Play! By Sephora February 2019 FULL Spoilers for All Box Variations!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

We have the FULL spoilers for every February Play! By Sephora variation! You have until 2/11 to sign up and get the February box as your first box.

Box A:

sephora play february box a

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Rhubarb
  • Milk Makeup Blur Stick
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Fresh Rose Face Mask
  • Caudalie Vinosource Moisturizing Sorbet
  • Stella McCartney Stella

Box B:

play by sephora february 2019 box b

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Sake
  • Clinique Quickliner for Eyes in Intense Ebony
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Clinique Moisture Surge 72-Hour Auto-Replenishing Hydrator
  • Caudalie Vinoperfect Radiance Serum
  • Kat Von D Saint + Sinner Duo

Box C:

play by sephora february 2019 box c

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Maple
  • Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Fresh Rose Face Mask
  • Saturday Skin Rub-A-Dub Refining Peel Gel
  • Kat Von D Saint + Sinner Duo

Box D:

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Maple
  • Clinique Quickliner for Eyes in Intense Ebony
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Clinique Moisture Surge 72-Hour Auto-Replenishing Hydrator
  • Fresh Vitamin Nectar Moisture Glow Face Cream
  • Marc Jacobs Fragrances Daisy

Box E:

  • Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover
  • Clinique Quickliner for Eyes in Intense Ebony
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Fresh Rose Face Mask
  • Lancôme Hydra Zen Anti-Stress Gel Moisturizer
  • Marc Jacobs Fragrances Daisy Love

Box F:

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Maple
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Foundation in 2N1 Desert Beige
  • Caudalie Vinosource Moisturizing Sorbet
  • Clinique Moisture Surge 72-Hour Auto-Replenishing Hydrator
  • Dolce & Gabbana The Only One

Box G:

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Rhubarb
  • Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Foundation in 4N1 Shell Beige
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Sleeping Mask
  • Lancôme Hydra Zen Anti-Stress Gel Moisturizer
  • Dolce & Gabbana The Only One

Box H:

  • Clinique Quickliner for Eyes in Intense Ebony
  • Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Foundation in 7W1 Deep Spice
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Caudalie Vinosource Moisturizing Sorbet
  • Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Sleeping Mask
  • Stella McCartney Stella

Box I:

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Sake
  • Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Caudalie Vinoperfect Radiance Serum
  • Saturday Skin Rub-A-Dub Refining Peel Gel
  • Marc Jacobs Fragrances Daisy

Box J:

  • Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Maple
  • Clinique Quickliner for Eyes in Intense Ebony
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks
  • Lancôme Hydra Zen Anti-Stress Gel Moisturizer
  • Caudalie Vinosource Moisturizing Sorbet
  • Kat Von D Saint + Sinner

What do you think of the spoilers? Which items do you want? (You have until February 11th to sign up and get the February box as your first box!

Play! by Sephora is $10 a month. Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

How do subscribers rate Play! by Sephora?

554 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Play! by Sephora? Add your rating now!

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: play by sephora | 159 comments


  1. I was supposed to get box A according to my email, but my item #is 682 so I got box B. Not really into anything in the box, other than the eye masks. Was really hoping for Box G to try the Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Sleeping Mask and the Lancôme Hydra Zen Anti-Stress Gel Moisturizer. Wish they had better boxes fitting our profiles, I hate getting make-up I don’t wear it at all.

    • How do you know what box/variation you will get

      • You have to check the website itself. Go to your orders and it’s the last three numbers of your ITEM number, not the order number. The way to know which box variation is when you get it in the mail on the bottom of the box it will have the barcode and above it has the month, year, and box letter. Above that is a confirmation of your item number.

        • I can’t find the item number it only says the order number I wish I knew what box I was getting

          • Make sure you’re on the desktop version, the app won’t show your item number.

