Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter Review – March 2018

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

monthly mystery box of awesome unboxing and review

The Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter is a subscription offered by They send a variety of random items that should exceed the cost of the subscription and every month one subscriber wins a SUPER box with a really expensive item in it. What will you receive in your mystery box? It’s a complete surprise!

monthly mystery box of awesome random surprise subscription box unboxing

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out our review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

This is a review of the Standard box, which is $24.99 a month.

all items in monthly mystery box of awesome for march 2018

About Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter

The Subscription Box: Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter

The Cost: $24.99 per month for the standard box or $34.98 per month for the deluxe box + free shipping

The Products: The products you receive are a complete mystery! There’s no theme and items are pretty much gender neutral.

Ships to: the US

Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter March 2018 Box Review

giveaway info

Each month, there’s a chance to win a BIG prize. This month’s prize was a spa. Next month, there’s a chance to win a Roomba!

naked wines vouchers

naked wines coupon

This month, I got two coupons for Naked Wines.

promo card for pet subscription box

promo card for other subscriptions

I also got some promo information from related subscriptions and sites.

ice scraper and glove

car ice scraper with glove

cozy glove with ice scraper attached

Car Ice Scraper with Attached Mitt

Oh my gosh, my friend Tim has one of these! He used it to help me scrape my car once this winter, and I’ve been thinking of getting one ever since. I’m awful at remembering to shove gloves in my pockets, so having a fleece-lined glove built right into your ice scraper is a great convenience. I wish it had a little more reach than it does (y’gotta really lean over the windshield to get all the ice with this guy). Still, this is going into my car ASAP. Spring has supposedly sprung, but in Pittsburgh, we’ve had snow flurries then 65 and sunny days then more flurries then freezing rain… Never hurts to be prepared!

ceramic lined pan

red pan

red ceramic lined frying pan

info about pan

Family Chef 10″ Ceramic Sauté Pan

I haven’t been able to find this brand online, but other ceramic-lined sautee pans seem to start around $25-$30 and move up from there. I like the non-stick nature of this pan (great for cooking eggs, which are my favorite thing to whip up in a pinch) and the bright red color doesn’t hurt either! It’s a cheerful medium-sized pan that should get a lot of use in my kitchen. I love that it’s dishwasher friendly, too!

silicone measuring cups

stacking silicone measuring cups

detail shot of silicone measuring cups

silicone measuring cups inside

Fuller My Kitchen My Home Silicone Measuring Cups

I can’t decide what I think about these flexible plastic measuring cups! The box mentions that the material can bend to form spouts for easy pouring, but I worry that liquids inside will splash or squish out as I pinch the sides to pick up the cup… Maybe I’m overthinking it. Maybe I’ll just use them for dry ingredients!

hashtag me game

hashtag me game and pieces

questions in hashtag me

scorecard in hashtag me

hashtag cards in hashtag me

back of hashtag me box

Hashtag Me The Game  – Retail Value $15.99

This game seems like a nice icebreaker for a dinner party full of new faces. The idea is that players pick up cards that prompt them to tell stories. As they do so, other players use cards with hashtags on them to comment on the story being told. It’s a cute way to encourage people to engage with each other and get some laughter going.

smores hot cocoa kit

mugs and ingredients

dove chocolate bar

dove chocolate bar ingredients

purple snowman mug

holiday hot cocoa

hot cocoa packets

hot cocoa instructions

ingredients for all items in hot cocoa pack

S’mores Cocoa Mug Set – Listed Value $9.98

While it is snowing in March in Pittsburgh, it definitely doesn’t feel like the holidays anymore. So this holiday-themed cocoa gift set feels a little out of place. That said, the presentation is cute—they include literally everything you’d need to create two cozy cups of fudgy cocoa and a few smores, to boot! And if I stash the snowman mugs away for next December and use some regular mugs instead, that Christmastime vibe will fade away.

edible arrangements snack boxes

edible arrangements holiday treats

edible arrangements card

edible arrangements tag

all treats laid out

Edible Arrangements Sweet and Savory Gift Collection

It looks like this assortment is no longer available on Edible Arrangements’ site. It also has a holiday vibe with its snowflake-patterned boxes. The treats inside taste just fine, though. As the name suggests, there’s a nice mix of savory and sweet treats, including trail mix, caramel corn, chocolate toffee pretzels, yogurt pretzels, and a slew of chocolate-dipped goodies like peanuts and graham crackers. I think my favorite treats were the hazelnut twists—I just love the light, crisp pastry and the contrast of the thick, yummy cream inside.

The Verdict: While I don’t doubt the quality of the holiday treats I got, I will say that they made the box feel a little more clearance-aisle-ish than it usually does. I was most pleased with all the useful products I got, like the ceramic-coated pan and the car scraper (though hopefully, I don’t have to use that much more this year). This box is definitely unpredictable, but if you’re up for a surprise, I’d say it’s worth a try!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? There’s no telling which random items you’ll get inside this box, even if you sign up today. Subscribe now to get your own box of surprises!

Value Breakdown: This box cost me $24.99 (with free shipping). There were a few items that I couldn’t find prices for, but what I was able to find amounted to $25.97, which is already over the cost of the box. Based on the $24.99 price, I paid an average of $4.17 per item.

Check out all our Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter reviews and the Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter?

How do subscribers rate That Daily Deal Monthly Mystery Box?

17 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to That Daily Deal Monthly Mystery Box? Add your rating now!

Written by Anna Reilly

Anna Reilly

Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she’s swooning for all things kawaii!

Posted in Monthly Mystery Box by Jamminbutter Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: Monthly Mystery Box of Awesome | 9 comments


  1. Nice assortment! I really like the pan.

  2. My box was a little different
    I got the
    Pan ( which I love )

    Measure cups
    Hashtag Game ( I’m going to gift these )😉

    A huge Disney glass collectible doll from “Frozen” movie on Amazon for $19.95

    All the treats but seems like I got 6 boxes from small to big

    A big letter stencil set for walls

    Overall I was happy

  3. This would have all been junk for me. The “wine vouchers” are usually a $100 off when you spend $150… they’ve sent those non magazines and random hand outs. I’ll be avoiding this box 🤦🏽‍♀️

  4. I would strongly advise against using those measuring cups for dry ingredients in baking. You will not get accurate measurements using something intended for wet ingredients and that will typically cause issues with baked goods.

    I think as long as you don’t pinch the container too tightly, it should work just fine.

    Just my two cents as a long time baker.

    • Second this.

    • I appreciate this SO much, Jackie! I’m still a relative amateur in the kitchen, so I need good advice from experienced bakers and cooks <3 Thank you so much!

    • I’ve heard that the silicone measuring cups can be especially good for wet ingredients because if you pinch them the right way, they can function as a funnel.

  5. Just put the sweets in Easter eggs and voila!

  6. If I knew they would send me sweets/snacks, I would sign up right now. I am not fussy about the decor as long as the food is fresh.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!



Get alerts on your desktop for the best deals and spoilers!