Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Pharmacy Green Clean balm
Lace charcoal Mask
Pur Palette
IT Cosmetics superhero mascara
KVD lipstick in shade Mother – it is a bright pink/plum color, good for summer mths
So glad I did not receive the Ahava lotion, already have a large tune sitting around somewhere, the scent brings on a migraine.
Reply
Selina
Update, used the Pharmacy Cleansing balm and it felt amazing after. Holy Grail Product for sure!
Reply
xgirlmama
I’m getting lovesick, which is much better than the usual poo brown lipsticks that BC sends me. Unfortunately I already own it
Reply
Linda
Who else got Hawkwind and what other products did you receive?
Reply
Pink5
I haven’t even gotten a ship notice yet. 🙁
Reply
Tanya
Same here!
Reply
Toni Marie
I cant wait to see the December boxyluxe spoilers. It will be a deciding factor if I should take a break from boxy for a few months.
Reply
Angela
Me too
Reply
Hanna
Totally agree! I am dying to see those spoilers too!
Reply
Lexana
I don’t like to complain because it is $21 for a bunch of products, but I feel like the quality has started going downhill over the past couple months. Perhaps I just feel that way because I am a bit on product overload, and keep buying what I actually want.
Reply
Steph
I lucked out and got variation 1 which has the farmacy cleanser and the charcoal mask. I also lucked out and go the shade “Mother” which is a really nice every day color for me. I’m so excited because I’m known for getting bright orange lip products in these things!
Reply
Cady
Received my box today. I have version NUMBER 6!
I received:
Full size it cosmetics mascara
South mane beauty under eye gels (not happy of these but my mom enjoys under eye masks)
Pur Palette
KVD lipstick in crucifix
Briogeo leave in moisture mask
Reply
Amy Steppe
My money = My right to be sour
My opinion = my right
This box has nothing in it I will use. It holds zero value for me. I don’t do poop brown lips and glitter eyes.
I don’t want more hand cream and I don’t like the hair conditioner. I’ve tried it.
I buy a lot of sub boxes and this one is awful.
Reply
Chrissy
I don’t want no damn hand cream. :/
Reply
ALISHA K SWARROW
What happened to 5 FULL size items?? Those two items don’t look to be full size. I’ve been trying to hold out for December’s luxe but at this rate I’m ready to cancel and just stick with my ipsy glam plus and my regular ipsy. Ugh!! Has anyone got an answer to why they are sending two deluxe size items when they promote 5 full size??
Reply
Jessica
I was actually wondering the same thing.
KC
I don’t either…..blah….boring stuff lol
Reply
Lisa
I really hope I do not receive this variation :/ I’m getting the Kat von D shade in Bow n arrow and so far everyone who has that shade has this variation. I have thick curly hair so that 2oz hair mask won’t do anything for me and that hand cream isn’t even full sized. I’m hoping for a miracle that I receive the cleansing balm and face mask.
Reply
Melissa Cherney
I received variation 2 with bow and arrow kat von dee. But I received the mask and the hair stuff. I won’t use the mask, or the hair stuff. I was really hoping for the farmacy green as well oh well guess I’ll have to buy it.
Reply
Maya
hey so I have bow n arrow too but I saw a YouTube open her box, with the same shade but a different variation
Reply
amyr
Nothing I post shows up anymore. I have no idea of why but why comment if the filters are set so high nothing goes through?
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
Same. Super annoying.
Reply
amyr
I bought the October box and immediately unsubbed. I guess I will still get it. I have had no confirmation on what I am getting. I was billed on Oct 3rd and cancelled Oct 5th so I assume I will get this box of junk.
These boxes are awful! This one is worse than the first spoiler. I daresay I will get stuck with all of this.
This is one of the stupidest impulse purchases I’ve ever made.
