over-in-a-minute party supply.


Sensational Succulents Adult Coloring Book – Retail Value $11.59

I’ve always found adult coloring books to be such a nice idea, but haven’t spent much time with them. I really like that this one doubles as a journal. I think the dual uses of this book would make for such a nice travel pastime. I’ve been hard at work bringing my daughter’s Sesame Street coloring book to life alongside her, so my coloring skills are all brushed up and ready for the finer detail in this succulent one.


Mantra Mask Hemp CBD Collagen Sheet Mask – Retail Value $15

I admittedly had to giggle when I saw the name of this sheet mask: “Hemp CBD Collagen”—how many more buzz words can you fit in? Jokes aside, I have no issues with using hemp products and collagen, but after years of trying to conform to the sheet mask craze I finally admitted to myself that they simply don’t put me at ease. They sort of just make me feel drippy and stuck and stress me out. I think I’m in the minority here, and can think of several friends who will welcome this mask experience with open arms.


Sugarfina Italian Spritz Gummies – Retail Value $8.95 (currently on sale for $2.68)

I’m not typically a gummy person (chocolate, always!), but I do think Sugarfina has a way of coming up with interesting and delicious flavors, so I was happy to give these a try. My daughter and I ate about half the box and then I had to go hide them because the sweet citrusy flavor was pretty great for a hot summer day. Better than a gummy bear, in my opinion!

Paper Source Virtual Workshop Pass – Retail Value $25

I learned from reading Marne’s past PS reviews that the Paper Source subscription includes a voucher every quarter. This time around it’s a $25 voucher for one of their online workshops, which include things like hand-lettering classes, watercolor lessons, and the one I think I’ll take, which is learning paper quilling. I’ve always been fascinated by this craft! The workshops all cost $25 so this voucher will cover the total cost.

Verdict: My first Paper Source subscription has me doing a celebratory jig over here! What a thrill of a lifestyle box to receive and explore. While I was sent the Fall box on the early end of their shipping window, meaning I received it while it still feels like summer, I thought the contents were versatile enough that they didn’t seem off-season. My favorite items were for sure the stationery-themed ones (the box of cards and the doodle pens), but the rest of the assortment was enjoyable, as well, highlights being the matches, the manicure kit, and the birthday cake sparkler. I received a total of 13 items plus a $25 voucher for an online class, which all together add up to a retail value of $158.78. I calculated this value based on a combination of actual retail values found online (using the sale prices for the manicure kit & Sugarfina gummies) and, for items I couldn’t find online, listed values provided by PS. This total is not as impressive as the promised value of $197.35 (found by adding up all the list values on the PS info card), but it’s still a great deal for the spread of useful and adorable products sent in this $49.95 box. I’m happy with the value and the curation. I really look forward to next quarter’s box!

If you’re interested in more great lifestyle subscriptions, check out our list of the 19 best subscription boxes for women in 2020!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes! As of the publication of this review, the Fall box is still available.

Value Breakdown: At $49.95 for this box, you are paying approximately $3.84 for each of the 13 items. Or, $3.57 per item if you include the voucher.

Check out our other Paper Source subscription box reviews right here.

Keep track of your subscriptions by adding this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Do you like what came in the Fall Paper Source subscription box as much as I did?

"Paper Source Lifestyle Box is a quarterly subscription that delivers exclusively curated lifestyle products. Each of the four boxes contains $200 in retail value."
Christen Russo
Christen Russo
Christen is a smile collector, outdoors enthusiast, and appreciator of soggy French fries. Her favorite subscriptions involve eco-friendly products and clothes, nature supplies, stationery, and coffee. She can be easily won over with a good sheet of stickers.

Christen Russo
Christen Russo
Christen is a smile collector, outdoors enthusiast, and appreciator of soggy French fries. Her favorite subscriptions involve eco-friendly products and clothes, nature supplies, stationery, and coffee. She can be easily won over with a good sheet of stickers.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


Joy-Not the Other One

I went for it! Spent some time going through the older reviews on here and couldn’t find a single month I would have been disappointed to receive. So excited!


I love this box! I was just going to go sign up for a box, but it says that it first authorizes your card for 199, then charges for 49.99. I don’t mind being tied in for a year, but I’m not liking that they want to authorize my card for $200 right away if it is going to be paid quarterly.

Christen Russo



What a great, thorough review! Honestly, this box looks better than anything in FFF this season – I’d definitely use everything here. Not sure I’m ready to sign up for an annual sub, though.

