MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm Premium August 2020 Choice Time!

BoxyCharm Premium December 2019 Spoiler #4!

We have a new spoiler for the December 2019  BoxyCharm Premium box thanks to Yosef!

There is a third palette variation for the December 2019  BoxyCharm Premium.

Your December box will include one of the following palettes:

Natasha Denona Cranberry Eyeshadow Palette – $48

Dose of Colors Hidden Treasures Palette – $50


Storybook Cosmetics Fairy Tale Book Club – Little Briar Rose – $55

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Pink Juice Moisturizer

In case you missed the previous spoilers, the choice items are:

Skinfix Dermatitis Face Balm OR Bite Beauty Agave+ Nighttime Lip Therapy


What do you think of the spoilers? Which palette do you want?

We also have a possible spoiler for an upcoming BoxyCharm Premium:


Source: boxycharmsneakpeek

Too Faced Palm Spring Dreams Eyeshadow Palette

^This may be a spoiler for the January box – this has not been confirmed yet

Here’s everything you need to know about BoxyCharm Premium:

  • It’s $35 a month
  • 6-7 beauty items a box
  • $175+ Value
  • You get to pick one of the items
  • The items will be different from BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe – you can subscribe to both with no product overlap.

Are you going to sign up for BoxyCharm Premium?

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, and our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more about this subscription.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, BoxyCharm Premium Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 64 comments

Comments (64)

  1. Yes I got the same email as you did that they had duplicated my bl and bp with little rose briar pallet
    They said that they were going to make it up to me with a nd product. Box has just recently shipped both of them. Haven’t received either one of them yet. However they said in the email they would send a tracking # when it shipped. Hope its the pallet.

  2. So, i got an email from boxy today saying they’ve been made aware that they sent me the storybook palette in my Premium (which I haven’t received yet) which they also sent in my Luxe and that they were sending me a Natasha Denona “product” to make up for it. Anyone else get this? I mean, i hope its the cranberry palette but what the heck 😂 product? Can you be more specific please? 🤦‍♀️ Hoping its not the lip liner or the blush i already received

  3. I’m confused on something I get all three so this month will I get all three or just premium and lux or what I’m so confused 🙁 I already got my premium so do I get my base box too or just luxe

  4. I simply cannot look at the Dose palette. The fact the its not symmetrical drives me bonkers!

  5. If I got the Storybook palette in my Luxe will they make sure I don’t also get it in my Premium box???

    • Yes

  6. I did not get off premium waitlist , guess it’s a random choice, that’s BS since I’ve been a loyal customer for years . All good I cancelled the luxe for December . I’ll wait for premium next month .

    • I know I have not been taken off the waitlist since the day it began however I did do one thing I cancel my boxyluxe kept my boxycharm but wanted the premium Nola

      • What’s premium Nola ?
        Sorry confuzzled Nola ?
        Thanks 🙂

  7. Received an email today that I’m off of the waitlist. No telling what I’ll receive in the regular BCharm, BoxyLuxe, and now the BoxyPremium combined.

    I know that a person must be an active BC regular subscriber to get BLuxe, but is that still the case after becoming BPremium? Just curious if they will accept the active BP versus BC. Meaning, can someone cancel BC and keep BP and get BL? I do like BLuxe the best, but I think it’s all becoming just too much, especially if they expect someone to remain an active subscriber to all three.

    • No you can cancel regular BC after you get your premium , that’s what I’m gonna do .

      • I emailed Boxycharm a week ago and asked if I could do this and they said I had to keep the regular boxycharm subscription in order to have Premium. I wanted to just get Luxe and Premium, and they said that since Premium is not an upgrade, that I had to also have the base box too if I wanted Premium. This month, since its a Luxe month, getting both Luxe and Premium.

  8. Still not off waitlist for premium :/
    Cancelled for boxyluxe that’s too much money and nothing grabs my FOMO for December boxyluxe , also bought so much on pop up sale

    I too wonder where are spoilers for regular boxy 🤔🤔

  9. Any more spoilers for the regular boxycharm, besides the eyeshadow palettes… Im ready for some spoilers for some reason none have been posted recently.

