My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm February 2021 Box Full Product List!

ByMSAFeb 5, 2021 | 38 comments

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

4.3 overall rating
1982 Ratings | 228 Reviews

Here is the full product list for the February 2021 BoxyCharm base box!



Your February box may include:

Saturday Skin Yuzu Vitamin C Sleep Mask OR TULA So Poreless Deep Exfoliating Blackhead Scrub

The Beauty Crop Illuminating and Hydrating Face and Body Mist OR Trestique The Eye Duo Good Vibes Mascara + Eye Pencil OR Wander Double Date Lip and Cheek (multiple shades)

The choice items for February were:

  • Brow Bar By Reema – Bombshell Brow Kit in Light, Medium, or Dark
  • Ace Beautè – Nostalgia Palette
  • Wander Beauty – Getaway Eye and Face Palette

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular BoxyCharm box is $25 a month.

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm to learn more!

BoxyCharm ($25 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 4-5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and established brands, with a total retail value of over $100 in every box. The beauty item... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I loved my Boxy this month – again – for the 3rd month in a row. Haven’t had a bad box yet. I received the lipliners, Hanskin’s AMAZING moisturizing essence/toner, the Ace Beaute palette, Lavido face lotion, and the Wander balm/gloss (the one dud of the lot, but I’m fine with it).

Honestly I get a lot of sub boxes and Boxy has knocked it out of the park with the base boxes and add-ons/pop-ups. I’m kind of blown away. Maybe because before getting Boxy it seemed like people were always unhappy with them, but all the amazing stuff I’m getting? I mean, for $25? Yes please!!


BROKEN ITEM; Be sure to check your box and its contents. I received box C2102016-BA
BOTH Saint Luxe Beauty Limited Edition Liners have broken off tips and useless. I do bet this is filler crap. Did anyone else experience this broken item? TWO lip liners both broken off tips.


Can’t they be sharpened? I received the same liners but haven’t opened the box yet. Are they not sharpenable (if that’s a word)?

Steph H.

I didn’t have this problem with mine, but I don’t plan on using them anyway. If it’s just the tip of the liner broken off you could always just sharpen them again.


Yes, the black eyeliner that came with that mascara was broken off about a half an inch (if fell on my light carpet…ugh). Also, a few months ago with the premium, there was a Fenty brow pencil, it was broken from the point it was attached making it completely useless.


My base box was an epic fail this month – the only product I’m excited about is the Saturday Skin Mask. I also received the Wander Beauty pallette abd it was meh – the rest of the box was not good at all, and the values were completely inflated:

– TreStique Good Vibes mascara RV $44.00 Value – third time I’ve received it and it’s terrible. I loathe this brand.
– Saint Luxe lip liner duo – 1 of the pencils is brown 😕 RV $40.00 (seriously!?)….
– Glamierre set of 4 eyeshadow brushes (dollar store caliber) came in a plastic pouch that smelled like cheap pool toys. RV $29.00


Check BOTH your liners to be sure the tips arent broken off and useless. BOTH tips from my liners are damaged making them useless. I have contacted BC support and sent pics etc.


No FOMO here.


Ugh, my base box was bad. I guess overall the products are okay but it felt like a box of just leftover stuff from previous month. Especially when I was looking forward to the Saturday Skin or Tula item that was a spoiler and I got neither. I got none of the spoiler items other than my choice item.

I would understand a box like this if I joined boxy at the end of January or beginning of this month where it would have to be put together last minute or something but when I have a continuous subscription for over a year…I don’t think so.

For choice I picked the wander beauty palette the rest of my items were the following:

-Lavido Hydrating Cream
-Tarte Face mist (item from a previous month)
-Farmacy Toner (item from last month’s base box)
-DOSE of color block party single eye color in the black/silver color (item from a previous month)

I think I am going to buy the Glow Recipe item currently in pop up that I have chosen for March and cancel. I have so much skin care right now that I am probably good for a while.


