MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

BoxyCharm February 2019 Spoiler #1!


We have the first spoiler for the February 2019 BoxyCharm box thanks to Yosef!

The February box will include:

Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

What do you think of the spoiler?

If you sign up now, the January box will be your first box! Check out the full spoilers for January here!

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

PLUS Special Offer
PLUS Special Offer


How do subscribers rate BOXYCHARM?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 41 comments

Comments (41)

  1. Awesome! I almost bought it today and I forgot lol my favorite mascara!

  2. I have this mascara. Its one of my go-to mascaras but Loreal Lash paradise does a an better job the only reason I do not make that one my go to is because its a pain in the arse to get it off my eyes.

  3. I enjoy this mascara. I don’t want a million mascaras but I like this one.

  4. Eh, it’s a good mascara. Would have loved to see something new and amazing… I just use this product all the time and I’m currently working on finishing a full tube I have. I’ll definitely gift this to my mom.

  5. *adds to giant pile of mascara from boxy*

    • This mascara is amazing tho

  6. Now if only we could get the Top Faced diamond pallets that would be perfect! I love glitter!

    • I would LOVE to try the Diamond highlighters!

      I love Too Faced and wouldn’t turn down much of anything from them, but it does surprise me to see this in a sub box, since it is one of the all-time best selling mascaras by any company. I would imagine they don’t need to hand out samples. …but I wouldn’t say no 😉

  7. Yaaaaaasssssss! 😍😁

  8. This mascara is okay, I usually layer it. I would much prefer the Mascara Melt-off, though. Still, glad to see Too Faced…

  9. This is my HG mascara so this is great for me. This already looks better for February than January’s box and I’ve only seen this one thing. You win some, you lose some. Now that Too Faced is in a box, I wonder if we will get more? Other than the occasional dud, I have loved most all of their formulas for everything. With that said, for the love of everything still good in the world, no bubble gum pink. Please and thanks in advanced. 😂

    • I am skipping January as I just cleaned out my Tarte makeup. The smell irritates me and my eyes hate the shadows. My skin also hates Tatcha. (The ingredients are questionable for everyone). So its not just you. Not yet tried this Mascara but DEFINITELY excited to.

  10. Next to Tarte man eater …this is the best mascara ever! Right up there with the Wander mascara. And Love seeing too faced in a sub box! Of course that means it’ll be a variant and the one I ACTUALLY get will be Lorac, butter, or Grande. All of which I despise.

    • Its not a variant. I heard that everyone is getting it.

  11. Boring.

    Got it, it’s okay.

  12. It’s a good mascara. I have three of them so for me this is a meh. It is nice to see Too Faced in boxes though I’d rather see eyeshadow, blush or highligher.

    • Please Beauty Goddess, no more highlighter!

      I have at least six of various brands, and I don’t use it.

      • You only have six? I have more than twenty…probably closer to 35. I just don’t use them (although the photos on Instagram showing their uses are pretty).

      • I don’t wear highlighter either. I’m thirty-nine and I don’t want to call attention to anything on my face. Especially not the tip of my nose. Why oh gawd why do they do that?

      • I emptied my highlighter stockpile in Christmas presents. I have no interest in looking shiny, but my daughters do!

      • Haha. I live in South Louisiana. It’s so humid that we’re all shiny naturally. I feel you. And I’m 39 too.

    • Too Faced has the best highlighters in such pretty packaging. I may already have enough highlighter to glow queen my face for the next 15 years to even want anymore but I still do in the right brands. I have a crazy amount of Too Faced eyeshadows in my palette collection too and I have yet to get tired of their eyeshadow palettes. Lol

  13. Meh

  14. Never use black mascara so this is of no value to me

  15. Excited for this mascara!!! I love that boxy gives us the chance to test out so many different popular mascaras . Not everyone is going to love every single one , but it’s fun to test them out without paying full price .
    Which is kind of the entire point of a subsciption box.

  16. I know a lot of people so far aren’t too excited about this mascara, but this is my absolute favorite go to mascara and I really hope I get it in my box! Maybe it’s too clumpy for others but my eyelashes seem longer and they have more volume compared to all the other mascaras I own.

  17. I personally dont like this mascara. It’s very clumpy and way overpriced for what it is. L’oreal Lash Paradise is 100x better (and 1/3 of the price) and Monsieur Big from Lancome is fabulous for a higher end one. I’ll give this to my teenager or her bestie, they will be happy. Still cool to see it in the box though.

  18. Still haven’t used the mascara from past boxes, but if it’s popular, should be easy to swap so I’m not complaining too much.

  19. Yasssssssssssssssss! too!

  20. I like this mascara but I always wear a primer under it and don’t layer.

    Has anyone heard if it will be in all boxes or just a variant??? They seem to be avoiding saying “all boxes.” Hopefully it’s a comparable variant if it is!

  21. In my experience, it’s clumpy and definitely does not live up to its silly name. Pass.

    • Ugh, totally agree. I got the sample in my Too Faced book a while back and don’t understand the hype, just clumps my lashes together.

    • I mentioned to my husband how much I disliked the name, and he agreed that it was awful. Then he pointed out that there is also a cake of the same name.

      • The cake does, in fact, live up to its name LOL

      • That cake is SO good though!!! I do, however, remember being quite embarrassed when my mom announced at my 5th birthday party that it was the recipe she’d used for my cake 🤦🏽‍♀️

      • Your mom lol how embarrassing

  22. I hate the brush on this. Sigh.

  23. Meh

  24. Finally! I’ve been waiting for some too faced and the mascara is my favorite !

  25. I hope they aren’t old stock because speaking from experience, these don’t store well. But still cool to see it in the box.

  26. Yasssssssssssssssss!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.