MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm September 2019 Spoilers!


We have our first round of product spoilers for the September 2019 BoxyCharm box thanks to boxycharmsneakpeek!

The September box will include:

Image: hankandhenrybeauty

Hank & Henry Beauty Liquid Liner in Blickity Black


M·A·C Cosmetics Frost Lipstick in CB 96

We also have spoiler brands for the September 2019 BoxyCharm box! FYI – these are variation brands, so you will not receive all 3 in your box.

The spoiler brands are:

  • tarte
  • Violet Voss
  • Too Faced

What do you think of the September spoilers? Which one is your favorite?

(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

If you haven’t signed up for Boxycharm yet:

Now through August 31st (or while supplies last), use this link when you sign up for a Boxycharm subscription to get a free Butter London Palette ($32 Value) AND a free Luxie Brush Set ($30 Value) with your first box!

*Valid for new subscribers or those who canceled before July 1, 2019. Expires August 31, 2019, at 11:59 pm ET or while supplies last.

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Click here to sign up. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 69 comments

Comments (69)

  1. Love the rest of the box. But, I already own CB96. Still skipped Allure for this. It’s so bad this month.

    • I know right! Allure is going to have the new, not launched yet Sunday Riley Ice moisturiser next month, i cant wait! I love Sunday Riley!

    • I dont see the point of getting the boxy luxe? It seems like I wouldve gotten the same main items for half the cost , maybe Im thinking somthing wrong? I paid the 21 than 28 for upgrade. stuff is good but Im going to cancel the luxe and keep regular box for now

  2. I’m shocked that people complain about getting palettes. Those are my favorite thing to have and the main reason I subscribe to BoxyCharm. I could have 1000 and still want more. I love variety.

    • Same! I love eyeshadow palettes. It was my favorite thing about boxy n I’m very disappointed they arent sending them every month

      • Hate this months boxy. I mean what is the point in the beauty quiz if the items I note as rare are the items I end up getting? I am not happy with the Violet Voss eyeshadows and I am tired of liquid liner in every box.

  3. Girls, how many product will i get in my boxyluxe?

  4. I followed the link up top for more regular Boxycharm spoilers. Am I missing something? Didn’t see anything else pertaining to this box. Is it hidden in the comments?

  5. I most definitely agree these last couple of boxes suck. I I get another eye color palate I’m going to scream. why can’t we get a list of items and we can pick which we would like. I’m a darker shade and everything I get makes me look like a ghost they are too light

    • I agree I just got the BUtter London palette for July and that should be enough for a year. The I got send the two cute Ace Beaute shadows in AUgust which I gave away bc I dont need more eye shadows. Now I see this September box has more palettes. Do people go through palettes that fast? Butter London is a good size

      • While I agree the last few boxes have sucked I’m bummed boxy hasnt been sending palettes as often. My main reason for getting boxy was to get an eyeshadow palette every month. Some of us enjoy having a variety and boxy was a great way to build my collection. I have close to 100 palettes n still want more

      • Eyeshadow palettes have an expiration date. And many of the ones that they include in the boxes are not new from the factory. I would not recommend holding onto eyeshadow palettes for more than 12-24 months because the material does get into your eyes, and there are sometimes questionable ingredients. Be safe.

      • I’m sorry I will not throw away a Powder item just because they say it’s only good 12 months. I keep my brushes extremely well cleaned, I wash them after every use. I also periodically clean with alcohol. If it doesn’t look or smell funny and is working as it should I’m keeping it. Obviously if I was to get an eye infection or such anything used would have to go. I do replace my mascara and and any liquids every 3-6 months but powder products nope they stay as I said unless they change color, consistency or smell.

      • The Butter London palette sucks and is not color fast. I personally love mixing and matching palettes, and if the Butter London palettes is enough for you then great. Ask for an opt out and only stick to 3 matte colors for a year.

        But for everybody else, there is more than 3 pastel shimmer and 3 matte shades that fade within an hour or two. There are reds, blues, purples, greens, light and dark neutrals including black and white…..all of those come in mattes, shimmers, satins, and glitters.

        That’s why most people aren’t going to be happy being limited to the one palette you think they should be. Try selling yours online if giving them away is eating that much out of your subscription.

  6. Have not subscribed to Boxy for about 6 months. Are they using anybody’s profile to curate or is it still random?

  7. Hi! I am new to subscriptions. How do I get to where I can rate products I have received so I can earn charms? Also, i have not been able to find an app to use on my iPhone. Any help will be appreciated! Thanks in advance! I absolutely love the Becca powder!!

    • Boxycharm does not have an app that I’m aware of. Ipsy does. If you go to their site, and click on “boxes” in the menu, it will bring you to the latest boxes and you can add your reviews. Be aware that boxy reviews are not reliable, people just review products to earn charms. 😊

  8. I love Boxycharm. To me they get better and better. They’re shipping is great, most of the time things comeWell packed. I do hope the eyeliner pencil, is a variation product. I just cannot wear black eyeliner. It is way too harsh. I wish that they would give colored eyeliner pencils.

    • I got a forest green eyeliner that kind of looked cool, I have bright blue eyes though so it’s really not for meXD

  9. Ewww! Orange lipstick! No thanks…I just subscribed 3 months ago and I have yet to like anything in my box, I don’t use none of the eyeliners or lipliners, is there a better box out there? 😭

    • I would try Ipsy glam bag plus.

      • I had to cancel most of my sub boxes bc my recent move cost me way more then we thought it would. The only box I kept was Ipsy Plus. I ended up getting August’s BC and again Ipsy killed BC. I like BC as a company but Ipsy just continues to be the best. The two subs I think give the best value per $ is Ipsy Plus and Allure. Next is reg Ipsy & BC. The problem with BC is that while they do have a lot of monetary value per box the products often don’t hold value for me.

    • im with you. I was going to try this box, but I do not want these items. I think I will wait and try the box in a different month. I LOVE the Allure box. It seems to have plenty of skin care items.

  10. Want the eye liner please!

  11. CB 96 is actually an awesome OG MAC color. Try it with a variety of different lip pencil shades.

  12. I’m actually stoked for that lipstick color. I was like all of you and thought “Eww orange lipstick” until I TRIED an orange kokie lippie n it actually looked FANTASTIC on me! I’ve picked up 2 more orange lippies and loved those on me too. Take a chance. Thats what sub boxes are for, to try something you wouldn’t normally try. The only thing I’m bummed about is it’s a bullet lipstick n I prefer liquid lips. I’m getting Luxe and hope I get both of these spoilers. I love Hank and Henry lippies so hoping I also like his liners.

  13. Will this box include a palette or something spoiled from the boxyluxe?

    • My guess is yes since the regular charmers get the left-overs from the luxe boxes on those months. That’s why we have a variation, it depends on what’s left. If you look back at previous luxe boxes and the same month boxes for charmers you can see the variation items are generally the same.

      So this month for charmers should be:
      Hank & Henry Beauty Liquid Liner in Blickity Black
      M·A·C Cosmetics Frost Lipstick in CB 96

      Moda brushes

      Violet Voss Essentials Eyeshadow Palette
      Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette ( 2 color options)
      Tarte Park Ave Princess Chisel Palette
      Too Faced Natural Face Palette

      And a skin product…maybe the leftover sunday riley or Glow recipe but who knows.

      If i was luxe I would be really angry if i got sent a park ave palette again after getting one in the last september box but maybe thats just me.

      • Wow, that’s a pretty amazing box! Lol I just joined this month, I hope you’re right and they send those things! I’d love the too faced natural palette!!!!!! 🥰

      • How many palettes can one person have? I got the Butter London one end of July and thats enough for me for months maybe even a year. Every month seems to have a mascara (which I do not use) or a palette. These palettes are full size they will last months at minium and have plenty of colors

  14. I wanted to join this month but I don’t want an orange lipstick… Horrible

  15. does it really matter anymore, they send you what they want to send out…that’s all there is to it..

