Cult Pop Box Subscription Review – January 2019

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Box Top

Cult Pop Box is a brand new subscription celebrating some of our favorite 80’s and 90’s cult classic movies.

Cult Pop Box January 2019- Insert Packaging

Every box will be dedicated to one specific theme, bringing you collectibles, apparel, decor and accessories from amazing independent artists, each paying homage to that month’s movie.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Open Box1 Top

This month spotlights Heathers, the 1988 cult classic that is all about a popular high school clique made up of three Heathers and a Veronica. This movie portrays teen angst and also what it is like dating a sociopath. The “I’m a Veronica” box celebrates this movie’s excellent one-liners and several classic scenes we all love from this groundbreaking film.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Open Box2

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Cult Pop Box January 2019- Insert Contents

About Cult Pop Box

The Box: Cult Pop Box

The Cost: $60 + $12 shipping

The Products: Each month you will receive items such as apparel, decor, accessories, and pins pertaining to that month’s cult classic movie theme.

Good to know: Boxes, at this time, are only available as a one time purchase.

Ships to: US & Canada

Cult Pop Box Heathers “I’m a Veronica” Box Review

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Info1 Front

I loved opening up this box to Heather C’s “suicide” note! It provided me with a myriad of laughs.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Info2 Front

Cult Pop Box provides an itemized list of products featured in your box, including the artists behind each item and a price for each product. None of the handmade products included are available for purchase online (yet!), but I provided links to the artist’s online stores.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Ouija1 Front

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Ouija2

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Ouija3

Cult Pop Box January 2019- Ouija set

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Slide1 Front

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Slide2

Summon a Heather Ouija Board & Planchette Set by Demonic Pinfestation– Listed Value $30

Greetings and salutations! An Ouija Board is not complete without an accompanied planchette, and this one really connects all the dots! Christian Slater’s character J.D., a sociopath with an inclination to murder, is known for his quick wit and cool (dangerous) vibes. His quotes in this movie, like the one found on the slushie on the planchette, are so iconic, just like his name, James Dean.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Insert Pin Front

My Afterlife is so Boring Enamel Pin by Demonic Pinfestation – Listed Value $13

I love this scene; Veronica is dreaming of Heather C’s afterlife, where she is still definitely not Mother Theresa. I have a slight pin addiction, and Demonic Pinfestation makes killer ones! This pin is massive, too! It measures 2 inches by 2 inches and has three pins at the back to keep this baby secure. Each of their pins is painted by hand, making each one unique.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Tshirt1

Cult Pop Box January 2019- T-Shirt 2

James Dean T-Shirt by Brett Sailor of Snotty Rockers – Listed Value $28

J.D. is not a rebel; he’s a psychopath! He makes it pretty obvious throughout the movie that he does not like Veronica’s friends! This soft cotton tee is the perfect fit, and the graphic by Brett Sailor includes a portrait of J.D. (played by Christian Slater), bomb and all! I love how unique this design is, and I feel that wearing the red scrunchie with it is contradictory, but chaos is, after all, what killed the dinosaurs.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Big Fun Magnet Front

Big Fun Magnet by Brett Sailor of Snotty Rockers – Listed Value $5

Oh, Martha Dumptruck.. Martha Dunnstock’s infamous t-shirt with “BIG FUN” printed on it only gives the Heathers more fuel to target her in their mean girl games. This bright magnet “isn’t just another example of a geek trying to imitate the popular people at school,” it is BIG FUN, and I can’t wait to display it on my fridge.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Mug1 Front

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Mug2

Give me the Cup, Jerk! Mug by Brett Sailor of Snotty Rockers – Listed Value $14

I have to say that this is my new favorite mug. “Just give me the cup, jerk!” is the next to last words that come out of Heather C’s mouth (portraying her perfectly), as she drinks the Hull Cleaner that J.D. told her was a passed down hangover cure he concocted. This mug is your standard coffee mug that holds about 8 ounces of liquid comfortably, and her face makes me laugh every time I look at it.