    • I was wondering, too. It’s odd that there have been no more at this last day of the month.

  10. So today, ive opted out of Premium waitlist. I honestly went back and forth for a little bit, and I am happy with my regular boxy and boxyluxe. Plus, I receive fab fit fun boxes, so I will wait to see all of your reactions to dec premium to see if its worth it for me to join again. My family is saying I dont need anymore, so i guess i signed up in fear of missing out, but ill be okay. Two 50 dollar subscriptions and another 35 in the holiday months for products that I am not t sure i will use is a roulette wheel of chances; and ill stick to my odds with what I know. Have a great holiday everyone!

  11. I’m on the waitlist for the Premium box but I think I need to cancel and sign up again if I want to try for January. I’m already getting BoxyLuxe. I own the Cranberry palette. I like Dose of Colors as a brand, but that Hidden Treasure Palette bores me. I already have a bottle of the Watermelon Moisturizer from Ipsy and just bought a set from Sephora that has another bottle of it. (I bought it because it’s got a full size watermelon sleeping mask and is cheaper than the sleeping mask alone.) Since those of us on the waitlist didn’t get to choose, I bet we get stuck with the Dermatitis Face Balm, and my oily skin doesn’t need that. I’d end up giving everything away. Sigh!

  12. You know there will be at least 50 variations!!! My sub box love is just about over. In total I’ve had 25 since I started with Ipsy 4 yrs ago. I’m going with all quarterly boxes in 2020. With what I spend every month on monthly subscriptions, I could buy anything I wanted from Ulta and Sephora. Plus we all know that Boxy is famous for the “unicorn” item. Let’s all quess which one that will be, shall we??

  13. I would LOVE to get the cranberry palette!!!

  14. I don’t mean to hijack this thread but has anyone tried the Korres Vitamin C Rose Oil? I receive it yesterday and it smells awful! It’s a very overpowering scent. Is it supposed to smell that way?

    • I bought it from Korres and returned it! It is different than the original. They have given it a different scent now.

      • OMG! I just purchased it from boxy pop yesterday:(

      • I bought it too , it has great reviews , as long as it works as many say…smells don’t bother me as much as some. 🙂

  15. I was so disgusted with their handling of this pop up that at the last min, with a few items in my cart, I couldn’t justify giving them a single penny more of my money. I cancelled all my subscriptions with them and unfollowed them on social media. This will be my last interaction of any type related to boxycharm. I decided that this was the best way to let them know there haphazard business method doesn’t keep customers. Until now I really enjoyed receiving my boxes in the mail. I just can’t feel good about it anymore.

    • Good for you,Kimberly! I completely agree and I’ve been posting similar thoughts and mentioning how much I really need to stop doing business with them. Because you’re exactly right, they’re never going to change a thing until people finally cut them off. Unfortunately it’s going to take LOTS of folks deciding to do that. And even then it’s not guaranteed to prompt changes given how aggressively they go after new customers. I think it’s going to take customers and Influencers all putting their foot down but I just don’t see that happening. I was bad and spent way too much when the pop up sale finally worked. Although it was still stressful having to rush so fast to compete with other customers. But I have decided to make some major changes with my spending after December, especially my sub boxes. I’m on major product overload and I can’t keep throwing money away on things I don’t need and especially to a company that in NO WAY appreciates my business despite getting my money for over five years. Also I am trying to restrict my beauty and household products to cruelty free brands and cleaner ingredients.