    • Exactly, I don’t understand why all this complaining. The whole point of subscription boxes is to able to try new things. Plus only one of those items cover the whole box.
      You’re basically getting four items for free. 😘

      • I agree Reyna! I was thinking exactly the same thing when I happened upon your comment. I’m convinced that some people just like to complain. It’s supposed to be fun to try different things. I’ll just pass on what I don’t like or use to my daughter or one of her friends. No biggie. I’m excited and think these boxes are well worth the money and fun!

      • I personally make up beauty bags as pressies with all the things i won’t use. goddesses love them!

      • The only issue is if you get something you absolutely will not use and try to sell it for the sake of maybe getting something out of it so you don’t feel like it’s going to waste, I’ve noticed I have an awful time selling some of these products online, some things have went well (lipglosses and liners, unused or swatched) but other things (surprisingly, palettes and skincare) do not re-sell well because there’s always someone who has it listed cheaper. So the 30 dollar palette you received that covered the cost of the whole box that you happen to hate you end up having to sell for 7 dollars online just to de-clutter

  16. That lipstick color is horrific (for me). I wouldn’t be sad about a liner because I am actually running low because some have dried up. I don’t really want any of the palettes offered in boxyluxe. So far, this is a skippable box. I have a lot of great stuff. Maybe it’s time for a break.

    • Maybe try it as an eyeshadow or blush

  17. Awful spoilers 🙄 I’m glad I’m getting Luxe 😁

    • This will be in the luxe box as well. The 3 main items from the regular box are in the luxe box, always been that way.

      • Oh well lol did not know that , that s*cks 😂 I’ll just donate those two hopefully the rest of my box is decent – but as someone says they send what they want with all the variations so who knows what I’ll get 🙄

  18. These are spoilers strictly for the regular boxycharm right?

    If I am getting LUXE, i shouldn’t be getting these? I don’t want to seem ungrateful, but I just can’t stand another liner!

    • Nope you’ll just be getting Luxe

    • The luxe box includes the 3 main items from the regular box, so, yes, these will be in the luxe box as well.

  19. Well I signed up in August for the palette bc I had regret from July. Promptly cancelled today. No FOMO here…

  20. These spoilers are so bad I cancelled boxy after reading them

    • Me too. Ugh!

  21. I just joined in August haven’t received my first box yet but I’m not sure if I can do this box if I’m going to get orange lipstick.

  22. WompWomp👎🏼

    • So funny girl! Luxe subscribers have cried since day one about getting same as regular box. I am happy for any color of lipstick and thrilled it isn’t another dang liquid lip. I hate those!

      • Same here on the liquid lipstick. Every formula seems to dry me out. I went to the MAC site and used the “try it on” tool to sample this color everyone is bashing and it actually looked pretty good on. Here’s hoping because I do like MAC lipstick.

  23. Way to compel people to upgrade to Luxe. Orange lipstick and yet another eyeliner.

    • You get the same regular box items with luxe so🤷🏼‍♀️ It’s funny to see luxe subscribers feel so entitled because they spend twice as much money thinking they’ll get better stuff when half the time, the regular box subs get whatever was in the luxe box the following month

  24. I’m so sick of getting black liquid liners and black mascara in this box! Why not a different color every so often? How about some blue or brown? I just cancelled my Luxe because they refuse to go by my profile. Why have people take it if it has no purpose? I’m honestly gonna switch to a different sub soon. There are better, cheaper options available. And now you can’t even review all your products! I just cashed in all my charms because if this continues I’m done. Also the Charm Room is a legit bummer. It’s hardly ever got anything worth using your hard won Charms on.

    • Wait. We can’t review all of our products anymore?