    • My email also indicates that I should have gotten Box B but my # is 682, too! Looks like it’s arriving today, so I guess we’ll see… Have you already gotten yours? I would prefer box A because I think the bite rhubarb will look better on me than the sake.

      • My spoiler says box A and my item # is 190. I was hoping for the watermelon sleep mask as well. C’est La Vie!

        • *690

      • Sorry, my spoiler says I should have gotten Box A but by my number it should be Box B. Hmmm. Fingers crossed for actually getting A!

      • I got variation G that’s what I wanted. I love it I just wish it was bigger sizes

    • The email I received from Sephora said Inwas supposed to get Box A, and I got Box B too. I had #729

  2. The app says my box, 724 is A. Although I know that other’s that have received box 724 have box F. The app might be glitching again, like last month. Mine arrives tomorrow so I guess I will find out then. I am actually happy with all variations this month so I wont be disappointed either way.

    • Where on the app does it show your box #? I’d love you to check mine.

      • Go to the app and click shop, then scroll all the way to the botttom where it says Play! By Sephora and click that, then click the icon current box and it shows the contents.

      • When you go to your recent orders click details. Make sure you are on the desktop version tho, the app won’t show your item number.

    • Yes, says I’m A too.. but item number 690

    • My app said I would get A but I got my Sephora today and it was G I am so happy that’s what I wanted.

  3. I know it has been explained many times, but I still have never found a letter for the box I will be getting. I just see the item#.

  4. I have 732 and my current box on the Sephora website is showing the contents of A

    • That’s my box as well (crosses fingers). I am happy with mostly everything although I would have liked to have received the Daisy perfume and Fresh Vitamin C cream.

    • That’s whats showing for me as well, but it wont be what I get. They did the same thing last month.

    • Same here. Box 732 with the contents of box A. Definitely my least favorite box of the bunch. I’ve already gotten the Fresh mask, have a bunch of Bite lipsticks, receive Caudalie over and over, and have enough Stella samples to fill a rollerball perfume. Ultra disappointed with the Milk sample. However, this is only my second disappointment since sephora play opened to all.

      Wish we could rate our samples and boxes.

      • I got my box today and I ended up getting the contents of G not A even though that’s what they’re showing me receiving. I’m not mad though bc I wanted box G!

      • Update: I got box G! You guys were right. My Sephora Play reveal on the site was inaccurate. MSA sleuths are the finest detectives.

  5. Has anyone with Box 740 gotten their box yet? I’m dying to know what we’ll be getting in our box.

    • 740 is box A! 🙂

      • Hmmm……I thought 674 was Box A

        • I have 674 and I just got my box, it’s the contents of Box A.

          • Thanks for confirming that for me. I’m still curious as to which box is 740, since I’ve only seen unboxings of Boxes 674, 682, and 724 so far.

  6. 760?

  7. 724 is Box F….I received it today unexpectedly because I never got an email or app notification that it was shipped lol It still says “in progress” on the app??? Oh well. So far, I don’t like the perfume…too musky/strong for my taste. The foundation color might actually be a great match for me surprisingly! The Clinique moisture surge is TINY….The Bite Beauty in Maple is a beautiful dark red…not mad at it lol I know a lot of ppl are complaining about too many lip products but I LOVE getting them!

    • Nevermind the foundation is maybe a shade or two too light for me…Iooking a lil ghostly right now…grrrr…

      • You could use it for a highlight shade when contouring, or mix it with a too dark foundation sample

  8. Ahh bummer getting another red lipstick. I have a collection now.

  9. I’m patiently waiting for my box to ship. Last month I didn’t receive my box until the 26th. What I received was nothing like the email I was sent showed. I cannot figure out which box I am getting. I sent an email asking what I was getting and they would not tell me. I’m becoming disappointed with this box and it’s service

    • I’m with you on that. I don’t know why Sephora is being so non-transparent to their customers, no less.

