BoxyCharm Subscription Box Review – October 2018


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

BoxyCharm is a full-size beauty and makeup subscription box. They always provide a great value compared the cost of the box. (If you are a makeup addict – I HIGHLY recommend this box!)

This box was sent to us for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

The Subscription Box: BoxyCharm

The Cost: $21 a month

The Products: 5-6 beauty items that will include nail care, skin care, makeup, haircare, fragrance and more. (At least 4 of those items will be full-sized).

Ships to: US and Canada

Check out all of our Boxycharm reviews!

Each box comes with a card detailing the items included. This month is a “Alter Ego”!

And on the back of the card are coupons from some of the brands featured in boxes:

Now, on to the items!

KAT VON D Everlasting Liquid Lipstick in Bow N Arrow – Retail Value $20

All subscribers will receive this item. Shades will vary.

This liquid lipstick has a matte finish, great pigment, and staying power, and wears down evenly.

(Swatched in lower photo.)

PUR Midnight Masquerade – Retail Value $38

All subscribers will receive this item.

This palette includes 6 eyeshadows: 5 shimmers, and one burgundy matte.

On the opposite side, there are 2 blushes, a bronzer, and a highlighter. (All shimmery!)

The pigment is great throughout this palette. Here’s a swatch for each color under the liquid lip:

(All swatches are one heavy-handed swipe)

IT Cosmetics Superhero Mascara – Retail Value $24

All subscribers will receive this item.

IT Cosmetics is one of my favorite makeup brands (they make the best ever under-eye concealer) and this mascara is impressive, too. The formula provides awesome length and volume, and I was able to apply many layers without any clumping.

Briogeo Don’t Despair Repair! Leave-In Mask (2 oz) Retail Value $14

This is a variant item.

This mask smells lovely, and it left my hair feeling soft. Plus I’m happy to report that it didn’t weigh down my hair.

AHAVA Mineral Hand Cream – 40 ml Retail Value $10

This is a variant item.

The formula is super hydrating, but it somehow still absorbs almost immediately – no greasiness!

Verdict: The total retail value of this box is $106! As usual, I think that’s amazing for a $21 box, but I must admit, I’m pretty envious of subscribers who received the other Boxycharm spoiled variation. (It’s not that I don’t like the Ahava and the Briogeo, but the Farmacy + lace sheet mask are items I haven’t tried before.) The makeup items everyone receives are great, though!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes! The Boxycharm waitlist is temporarily lifted!

Check out all of my BoxyCharm reviews and the Beauty Subscription Box Directory!

What do you think of the October 2018 Boxycharm Box? Which variants are you getting?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Recommended beauty boxes for you:

  1. Birchbox
  2. Ipsy
  3. Boxycharm

See other beauty boxes

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Boxycharm Reviews, Canadian Subscription Box Reviews, Featured Review of the Week, Makeup Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: boxycharm | 63 comments

63 Comments

  1. HI! I just subscribed to boxycharm and it says my weight is 0.8? Does anyone know what that box will contain?

  2. No matter what I do, Boxycharm never sends me any spoiler emails or emails of any kind. My boxes just show up every month and I notice they’d charged my card on file..

    The good part is, they almost always send me the really nice variation. I got the Farmacy balm and the lace masks. My KVD lip color is very pretty, Loving, I think it is. No hint of gray, orange or red, which makes me happy.
    My box arrived almost smashed but the palette was just fine. Yay for Boxy boxes. 😉

  3. I got variation 1 with the farmacy makeup remover omg im in love. It works so well. After im out definitely have to buy more. My box weight was .9.bJust an fyi. I was praying for this one.

    • I think I got variation #1 as well. Soooo happy I got the Farmacy Green Clean. Love it. My KVD color is K-Dub, which I knew from the spoiler. Eh. My box weighed 1.00 lbs, by the way. Also got the Lace A Peel Mask, however I remember a comment about it being harmful to your skin? Does anyone have more info on this? Want to use it but a little scared.

