Supernatural Box Review – Winter 2018


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Box Review Front

The Supernatural Box is a quarterly subscription box for the Supernatural superfan. Each box includes premium collectibles, apparel, and artifacts from Supernatural. It comes from Culturefly – the same team behind Pusheen Box, The Nick Box, DC Comics World’s Finest: The Collection and a few more!

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Box Open

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - All Products

About The Supernatural Box

The Box: Supernatural Box

The Cost: $49.99 per quarter or $179.96 for an annual subscription

The Products: Eight items, including 100% exclusive apparel, accessories, collectibles and more valued at over $100.

Ships to: the US for $7 US, Internationally for $20 – $30

Winter 2018 Supernatural Box Review

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Theme

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Info Card

As soon as I opened my box, I was presented with a ton of Supernatural gear and this card which lists all the items in the box.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Art Print 1

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Art Print 2

Art Print

The first item in the box is this great art print featuring Sam, Dean, Castiel and Crowley in front of a church with falling stars (asteroids?) all around. Ah, I am in LOVE! I could look at this all day long. However, my daughter (Team Dean) has called dibs on this so I guess I won’t be hanging this in my bedroom.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Melamine Plate SetSupernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Melamine Plate Set 1

Melamine Plate Set

The next item I got in the winter box was this pair of plates.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Melamine Plate Set 2

The first plate has a design I see a lot in this box which I find pretty busy. It says “Saving People, Hunting Things, The Family Business.” It has angel wings and halo, fire, devil’s tails, an outline of Sam and Dean, the anti-possession symbol, Dean’s 1967 Impala and an angel blade and demon-killing knife crossed over each other. I mean, it pretty much is the whole series in one picture. Either way, it’s a cool plate.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Melamine Plate Set 3

Now I like this plate so much more, from the colors to the design. I love the blue against the black. It says “Dean Says ‘Eat More Pie, Join the Hunt.’” Both the plates are the perfect size for a perfect piece of pie.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Knit Beanie

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Knit Beanie 1

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Knit Beanie 2

Knit Beanie

I really liked this beanie! It is black, accented with blue and grey and features the anti-possession symbol all around. The blue pom on the top is perfect! Wearing this, I know demons cannot possess me! Try again!

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Castiel’s Angel Wing Silicone MoldSupernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Castiel’s Angel Wing Silicone Mold 1Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Castiel’s Angel Wing Silicone Mold 2

Castiel’s Angel Wing Silicone Mold

Alright, all cards on the table this is one of my least favorite item which is a total and complete bummer because Castiel is my favorite character! It is a blue silicone mold of angel wings and a tie (?) looking shape in the middle. I guess it would make sense if it were a tie considering Cass’s extremely limited wardrobe. But the mold is too big for ice and I don’t really make Jell-O. I guess I could use this for cookies – if I ever make cookies. Either way, it was a miss for me and, like I said, total bummer.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Sam Vinyl Figure

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Sam Vinyl Figure 1Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Sam Vinyl Figure 2

Sam Vinyl Figure

Whoa, talk about a miss! This is my first Supernatural Box but I have seen previous ones that featured other vinyl collectibles like Dean and even then, I thought he looked nothing like Dean. Mine is no different. The only way to know this is Sam is by the hair. That’s it. I do wonder why these lack so much character and significant details. Maybe they should include more about the design or the artist to get a better comprehension about the design. Or lack thereof.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Ceramic Mug

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Ceramic Mug 1Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Ceramic Mug 2

Ceramic Mug

The next item I received in this season’s box was this black and blue ceramic mug. The design matches the white plate but the colors match the other one. It is neither dishwasher or microwave safe.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Metal Pie Charm

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Metal Pie Charm 1

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Metal Pie Charm 2Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Metal Pie Charm 3

Metal Pie Charm

I liked this item! It is a tiny charm, with a piece of pie on a plate and a fork next to the pie (Ah, Dean and his love of pies). It has a clasp to add to any charm bracelet and that is where I have a bit of negativity to share: what if I didn’t have a charm bracelet? I mean, a lot of people don’t. I do wish that a charm bracelet was included if they are going to start sending out charms, which would make charms something to look forward to in every box. Charm bracelet or not, it’s a cool inclusion for me but I am not sure if every subscriber would feel the same way.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Throw Blanket

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Throw Blanket 1

Throw Blanket

We released a spoiler a few months ago so I was really hoping to get this blanket. It fits the theme of the box, black and blue and features the devil’s trap symbol. It is a really cool blanket and is pretty cozy, though it isn’t for very tall people. The image above is being held by my 8-year old daughter who is a whole 3 feet 9. We will be cuddled up together watching Sam and Dean blast monsters with this.

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Cute Little PigSupernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Cute Little Pig 1

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Cute Little Pig 2

Supernatural Box Review Winter 2018 - Cute Little Pig 3

Pig ‘N A Poke Cutting Board

The final item I received is this cutting board of a cute little pig advertising the Pig ‘N A Poke. This is the Groundhog Day-like episode that Same keeps reliving Dean’s Death. Dean orders the pig n a poke with a side of bacon and tries to change the dish to offset what the day should bring. Probably one of my favorite episodes, so I was excited to get this.

Verdict: This was my first Supernatural Box and I was pretty stoked when the mailman brought it to my door (too big to fit in the mailbox), and yes, I just happened to have it on Supernatural at the time (currently on season 7). As soon as I was able to, I opened it up to see what was inside. I am pretty pleased with the items, except for the vinyl figure. Though I do not know what to do with the silicone wings and tie, I don’t mind it, but hope I get a better Cass item in future boxes.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? If you sign up now, you should get the Spring 2019 box.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $49.99 + 7.00 shipping; a total of $56.99, which means that each of the 8 items in the box has an average cost of $7.12.

Check out all of our Geeky Subscription Boxes in the Subscription Box List. Rate, review, and follow this subscription on the Supernatural Box profile page.

What do you think of the Winter 2018 Supernatural Box?

How do subscribers rate Supernatural Box?

5 subscribers rated this subscription
4.7
out of 5 stars
Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Supernatural Box? Add your rating now!


Written by Carol Castaneda

Carol Castaneda

I am a mother of 2 going on 3 soon and enjoy the little things in life, especially in surprise form! Monthly subscription boxes give me that surprise every time I see the mailman delivering them! My favorite boxes include beauty boxes, lifestyle boxes and anything pregnancy-related boxes; my all time favorite is my FabFitFun subscription.

Posted in Subscription Box Reviews, Supernatural Box Reviews| Tags: supernatural box | 9 comments

9 Comments

  1. They did send a charm bracelet in box 4 I think. Now a charm comes in every box. I am really enjoying these boxes. I feel like a kid waiting for it to come in the mail and I am 47!

  2. Wow I thought it was all high quality, awesome stuff. That little charm could be hooked on a million different places.. The Sam figure is supposed to be a cartoonish version. I think its all awesome

  3. I want to subscribe, but I hate the look of the vinyl figures. 🙁

  4. I have watched these young men suits season 1 and I just signed up to subscribe to this box I know you said it wasn’t all that great but I don’t care I just love them glossy I dropped Birchbox so now I can afford this little wonderful thing that delighted absolutely delighted

  5. I would fill that mold up with chocolate my self. They just got renewed for season 15!!

    • That is brilliant! Homemade Valentines chocolates!

  6. Pretty sure the print is of the angels falling to earth not asteroids.

    • That would make sense. Im only in season 8 so I’ve yet to see that happen.

      • I just finished the season finale of episode 8 and they are definitely angels falling to the earth!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

*