  10. I’d have preferred C or I, but I’m totally not mad at B. It’s all stuff I can use.

  11. Anyone else have box #729? I’ve called twice and they wouldn’t tell me what letter I was.

  12. Anybody know which letter box 154 is?

  13. Box 724 any idea which one is it?

    • F…received mine today.

  14. Anyone know what letter coordinates with box 976?

    • It’s going to be E,G,H or I

      • Lol of course. Cause I thought I’ll be fine as long as I don’t get one of those.

  15. I think the problem with Sephora play is that they have too many versions of the box and people get disappointed when they don’t get the samples that they would like. I believe they would hold more customers subscriptions by offering only a few versions and maybe even allow you to request which box you would like to receive based on the variables spoilers. I really wish all of these companies would allow their customers to be able to skip a month or offer more flexibility. I don’t know what the answer is but this sub in particular shows all these possibilities then people feel let down.

    • I agree with this! I think Sephora play was better when it was just 1 box for everyone – it meant that the products they included were the sorts of things most people would like! As opposed to trying to (randomly?) personalize. I do wish there was a way to veto perfume samples though, mine go straight into the garbage

    • i disagree tbh. I was subbed to them for over a year and got same things over and over and over. The whole point of these boxes is to have new items, to try new things, to get exited about smth new, not to get the same Clinique surge 10th time in a row and all the other same items. I would get 3 to 4 repeats EACH box EVERY month…If i was still subbed i wouldnt care which box i would get cuz i literally got ALL those samples multiple times….been unsubbed for almost 6 months now, i think, and so glad i unsubbed tbh. Same old crap. Got an email from Sephora saying their box got improved, they finally listened…well its been 2 months since that email and i been stalking mysubaddiction to see if it was true….it aint…literally got all those samples in ALL of those boxes multiple times….a multibillion company with a huge variety of products to choose and buy from and only like 30 variations of deluxe samples to get….

      • I absolutely agree. Their improved box is not an improvement at all. I was pretty disappointed when they stopped giving the cloth drawstring bags. Now they give you a plastic ziploc bag.

        • Yep…same here.

  16. Ok, I’m canceling. I get the same stuff over and over from this company! I can’t tell you how many samples of Sinner and Saint that I have and I’ve only gotten it from them. Its a pretty perfume (saint) but im sick of it. STOP sending out the same tired stuff!

    • I LOVE Sinner and was really hoping to get another sample of it. Instead, it appears that I’m getting Daisy, which I really don’t like. I resubbed this month only for the Saint+Sinner spoiler. Not really happy with my box again, so many repeats, time to cancel for good 🙁

      • I’m getting box C and I’d gladly give you my Sinner+Saint duo since I don’t care for KVD.

        • That’s very generous and I appreciate it! I’m not sure how to do that since I’m not on the swap page.

    • I decided if I got Sinner/Saint again this month, I was going to cancel. I did, and I did. I also got Caudelie serum again, 😒.

  17. You guys have covered all but E,G,H and I


    • I think E-716

    • This is assuming that these numbers actually correspond to the correct box- unlike last months fiasco,

    • Actually they told me I was getting box F via chat and my box number is 724 – This was on the 5th.

    • Well I’m glad I’m not getting that nasty watermelon mask. I bought a full sized and hated it. It was soupy, sticky, and pilled up on the skin.

    • F is actually 724…received mine today.

  18. Box 344 is box F!

  19. Item 732 anyone know which box?

    • BOX G

  20. The last three of my Item Number is 732. Can someone tell me what letter I’m getting, please! Thank you so muc!!!!

    • I still can’t find the item number I only see the order the number please help me

  21. I unsubscribed after my January box 🙁

    My first box I was so pleased, and after that just horrible shades of lip liners/lip sticks and products I just wasn’t interested in. I feel like they don’t really consider the information you provide. I wish they would let you pick something that comes in your box or listen to the products people actually want

    • I only started subbing for this box in November. This will be the third time I have received the Clinique moisture surge from them in that short time frame. WTH???? In the few months I have gotten the box I have found one item worth buying… for my daughter who has a very dry, itchy scalp. She loved the dpHue Apple Cider Rinse.

      sigh I want soooo badly to love this one more. :S

  22. I just chatted with a Sephora rep and she told me that item #765 is box J.

    • Darn. I really wanted Box J. I have Box 740, so I now bet that it will be Box H or I, of which I don’t want either. I’m no longer excited about Sephora Play this month.