  4. I got variation #2 (boooo!) with the AHAVA hand cream (this my favorite hand cream of all time, but I already have two of these sized ones, an oversized one, plus like three other kinds of their creams; it truly is amazing but I don’t need another), Briogeo leave-in hair mask (again, I already have the mask and the rosarco leave-in, so I have no need of combo), and the KVD liquid lip in Bow n Arrow (it’s a dark nude – I love these lipsticks, but this color just washed me out; i really only wear red lipsticks and would jump for joy of anyone wanted to trade). I’m not partial to keeping any of those three, if only on the basis that I’ve already tried them. If anyone is willing to trade, I would love any red lipstick- I swear, just about ANY red lipstick would do- and would absolutely kill for the Farmacy Green Clean cleanser. If anyone wants to trade I’m down!!!

  5. I got Box 1.

    No Ahava, but I did get a full-size Farmacy cleansing balm. I’ve tried it before and it’s nice.

    The Superhero mascara is a full size.

    The KVD liquid lip shade is “Mother”. Yuck. The box for it came a little crushed and the bar code was scratched out with black marker. That just seems odd.

    The palette looks nice. The box was sealed on both sides with sticky tabs and the color pans were protected with plastic sheets that were stuck on with the sticky tabs.

    • My KVD was also crushed and the barcode marked through. I’m no longer using her products due to her antiVax rhetoric. I’m a former Neonatal ICU RN and am currently awaiting a kidney transplant. So I worked with the population in danger from NonVaxers. My immune system is is suppressed for transplant prep and so I am in the high risk group now too. She has a right to raise her baby as she wishes just as I can chose not to support her brand. My gloss is going in the trade box.

  6. I am afraid to publically say what color KVD lippies I don’t want to receive because I will end up getting them, and afraid to say the one I really want because then I won’t get it. Just hope they treat me right this time.

  7. I love my box!!! I got the good variation though. I got the PUR palette, the mascara, my Kat Von D lipstick shade is Lovesick, which is a gorgeous mauve color, the Farmacy cleansing balm and the black bamboo charcoal peel off mask. PUR palettes don’t excite me that much, but they aren’t bad, and I love all the other stuff, so overall I like my October box!!!

    • Jeweil27:
      I received the same box, even to the color of the KVD lippie (Lovesick). It’s a pretty fabulous box (with the exception f the palette which is just not good for me….however I’m sure it will be great for someone who will get it in my Donation box.

      Even ‘bad’ months are OK with me. I think there was only 1 month’s box that totally disappointed me in all things, but heck, I have been a subscriber for almost 3 years now. Pretty good ration as far as I’m concerned.

      Love Boxycharm (and Allure)…my 2 faves!

  8. The colors in the PUR palette are much nicer than the promo photos show. I am still unsubscribed, but I would have reconsidered if I had seen real-light photos of that palette. The only other item I would have used is the Briogeo. I really like that line of KVD lippie, but I’m sure I would have received some hideous brown. There were only two colors offered that interested me.

    Still hoping for something better that will tempt me to resubscribe.

  9. Got my box today, I was worried I don’t get spoiler e-mails so had no clue my variation. I received bow & arrow for my KVD, the lace mask and the briogio leave in. I wanted the Farmancy but I’m quietly happy with my variation #2.

  10. Finally got my ship notice. It should arrive Thursday, same as Birchbox.

    Just in time for my standing dinner date with my husband.

    I have a full size Superhero and a sample size. Not really a fan; it’s okay but doesn’t wow me.

  11. I got a worse variation than this one unfortunately. Was really hoping for the farmacy product and would have been ok with the travel size Ahava hand cream but instead got some cheap looking eye masks! And my Kat Von D looks used, it is a dark brown color (crucifix), which isn’t something I would ever use anyway. If it didn’t look used I would have passed it on to a friend. Pretty disappointing box overall, the only useable products in here are the mascara and Briogeo spray (which I have been wanting to try out so I’m happy about that product, wish it wasn’t so small though). I have only been subscribed to Boxy for three months and the boxes have all been quite underwhelming. I will not be renewing after the 6 months I purchased are done! My Ipsy on the other hand has been amazing!