      It’s definitely going to be difficult because all jokes aside I am truly addicted to beauty products. I always have been but it got even worse once I discovered sub boxes. But eliminating Boxy at least has been weighing on my conscience for so long now. Probably since the Boxyluxe fiasco. I left for two months this summer but let them seduce me back with the pop ups, choice and the Premium option. But of course I didn’t see the announcement in time and probably won’t be off the waitlist for December either. I’m glad though because I’m already getting Luxe and after seeing this post I am just as turned off of Premium as I am the regular box. Three different eyeshadow palettes??? Not 3 different shade groups or 3 from the same company. Three wildly different brands, shades, sizes, quality. If they let you choose it would be one thing. But if I got one of the two previous spoiler palettes knowing some got the ND palette I’ve been wanting I would be so disappointed. The main reason I was enticed by Premium is that I thought with such a limited number of boxes there would be little to no variations because they’d be able to obtain the full quantity of each product needed. Of course not. That would be too logical and too fair to customers.

      Anyway…apologies for the rant. I’m probably still psyching myself up to cut ties. You’ve inspired me and I applaud you. Hopefully more people will follow your example!

      • This is EXACTLY what I was thinking. I was hoping that Premium would mean less variation. NOPE. Not the case. I have been on the fence about cancelling, but I agree. I don’t think it is getting any better, so I might as well just suck it up and cancel. It’s hard to cancel sub boxes when you’ve been subbing for so long!

  16. I don’t want to sound like a brat because I’ve already gotten my pop up sale items, but They didn’t send my entire order. I was missing Two Paula’s Choice Toners and a Saturday Skin Essence. So, they sent me a replacement order for the items missing. Guess what, that was wrong too. They sent me three more Paula’s Choice toners and no Saturday Skin Essence lol, so now they have sent me another replacement order. Let’s see if it’s right this time lol I was one of the lucky ones with getting my order placed before the first pop up got shut down, but it’s been a nightmare ever since.

  17. Ohh, I would totally be looking to swap or buy this palette! I’m on product overload, so subscribing doesn’t work for me, but I’m dying for this palette and the Storybook palette.

  18. Oh look! It’s the unicorn! After we got teased with the Too Faced highlight, palette, and the glow mask. I’m sure a couple influencers that get both will get the ND and then maybe a few reg folk but most will get the Dose. Unless they are trying to makeup for all their mistakes lately. I doubt it though given the ND palette they used for premium last month. The dose probably costs them .50-1.00 each whereas the ND would be more like 5.00 each. It isn’t as economical for them.

  19. Please let me be off the waitlist and please let me get the Natasha Denona. I am not slightly interested in that Dose palette and I’ll be getting that Storybook one in Luxe I believe. I love ND shadows!

    • Apparently ND palette is most likely for those who are subscribed to both Luxe and Premium. Josef said in insta that if they don’t have enough Dose of Colour palette for variation, they will give out Natasha Denona. So probably most people will NOT get it.

      • I am subscribed to Luxe so I know I’m getting the Storybook palette. I just really dont like that Dose palette and ND is amazing!

  20. Boxycharm sends a palette in each box. That’s what they’re known for. There are other subscription boxes or you could sell / trade.

  21. @boxycharm… I’m begging you, can we please have like 2 months WITHOUT an eyeshadow pallet? It’s kind of getting old. I have like 15 pallets and I think I’ve used 1 in 6 months because I DON’T WEAR EYESHADOW. So, please I’m sure you can find something else besides eyeshadow every single month.

    • Exactly the same for me!!!! I use eyeshadow maybe 2-3 times a week, I do love makeup, I wish they sent something else…

    • I just started with subscription boxes…so far I have four eye palettes that I can’t wear because the colors are too crazy or have too much shimmer. I have to open all of them across my vanity to attempt to create a look that is acceptable in public. People complain about the neutrals but they need to remember that everyone didn’t sign up when they did.

      • So true. Give us some neutral mattes!

      • I agree with Alice about the neutral mattes. Glitter is not for everyone.

      • I only wear makeup for work and I cannot use all that shimmery glitter! I’m at the tipping point on makeup subs. I’m going to move to purchasing exactly what I need instead.