      • Don’t be discouraged yet. It is possible that you could still get Box J. Multiple box item numbers could have the same box letter. I’ve seen it happen in other months.

        • I have box 765 it’s j

    • Every time I ask they tell me no and that I have to wait until my box arrives lol

      • It’s luck of the draw, some months I get them to reveal it and some months, I get denied.

  23. My box is #708, what’s letter it would be ??

    • I emailed sephora, when they tell me I’ll come back and let you know!

    • Denied! They flat out refused to tell me!

      • You’re getting box D 🙂

        • Thank you Hanna. I was hoping they tell someone. They denied me multiple times.

  24. Unless you can pick your box, Why in the world would they include foundation????! That’s just stupid. I canceled my subscription a long time ago but if I was still a member and got the box with that super dark foundation I’d be livid!!!

    • I believe they use your profile for the foundation color. The colors they have sent me are generally on light/medium which is what I am. I am excited to try the double-wear 🙂

  25. Getting box F, hopefully the foundation is the right color for me as I am really looking forward to trying it!

    • How do you know which box your getting? Customer service wouldn’t tell me!

      • I chatted with them online and they lady told me. My box number is 724

        • Thanks! Funny I asked you & turns out we’re getting the same box lol

    • Do you know what box number that is? I was hoping I’d get that box too.

    • What number was for box F

  26. 674. Box A. Ty Sephora! The rep said you can find the box number in the subscription tab under your “order number”. My box number doesn’t show…

    • When I went into Order Detail it shows Item # right under “Play by Sephora” where it shows : Price Qty Amount

    • Mine doesn’t show either. It shows the order is being processed, but the item number is blank. They same thing happened last month. They also sent me an email showing products that I didn’t get in my bag. I’ve been a subscriber for two months now and so far I am frustrated enough with the communication and unknowledgable customer service to quit for that reason alone.

      • Did you contact them about getting the wrong items? Did they send the items you were supposed to get?

  27. Confused…. I emailed support and they said my box is #2172708. I see everyone else with 3 digit boxes.?.?

    • Your box number is the last three digits, so your box # would be “708”

      • Thank you! I figured it was like that but unsure what set of 3 as I didn’t see any of my numbers listed here.

        Thanks again!

    • Why are you now identifying boxes by A,B,C,D,E,F, etc. That does not help identify our boxes which have numbers?????

    • you should be D

  28. Does anyone know which box is 690?

    • Box C!

  29. Box 344 anyone?

  30. I’m 674 and per above it’s box A. I’m meh about it. I like the rhubarb lippie as I already have it. I think only the eye masks and maybe the Milk product are new. I’ve literally received everything else before.

  31. Perfect box for me would be all the Bite lipsticks!!

  32. I just subbed today! February will be my first month. I’ve heard mixed reviews about this box but I’m looking forward to it anyway! I can always use black eyeliner and face products! I’m not a big fan of lipstick but I wouldn’t mind the Sake shade. How/when do you find out what variation you’re getting?

  33. I have my fingers crossed for G… Did anyone notice the foundation is only sampled for medium tones? WTF? The sinner and Saint perfume is awful.. And the Wander eyes masks are useless for a one time use. I’d love to see a little more variety for the makeup… Like… Eyeshadow maybe…

  34. So we know #674 is A and my box #682 is B…I’m happy about 4/5…would have been basically perfect if I could have mixed A and B together since I would have liked the Caudalie sorbet instead of the Clinique moisture surge. Glad I got the color sake though instead of a purplish rhubarb. Not mad at all at B. Thank the Lord for a decent month lol.😂

    • I wish I could trade you my Caudalie for the Clinique.