Christen Russo

I appreciate your kind words so much, Charlotte! I agree that this box is still fantastic without the inflated pricing (and actually, accurate pricing representation would be one more detail that would make me love this box even more, if that’s possible). Perhaps you have Paper Source in your future!


Also, just want to say I appreciate you pointing out the pricing discrepancies. It’s weird, because I don’t think they need inflate the RV to make this box appealing (but then I’m someone who gets sub boxes because I like what’s in them, not because I think I’m getting a steal).


This seems like a weird (and somewhat rudely phrased) request.


I don’t believe I have ever looked at a review of this box before but it looks great. I agree with you on the face masks. I really really……..hate those things. I find it difficult to believe that the majority of people want those cold, slimy things on their face. Any hoo, great review and good products


I soak the packets in warm water before opening and putting them on my face. Makes a big difference

Christen Russo

Woahhh I am learning so many sheet mask tricks. I might have to try this before writing them off completely! Thanks for sharing!


Thanks for the tip!


Thank you for this joyful review. It looks like a wonderful box. Unfortunately, I have given into resubscribing to FFF and a few others.. so will have to give this a miss. I hope we can get a preview of the Winter box before it sells out?

Christen Russo

Thank you, Al! Keep an eye out for our Paper Source spoilers posts, we usually launch them at least a month (sometimes more) in advance!


Your review was so great! I looked at the photo of the products and thought, “Not for me. Maybe next quarter.” Then, I read the review, and I want it.

Also, I read a game changing tip about sheet masks on MSA (thanks to whoever posted it). —Amazon sells a thing called a sheet mask cover. It’s a face sized piece of silicone that has cut outs for eyes and mouth, a contoured cover for the nose, and straps to go behind the ears to secure it and your sheet mask in place. It’s not pretty, but it works, and I now use all the sheet masks instead of stashing them away.


All of the Daiso stores in my area stock those reusable silicone sheet mask covers for $1.50 – it’s great because it keeps the sheet mask in place and retains moisture by preventing evaporation. I use mine way more than I expected to!

Christen Russo

Thanks so much for reading my review, Tiffany! Also, that DOES sound game changing. I feel like that mask cover itself would be a great thing to receive in a subscription box!

Joy-Not the Other One

First off, loved this box and review. Second, Um…why in the world would you think you could rock those awesome earrings in this review and then not even mention them or share where you got them?!?!?! Spill it! Those are AMAZING!!

Christen Russo

Oh my gosh! Thank you so much! They’re radishes—I made them using polymer clay. It was my first time using it since I was a kid and I went to town creating gigantic fruit & veggie earrings ’cause why not? 😅

Joy-Not the Other One

You made those?! Holey smokes, that is even cooler. 🙂 Do you happen to sell them on Etsy or anything? Sorry to be so nosy but I LOVE THEM!


I should just bite the bullet and sub to this. I usually like 75% of each box and that makes it still worth the splurge. Not sure what’s holding me back. I would totally use that voucher.


I’ve been subbing since the start and I always like enough to make it worth the cost! That’s hard to do!

Christen Russo

Oh my gosh Pamela I wish I could go back in time and subscribe to this one from the start. I feel like I need to make up for lost time!! Next quarter can’t come soon enough!

Christen Russo

Sometimes when subs include a discount code or voucher it just goes right in the recycling bin, but this is one I know I’ll actually use. It definitely adds to the value of the box for me! How serendipitous is this: the day after I wrote this review, a birthday card arrived in the mail from my childhood best friend, and it was a Paper Source card with a paper quilled llama on it. It was way too excited!


Does this sub ever go on sale or have a discount??

Christen Russo

Hey Jeanette! To the best of my knowledge, the Paper Source box is always “limited edition” and they tend to sell through them full price. But, if a discount opportunity arises, we’ll include it right under the price indication in future reviews!


This is my favorite review of all time! I love how much joy you put into it. You also make me want to step up my friend game and start sending my stock pile of cards to people. So lazy though!!!

Christen Russo

Thanks for tagging along for the ride, Kristin! I sent about 30 cards right when quarantine started and totally burnt myself out, so my friends will have to wait a bit for their next installment, lol. It’ll happen for you when the time is right!


Great box! I think this sub will be my birthday gift to myself.

Christen Russo

And a wonderful gift it will be!

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.