    • I totally agree with you Kelly it’s so many eyeshadow palettes, so many every month. I barely ever wear eyeshadow. I would rather have another color FX face palette , that was my favorite >3
      something different then just eyeshadow palettes every month, but I guess I enjoy the other products in the box. Just wish there was more variations, then just eyeshadow palettes .

    • Kelly Boxycharm originally sent an eyeshadow palette EVERY month. It was what they were known for and the reason MANY of us signed up. As much as you’re disappointed with palettes many of us are disappointed they stopped. Most people don’t need multiple face or blush palettes because you can only wear 1 set of colors (fair, neutral or cool) and Boxycharm doesn’t customize (when they tried they screwed up a lot sending fair people a dark palette n vice versa) so at least with eyeshadow more people can get a variety of useful colors. I can make a neutral or bold palette work I can’t make a dark face palette work.

  22. Say what?! Wish they would let us choose our palette instead of just skin care items. Totally want the ND palette.

  23. Hoping I don’t get the denona as I just bought it from Sephora during their big sale. lol

    You would be surprised at how absolutely blendable it is, if you get it please try it, you may be surprised!

    The only palette above I’m feeling is the Too Faced, so fingers crossed! lol

    • That Too Faced palette is a possible spoiler for January. December, it looks like, will be ND, Dose, or Storybook. I want that TF palette as well. I was going to buy it but then I saw these spoilers. After so many months of getting a palette I already own, here’s FOUR that I don’t!

  24. so when will we find out if were off waitlist for premium? just wait and see how much we get charged on 11/30 or 12/01?

    • Yes, that is correct.

    • Really?! This is why i am getting so frustrated with boxycharm! They spoil to us the whole time about a product and then bam right before the first they say oh you may get this product OR heres another variation. Quit with the bait and switch boxycharm. And yall know damn well everyone is gonna want the natasha deona palette! And our choice items should have between the eyeshadow palettes and not skincare all the time!!

      • I actually do not want the ND palette. I like it, but really do want the Dose of Colors. I’ll be happy either way though .

    • I just found out I’m off the waitlist. Too late for choice 😿 would have picked the BOTE so fast. I am obsessed with bite and I use the balm shown every night without fail. I love, love, love Bite.

  25. Since I’m waiting on my Tati Beauty to arrive and it’s a neutrals palette I’m hoping for the ND palette. I will be willing to swap 😉

    • I bought the Tati Beauty Neutrals palette and I love it! ❤❤❤

  26. Looks like a good box. But am broke. I have to buy a sofa for Christmas. Am on a no buy. Am over that feeling of missing out.

  27. I like ND but I really hope I don’t get that eyeshadow palette.. Reds just do it for me.. I’d look really sick if I tried it…

    • I meant reds just DON’T do it for me..

      • The shades of the ND palette are stunning but I could never pull them off. I’m hoping I get the DOC palette!!!

      • I know what you mean! Truly, unless one is into outlandish looks, who could possible use such colors?! I might use them in my art, but not on my face.

      • I use colors all the time. If you blend and smoke them out, they are pretty and not weird. Even the brightest palette can be blended to a wearable look.

      • I don’t have that kind of time to fiddle with them.

      • Right, I agree. I always use colors lol. I can’t stand neutral colors unless maybe I was going to something professional, which I never do. I have my few palettes with them and they are are so similar I don’t need more. I love getting pretty colors to play around with. As long as they are blended out and stuff they look pretty.

  28. These are premium spoilers not luxe.

  29. So if I’m getting the luxe then it should either be the DOC or ND, hopefully the ND.

    • Same! ND is much more exciting to me than Dose again. Unless they add another palette variation to luxe…

      • Yes I got the same email as you did that they had duplicated my bl and bp with little rose briar pallet
        They said that they were going to make it up to me with a nd product. Box has just recently shipped both of them. Haven’t received either one of them yet. However they said in the email they would send a tracking # when it shipped. Hope its the pallet.

      • I hope some got there’s I was supposed to have received the Natasha denona cranberry palette and didn’t after they confirmed it I’m heartbroken

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.