  35. Maybe it’s just because I’ve tried a lot of these already but nothing is screaming at me. I’ve been wanting to come back but can’t pull the trigger. I’m glad there are products that people want tho

  36. How do you know which box you’re getting?

    • You can live chat like I did on Sephora

      • What did you ask them? Last time I tried they told me what my actual box number was, not the letter 🙁

        • I gave her my order number and my item number which has the last 3 digits of 682 and she told me that my box was B so I copied and pasted what box B has in it and she confirmed that was the box.

  37. I got box #674 and its box letter A 🙂

    • Same! I was kind of hoping for B or D, but I’m happy with A as well! It is a VAST improvement over the crap I got in January, for sure!! I am glad to get the Fresh product – I got one of their masks in a box last year, and really liked it and am happy to try another of their items.

  38. Only ONE box variant has the advertised Fresh Vitamin Nectar cream in it? Not cool.

  39. I think the selection is great this month, I re-subbed 🙂 I really want to try The only one perfume.

  40. 682 here. I wish soooo much i get J since it has products i like and scent i tollerate but i see the shade sobibknow i will not get anything i like. No one gets Milks just A?

    • How do you know which box you’re getting?

      • I guess i have fair complectio so they dont send me dark shade Estee Lauder.

        • It says it is Lancôme Hydra Zen Anti-Stress Gel Moisturizer, I don’t think it’s foundation.

  41. Please please please G!!!! I’m in love❤

  42. I have box 740 I’m hoping for box A or box B…. I just started my subscription back up and I can’t wait to try the products that they send….

    • 674 is A

  43. I cancelled last month, only to resubscribe after seeing this month’s spoilers. I’m box 740. I’m hoping that it’s Box J.

  44. I’m box 682. Anyone know which one that is?

    • Me too and I’m yet to see anything on it. Last month I unsubscribed after my box was shipped then went in resubscribed after changing my profile only to get the same box twice 🤦‍♀️. It was at least a semi decent box. I’m hoping adjusting the profile works better this time.

    • How you know what number the box you have ??? Thanks

    • Great news #682 is box B. My faves are A, B and I, so I got a good box in my opinion. Thank God it wasn’t C or D, wouldn’t have been happy. Last box I liked 4 items too…Sephora is on a roll…shhh don’t wanna jinx it lol.😂

      • Thank you for the information.

        • I wish I wasn’t box 682! Lol If anyone wants to trade Sake for Maple when they ship, let me know! 😁

          • Interested! I’m getting Maple (Box D).

  45. Bummer, I don’t think any of the Estee Lauder samples are in a shade I can use. I guess if I do end up with one I could use it to tint primer or moisturizer. So I guess Box A would be my favorite variation. I’d love to try the Fresh vitamin nectar cream, it’s too bad it’s only in one box!

  46. I want the peeling gel. Is that okay to post MSA?

  47. I’ll take C,D,Or I. I really want that peeing gel

    • That typo made my morning 🙂 LOL

      I will take whatever box gets me the lipstick in Maple 😀 I am always down for trying new skincare, I already have about 3 samples of the moisture surge, so crossing my fingers I get something else to try this time.

  48. Fingers crossed for box D!

  49. I love Fresh masks and bite lipsticks but my friends and family have more than enough black eyeliners donated from my neverending stash but I guess it’s better than another mascara.

  50. I would sign up for this box if there weren’t so many variations, or if there was a way to request a variation out from the list.

    • Same.

    • Same. I’m on complete beauty overload but I would buy a variation that had something in it I wanted to try.

      • Same. I will wait for their next box sale to snag one. Can’t chance not getting the box I want especially after last month’s fiasco; and at this point I do not need any more beauty stuff!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!