Allure Beauty Box Review – February 2020


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Allure February 2020 makeup and beauty subscription box review

Allure Beauty Box is a monthly beauty subscription from Allure Magazine. Each month they send out a mix of deluxe and full-size samples from mostly high-end brands. (It was named one of the best beauty subscription boxes by MSA readers in the 2020 Subscription Box Awards.)

open allure box

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

all item group shot

About this Box

The Subscription Box: Allure Beauty Box

The Cost: $15 a month + free shipping. Save with a yearly subscription.

The Products: Deluxe and full-size beauty and makeup samples.

Ships to: The US and Puerto Rico for free

Allure Beauty Box February 2020 Review

 

A handy booklet has all the product info inside.

 

 

NYX Pro Powder Brush – Retail Value $17.00

FYI: Subscribers will receive either the Nyx Pro Contour Brush OR Nyx Multi-Purpose Buffing Brush OR Nyx Pro Powder Brush

I am completely aware of the fact that I am now a brush hoarder. I am not quite at 100 brushes, but I am embarrassingly close. Am I sick of brushes? Nope. I freaking love them. I think this is because I also have a painting background, so I have always collected brushes for that purpose and this feels like an extension of that sort of collecting, but for my face instead of a canvas. Even with all of my brushes, this is my first NYX brush and I am very impressed. I love the solid plastic handle and matte black ferrule. The bristles are synthetic and feel so soft and wonderful against my skin. They also grab up the right amount of product and diffuse powders across my skin beautifully. Did you know if you buy these brushes from the NYX site you can have them custom engraved for a $2 upcharge? I love that! Not that I need more brushes, but… I kind of need an ‘MSA Megan’ brush, right? Or three?

 

bareMinerals Skinlongevity Vital Power Infusion Serum, 7.5 ml – Estimated Value $8.70 (Buy a full-size 50 ml version for $58.00)

Though this wasn’t my favorite serum, it does have some great stuff inside! Scanning through the ingredient list revealed niacinamide, squalane, poppy extract, and ginseng. I was less crazy about the alcohol which was also on that list, but I have drier skin and try to avoid alcohol in my regular-use products. I did really like the texture this stuff left behind on my face. It worked really well under makeup and felt like almost a primer finish. It also had a really great scent. What did you think of this?

 

belif Aqua Bomb Sleeping Mask, 10 ml – Estimated Value $4.53 (Buy a full-size 75 ml for $34.00)

FYI: Subscribers will receive either the belif Peat Miracle Revital Eye Cream OR belif Aqua Bomb Sleeping Mask OR belif True Cream Aqua Bomb

Um, how cute and helpful is this little blue lid? I know I always get frustrated when I get a peel open sample and then I have to either toss it or store it in a zip-lock bag to continue to use it without exposing it to the open air. This lid really solved that problem, and it is a good thing too because there are quite a few uses inside this lil’ pot! In fact, if I had to guess, I would say I could easily get about 10 applications without even being too careful. This heavier gel goes a long way! I loved slathering it on before bed last night and waking up to soft and calm looking skin. The hydration locked in all night and I even went easier on my moisturizer the next day. Add in the yummy fresh scent and I liked this very, very much!

 

Honey Jarret Super Beau’tea Mask – Retail Value $3.00

I sheet mask all the freaking time, so I am always happy to get a new formula to try. This one is made of a well-fitting soft pink fiber sheet covered in clear serum with just a barely-there rose scent. I didn’t notice anything super groundbreaking here, but I also don’t need a sheet mask to blow my mind. I just expect it to calm my skin, add hydration, and be relaxing, all of which this one did well.

 

Appeal Cosmetics Luxurious Lipstick in ‘Muse’ – Listed Value $21.00

It looks like Appeal has changed up their lipstick packaging and I like this look. I also like the springy pink shade inside the clear and gold tube. It had great coverage and a nice satin finish. Not hours and hours worth of wear here, but I generally don’t get that sort of longevity from a creamy finish anyways, and I never mind reapplying. The pink is very girly but in a sophisticated and wearable way, meaning even if you aren’t into pinks, you might end up enjoying this.

Is it spring yet?