Out of the 5 things that I didn’t want…I GOT 4 OF THEM. But at least I got my choice, the brow product. The medium was way too light …so this box was a 0 out of 5. I expect not to like 1-2 things but this was disappointing…ugh…those brushes are so terrible. I wish they would stop with the products like this…with the ridiculous prices from companies that don’t align with what subscribers expect. If you order off a website from China and slap some name on a product, we do not want your product. That is taking advantage of millions of people that subscribe.


That’s why I canceled Boxy. I got box after box after box with 0 out of 5 hits. I would get boxes that had NOTHING in them that would work for me. And month after month I never would get any of the good items. I would ALWAYS end up with the products that NOBODY wanted. Bright eye color palettes (I’m almost 50 and could never pull off the bright orange or bright blue eye colors) and bright orange lipsticks etc. It was terrible. Its what keeps me hesitant to give boxy any more of my money even today.


Ooh, I’d love that big bottle of Hanskin essence. That stuff makes you glowy!


I received this and am excited and hoping I like it. I also received the Lavido age away hydrating cream. I’m hoping to love both cause everything else is of zero interest to me. Also BOTH my Saint Luxe Liners had fully broken tips making them useless. I want to be sure everyone checks theirs if they received this filler item.


I’m so glad to hear that! I love all toners and essences – I got the Hanskin in my Boxy – and can’t wait to try mine. Yay!

Thank you!


I chose the Ace Beaute Palette. Since choice came out my boxes have been great! When you get the one thing you wanted it makes it all worth the splurge. I know I’m in the minority by saying I’m glad I don’t get as many neutral pallet everytime anymore! I like to mix it up! It keeps me exploring new looks and improving my eyeshadow game.


I got my box today (fastest ever) and it’s my favorite Boxy Box I’ve received. The only thing I won’t use is the primer, but I can give that away. The other things I received were the Saturday Skin night mask (love the brand and I mask regularly), the gorgeous glitter-lamp brushes, the Trestique liner/mascara (love this brand too), the brow kit (I tested it after my workout and before my shower. I waited to shower because I didn’t want to wash off my amazing brows). I just can’t believe I got such a box of fabulous for 25 bucks! Usually I only have 1 or 2 things I like and I’m disappointed. This box made up for those other months!!

Whitney Earl

You got a GREAT BOX. I’m hoping to get the primer, the Wander Beauty Lip and Cheek, the Saturday Skin Yuza Vit C sleep mask, I chose the Brow bar by Reema and the Hanskin Essence. Ive been with boxy almost 10 years, so I’m hoping I get a really great box. I’m a primer junkie, idk why but I LOVE that product. Lol. My premium box shipped on Thurs and I normally get both regular and premium a day apart, but I’m just EXCITED to get my box!!! 🙂


This is more of a general question than a question about the box, but is there any practical difference between cuticle oil and other oils? I suspect that it’s just fine for me to use body oil on my cuticles, but can I also use cuticle oil on my body?


Is google that question


I’m pretty excited. I like almost all of the products so hopefully I can manage not to get the 3 or 4 I’d rather not have.


I’m happy I canceled the base box, I don’t like anything about this month, and the spoilers came out very late, I’ll stick with the premium box that’s more interesting.


is anyone going to talk about their new member gift? lol

I did not like it the first time for my first box ever, there is no way I would sign up for another queen palette. I see the queen palette on eBay and everywhere, everyone is trying to get rid of it. now you get it from Walmart too (online) if anyone still wants it.


Normally I’d be annoyed by repeats but I would be down for a second Farmacy toner (though hopefully they’re keeping track and I won’t get one)

and I would love to get the VV olive palette since I missed it in January

Mine is 1.2 lbs and 9x7x3 with brow bar choice (kinda regretting that, I don’t do my brows and was hoping to be inspired but I feel it’s unlikely now lmao)


Mine’s the same size/weight as yours, and I also chose the brow bar. I got the VV olive palette last month, so if we have the same box, one of us is going to be disappointed about the palette. 🙂


Maybe I will have a chance to get the Olive palette this time around. I really think it is dumb they have the same products from the month before. I guess that could be good if I missed something.


Yes! I’ve seen YouTube unboxings of the premium and they r receiving the ofra banana powder and the Bali balm. I’ve received both already so I should be safe but u never know with boxycharm ☹️.


