Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
$25 OFRA Mystery Boxes Available Now + 40% Off Coupon!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
My bag came with two liquid lips (a shimmery pink and a metallic pink-purple) two eyeshadow refills (matte caramel and shimmery beige) a highlighter (back off haters – a bronzer color) and a mineral powder (kind of a warm beige tone). All were full size. I also got a lanyard.
Reply
Cyndi
In my bag:
Liquid lipstick in Plumas, a plum-pink shade
Eyeshadow in Bohemian, shimmery brown
Blush/bronzer in Format
Eye gel primer
Pencil eyeliner in Evergreen – up for swap
Translucent powder in Dark – up for swap
Lanyard – odd item
Overall a good deal for me.
Reply
Frances
My bag contents:
Long lasting liquid lip – Hollywood (Flamingo pink-matte)
Long lasting liquid lip – Napa Valley (Vampy metallic purple)
Long lasting liquid lip – St Tropez (Bubble gum pink with a hint of purple-matte)
Concealer Wand – Amber LT ( think the LT stands for Light)
Mini Highlighter Godet Refill – Rodeo Drive
Blush/Bronzer – Format
I think this was a great value for $18.50. I don’t use liquid lipsticks so those will go up for swap but I was looking for a new concealer to try so perfect timing on that.
Reply
Frances
I forgot one more item I rec’d in addition to the lanyard and bag that everyone got:
Peptide Brightening Mask (generous 3oz tube)
Reply
Zo
Received my bag today and I’m actually pleased with almost everything. Great deal for $18.5.
Eye gel primer (love)
Eye shadow in Divine. It’s a light coppery metallic. Pretty.
Mini highlighter in Rideo Drive.
Liquid lipstick in St. Tropez (bubble gum pink)
Eyeliner in Evergreen. Love the color but its not very smooth.
Blush/bronzer in Format. Its the only item I won’t use.
I think I got lucky.
Reply
Darlene
My bag had a liquid makeup in Ebony. This is for an african american women. I am white. The darkest purple black lipstick. One eyeshadow. One highlighter.
Buyer beware.
Reply
Donna
Liz, wondering if the Ofra Mystery Box could be added to the swap site? Thanks!
Reply
Paula
I got the ultimate boobie prize of a mystery bag:
Ebony foundation and porcelain pressed powder.
Jeeez…who put that together???
I also got a Barbie pink lip gloss, green eyeliner, black eyeshadow and orange bronzer. Blech!
Oh well, you win some and you lose some!
Reply
Coco
Got mine today. Yuck. A lanyard – seriously? I’m fair-skinned, and got Mahogany liquid foundation and Dark translucent powder; 2 liquid lipsticks in terrible colors (Coven, a metallic brown, and Spell, a neon coral); blush/bronzer in Format (too dark for me); and a brown metallic eyeshadow (Bohemian), which is the only thing I like and will use. Mystery bags are a gamble, and I lost on this one. Glad I didn’t pay more than I did!
Reply
katie
I got the bag,the lanyard,liquid lip in Fantasia,blush/bronzer in Format (case is cracked),lip liner in savage red,eyeshadow in Mistic blue,and highlighter in Blind the haters. Not bad for the price.
Reply
Mary
I got my bag today. I got the makeup sponge, blush/ bronzer in format ( orange undertone) Eyeliner in coffee bean, eyeshadow godette in bohemian ( copper color), liquid lipstick in st tropez ( pinkish) and a liquid foundation in cream biege. Overall worth it. I dont know why throw in a foundation. I would of loved to get the rodeo drive highlighter
Reply
Laura C
I got mine today. It included the bag and lanyard, two liquid lipsticks in Wonderland and Treasure, two 4g Eyeshadow Godet Refills in Bohemian and Iron, a mini Rodeo Drive highlighter and a Format blush/bronzer. I already own the two eye shadows and a full-sized Rodeo Drive highlighter thanks to Boxycharm. However, the eye shadows I received today are much larger. Overall, a great value for $18.50.
Reply
Wendy
It’s a mystery bag, so I don’t expect to love every item, but I got nothing I will use. 2 liquid lips, lipliner, blush, loose eyeshadow, and slate eyeshadow godet plus bag and lanyard. Was hoping for at least one thing I would like. Oh well…. off to swap I go.
Reply
grim
Got mine today, altogether pretty impressed. I got the bag/lanyard, lip gloss in cherry mocha (light pink), liquid lipstick in nappa valley (glittery purple) and st tropez (mauvish pink), blush/bronzer in format, eye shadow refill in french mocha (matte brown), pencil eyeliner in ever green, and a liquid foundation in a shade that’s way too dark for me. