MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Our Subscription Box Favorites for September!

We’ve started a new monthly post highlighting our favorite discoveries from subscription boxes! Here are our favorite items from the past month:

Anna Reilly’s Favorite:

robb vices rum

The Item: Clement VSOP Rum

The Cost: $47.99

From: Robb Vices “Ultimate Daiquiri” Box

Why I love it: Gin? Bourbon? Sure. But until this box, I’ve never thought of myself as a rum person. This smooth, flavorful rum was a beautiful gateway for me to learn about what the drink can be beyond the world of rum and Cokes at hole-in-the-wall bars that I’m used to. The simple daiquiri recipe that was printed in the booklet for the box is officially my new favorite weekend treat. It’s an easy way to impress friends who drop by or to make Netflix night a little more fun.

Read more reviews by Anna!

Abby’s Favorite:

The Item: Smashmallow Cinnamon Churro Smashcrispy, 1.15oz

The Cost: Buy a 6 pack here for $5

From: SnackSack (Coupon: Use coupon code MY15 to save 15% on the lifetime of your subscription!)

Why I love it: This snack is a very fun twist on your average rice crispy treat. Fall is here, and I’ve been craving spicy cinnamon sugar, and at 130 calories a bar, this chewy, sticky snack is the perfect, guiltless solution!

Read more reviews by Abby!

Jessica’s Favorite:

The Item: Different Dimension Sick of Your Crop Nail Polish

The Cost: this is an exclusive shade made just for The Holo Hookup, but check out other holographic polishes from Different Dimension here

From: The Holo Hookup

Why I love it: This duochrome holographic polish is truly epic- it has a full rainbow holo shift as well as a duochrome shift that goes between copper, violet, and green. This polish was exclusive only to the September Holo Hookup box, and I will be treasuring this beauty for a long while to come.

Read more reviews by Jessica!

Laine’s Favorite:

The Item: Character Toothbrush Kit

From: Yume Twins (Coupon: Use code 3OFF to save $3 off your first box!)

Why I love it: I travel a lot, but not usually on long trips; an overnight to my mom’s house, a quick work jaunt, going out of town for a wedding, etc. For some reason, I always forget my toothbrush! This set is so cute; I love the dark purple, Hello Kitty pattern. The toothbrush folds into itself, so I can also keep it in my purse if I want, and I like the cup, too – it will also be great for these short trips, so I don’t have to waste paper products in order to have water on my nightstand.

Read more reviews by Laine!

Ragan’s Favorite:

Kitnipbox September 2018 Wand

The Item: Tiger Tail Mascot Wand

The Cost: Listed Value $7

From: KitNipBox (Coupon: Save 15% off your first box with code SUBSCRIPTIONADDICTION15)

Why I love it: A lot of the time, I pick the item that gets me the best cat pictures.  I could look at cat pictures all day.  This toy was well-loved by several different cats:

Kitnipbox September 2018 Angus 4

Kitnipbox September 2018 Monkey 4

Kitnipbox September 2018 Sneaky 4

Read more reviews by Ragan!

Nich’s Favorite:

singlesswag gloss

The Item: Pūrlisse Watermelon Energizing Aqua Balm, 1.7 oz 

The Cost: $45.00

From: SinglesSwag (Coupon: Save 20% off your first box with code MSA20)

Why I love it: I love this lightweight moisturizing gel-cream face balm. I have been using it daily with the Blue Lotus 4-in-1 Cleansing Milk, and it has left my skin moisturized and refreshed. I tend to use face creams that are heavy, and this is a welcome change to have a moisturizer that’s so lightweight and effective. The energizing balm is oil-free and best for all skin types.

Read more reviews by Nich!

Brandi’s Favorite:

The Item: Disney Parks Mickey and Minnie Pumpkin Salt and Pepper Set

The Cost: $22.85

From: Mickey Monthly (Coupon: For a limited time, use code MY5OFF to save $5 off your first box!)

Why I love it: This was a tough month to choose a favorite since I received so many great items, but being that it’s finally October, I am getting all the Halloween feels, so these are what came to mind first! Halloween is my favorite holiday and anything that helps me celebrate it is always appreciated. I love the cute Disney twist on jack o’lanterns and that these aren’t just decorative but also useful! These salt and pepper shakers are currently looking very cute and festive on my kitchen table and I’m glad that I have them to bring out each year!

Read more reviews by Brandi!

Colette’s Favorite:

The Item:  Azucena Leather Wrap Bracelet (Forest)

The Cost: Exclusive to the box! 

From: My Meraki Box

Why I love it: I’m so into wrap bracelets this fall, and I love the beautiful green complimented with the sterling silver clasp. The quad wrap is a fun twist, and I love the thin leather coupled with the 4 wraps for the perfect, easy, go to the bracelet! 

Savannah’s Favorite:

The Item: 2017 Restless Earth Grenache

The Cost: Retail Value $24.99 (or $19 through subscription)

From: Winc Wine of the Month (Coupon: $25 off your first order, no coupon required, just use this link)

Why I Love It: I’m not much of a red wine fan, so originally, I wasn’t very excited to taste test this grenache. Boy, was my attitude all wrong! It was light, smooth, and crafted with such care. The grapes were grown at 2800-3200 feet above sea level, in a high-elevation location that provides a great deal of UV intensity. A daily temperature swing between 30-40 degrees protects the grapes from the harshness of the sun. Then, they’re picked at night and fermented in a whole cluster. I’ve never had a red like this before, and I’ll make it a point to have more reds like this in the future. Did this grenache just make a red wine believer out of me? I think so.

Read more reviews by Savannah!

Marne’s Favorites:

Premium Snail Wrinkle Serum by Haute Cuisine

Sun Project Water Sun cream with 50 SPF from Thank You Farmer

The Items: Tie between Premium Snail Wrinkle Serum by Haute CuisineSun Project Water Sun Cream with 50 SPF from Thank You Farmer

The Cost: Retail Value $28.40 + $23.00

Both From: JoahBox (Coupon: Use code MYJOAHBOX to save 10% off!)

Why I love them: The serum is made with snail slime which is just cool and the combination of it with the super thin and sun-blocking moisturizer makes my skin glow!

Read more reviews by Marne!

Andy’s Favorite:

Olight S1 Baton Flashlight with 16340 Battery

The Item: Olight S1 Baton Flashlight with 16340 Battery 

The Cost: $44.95

From: BattlBox (Coupon: Use code MYSUBTEN to save 10% off your first box!)

Why I love it: I have been carrying it daily and have found myself using it almost every day for minor things here and there. It’s so tiny yet super powerful.

Read more reviews by Andy!

What do you think of our favorites for September? And what were your favorite discoveries?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Subscription Box News| 6 comments

Comments (6)

  1. As always, no Liz favorite at publication

    • Maybe she can’t pick just one or didn’t like anything enough to list it as a favorite.

  2. Liz can we please get an update on the swap site changes that were supposed to be made? And thank you for removing the ads on the swap page! Thanks in advance for the reply.

    • I 2nd that thank you for removing the Ads.

  3. So many great items this month! I really like the Mickey pumpkins 🎃. I notice your favorite isn’t listed @Liz. My favorite this month is the S’well wooden water bottle from causebox.

  4. The Pūrlisse Watermelon Energizing Aqua Balm from SinglesSwag is my favorite too. Love the scent and it’s the first moisturizer I’ve used that doesn’t make my oily skin oiler.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


The Cyber Monday Box Deals We’re Actually Buying
See The Best Deals