Reply
Natalie
I know this variation isn’t great. But come on. It’s $21 including shipping. This variation is still over $100 in value. I think if you expect nothing but stuff you love then sub boxes aren’t for you. I don’t agree with the way they do the variations but for $21 I’ve never been totally disappointed. Like the cuticle oil I thought what a joke but I love it. I would of never spent that much on a cuticle oil but it’s awesome. Try to think on the positive side there’s no reason to be sour.
Reply
Jessica
I hate it when i see people on here scolding other people for complaining. They say the same thing every time, “Sub boxes aren’t for you”…If we can’t come here to vent where can we go??…I mean isn’t that what a “Review” sight is for?? reviewing and giving opinions?? Oh yeah and it does say “What are your thoughts” In case you missed it…Smh. If you don’t like peoples opinions, positive or negative…Maybe a review sight isn’t for you. Maybe there is a sight that’s all about sub box praise and worship that you could find.
Cady
The way I do it is I keep items that I’m not into safe and to the side and for birthdays or holidays I put together goodie bags for friends/family who would use them. It’s usually only one item out of the box I won’t want and most of the time I find some use for all of the items. At the end of the day I consider it a great deal and am always happy to try new products out but I can also see how some who aren’t as willing to try new products that they are unsure of may find this and other subscription services not worth it.
DocN
I’m getting the shade mother, which looks ok.
I’m hoping and praying that I don’t get Ahava. For starters, I boycott the brand. Second, I think their products are godawful. And third, I don’t use hand cream at all.
I’m hoping for the Farmacy.
Reply
marjory k
im getting lovesick for the lippie and im good with that just hope i dont get the hair care thing because i already have two things of it and received it from boxy
Reply
Jana
I am getting Lolita – So I am excited! One of the only lip products that lasts through my 12 hour shifts! The Palette looks intriguing – I LOVE the PUR Contour Palette – I use it to contour and as eyeshadow. Also – That vanilla smell!
Reply
Danelle
No sample or deluxe sample sizes in boxy should happen. Just not a good thing. The items aren’t bad, but the variations are getting pretty annoying. Why can’t they simply send one box out. I don’t get it. They don’t utilize anything on their customization. At least I have never received anything that was specific to me. I always get super bright or brown Lippies. Never a berry or rose color to match my skin tone and professional classic makeup look. I don’t mind trying new things, but they always seem to be a bust and get tossed.
Reply
SunnyT
Sorry my post showed so many times. Nothing was posting earlier and I kept getting a spam pop up.
Reply
Jay
I canceled last month but signed back up for the Farmacy so I’m going to be pissed if I get this variation instead.
Reply
Nancyisshopping
I’m getting K Dub ..I sure hope that is the version that comes with the Farmacy!
Reply
Ellen
Wow this variation sucks…
Reply
Samantha
They better not even try me with this mess. Lol. Jk. I’d still stay subscribed because of Boxyluxe; I feel like I am stuck with them now because if it. 😂
Reply
Nurse Jen
Me too! I hope they eventually have a Boxyluxe only sub. I’d be cool with getting only that every 3 months. I loved my Sept Boxyluxe!
Reply
Iggy'sRock
That is what they want…
Reply
Dianne
I’m getting k-dub lippie my profile is a natural lippie ok
Reply
Christine
And I’m getting bow n arrow when I hate nudes and only want reds and pinks 😩
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
They aren’t using the beauty profiles yet. They are working on implementing them in the future.
Reply
Dianne
fuchsia and vampire black and hot pink and purple and poopy brown is what their surveys should say for lippies.
My profile says natural colors like nudes.
Am getting K-Dub.
Ok not cool
Reply
Lexana
“Poopy Brown” is a neutral color…so once they implement it you will likely get more.
Reply
Nicole
Yea me too. Ugh
Reply
Geena
Well, I’d like to thank Boxy for curing my FOMO? I was avoiding them over the KVD but reeeeaaally wanted to pull the trigger for the mask and the Farmacy – now I know I probably wouldn’t get it! 😂
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.