 

Olay Regenerist Retinol24 Night Moisturizer, 5 g – Estimated Value $4.06 (Buy a full-size 48 g for $38.99)

Our final item was a little pot of Olay night cream. I don’t use Olay, but my mom and grandmother have for decades, and they both look great, so I am certainly not knocking it. I tried this night cream after a really long day full of snow and wind, and I was pleasantly surprised at how soft and smooth my skin looked the next morning. I am also really, really appreciate that this formula is fragrance-free, and lacks that very distinct Olay small that I don’t like very much. The box also came with a $3 coupon, which is always nice.

Verdict: This Allure box has a total value of at least $51.29 even without the value of the lipstick, which I could not verify elsewhere online. Considering the lipstick is full size, I feel like there is some good value this month for sure. I think my favorite thing was that makeup brush. (I know, I know…) I also really liked the lipstick and highlighter, and I was so impressed by the sample quality of the belif sleeping mask. The sheet mask was another win, and I was surprised at how much I liked the Olay sample. All in all, I quite enjoyed this box and think it was well rounded and fun.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes! Scroll down this page to see what items you will get when you first sign up.

Value Breakdown: At $15 for this box, each of the 7 items has an average cost of $2.14.

Check out all of our Allure Beauty Box reviews and some more of our other favorite beauty subscriptions. 

Swap for any item in this box from the Allure Beauty Box Swap page!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the February Allure Beauty Box? What was your favorite product in the box?

How do subscribers rate Allure Beauty Box?

686 subscribers rated this subscription
3.5
out of 5 stars
Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Allure Beauty Box? Add your rating now!


Written by Megan Kirkland

Megan Kirkland

I love natural/vegan beauty products, Korean skincare, unique jewelry, and weird candies from far away places. When I am not waiting for my next exciting box you can find me painting or taking photographs of interesting people. I never leave home without pug hair somewhere on my shirt and a bold lipstick on my smile.

Posted in Allure Beauty Box Reviews, Beauty Subscription Boxes, Makeup Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: allure beauty box | 56 comments

56 Comments

  1. I received one of my box and it was the exact same variation. Lipstick color looks good to me! Fingers crossed that I will receive different brush and eye cream in the second box 🙂

  2. I just got my box today. Same box as above except for the eye cream instead of sleep mask. It’s a solid box imo. I’m kind of unhappy about the alcohol as well in the serum, but on the positive side, it’s not denatured alcohol. That’s the worst! Love the lipstick! Mine appears lighter than this on but it’s so soft and flattering! Love the Olay and coupon as well. For me Olay is always a safe bet when unsure of the ingredients in everything else I have on hand.great box overall. Thanks for the review!

  3. Have been disappointed in the Allure box for a while. I remember when their boxes contained higher end products. Now it’s just like the Ipsy box.

    • I completely agree. The boxes have been going seriously downhill over the past months. Seems like the “full size” items are mostly drugstore brands, and the non-drugstore brands are tiny samples. This month’s box was a huge disappointment. Every month I keep holding on because I have major FOMO that as soon as I drop, the next month will be the one that goes back to the awesome full size product…but every month of late I’m let down. Allure used to be a great box, but not anymore–I really hope they step it up!

    • To each their own, I guess. I cancelled Allure for a long stretch in 2019 because I wasn’t happy, but resubbed in November and have been thrilled with every box since then. Bareminerals, Belif, and Wander are all brands I’m happy to see in a sub box, particularly if it’s a product I haven’t tried before, and I also like discovering new brands.

  4. I first signed up for January and thought that the box was fantastic but I do not care for February at all. It’s a big disappointment.

  5. My Feb box just arrived and I LOVE the variation I received. I got the exact variation as shown in the review above. The lipstick is beautiful, the brush is super soft and so glad I got the Belif sleeping mask. Totally worth the $15.00 investment.

  6. It appears that the Appeal lipstick is now called Muse Ultra Creme Lipstick on their website and states pre-order on Jan.1st. It shows that all their Luxurious lipsticks are out of stock.

  7. Got my box today.

    It’s identical to the review box.