Cult Pop Box January 2019- “Hull Clean” Body Wash 1 Front

Cult Pop Box January 2019- “Hull Clean” Body Wash 2

“Hull Clean” Body Wash by Dearg Due Bath & Body – Listed Value $10

Big Blue! I couldn’t help but laugh when I pulled this body wash out of the box. This is how Heather Chandler met her demise; downing drain cleaner with potential phlegm gobbers in it. Dearg Due Bath & Body is an indie brand that makes 100% vegan and cruelty-free products, and this body wash (and its packaging) is awesome! I love the pearly blue color, and the scent, which I can’t quite put my finger on, might just remind me of blue raspberry?

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Heather’s Red Scrunchie

Heather’s Red Scrunchie – Listed Value $3

The infamous red scrunchie of power! The scene where Veronica is burnt to a crisp, grabs Heather Duke, snatches the scrunchie from her hair and says “Heather my love, there’s a new sheriff in town!” and kisses her on the cheek.. Classic! Plus, scrunchies are back, right?

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Bbq1 Front

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Bbq2 Back

Corn Nuts, 1.7oz – Buy 18 Bags for $17.50

Heather Chandler loved her Corn Nuts, so much that those were her last words? I’d have to agree with her that BQ is the way to go, and I’ve been munching on these all day! You don’t have to be a Heather to appreciate this great snack.

Cult Pop Box January 2019-Westerburg High School Sticker

Westerburg High School Sticker – Buy Similar for $2.55 here

Go Rottweilers! Westerburg High School is a main setting of this flick, so it only makes sense to show some school spirit in this box.

Verdict: If I were to judge this month’s Cult Pop Box, it would receive a charismatic “How very!” I thoroughly enjoyed reliving one of my favorite cult classic films through all of these indie products. Everything was so thoughtfully carried out, and I love all the different aspects of the movies that each item represented. Everything was made by independent artists, and you can tell that the curator and craftsman really put thought and effort into this fun, exciting new subscription box! March’s box is going to spotlight the movie Crybaby, another favorite of mine.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Unfortunately, this box is sold out, but sign up by 2/15 for March’s Crybaby box.

Value Breakdown: This box had a total listed value of $103. It costs $60 + $12 shipping, which means that each of the 7 items (not counting the sticker or the Corn Nuts since they weren’t listed with the other items) in the box has an average cost of $10.29.

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think about Cult Pop Box? Should we review March’s Crybaby box? Let us know in the comments!

How do subscribers rate Cult Pop Box ?

No subscribers have rated this yet
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Cult Pop Box ? Add your rating now!

Written by Abby Holsinger

Abby Holsinger

Abby has been a box enthusiast since July 2011, finding her calling with Birchbox. That was the start of a new era for Abby, because she is now hooked on the subscription box life; she loves the idea of receiving (several) thoughtful treats from genius curators such as Lisa Sugar and Rachel Zoe. A few other loves of hers would be her dog named Bill Murray, Bill Murray and chocolate babka.

Posted in Cult Pop Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: cult pop box | 6 comments


  1. Awesome curation, but I’ve got to agree with others – the price point on this would keep me away. I also kind of feel like a lot of this will turn into dust magnets, just sitting around and not super useful.

  2. Was super excited for this until I saw the price! $50 would be a little more reasonable for a sub box.. that being said, if the price ever lowers I’m fully on board!

  3. I have never ever wanted a subscription box as much as I want this one. Heathers is for sure in my top 5 favorite movies of all time, and Crybaby too?? I can’t wait to see that one! Sign me up!.. gently… with a chainsaw. 😉

  4. While everything was totally on point for the movie, and it sounds like they are going to have lots of my favorite cult movies….this price point just seems super high. Even high shipping too.

    • I HATE paying shipping for subscriptions! It’s almost always a deal breaker for me.

  5. If I could actually use this stuff or the price tag was lower I would sub just to be reminded of these movies I watched over and over.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!



Get alerts on your desktop for the best deals and spoilers!