Facebook PixelThe Supernatural Box Review – Spring 2019 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Supernatural Box Review – Spring 2019

Supernatural Box - 2019 Box

Supernatural Box
4.6 overall rating
7 Ratings | 1 Reviews

The Supernatural Box is a quarterly subscription box for the Supernatural fan superfan. Each box includes premium collectibles, apparel and artifacts from Supernatural. It comes from Culturefly – the same team behind Pusheen Box, The Nick Box, DC Comics World’s Finest: The Collection and a few more!

Supernatural Box - 2019 Open Box

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Supernatural Box - 2019 All Contents

About The Supernatural Box

The Box: Supernatural Box

The Cost: $49.99 per quarter or $179.96 for annual subscription
The Products: Eight items including 100% exclusive apparel, accessories, collectibles and more valued at over $100
Ships to: The U.S. for $7, Internationally for $20-$30

The Supernatural Box Spring 2019 Review

Supernatural Box - 2019 Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Back

My box came with an insert that showed exactly what was in my box. I took a quick peek then put it aside; I really want to be surprised when I look at everything for the first time!

Supernatural Box - 2019 Mirror

Supernatural Box - 2019 Mirror Open Box

Supernatural Box - 2019 Etched Glass Artwork with Frame Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Etched Glass Artwork with Frame Top

Etched Glass Artwork with Frame

The first item in my box is the super cool artwork. I get a lot of artwork in subscription boxes and the majority of them are just on a piece of paper, so it was really delightful to get this artwork etched in glass. The glass is reflective and can also serve as a mirror. It features the shadows of Dean, Cass and Baby, Dean’s Impala. It also has the logo: “Saving People, Hunting Things, The Family Business.” This will go great on my desk.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Anti-Possession Book Ends Top

Supernatural Box - 2019 Anti-Possession Book Ends Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Anti-Possession Book Ends Side

Anti-Possession Book Ends

Not too long ago, I was on the search for the perfect bookends for some of the guideline books I have at work. I was so psyched to see these included in my box this month! They are metal and have the anti-possession symbol that Dean and Sam have tattooed on them which sits on top of Cass’s wings. These are perfect and while they weren’t exactly what I had in mind, they worked just perfectly for what I needed.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Castiel Plush Top

Supernatural Box - 2019 Castiel Plush Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Castiel Plush Back

Castiel Plush

It is like CultureFly read my last review and curated this just for me! I hoped to receive more Cass items in my next box and dun-dun-dun!! A Cass plush! I prefer this plush to the vinyl figures. Even though the face is not detailed, its pretty cute. He’s got on his tie and his trench coat and, of course, his wings. I adore this little plush and hope to build a collection.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Castiel’s Wings Charm Top

Supernatural Box - 2019 Castiel’s Wings Charm Top

Supernatural Box - 2019 Castiel’s Wings Charm Open

Castiel’s Wings Charm

Another Cass item?! Please and thank you! I enjoy the charms that I receive in my Supernatural subscription. Last quarter it was a piece of pie and this month is it Cass’s wings. They are silver and are pretty detailed for being so small and has a clip to attach to a charm bracelet.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Supernatural Art Work

Supernatural Art Work

This is only my second Supernatural Box, but I have learned that artwork is apart of each one and they are welcomed! This one shows the shadows of Cass, Dean and Sam with different symbols. Above Cass is the angel banishing sigil, above Dean is the anti-possession symbol and above Sam is the standard devil's trap. The figures seem to be on some sort of glass mural, like something one would see in a church. I like this artwork it's pretty groovy.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Hey Ass-Butt Notebook Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Hey Ass-Butt Notebook Top

Supernatural Box - 2019 Hey Ass-Butt Notebook Open

Supernatural Box - 2019 Hey Ass-Butt Notebook Back

Hey Ass-Butt Notebook

As soon as I saw this I laughed. I remember the first time Cass said this when he threw the molotov cocktail at Michael in Adam’s vessel. Even though the episode is really sad and the beginning of truly horrific things for Sam, Cass brings humor to the episode. This notebook is spot on. It features Cass with his wings out and the angel banishing symbol across his chest. The pages inside are lined and have the angel banishing symbol on each page. The notebook has a red ribbon bookmark and has 77 pages.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Ballpoint Pen with Stylus Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Ballpoint Pen with Stylus Side

Supernatural Box - 2019 Ballpoint Pen with Stylus Top

Ballpoint Pen with Stylus

I love that CultureFly provided a pen with the notebook. This pen is really cool, with tribal etchings. Here and there, ‘Castiel’ and ‘Supernatural Join the Hunt’ is printed on the silver barrel. This retractable .05mm ball point pen features a blue grip and writes smoothly in blue ink.

Supernatural Box - 2019 Long Sleeved Logo TShirt Front

Supernatural Box - 2019 Long Sleeved Logo TShirt Top

Supernatural Box - 2019 Long Sleeved Logo TShirt Side

Long Sleeved Logo T-Shirt

The final item in this quarter’s Supernatural subscription is this awesome black shirt with red print. It has the same symbols we’ve seen throughout this box: anti-possession symbol, angel banishing symbol and a devils trap symbol. It states “Family Don’t End With Blood” and “Team Free Will.” I love how “Supernatural Join The Hunt” is printed on the sleeve. This shirt came in the size I requested, an XL, but it is truly an extra large and is big on me. I will be using this as a nightshirt while I binge Supernatural reruns on Netflix.

Verdict: I love Supernatural and have finally caught up on all the seasons. Like so many other fans, hearing its final season is coming up is bittersweet. This box really contains some cool, practical stuff from the series that I will 100% use. I am so happy that I received a plush instead of the vinyl figure and loved the shirt, even if it was pretty big on me. I also really loved the notebook; it makes me laugh every time I look at it. I liked this box a lot and am looking forward to future boxes!!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? If you sign up now, you should get the Summer 2019 box.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $49.99 + $7.00 shipping which means that each of the 8 items in the box has an average cost of $7.12.

Check out all of our Supernatural Box reviews and more Geeky Subscription Boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the Spring 2019 Supernatural Box?

Starting at $49.99
Subscribe Now
Supernatural is an officially licensed, quarterly mystery box from CultureFly. Each box will include 100% exclusive Supernatural items, including apparel, accessories, collectibles and more!
Carol Castaneda
Carol Castaneda
I am a mother of 2 going on 3 soon and enjoy the little things in life, especially in surprise form! Monthly subscription boxes give me that surprise every time I see the mailman delivering them! My favorite boxes include beauty boxes, lifestyle boxes and anything pregnancy-related boxes; my all time favorite is my FabFitFun subscription.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



That plushie is everything!

Reply ButtonReply


Be cool to see a Supernatual box that wasn’t based on the show.

Just a box on supernatural things.

Reply ButtonReply

P Suzanne Garrett

I like that idea… would be cool to see a paranormal investigation/ ghost hunter box.

Reply ButtonReply