Can I be pre-annoyed? I have a sinking feeling I’ll get the Farmacy toner, which I just got in my January box. Yes, it’s my favorite product I received in that box, but I’m nowhere close to needing a refill.
I’m sure they have algorithms and I won’t get it again, but my brain keeps wandering to I will.

Disclosure: for the first time in my 43 years of life I learned how to use eyeliner, so fingers crossed for some of that!


I only use liquid liner, the kind that comes with a brush. Everything else, even felt tip liners skip or make uneven lines. But on the plus side, NYX liquid liner is my favorite and it’s cheap. I can get right up against my lashes with no gap. I also start at the outside and work towards the center so most of the ink is used where I want it thicker and by the time I get to the center (towards my nose) I can taper off to a thinner line.

I use a pencil on the bottom lash line sometimes, but usually I just smudge some eyeshadow lightly, I don’t like to “close” my eyes and make them look smaller by ringing them fully with liner.

I never do a wing. I have tried and the technique it takes to do it when you have slightly hooded eyes isn’t worth the fight to learn it.


Now please teach me. I’m 47 and still can’t get the hang of it. My eyelids appear to have wrinkles in them that no one can see but the eyeliner gets messed up in those. What do I do????? I have small and close set eyes, so a liner that pulls out from the center could really help, but how do I do that????


Hey. I only use liquid liner. I just get to side of a mirror and apply. Ive gotten really good but I just apply one straight line with a small wing. I always test the liner before starting and if you mess up like there are bumps just take the tip of a qtip dipped in makeup remover and wipe to make the top straight then reapply the little bit of shadow you removed. I know some people use stickers to help as well.


Sorry to be a pest – I think I cracked it. I took a flat definer brush, dipped it in setting spray, then dragged it in a powder eyeshadow and pressed the line onto my eyelid. A bit of dragging and I even got a modest wing. Whew and woohoo!!!!!


Thank you Gabriella! Pot liner sounds easier than a pencil indeed. I really appreciate these real-life solutions!!!


You might try a gel liner! Comes in a pot and you’ll have to get the hang of applying with an eyeliner brush, but it isn’t difficult! I have shaky hands and can’t for the life of me use liquid liner, but I figured out gel liner when I was newer to makeup. It stays put! I didn’t have wrinkles, but I have very large hooded eyes that get squinty all through the day because of how I smile (imagine a teenage anime girl) and I thought the lasting power was better than pencil. I also think you’d like tightening 😊


Thank you JoJo and Laura! I will experiment and not give up.


I agree with Amanda. My eyelids also wrinkle when I apply liner. It applies smoother when I start from the outer corner and work inward towards my nose.


Dea if I could make a suggestion, I just learned to use eyeliner as well but not in the traditional sense. It’s called tight lining and it has totally changed my mind on eyeliner. It is now my favorite makeup to use after years of feeling I could not pull it off. It’s where you only line the part of your eye where the eyelashes are, like you line in between them so there’s no skin showing. It’s so much easier than trying to pull off a perfect straight line and it gives amazing results. The best part is you don’t have to worry about wrinkles! Also it allows you to wear colored eyeliner and not worry about it being too wild because it’s very subtle. Look up some videos on YouTube on how to tight line your eyes. It takes a little practice like everything new but once you get the hang of it it’s so amazing! Hope this helps!


Thank you Amanda!!!!!!! Great tip! I will try it tomorrow (in daylight).


Hi! I find that my liner doesn’t snag as much if I work from the outside in (towards my nose), instead of from the inner corner out… maybe it’ll work for you too! Amanda

You Might Also Like

Ellie: Luxury Activewear Worth the Hype
Ellie: Luxury Activewear Worth the Hype
October 13, 2021
What I’m Wearing This Week: Armoire
What I’m Wearing This Week: Armoire
October 8, 2021
Halloween Inspiration + BeautyFIX = Ultimate Beauty Resource
Halloween Inspiration + BeautyFIX = Ultimate Beauty Resource
October 14, 2021
Cult Beauty Advent Calendar Waitlist is Now Open (And That’s Not All)
Cult Beauty Advent Calendar Waitlist is Now Open (And That’s Not All)
October 7, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.