Play! By Sephora September 2018 FULL SPOILERS Box #764, #707 & #699!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have the full spoilers for three more of the September Play! By Sephora boxes! (Thanks Amanda, Meagan, and Megan!)

The theme for September is “Next Gen Beauty”.

Box #707 will include:

september sephora play box 707

Box #764 will include:

september sephora play box 764

Box #699 will include:

september sephora play box 699

Box #772 will include:

Sephora play september box 772

Box #723 will include:

Sephora play september box 723

Box #780 will include:

Sephora play september box 780

Box #715 will include:

And here’s a look at all the products that may be in your September box:

What do you think of the spoilers? 

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: play by sephora | 66 comments


  1. how exactly does it work? On the website my box number is 707.
    I just received it yesterday. I did not get the set of products listed here for the 707 box.
    I got something randomly customized that is not even described here. What the heck?

  2. My box was delivered today. I was getting box 681. Unfortunately I won’t be able to use it. My box was stolen out of my mailbox within 30 minutes after it was delivered. This is the first time I’ve ever had a package stolen. I was really looking forward to that box. 😭

  3. I got box 707 and it doesnt match what you said would be in it….I got the Ole Henricksen Serum, Sephora Mascara, Clinique Moistruizer, Marc Jacobs Eyeliner, Belif Cream and Two Faced Primer….

    • me too. this was the worst box ever. why would I want 4 face products?? I like trying new makeup and I get a boring crap eyeliner and cheap mascara sample. what a waste.

    • Same here…..

    • That’s what mine is showing too. Not happy at all.

    • Same thing happened to me with 707! I am so not happy with these products, and I was very much looking forward to the ones that was supposed to come.

  4. Am I the only one getting 681😑😑😑

  5. the items you have listed for box 707 are not correct.

  6. @MSA – the #707 you listed is actually the #681 (which is my box).

  7. I am pretty happy with 780, but what does a gal gotta do to get a Flowerbomb sample? I have received Black Orchid a number of times. Same with Chloe. Oh well. I suppose I can just cruise over to Sephora to see what it smells like. Very happy to get multiple moisturizers. Yay!

    • You can not only cruise over and smell it, but you can get a sample too!

    • 780 Is the 707 😁

  8. How do I figure out what box number I have?? I always see people who know their numbers but I’ve never seen mine before.

    • You have to go to the desktop site (not a mobile site), sign in and go to your orders. The last 3 digits of the item # is your box #.

  9. Box #749???

    • I got box 749…

      Marc Jacobs foundation in Y420
      Nudestix Pencil
      Too Faced Hangover Primer
      Boscia Cactus Water cream
      PTR Hungarian Thermal Water Mask
      Tom Ford Black Orchid

      Super disappointed since my spoilers over the weekend on the Sephora website showed a different box with the Sunday Riley cream in it and I was excited for it. Also, that foundation sample is waaay too dark for me. Not even close 😡

      • Oh no! This is my box too. And that foundation shade is going to be way too dark for me as well. I am hoping that I receive a different shade? I really wanted the truth serum.

      • LOL– I was annoyed to see the Sunday Riley and totally stoked to see the Boscia when I opened it up! (I resubscribed in hopes I’d get it.)

        But yeah, even when I’m tan, I am super pale. That Marc Jacobs is useless to me.

  10. My item number says I’m getting box 707, but when I log into Sephora and look up my current box, it’s completely different items…has anyone had this happen? I love box 707 and would use everything in it, but my current box makes me feel disappointed.

    What do you guys think?

  11. Anyone have spoilers for box #731 I have not seen anything about this box? Just dying to know.

    • Same here!!! 🤔🤔🤔

    • Box 731 has same products like 764 just instead of the make up forever foundation you get the mark Jacob’s one and a different parfum sampler.

  12. Any clue on box #737? I haven’t seen a spoiler on it yet.

    • Same! I have not seen anything on this box number yet, and my tracking has been showing the basic “shipment info received” message for 3 or 4 days now. If someone gets this one, please post what combo of items are included! (Not that I’m opposed to a surprise box, it’s just weird that there is no info on this one!)

      • Never mind, I logged into my account, and it’s showing the following as my September box (#737), even though I haven’t received it yet:

        1. OLEHENRIKSEN Truth Serum
        2. CLINIQUE Dramatically Different Hydrating Jelly
        3. TOO FACED Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
        4. NUDESTIX Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss
        5. SEPHORA COLLECTION LashCraft Big Volume Mascara
        6. BELIF The True Cream Moisturizing Bomb

        Generally pretty happy – I’ve been wanting to try the Too Faced primer, I needed a new mascara, and I got the belif cream from the rewards bazaar last month and am happy to have more of it. I’m kind of eh on Clinique in general, but I’m excited about trying the Truth Serum.

  13. After being with Play for around 2 years, this is the first box I won’t receive. I took a break to go to Allure for the next few months. I also get Boxycharm/Boxy luxe. So far, I don’t feel like I made a mistake.

    Recently, I had been getting repeat items and I was getting the last box on the list. Some of the time it didn’t even include any of the main items. One month I received at least 2 Sephora items in my box, instead of the items advertised. I already had at least 3 of those Sephora samples from previous boxes. Let’s not forget the infamous Tarte blush that we recently received. They were leftovers from the 2017 Sephora birthday gift. Not only are they giving out old products, but it seems like they’re just giving out random samples at times.