  12. First box, and last. Didn’t get the Pur palette, IT mascara, or Kat vonD lippie. But did receive cheap brushes, Violet Voss Feisty (ugly brown), Girlactik highlighter (yawn), Luscious es base, and Pretty Vulgar Nightingale palette. Really?

    • I was on vacation last month when my first box arrived. Totally disappointed. I don’t understand how they send some of the goth colors of lipstick. I wasnt impressed so I cancelled, but not in enough time as my 2nd shipment was sent out.. at least I feel validated that boxy charm is not for me. Another goth lipstick, the Kat Von D one. Another palette I won’t use as the colors are not for me. At least Sephora and Ipsy follow the guidelines of what the buyer prefers. Neutrals. Nothing in the boxy charm 2 boxes I have received are anything like what I would want. Glad I canceled.

      • In the Boxycharm FAQ, they say they cannot control what shades we receive, but they are working on it.

    • That’s the September box, not October.

      • Ordered in October for October box, received September box last Thursday. Now October is on it’s way. Misleading advertising, IMO.

    • That’s September’s box!!!

      • Yes! I ordered in October, and received the previous month’s box. What was advertised was the October box! So, received 2 boxes within a week.

    • Paula: That sounds a lot like the September box, not the October. I would give them more of a chance than just 1 month as well…can’t get much better than Boxy overall.

  13. First box, and last. Didn’t get the Pur palette, IT mascara, or Kat vonD lippie. But did receive cheap brushes, Violet Voss Feisty (ugly brown), Girlactik highlighter (yawn), Luscious es base, and Pretty Vulgar Nightingale palette. Really?

  14. I noticed his month everything was in box??? (Mascara,lip and pallet)🤔

    • Came in the box??

  15. Mine arrived today. Variation 1 per the card, I almost always get #1. Farmacy Green Clean and black bamboo peel off mask. Lip in Lovesick but it doesn’t have shade on the card. And yes my email silhouettes showed the Farmacy and mask.

    • How much did it weigh

      • .9 lbs

      • I got the same box, but mine weighed .8…so you really can’t give the weight all that much credence.

    • Thank you for this comment, I had the same email silhouettes and was wondering if they would match up.

      • My email showed the Farmacy Cleanser and lace masks, but I got Ahava hand lotion and Briogeo hair product instead. I was so looking forward to the Farmacy Cleanser and masks! 😭

        • Rebecca: go to Facebook and look up Facebook Swap groups. Once joined, you can see who is selling those items you missed, I have had very good experiences with that method. (Pssst, ALWAYS pay using Paypal)!

  16. The emails revealing your items aren’t necessarily accurate. I had what appeared to be the face mask & farmacy product as my spoiler but today I received my box and got version number 6 which variation items include the briogeo spray shown in this post and undereye masks from a brand called south mane beauty. Just a heads up. The shade of lipstick I received was Crucifix.

  17. I had such FOMO after finally cancelling last month. What a relief. 🙂 I might be upset I miss next month, but this month is okay.

  18. I received both my boxycharm packages today and they both have the face masks and the green clean. I’m not sure how to check the weight though. I DID receive the email everyone was asking about where it looks like the green clean jar and the face masks.

    • What was your lip color?

  19. Mine says .8lbs hmmmmm..

    • Hi just subscribed to boxycharm and this is my weight too, what did you end up getting?

  20. How much did your box weigh? Mine says 0.9lbs.

    • Mine says 1.00 lbs

  21. This looks like it’s 3 full sized products and 2 deluxe sized samples 🤷🏼‍♀️ Wtf?!

    • Exactly. Both variations have 2 deluxe samples. I just don’t understand how they get 4 out of 3 full size items.

  22. Ugh I got this same bow and arrow lip shade so I’m assuming this will be my variation. After December luxe I’m out for awhile. The theme actually went great with the masks and green clean but alter ego with hand cream and hair conditioner… not so much!

