Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Does anyone else think the product with the pink cap looks more like a trial size of drunk elephants TLC framboos then the lip gloss pictured. Idk. Might just be me. That would be pretty amazing tho. I love anything DE.
Reply
Em
Just a heads up – Boxycharm subscribers have received an email. All you have to do to know a product you’re getting in your box is follow Boxycharm on twitter and tweet why you love Boxycharm. I am getting the Tarte mist. I’d love to know what kinds of variations there are so tell me what you are getting.
Curious if it just tells you what you are getting between the tarte mist and palette. Let me know!
Reply
Jamie
Thanks for the info!
Reply
Cheryl
I received an email that stated i was getting the Crown eye shadow and I reeeeeeaaaaaallllyyyy dreaded being a prepaid member at that very moment😢 I literally cringed!
Reply
Vicky H
So someone said if you subscribe to the newsletter you’ll get an email to see what you are getting early. I haven’t… I only subscribed after they posted to join in instragram. 🙁
Also, anyone gotten shipping notices for charms yet? It hasn’t been 10 business days but I’m curious as I’ve never redeemed charms before now.
Lastly, I don’t know the source but someone said we are getting a wander mascara and some blush I’m not familiar with.
Reply
Tracie
The other items are:
Note Cosmetics – blusher
Wander – Mascara
and a white tube of something that looks like Chella brow gel or pomade (not 100% sure, but that’s what the white tube looks like on IG.
Reply
Jamie
That’s what’s being said – Chella brow product of some kind.
Chrystal
Just found out I’m getting the palette. Bummer 😩
Reply
momis
I don’t want that eye palette. I already have a few with similar colors.
Reply
Ashley
I really want the Dr brandt and the tarte mist. So if anyone wants to swap if I get the other two, I’d be more then happy to!!
Reply
LoriD
Oh I’m also getting the most & reeeaaallllly want the pallet so hit me up on Insta 😁😁😁👑✨👑✨👆👆👆
Reply
LoriD
Hey Ashley! I really want the mask and I have a feeling that I’ll be getting the Dr Brandt, I love the brand but I don’t have undereye bags luckily and I’m faithful to my eye cream for my dark circles sooo…. If you get the mask and I get Dr Brandt… Wanna trade? You can find me on Insta at lori 050174 just put it together 😉😉😉 thanks hon!
Reply
Dee
I’ll be receiving the face mist and most likely Dr Brandt if you want to trade.
Reply
Em
How do you know the skincare item you’re getting?
Daisy Reynoso
I’ll be receiving the face mist and most likely the Dr Brandt. If you want to trade.
Reply
annalily
I’m going to guess those who get the face mist will get the eye gel and those who get the palette will get the mask based on prices. I’d be pretty happy with either combo since one has my preferred skin care and the other my preferred makeup item. Still, I’d prefer the gloss. And I so hope we get either pink lipstick of a gloss! I love glosses and bright colors so much, particularly in the summer!
Reply
Christine
I hope you are right. I just found out in an email from Boxy Charm that I will receive the Tarte mist and I really want the Dr. Brandt.
Reply
Cady
How did you find out? I haven’t received an email 😞
Joyce
J would Live the eye shadow palette and the Farmacy brand is refreshing from always Dr Brandt. I think it’s ok brand a bit over priced for sure. Heard Good things about Farmcy. I’m so ready for anything THAN A BROWN LIPSTICK. I don’t want to look like I’m wearing concealer on my lips all the time. It’s good to put another color over I guess. But we older ladies r not left with a lot of pigment in r lips and brown is already there and not flattering There is a time and a place u can use it. But Goodness I don’t need ten. So would Love to see some color especially in the summer. Come on BC.
Reply
Elizabeth
😂🤣Yessss! NO more BROWN lip glosses or lipsticks!! You are EXACTLY right about it looking like foundation or concelear on the lips!😂🤣 I can kind of understand if it was fall or winter but it is summer🌡☀️! Let’s get some bright colors!💚💛💜💟
Reply
Lucy
If it is a bullet lipstick and hot pink is the color… LOL! I’m already missing the browns and nudes! I look horrible in pink!
Reply
Teresa
I really hope I get the dr. brandt needles no more® NO MORE BAGGAGE™ eye de-puffing gel this month!!
Reply
Lori Tinsley
Hoping for the Dr. Brandt! I resubscribed when I saw the spoilers for this box. Everything looks awesome!
Reply
Jackie
If you get the farmacy and I get Dr brandt, I’ll happily swap!
