MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

OFRA Perfecting Beauty Mystery Bag Review

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Box Top

OFRA recently released a Perfecting Beauty Mystery Bag, and y’all know I love a good mystery box. This box promised a full-size highlighter, all new packaging, and a value of at least $85.

FYI – this box is no longer available for purchase.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Box Open Top

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - All contents Top

About This Box

The Box: OFRA Perfecting Beauty Mystery Bag

The Cost: $35 + $3.50 shipping

The Products: $85+Value. “4 or more mini and full-sized makeup and skincare products and special V-day treats. A secret we can tell: All bags come with a full-sized highlighter compact and are in all-new packaging!

OFRA Perfecting Beauty Mystery Bag February 2019 Review

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Perfecting Beauty Bag in Pink Front

This box didn’t come with an info sheet, but all of the goodies did come packed inside this cute pink bag!

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Perfecting Beauty Bag in Pink All contents Top

Perfecting Beauty Bag in Pink – Retail Value $15

Do I think the retail value on this bag is a little nuts? For sure, but I am happy to get it in a mystery box at a discount! It is an impressive size and the interior should be easy to wipe clean if any makeup or skincare spills inside.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Eye Mask Front OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Eye Mask Back

OFRA Get Chilled Out Eye Mask

We also received this eye mask that has beads that can be heated in the microwave for a few seconds or stuck in the fridge to cool. The side of the mask that rests against your skin is velvet, and it fit my face well. Masks like these are a godsend when I am dealing with a migraine or just need help to relax after a long day, and I am happy to officially now own a second one!

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Sticky Front OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Sticky Back

Post-It Pink Heart Sticky Notes

To round out the Valentine’s day goodies this box promised, we got some pink heart sticky notes. They are Post-It brand, though!

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Mini Makeup Fixer Front

Mini Makeup Fixer, 2 oz – Retail Value $8 (found here for $3)

This is a makeup setting mist that has great skincare ingredients like aloe vera juice, Vitamin E, and chamomile. You can use this to set your makeup, to dampen your brush before going in with highlighter to really add some extra shine, or as just a pick me up for your skin. The small size means this could fit in my purse makeup bag with ease, too.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Cleanse It Off Wipes Top

Cleanse It Off Wipes, 15 ct – Retail Value $7 (found here for $5)

I genuinely can never have too many makeup wipes, and these did a pretty good job at taking off my matte liquid lipstick swatches! These are made with 100% cotton and aloe vera, and they should be able to take off all of your lipstick with one wipe.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Ofra Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in Mina Box Top OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Ofra Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in Mina Front

Ofra Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in Mina, Full-Size! Retail Value $20

Ofra is known for their liquid lipsticks and their highlighters, so I think it’s fitting that that is what came in our mystery boxes! Mina is described as a vampy berry, which I think is dead on. It actually is a bit too vampy for me, but I have a friend who absolutely adores shades like this one and will be happy to put it to good use.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Ofra Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in Tuscany Front

Ofra Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in Tuscany, 2 g – Estimated Value $5 (buy the full-size version for $20)

Tuscany is a muted mauve red, and this is about the darkest I like to go in terms of lip color. I love how easy it is to throw this mini shade in my purse, but with their liquid lipstick formula, not many touch-ups are necessary. I wore this before going out on a Saturday night, and my lips looked perfect until midnight. After midnight it did start to fade pretty quickly, but it faded really well (no dreaded clown lips where there’s a dark line on the edges and nothing in the middle). This was comfortable, too! I prepped my lips with a thick lip balm before blotting it away and applying this, and I didn’t notice any dryness.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Ofra Highlighter in All of The Lights Box Top OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Ofra Highlighter in All of The Lights Front

Ofra Highlighter in All of The Lights, Full-Size! Retail Value $35

This highlighter combines some of Ofra’s best shades in one compact (Rodeo, Pillow Talk, Star Island, and Blissful), and I love that I can customize the shade depending on which area of the pan I dip my brush into. This highlighter blends super easily and a little bit goes a long way, but you can also easily amp up the glam by applying it with a damp brush. I use this fan brush, and it is perfect for adding the exact pop of color I want in the place I want.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Swatches

Here are the swatches! I tried to show two different swipes of the highlighter to show the dimension it offers. The first swipe is a bit hard to see against my fair skin, while the other one is definitely more golden. After the two highlighter swipes, we have Tuscany on top and Mina on the bottom.

OFRA Mystery Box February 2019 - Selfie

Here I am wearing Tuscany on my lips and All of the Lights on my cheekbones, temple, under my brow, and my nose and cupids bow.

The Verdict: When I ordered this mystery box I wasn’t expecting to get an eye mask and post its, but overall I think this was a good box. I really appreciate that all of the makeup items come in OFRA‘s new packaging, which is definitely more high-quality than previous OFRA packaging. Value-wise, OFRA promised value of at least $85, and by my math, they met that with a total value of $90.

To Wrap Up:

Can you get this box if you sign up today? No, this is no longer available.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $35 + $3.50 shipping and I calculated a total value of $90 (not including the eye mask or post-its). That means you are paying approximately the following per item:

  • Makeup Bag: $6.42
  • Makeup Mist: $3.42
  • Makeup Wipes: $2.99
  • Highlighter: $14.97
  • Mina: $8.55
  • Tuscany: $2.14

What do you think of the Ofra Mystery Box?

Written by Jessica Hapak

Jessica Hapak

I am a staunch believer that pineapple doesn’t belong on pizza and when I’m not working as a family law attorney I enjoy hiking the Louisiana trails (alligator sightings are a favorite!) or relaxing with Duchess, my cat. I’m a sucker for anything labeled a mystery box and I’ve never met a bath bomb I didn’t like.

Posted in Makeup Subscription Boxes, Mystery Boxes, Ofra Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: ofra | 13 comments

Comments (13)

  1. Today they have their perfecting beauty mystery bag for the black Friday. The picture on the site show the same bag.

  2. I got the mystery bag too but my full sized lippie was a different color, the mini I received was the same shade and the highlight is the same as yours!! I love Ofra’s lippies and highlights they are the absolute BEST in the business in my opinion!! Jessica I think the products you are wearing look AMAZING on you, you look absolutely GORGEOUS girl!!💯💃🔥🙏💕

  3. Colors look great on you! And such a cute curation!!! I love all of the items for a cute valentines gift or gift to yourself 😏

    • Thank you so much Shai!

  4. Jessica, your whole look is fantastic and you look so pretty and put together. I read all your reviews and you always look lovely,
    I think this is the best look I’ve seen on you yet!
    And those lips! That shade looks amazing! Like it was especially created for you!

    • Thank you so much Dani! You’re so sweet.

  5. You look very pretty! Love the lippies, Tuscany looks great on you. But, the highlight on your Cupid’s bow reads like a runny nose.

    • I noticed that too

    • Thank you! And re the Cupid’s bow you’re not wrong!

  6. That lip color looks beautiful on you!

    • Thank you Esther!

  7. I’m so upset I missed this! I would have loves that bag and everything in it cause I love pink and I love ofra!

  8. Omg Mina is freaking gorgeous!!! I think Tuscany looks really flattering on you. Your skin is looking really glowy, too!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.