MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm January 2020 Spoilers + Coupon!

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

We have our first look at spoilers for one the January 2020 BoxyCharm base box thanks to Yosef! ($25 a month.)

The choice products for January 2020 are:

Too Faced Diamond Light Highlighter or Pretty Vulgar Under Cover Concealer

We can see a couple products at the top of the table – maybe more spoilers? It looks like Glow Recipe Watermelon Moisturizer. Anyone recognize the palettes?

What do you think of the spoilers?

We also have full spoilers for the December box!

Here’s one version of the December box:

If you haven’t signed up yet:

Use this link and coupon code JOLLYCHARM to get this tarte palette free with your first box!

Valid for new subscribers only, or those who canceled before November 1st, 2019. Must use coupon code at checkout. Valid while December’s box and Tarte gift supplies last. December’s box with new subscriber gift value shown. Box contents vary. Sample of items featured in past boxes or in current boxes shown. Promotion valid while December’s box and gift supplies last. You will be charged $25 plus applicable taxes and shipping. Free shipping to continuous US only. No refunds or exchanges. Monthly subscriptions will automatically renew each month. Prepaid subscriptions will automatically renew in the first month of the next subscription period. Cancel at any time by logging in and editing your “Subscriptions” in “Account Preferences” under “My Account” on

Boxycharm is $25 a month. Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 44 comments

Comments (44)

  1. I’m kind of confused by this, I just did my choice and it was the twin Ace Beaute palettes and the Dr.Brandt Eye Creme, so are the concealers and Highlighter just a normal item in the box then? Either way I’m hoping I get the Highlighter it’s been on my wish list for a while!

  2. Anyone know when the January choices are for each box? She said she’d discuss it the next day on her facebook but I don’t see anything.

    • December 10th

      • Boxycharm: 12/10/19 and Premium: 12/12/19

  3. So, I’m a slave to my email inbox b/c I keep looking for my BoxyCharm January Choice announcement. They only give us like 1 day to make the choice and I totally missed it in Nov.
    I used to see info on one of these pages about how to learn when the Choice window will be – it’s on FB Stories or Insta.
    Can anyone please tell me how to find the Choice window info? Thanks!

    • The choice window is actually listed on the main page of their website. It starts december 10th and last for 48 hours. Hope this helps you! 🙂

  4. Just wanted to give an update on my missing items from Boxy. Today I received my November choice item (Kypris), and a few days ago received the courtesy choice item (Becca) that they offered after failing to give me the promo gift with the October box. So, I’m ‘square’ with Boxy. I have no plans to reactivate, however.

  5. I’m no longer subbed, but this looks like a great box!

  6. Those are the two new Ace Beaute palettes. Vintage Dawn and Scarlet Dusk.

  7. I did receive the swatch but it’s way too dark so I didn’t even bother. However, I did fill out the quiz. I’m not really feeling the spoilers so far. Might cancel and take a break for a bit.

  8. Ok so what do they do if if I didn’t get a PV sample ? I got the Becca swatch :/
    So I they just gonna pick a random concelear color for those who didn’t get that PV swatch?
    Thanks 😊

  9. Pretty vulgar… perfect description of how the product looked on my skin. So yellow. Much too dark or much too light. It’s unfortunate they didn’t choose a company with more colors

  10. Awhile back they showed the two faced eyeshadow pallet as a spoiler. For that I may think about signing up. I think it may have just been bait. I just quit Boxycharm I was starting to feel as if they were slightly shady.

    • I believe that’s for premium box and highlighter for base box.

    • I’m thinking so to. For two months I’ve paid out all together 300 dollars. They said there’s another account with first the same email, then account number. So this month I’ve paid almost 200 dollars, for base box’s premium, which they told me I did not have, but it’s on the mail list and of course my luxe. Last month. I received 3 box. I paid out almost 200 dollars.

  11. I got regular and premium boxy and didn’t receive a swatch in either. Not everyone got them right? Seems weird to have a choice with concealer when not everyone has gotten to swatch them. Guess we’ll see what they end up doing

  12. Those are the new ace palettes at the top

  13. I received the pretty vulgar swatch. Not going to lie I HATE the company name. Feel like it’s way too young for me to appreciate, because I don’t. I will sell it on mercari if it is in my box.