    Disappointed to get the sleeping mask. I wanted the eye cream and I guess I’ll just have to buy it, though I have an Amazon box showing up in a few days, so hope springs eternal.

    I’m a little surprised by the lipstick. It’s MUCH lighter than in the pictures and less orange than what I saw in the Allure unboxing video. The case is also much lighter than you might think by looking at it.

    • Also disappointed in the lipstick. It’s slightly lighter than my natural lip and reeks of coconut.

    • Got my Amazon box that I don’t remember ordering, and it too is identical to the review box.

      And did I mention that the lipstick reeks of coconut? Really hate coconut.

      • Its also made in China, I am pretty dissapointed in this. I don’t feel this lipstick is worth anywhere near $21. My heart sank when I read that it was made in China, I try not to use anything on my face or in or on my body that isn’t made in the US, Canada or Europe. China requires companies to test on animals and I don’t trust the stuff they put in it.

        • I just got my box today. Same box as above except for the eye cream instead of sleep mask. It’s a solid box imo. I’m kind of unhappy about the alcohol as well in the serum, but on the positive side, it’s not denatured alcohol. That’s the worst! Love the lipstick! Mine appears lighter than this on but it’s so soft and flattering! Love the Olay and coupon as well. For me Olay is always a safe bet when unsure of the ingredients in everything else I have on hand.great box overall. Thanks for the review!

  8. I just received my box. I’ve been resubscribed since the hot tools offer (December?). The only variation from this box is that I received the eye cream from belief which I’m happy to have. I love 💕 this lipstick 💄. It’s pretty and feels great on my lips.

  9. My Allure box arrived today. I had canceled for a few months because I was so tired of the variations. Resubbed for January, forgot to skip February, but there’s a few things I will use. Called to skip March this morning.
    February box contents: The sheet mask, the BM serum, Olay regenerist (not using), WB highlighter (not using), Variations are: NYX powder brush (yes!), Belif Aqua bomb true cream (it’s a repeat from idk how many subs…. but I’ll use it) and the last item is cargo lipstick in Punta Cana ( This is the same exact brand and shade of the last one I got from Allure. I would think I would have gotten a different shade, but I got the same gaudy, hot pink shade!) I honestly even feel bad about putting it in the donation bin.

    • Hot pink looks good on deeper skin tones.

    • I agree! That shade of pink does not work for everyone there for it should not be in the box. I canceled Allure For the small sizes! They sent us a judge box compared to the Tiny Olay. I’m over it

      • I almost feel bad donating really small items, but then again, if I didn’t have anything…
        I expect sizes like that from bb or sephora. Allure has had some tiny samples of the good stuff and larger sizes of the not so good stuff lately. 🤷🏻‍♀️

  10. The olay clogged my pores so bad. I normally have a few but my face looked like a game of minesweeper, and where you would contour, on my face was full of clusters of acne, sore, ichy, puss filled terribleness

    • Sounds like an allergic reaction. Poor you.

  11. Engraved brushes? I’ve never cared to own a Nyx brush until right now 😂 I’ve been really into personalization lately! And that lipstick is gorgeous too!

    • I saw your comment so I had to read the whole review to see what you’re talking about… I could see doing that for someone as a gift. But, I would definitely have to have colors to choose from. That would be something really cute to give to a teenager, daughter, niece, friend, etc. A whole brush set with their name or something special engraved on them and then have them match their decor or favorite color. Still made me giggle though.

  12. Is everybody getting that pretty lipstick color, the likes of which I don’t think I’ve EVER received in a box, or will it be random? (In which case I’ll probably get yet another dark red, brownish purple or beigey nude I can’t use)

    • I think there are two or three possible BRANDS of lip product so I’m sure there are color variations as well. It’s such a shame because I also really would love to get this color. I’m starting to feel like Allure just isn’t my cup of tea anymore. They were in fire for a while but lately the best items are variants and just like Boxycharm, Boxy Premium, BoxyLuxe, and Ipsy, I always seem to get the worst ones.

    • If you get an Appeal lipstick, you will get the shade shown.

      It’s the Cargo that will vary.