  23. I am confused about the Briogeo item. They are listed on MSA as the same item but one is a spray on but the labels on the containers are slightly different. They are both 2oz. The one Liz received isn’t even on the Briogeo website. I wonder if it’s a discontinued item or an upcoming item. The link takes you to an aerosol item.

    I like how Liz’s box containers items that are all more than a one time use item. The other box has a face mask. At the same time the other box has a Farmacy item which tends to be a more desirable item.

    I would have preferred the second box only b/c of the Farmacy. Both are ok, but I think with the new Luxe box it looks like they are pushing more not so full sized items. I wonder if this is going to be the new trend.

  24. I thought Boxycharm’s claim is that they provide five full sized items. I have the Briogio — it’s 5oz, not 2oz. I have received Ahava before, and this is a sample size. They are great products, but I will also be unhappy if I get them over the Farmacy, and the lace mask has unique appeal. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

  25. My comments are not showing up so I will try again lol my label says .90 lbs and this variant is supposed to be 1 pound even according to a youtuber. So math wise, I think there is a good chance of getting tge other variant spoiled after I do the math. We will see I guess. Lol

  26. I can tell you guys that my shipping label has a weight of .90 lbs from fedex. This variant according to a youtuber weighs 1.00 lb. So if you do the math with the 1.7 ounce weight of the farmacy and then the lightweight face mask, I think I just might get the other variant spoiled 1st. Of course I’m not positive, but its possible. ☺☺ good luck! I hope you all get the variant you want!

  27. I can tell you guys that my shipping label has a weight of .90 lbs from fedex. This variant according to a youtuber weighs 1.00 lb. So if you do the math with the 1.7 ounce weight of the farmacy and then the lightweight face mask, I think I just might get the other variant spoiled 1st. Of course I’m not positive, but its possible.

  28. This version only has 3 full size products. They advertise at least 4. I will be envious of those that get the other version, it seems much better.

  29. Wow. I would be so mad if I got this variation! So glad I’m not caught in this variation mess anymore. There must be a huge value difference as well between the 2. I can’t imagine the 2 are equal in RV. So unfair! Wow!

  30. For anyone who hasn’t tried it, I got the small Farmacy cleanser late August & it immediately became my fav cleanser ever. It has a faint to moderate distilled lime scent & it’s got this amazing texture I can only describe as a whipped soft balm that looks looks like a wax. I still have a good week of use out of it, so it was def worth the $22 at Sephora. If I don’t get it, I’ll just buy the full size. FWIW, I like Briogeo well enough & can totally use it, but if the Ahava hand cream has a strong scent, I’ll use it for a stocking stuffer. (I react to the strong scent of their sea whatever hand lotion.)

  31. I want all of those items. Great curation imo.

  32. Liz, did your spoiler email show the farmacy and sheet mask silhouettes or the outlines of the products you actually received? Thanks!

    • Yeah! I want to know to??

    • I’m wondering that too. Because the ones I’ve seen posted online have all been the sheet mask and farmacy jar sillohuette…..and we know that cant be right.

    • There is a YT video of the second box. It’s a larger size Farmacy but not sure it’s the full size. It says is a Boxycharm exclusive which makes me think the size was created for the box. The sheet mask was just a sheet mask.

    • I think the silhouette is generic and means nothing. Seems like they create a box for the theme and then start throwing in other variations when more sign up.

    • The silhouette is definitely generic because I got the farmacy/face mask in the email but received briogeo & undereye masks in my box today.

  33. People are gonna be so mad… the spoiler email gave a lot of people the impression that they were getting the Farmacy and masks because of the silhouettes but it looks like everyone’s email was the same!

    • If I get that damn Ahave lotion I am going to be pissed. I HATE that stuff. And I was thinking that I got the Pharmacy because of my email!!

    • Yeah I agree! I had two accounts w Boxycharm and they both received the same email. I don’t know why they would do that.

    • Yup. Got my box today and received the briogeo item and some random undereye masks.

      • Were they the gold under the eye masks? I got those just recently in a past box.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!