    • I know what you mean, I’m almost considering Ipsy just since it’s so much more personalized and not necessarily a bunch of low-sales items left over from big brands who still need to make a quota for sales so they pawn it off to sub boxes, I’ve only been subscribing since May and although I’ve received a couple items that have become staples (the tarte eyeshadow palette I got in the first box(I think), the luminous face oil and the Becca Hydra-Mist powder) everything else I’ve gotten has been just more things that are going to sit on my vanity and never get used. I was super excited about the palettes that come almost every other month but I have gotten 3 since subscribing and only one has been decent in wearable colors when they give you a quiz at the beginning of subscribing asking about your preferences and I definitely don’t wear half of the shades of products they’ve sent, kind of disappointed: especially with the amount of LIP GLOSS they constantly send me, I despise lip gloss hahaha

      • I have had a subscription to Ipsy for a year now. They say that they personalize your products based on your beauty profile but the last three months, i have received nothing but products that i had marked RARELY to recieve. Every body feels differently about these subscriptions but if you look at the spoilers for the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus and the comments people have made, you will see what i am talking about. Ipsy is making alot of changes starting in October. The price of the regular bag will be $12.00, it was $10.00. The Glam bag Plus is still $25.00, with 5 full size products, then they are adding tha Ultimate Glam bag for $50.00. 8 Full sized products and 3 or 4 deluxe sized items, i am not for sure on the deluxe size. You get to pick a product with each subscription every month and have a choice of picking 5 add on products. I dont have the money for all of that so i am sticking with the regular Glambag. But, i have gotten products that were on clearance at Wal-Mart in my bag before. I would really think about joining Ipsy right now, i have a feeling it is going to be a mess with all these changes coming up.. That is why i have been looking at different subscription boxes.

  25. So, I am guessing that since the spoiler brands are variations, the actual products are the palettes by these brands listed in the Boxyluxe spoilers? I would love that Violet Voss eyeshadow palette. I’m not crazy about face palettes, contouring and highlighting aren’t my strong points!

  26. I really hope boxy decides to switch to cruelty free soon. I love the box but hate to see brands that aren’t cruelty free in it. It’s not often, and I’ll donate if I get the MAC product, but I’m afraid I’ll have to cancel if it continues to happen 😔

    • I would love it if they switched to cruelty free!

  27. LOL the MAC National Lipstick Day freebie that they must not have been able to get rid of.

    I can’t be super mad at MAC for not doing a true freebie freebie this year even though it was a great way to get more people into the brand and I, a longtime wearer, discovered my fave color from waiting in line at my local Macy’s last year, but seriously one hideous orange frost option with $25 purchase?? No wonder they have extras.

    I have never before turned up my nose at MAC in a sub box, but for ugly orange in my least favorite of their formulas, it’s a super easy pass for me.

    • I agree for sure. Why not color options? SMH.

    • Agree with you 100% why not color choices that is the ugliest color I bet like no one was buying that color and they usually make a certain amount they passed over to boxycharm so they could get rid of it I dont know but lately it seems like boxycharm it’s just dropping whatever items they can just for the sake of making a box the last 3 months been just bad

    • I completely agree, I was like Orange frost? Yuck. Not something I would ever pick out for myself, and I love Mac!

  28. I do love a good liquid liner pen, but I’m getting Luxe for September so unless the pen is in the mix for Luxe members I probably won’t see it. I’d love to see more brown liquid liner – seems like it’s always black for this type of product. I wear a brown liquid liner daily so I’m always looking for the perfect formula! Looks like there will be a lot of variety in the September Boxy!

    • Agreed, brown would be nice to get as there is so much variation in color for brown and it would be good to sample different shades and formulas. At the least, if I didn’t like the brown tone, but liked the formula, I would know the black would work well. I have way too many black liquid liners from subscription boxes that I can’t possibly use up before black is too harsh a look on my aging lids.

      • I’m afraid Boxy definitely trends young. Brown is so much softer for those of us who are long past our 20s! I wear black mascara, but I also love black-brown and even brown for a more natural look. I got a brown gel liner in my July Boxy though, so maybe there’s hope!

    • I also wear a brown eyeliner and would love to see it in a sub box! Also getting the luxe in September.

    • Brown liners do happen in boxycharm, last September if I recall. So don’t give up hoping!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.