  13. Waiting to see which variation I got.

  14. Thank you for pointing out when products have alcohol in them Megan. It makes me immediately lose interest in a product and lack respect for the brand a little. It’s always possible to formulate without alcohol, so why include an ingredient that’s known to break down the skin’s barrier over time? It just doesn’t make sense, so that detail is important to me! I can’t wait to try that lipstick with the way you described it! I’m excited for most of what’s coming in this months box!

    • Hey Nicole! I am glad this helps! I am trying to be more conscious about mentioning alcohol in skincare especially, though I am far from consistent. Admittedly, I tend to be a little more lenient with makeup! Thanks for reading and leaving me a comment 🙂

  15. Hi Megan. I heartily endorse indulging in the custom engraved brush (or three). 😀
    I always enjoy your reviews. They’re always informative and help me make better purchase choices. Thank you.

    • I mean… I kind of have to, right? I am glad you love the reviews and I am really happy they help you pick products you love. Truly, that means a lot to me. <3

  16. Hi Megan. Too funny because the Bare Minerals serum was on my table to try today. Thank goodness the scent was not overpowering for me! It did feel like it dried to a primer on my combo skin. I will give a few days to see how it holds under the makeup.

    • I kind of liked the scent more than I think I did the whole product, but I am a scent junkie. I do wish it was alcohol-free though!

      • I’ve gotten samples of the serum before and used them with no trouble.

        Personally, I think it’s a good product.

  17. I own just 1 makeup brush which is an eyeshadow brush from a FFF box yard ago. 🤣 I am thrilled with that brush and the rest of the box.

    • I think my MorpheMe sub was the catalyst for my brush enthusiasm. If you ever want to expand your collection, check that one out, but prepare to become obsessed with brushes.

      • Thanks Megan!

  18. Doas anyone know what the amazon box has for Feb? I thought they showed the items but it doesnt?

    • The box I got from amazon is exactly what Megan got in her box. I love the Appeal Lippie!

      • Thanks! I hope I get the same. The only item I don’t care about at all is the laneige sleeping mask as it does nothing for me. I do like the eye cream so would be happy with that instead.

  19. Has anyone gotten their box from amazon yet? What did you get? I’m specifically interested in what lipstick shade amazon is sending. Megan’s Muse shade looks really pretty.

    • I agree, that shade is lovely. But don’t get your hopes up. It’s almost guaranteed that Amazon subscribers won’t get it.

      • Oh but they did! Amazon got this exact same varient.

        • Glad to be wrong. I don’t get mine from Amazon until end of the month. I hope mine has it too. 🤞🏻

          • Mine was from Amazon and I got the belief bomb and a cargo lippie in punta cana. This is a hot pink shade and I only need so many hot pinks. It’s a repeat on both of these for me. Kind of bummed about that. But the brush I got is magical. It’s going to be amazing for face blending/powder. Dense, soft bristles.

  20. OMG, a hundred brushes! That is quite the collection (no judgement 😘). I am just starting to wear makeup again after a 10 year hiatus. Looking forward to a new brush since mine have seen better decades.

    • I absolutely have too many. But I just love them.. there are worse problems to have, right? MorpheMe was the subscription that started the obsession. Def peek it if you want to build yours!

      • Ipsy’s been doing bad things to my brush collection. As in making it huge. I don’t know if I’ve hit triple digits yet, but if the Glam Bag Plus has brushes, I will usually get it (them).

  21. This is a solid box. I’ll never say no to a full-size lippie. Any Amazon subscribers get their box yet? What did you get?

    • I got this same box from amazon!

  22. I was very happy with my box this month. I like the brush… I like that i get them in my sub box for less than they cost from from the brand… the face mask are also a personal favorite as well.

  23. When I see a brush in a sub box, it’s an automatic skip for me. That and a highlighter. Needless to say, this month was a miss for me and I am glad I skipped.

    • A brush is an automatic “yes” for me. The more you have, the longer you can go between brush cleanings, and they last many years.

      • Not me. I already have way too many that I got from BH Cosmetics and those are fantastic

  24. Any march allure spoilers yet? I hope theres something to make me think about resubscribing

  25. The lipstick color looks gorgeous

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

*

 
 

Get Your First Hello Fresh Box for $10.95!
Get This Deal