Reply
Nyesha
why the torture Boxycharm? It’s July-just come with the box variations already! I hate waiting lol
Reply
JoannaNYC
Agreed! I was already charged for the July box, and still don’t know what I’m paying for!
Reply
Jamie
Boxy is apparently sending out emails letting ppl know which item they’re getting in the 1st variant. I haven’t gotten mine yet so idk what I’m getting. Also I’ve seen 1 possible box variant that claims there’s a blush & mascara plus a 5th product, but more importantly they’re saying the palette and no more baggage are one variant.
Robin Hanscom
I agree. Just tell us whats in the box already!
Reply
Selina
Would love to get the palette and vitamin c mask!!
Reply
Rebecca Mckeel
Really hoping for the Farmacy Vit C Mask and the Tarte Setting Spray! Fingers crossed but it all looks great!
Reply
Jackie
Really hoping for the setting spray so if I get the palette, I’m open to swapping! Also hoping for the farmacy mask vs the Dr brandt, but if I end up with Dr brandt, I won’t be too disappointed. Hoping the other 3 items will be perfect for summer. I’ve got my fingers crossed for something bright!
Reply
Aly
I’d definitely be willing to swap if I end up getting the mask over the dr. Brandt product! I own a few of the tarte travel size setting sprays and don’t get me wrong, I loveee tarte but.. I have only used the setting spray to spray my sponge before patting out my concealer. Its not very useful to “set” but it is nice to just mist on your face to feel refreshed
Reply
Jamie
It’s not useful to set anything bc it’s not a setting spray. Tarte has a setting spray and it’s a separate item from this one. This is a skin refreshing mist. It’s more of a skin care thing.
StaceStace
Same. I want the shadow and I’m willing to swap 🙂
Reply
Cupcake
I want the shadow and dr brant. So I will def trade you if I get the others!!!
Reply
Iggy'sRock
WHAT??? Why the variations? Tarte is such a crap company- I have reported them to the BBB for taking my money, and giving me, ‘fake’ gift cards. The numbers never work on the gift cards. I don’t want ANY of their products!! UGH!!!
Why can’t we pick Boxy? Why?
Reply
Vicky H
I watched the video and I’m like 90% sure that it’s a bullet lipstick. 💄💄💄
Reply
Jamie
It would be the biggest bullet lipstick I’ve ever seen. It looks to be 4 inches tall at least and the top is only the size of a soda bottle cap.
Reply
Dianne
Hank and Henry lippie sitting on something black Maybe. Milk Makeup Charcoal Swabs Maybe. Could be a hair product.
Reply
Nicole BW
I DEFINITELY want that palette…I’m trading if I get the spray! Want that Vit C mask but this puffiness is bad when Aunt Flo’s in town…lol, so the de-puffing gel is lookin’ good too😕
Reply
Rachel
Same! I’m actually allergic to something in the spray. Gonna have to hope I find someone to trade with if that’s what I get. Really wish I could guarantee it’s not in my box. I worry it could leak and ruin everything in it for me.
Reply
Bushra
Swap with me! I’d like the vit c mask and the tarte mist spray!
Reply
Kiersten
When are the next actual spoilers for july… i need to know more!! Lol
Reply
Em
Tmrw there will be another spoiler on Boxycharms insta :))
Reply
Cady
Haha right I keep stalking MSA!
Reply
Jo
I have my fingers crossed for the vitamin C mask.
Reply
Grace J
Smashbox maybe?
Reply
Jacki
I want the little mirror on the table! I can wear bright pink lipstick and I love holographic lipstick so those are winners for me. The this or that spoilers will make or break this box depending on which I get.
Reply
disneyjoy1970
Yes, the little mirror would be such a treat! Something different. One can wish… 🙂
Reply
Pink5
The item on the table looks like a really bright pink lipstick.
I would rather it be the holographic lip gloss. Bright pink looks terrible on me.
I’m not optimistic about this box. There’s so much either/or going on that a subscriber could wind up with a box that’s either amazing or horrible, depending on their tastes.
Reply
Susan
This is why I dropped. Get this OR that. All the spoilers are this OR that.
Reply
RoguesEn3D
It’s like ipsy. What is the point of a spoiler? I suppose the upside is seeing something. Historically, I have been anxious to see Boxy spoilers. With BC, at least it’s only “this or that”. With ipsy, it’s “here are 7 spoilers… out of 30 items”.
I would love both lippies. I don’t know, I canceled BC (well, I canceled way back last month but got sent the June box anyway… so we’ll see) but I still hold hope that I may resub some day. Right now, the only items piquing my interest are the possible lippies, and perhaps seeing KVD and H&H in future boxes.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.