Facebook PixelThe Supernatural Box Review - Summer 2019 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Supernatural Box Review – Summer 2019

Carol Castaneda
ByCarol CastanedaAug 16, 2019 | 2 comments

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Box review Top

Supernatural Box
4.6 overall rating
7 Ratings | 1 Reviews

The Supernatural Box is a quarterly subscription box for the Supernatural superfan. Each box includes premium collectibles, apparel, plus fun and functional everyday items that relate to the TV show. It comes from Culture Fly – the same team behind Pusheen Box, The Nick Box, DC Comics World’s Finest: The Collection, and a few more!

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Box Open Top

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - All Contenet Front

About The Supernatural Box

The Subscription Box: Supernatural Box

The Cost: $49.99 per quarter + shipping. Save with an annual subscription.

The Products: Eight items including 100% exclusive apparel, accessories, collectibles and more valued at over $100

Ships to: The U.S. for $7, Internationally for varying rates

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 Review

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Card FrontSupernatural Box Summer 2019 - Card Back

Every quarter, my box comes with a card that lists the items and even shows little pictures. This helps to let me check through my box to make sure I have everything. I do this quickly, though, by counting then opening each item trying to avoid the pictures. I love being surprised!

Before I get into the items, I wanted to provide a little backstory on Baby, Dean’s beloved 1967 Chevrolet Impala. Dean got this car from his dad, who bought it in 1973 after future Dean convinces him to buy it over a VW van (episode 3, season 4). The trunk holds the guy’s stuff: a mass of weapons to aid the brothers through their hunting activities. Naturally, this is Dean’s baby and he has named her Baby. This quarter, a lot of the items are a tribute to Baby who even had her own episode (episode 4, season 11).

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Led Tote Bag FrontSupernatural Box Summer 2019 - Led Tote Bag Close ViewSupernatural Box Summer 2019 - Led Tote Bag Inside View

LED Tote Bag

This tote is the coolest bag I have ever received. Baby’s headlights even really light up! There is a battery pack in the bag that is easily switched on and off to make her lights shine. The bag is black and says “To Hell and Back.” Considering how many times many of the characters have actually been to hell and back, I’d say this is pretty fitting. The bag is also really roomy! I put my 8x10 picture of Sam and Dean inside and it still has a lot of room. This bag is great for almost anything, but I think I will be using it to tote around some files and snacks for my day.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Graphic T-Shirt FrontSupernatural Box Summer 2019 - Graphic T-Shirt Close View 1Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Graphic T-Shirt Close View 2

Graphic T-Shirt

I love the shirts I get in my Supernatural sub. They are original and pretty fun. This month, I got a short-sleeved all black shirt with a Supernatural design on the front in white. The design is something I would expect from this sub: a logo with angel wings, the anti-possession symbol, and the devil’s trap symbol. The shirt also has the quote “The Family Business, "Saving People," and "Hunting Things” on it. The shirt is a size XL and is a bit big since I am (slowly) losing weight after baby #3, but it is perfect for sitting on the couch bingeing the final (sniffle) season.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Tumbler 1Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Tumbler 2Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Tumbler 3Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Tumbler 4


This is a pretty rad tumbler. It's black and red and has ready-to-fight Sam and Dean in front of Baby. It is a great cup with a plastic straw and is BPA free. The cup is not microwaveable and should be hand washed only.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Dean Plush 1Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Dean Plush 2Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Dean Plush 3Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Dean Plush 4

Dean Plush

Oh my goodness!! I love this little Dean! These plushes are so much cooler than the vinyl figures we used to receive. Even though there really aren’t facial expressions, it is easy to tell who is who. Dean is wearing jeans, brown shoes and a button-up plaid shirt over a plain colored shirt. He has light brown hair and is super adorbs. He looks great with the Cas doll I got last quarter.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Acrylic Keychain 1Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Acrylic Keychain 2Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Acrylic Keychain 3Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Acrylic Keychain 4

Acrylic Keychain

I like keychains; I feel like they bring character to boring keys. This keychain also speaks the truth and the number 1 car rule: Driver picks the music (though these days I am stuck listening to Elmo and the baby is not driving). The keychain features Baby and looks like an old diner sign. It's cute, it's small and is perfect for the car keys.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Baby Charm Top 1Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Baby Charm Top 2Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Baby Charm Top 3

Baby Charm

I look forward to a new charm every quarter! This month, it is Baby! The charm is right of her front view, showing her bumper and lights, hood, and front windshield allowing us to see a little into the car. The charm fits perfectly with the other two I have received since subscribing. Together, I have a great Supernatural charm bracelet coming along.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Art Print Front

Art Print

Culture Fly includes some sort of art print in every box. This quarter is of a smoldering Dean and Sam in what appears to be a tunnel (I think it may be their bunker). Ah, it takes my breath away. The only thing it is missing is their autograph. While I like these photos, I haven’t really hung them up or displayed them. I just keep them in an easily accessible corner that I visit every now and then to admire them.

Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Pcture Frame 2Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Pcture Frame 3Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Pcture Frame 4Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Pcture Frame 5Supernatural Box Summer 2019 - Pcture Frame 1

Picture Frame

The last item in this quarter’s box is this picture frame. I actually really like this frame! I love the tread marks down the sides of the frame and of course Baby on the bottom. This frame is perfect as-is if I wanted to keep Sam and Dean framed or I can switch it out when my oldest starts driving. Since that is a few years away, I will keep Sam and Dean framed. They really are pretty cute to look at...

Verdict: The Supernatural Box by Culture Fly is really fun for fans! Every box has similar items, such as art prints or charms, but I always look forward to them and the different designs I may receive. I liked how this box featured a lot of Baby, and even though they don’t name a theme, the boxes center on something specific. I really liked the tote bag and charm in this box with the charm being my top favorite item. For $56.99 ($49.99 + $7 shipping), I received authentic, original Supernatural items. Considering the quality of the 8 items, I consider it a pretty fair deal.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No. If you sign up now, you should get the Fall 2019 box.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $49.99 + $7.00 shipping which means that each of the 8 items in the box has an average cost of $7.12.

Check out all of our Supernatural Box reviews and more Geeky Subscription Boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the Summer 2019 Supernatural Box?

Starting at $49.99
Subscribe Now
Supernatural is an officially licensed, quarterly mystery box from CultureFly. Each box will include 100% exclusive Supernatural items, including apparel, accessories, collectibles and more!
Carol Castaneda
Carol Castaneda
I am a mother of 2 going on 3 soon and enjoy the little things in life, especially in surprise form! Monthly subscription boxes give me that surprise every time I see the mailman delivering them! My favorite boxes include beauty boxes, lifestyle boxes and anything pregnancy-related boxes; my all time favorite is my FabFitFun subscription.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Why can’t they make a Stranger Things box? 😩

Reply ButtonReply


I’m a bit embarrassed to admit this, but I think the print is of them in the car garage at the bunker. 🤷‍♀️

Reply ButtonReply