    The too faced highlighter. I paid full price for that at Sephora and it is so cute, so amazing. We don’t need another but that os a great item even if you already have highlighters. I like this on my arms in the summer months. This is the ideal gift for anyone who is girly. Too bad it is in January because I could gift it in December since I already own one.

    I have been doing holiday shopping at Marshall’s and tj Maxx you cannot believe how many recent sub box items are at the discount stores! I think beauty sub boxes buy through these channels as the discount stores. You still pay less through subs. I saw the moonchild palette we are getting in the allure box for 14.99 at TJ Maxx so the rest of the box is free. Sub boxes are a good deal, you just don’t have to go to the store or get choice.

    • Agree on the company name. Awful.

    • I definitely agree about the possible sourcing! I’ve seen the same things. Unfortunately the problem with my locak TJ Maxx and Marshalls are some of the people shopping there. Every worthwhile item is clearly tampered with on the box or the product itself. Makes the experience so frustrating and I simply don’t trust the items for this reason.

      • Agreed 🤮 you don’t know who’s fingers or hands were touching the stuff , pieces missing, boxes opened , smudges on color palettes … some people don’t have manners at stores you can look , but touch really

  14. I’m glad Dec would be my last month and will not renew until a really solid box

    • Same here.

    • The issue anymore is their’s so many different variations. That was one of the things I liked at first. Everyone got the same stuff. Now the box may look solid but you still end up with junk you don’t want. I don’t know why they have you take a quiz, they don’t follow it all.

  15. I don’t know why, but it annoys me he’s using a dirty scratched up table for this. Could you at least make it look a little nicer to promote the products lol?

    • Pretty much everything that guy does annoys me 🙄

      • Right!i thought i was the only one who got annoyed with the way he decides to show you cant just get to the point like every other company &stop beating around the bush..Love boxycharm but thats always been something that annoys me.

      • This is too funny. I was under the impression everybody loves him like he’s some kind of rockstar. I’ve watched him really hard trying to see what other people maybe see and sure he’s alright and he’s successful but I’m not charmed by his mannerisms or affect. To be fair, I doubt he would be charmed by me either since these things are often reciprocal.

  16. I’m not falling for the stuff in the background thing. He has staged so many things so many times and they didn’t come though. Remember the time he had Pat McGrath foundation in the background?

    • I dropped Boxy because they’re so shady. I don’t like him, he strikes me as a used car salesman type.

  17. Well, the pretty vulgar were all too dark for me so I guess I know what I’ll HAVE to pick!

  18. Hmm well since my complexion test is the pretty vulgar concealer I’m thinking that’s the one I might be getting I’d like both lol

    • Does anyone else see the new from dusk to dawn palettes from ace beauté?

      • Yep! I agree with you. Those two palettes are completely different, too!

      • Yes! That’s exactly what I was thinking those palettes were. I’m going to wait to buy them until we see if they’re spoilers. But boxy is so tricky so who knows.

      • I think I will pass on this concealer cause the color is bound to be a disappointment. I got the swatches and not one really matched, so the highlighter it is. It looks good too! So i guess in the next box we are getting the becca foundation?

  19. Choosing either the Pretty Vulgar Concealer or Diamond Highlighter?

  20. I believe the palettes are the new ones from Ace Beaute. The Glow Recipe sleeping mask is easily recognizable but I have no idea what the product is next to it.

    • I hope not the ace ones. I just got them with cyber Monday code.

  21. Ooo I could use this concealer

    • Notgoing to miss anything here.

    • It doesn’t matter if you didn’t get the swatches in your box, you can complete the complexion quiz without it. It lets you choose from numerous brands. The box looks great to me, a bit of makeup and skincare. I’m not sure what would make some of you happy. Apparently everyone hates eyeshadow palettes (whether neutral or fun colors), blush, highlighter, lashes, eyeliner, lipgloss, concealer, etc lol. Why are some of you subscribed to a makeup box ???

      • I’ve wondered the same thing myself.

      • You are so right… They act like they are paying alot of money.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.