  14. I am box 749, does anyone know what’s in that box? 🙂 I hope I get the nudestick

    • I have #749!

      I received:

      1. BOSCIA Cactus Water Hydrating Cream
      2. PETER THOMAS ROTH Hungarian Thermal Water Mineral Rich Mask
      3. TOO FACED Hangover Face Primer
      4. NUDESTIX Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss
      5. TOM FORD Black Orchid Perfume
      6. MARC JACOBS Shameless Foundation in Tan

      For being my first box from Sephora, this is pretty great. Although I can do without another perfume sample or that foundation in tan….not my color lol.

  15. Anyone know about box #749?

    • I’m 749 and I want to know too!

    • I received box 749
      -Black orchid sample tom ford
      -cactus water boscia
      -marc jacobs foundation
      -nude pencil
      -peter thomas roth thermal water masque

  16. I know that I subscribe to too many subscription boxes but it seems like I have enough samples of Truth Serum to fill my bathtub now. LOL

    • its a great serum I love it

  17. Does anybody know what is in box 731? Normally when the spoilers come out, my box is always shown like on the first day, and I have not seen it or have even heard anybody else mention the same box #.

    • Same here. I wanna spoil it and know what I’m getting and it’s taking forever!

  18. Yes! I’m getting #723. It’s absolutely perfect for me. I do wish I could have gotten a foundation sample but I doubt they have my shade anyways (ghostly pale). Mascara is meh since I’m getting a Mac mascara in my birchbox but everyone is getting it and I’m not on product overload (yet) so I don’t mind having an extra.

    • I LOVE MAC mascara… I welcome that stuff EVERY time! I got Loereal lash primer in the Target box, and combined, those are my favorite lash items!

  19. I received box 715 and I loved it! 😘

  20. Does anyone know what is coming in box number 756? I am as just wondering because i haven’t seen a spoiler just yet.

    • It’s the Marc Jacob foundation, Peter roth, the Boscia moisturizer, too faced primer, Sephora mascara and Tom ford perfume 🙂

  21. Got 723… pretty happy except I would have loved 715 because I’d rather have foundation than another mini lipstick…

    But I’m excited to try the truth serum, mascara, too faced primer, and cactus moisturizer.

  22. My box number is 756, I believe.

    It should contain the following PTR Hungarian water, Boscia cream, Too Faced primer, Marc Jacobs foundation, Sephora mascara and most important Black Orchid perfume (instead of Flowerbomb which I am always getting samples of – hate the fragrance).

    I an pretty happy with my box. Most of the selections are new to me.

  23. #764 for me and I LOVE everything they’re sending!!! FINALLY, FOUNDATION!!! 😉 😉

    Soo happy with the box I’m getting. NO mascara and NO Sephora brand sample. ;)!

    MAKE UP FOR EVER Ultra HD Perfector Skin Tint Foundation SPF 25
    NUDESTIX Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss
    TOO FACED Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
    PETER THOMAS ROTH Hungarian Thermal Water Mineral-Rich Moisturizer
    BOSCIA Cactus Water Hydrated Cream
    CHLOÉ Nomade Eau de Parfum

  24. I’m getting box #723. Disappointed 🙁 All I wanted was the Marc Jacobs Highliner in Earthquake, but of course that’s not going to happen.

  25. I am 764 and feel very underwhelmed.

    • yeah im getting that same box as yours

      • Mine actually came today. The bag is crap.

  26. Ughh getting box 699 and I’m not excited at all.

  27. I want box 772 or 715…I’m getting box 707. :/ I never seem to get a box that I want.

    • how do we tell which box were getting again?

      • On sephora’s website (not the app), if you go to orders, it the last three numbers of the item number (not order number).

  28. I’m getting 699. I’m happy for all except the mascara. I’ve never tried any of the rest. But I always get mascara in everything. I’m overloaded with mascara samples. I would have liked to try the cactus water though.

  29. Anyone interested in swapping let me know I’m getting 723 and love it all but also own it all!

    • I’m getting 707 – how about that?

      • Yes that works😊😊 send me your info and I’ll message you

  30. Does anyone have #681?

    I am eager to see what goodies await me this month 🙂

    • 681 is my box, too. I hope it includes viktor&rolf flowerbomb – one of my favorites lately.

    • I have 681 as well and hoping our spoiler pops up soon! All the variations look decent so far! My variation spoiler is always the last to show up, ugggghhh, lol

      • I read in one of the other threads that # 681 is the same as # 707.

    • Just got my 681.
      Sephora Lashcraft mascara
      Peter Thomas Roth Hungarian Thermal Water mask
      Nudestix Lip Cheek pencil
      Too Faced Hangover primer
      Sunday Riley Tidal cream
      V&R flowerbomb perfume

      • Maria,
        Thanks for sharing, I’m supposed to be getting this box. What’s the difference between this box and 707 shown up above? It looks exactly the same.

        • Exactly the same. Super excited that this is my box!

      • YESSSSSS! GOt all the ones Inwouldve picked and dying to try that V&R perfume!

    • I do. I get my box Wednesday.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!