MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

ShoeDazzle Fall OTK Boots Subscription Review + Coupon – October 2018

shoedazzle october packaging

ShoeDazzle is a monthly shoe, clothing, and accessories subscription service. You can shop their merchandise like normal retail, but they have a VIP subscription that gives you better prices – many styles are only $39.95 (or less) for VIPs. When you sign up for a membership, you complete a style profile. On the 1st of every month, they release new styles, and you can pick any item you want – either from your personal “Showroom” or across the site. You can also skip the month. However, if you don’t pick or skip, you get charged $39.95 store credit to spend any time.

shoedazzle october unboxing

This model is similar to how JustFabFabletics, and AdoreMe work. (Which makes sense, as JustFab, Fabletics, and Shoedazzle exist under the same umbrella company!)

My Subscription Addiction pays for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes)

shoedazzle october unboxing and review

About Shoedazzle

The Subscription Box: ShoeDazzle

The Cost: Each month, you have until the 5th of the month to make a purchase or choose to skip the month. If you don’t choose something or skip, you’ll be charged $39.95, which will live in your account as VIP Credits, which will stay in your account until you do decide to make a purchase.

COUPON: Get your first style for $10 No coupon needed - just use this link.

The Products: ShoeDazzle offers lots of exclusive shoes in addition to clothing, accessories, and jewelry

Ships to: All VIP orders over $39, shipped to addresses within the contiguous United States qualify for free standard ground shipping. VIP orders shipped to APO/FPO addresses, Alaska, Hawaii or US territories receive a $5 discount on standard ground shipping charges.

Shoedazzle Fall Over the Knee Boots Review – October 2018

shoedazzle october naked wines coupon

shoedazzle october naked wines 100 dollar coupon

I got a coupon for Naked Wines in this month’s package! Coupons like this almost always appear in my ShoeDazzle boxes.

shoedazzle october otk boots

Lilou Mixed Material Boot, Size 8 – Retail Value $84.95, Member Price $46.95

I LOVE the look of OTK boots. Slipped over a pair of skinny jeans or worn under a short skirt or dress? Adorable. Unfortunately, I haven’t had much luck finding over the knee boots that work for my legs. I’m 5′ 3″ with relatively short legs. My calves are pretty standard, width-wise, but my thighs are on the wider side. Some of the first boots I got from Shoedazzle were an OTK style that I got in wide-calf, just to accommodate for my pudgy knees. I found them a little slouchy when worn without jeans/leggings, and after wearing them around a bit more, I noticed that they tended to sink down over my skinnies, too. Not ideal, especially when my favorite part about the OTK look is how sleek it can be.

Long story short, I opted for a regular ol’ size 8 when ordering this pair of black boots rather than going for the wide-calf choice. My thinking was that since these boots have stretch-fabric backs, they would probably allow enough give without being slouchy. But it looks like I might’ve misjudged the fit just a bit!

shoedazzle october over the knee stretch boots

shoedazzle october back of over the knee black boots

I first tried these boots on over skinny jeans—or, I tried to try them on. The scuba-like stretch fabric did NOT want to shimmy up over my denim jeans no matter how hard I pulled! After a few tries, I switched my jeans out for thin, smooth leggings to see if they’d work in that scenario. (Plus, I could see myself wearing these over leggings or thicker tights in the winter.) While they did go on much more easily, you can probably tell from the photos that my upper calves (especially right up around my knees) are pretty sausaged in there. What’s frustrating is that the boots fit great through my feet, ankles, and calves. It’s just that they’re cut a bit too straight to work with my knee pudge. To be clear, they do “fit”, but the tight upper edge of the boot shaft really digs into my legs in a way that 1) isn’t that comfy and 2) doesn’t seem like it’d be secure enough to stay put during an afternoon walk down the street.

shoedazzle october over the knee boots

But of course, I’m only bummed that these boots didn’t work because I like them so much! The style is right up my alley with the faux-suede fabric and radiant gold accents. The faux-leather strip up the back classes up the stretch fabric panels, too. They’re exactly the kind of look I’d want to sport this fall. They just aren’t quite the right shape for my body. Wahhhh! 😭

The Verdict: So I didn’t have the greatest luck with this pair of boots. Le sigh, le sigh. But I’m still a big ShoezDazzle fan, and here’s why: first of all, returns and exchanges are easy—you can print a free return shipping label via your account and return/exchange merchandise within 30 days. (There are some exceptions, but you can see all the details here.) The quality of what I’ve gotten feels parallel to the trend-conscious pieces I’d find at my local department store, and the price point seems fair for what you get. And most importantly, I just really like the selection. Now, be forewarned—Shoedazzle isn’t for everyone. They do offer some more classic, crowd-pleasing styles (like the black fall booties I got last month, which I am looooooving), but the vibe of the site is very trend-focused. Of-the-moment color palettes and patterns, sexy silhouettes, and seasonal statement pieces make up the brunt of the offerings, with some basics and staple pieces mixed in for good measure. If that’s your style, I highly recommend taking a look at Shoedazzle! (And I mean, have you SEEN the $10 intro special they have going on right now?!) If not, you might want to look elsewhere for your fashion fix.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes! As of writing this post, these boots are still available!

Coupon – New VIP Members, get your first style for $10! No code need—just use this link!

Value Breakdown: The retail value of these boots is $84.95, and the member price was $46.95 + free shipping and returns. That’s about a 45% discount.

Check out all of our ShoeDazzle reviews and the top ShoeDazzle picks each month!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What was your ShoeDazzle pick this month?

your first box75% off
your first box75% off


How do subscribers rate ShoeDazzle?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about ShoeDazzle!

Enable notifications () to get the latest ShoeDazzle spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Anna Reilly

Anna Reilly

Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she’s swooning for all things kawaii!

Posted in ShoeDazzle Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: shoedazzle | 1 comment

Comment (1)

  1. If these boots are available in Wide calf, you may want to try them. I am plus size, wear a size 16 pants. I have fairly skinny ankles and calves and larger thighs. I am able to wear thigh high boots from both ShoeDazzle and JustFab.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.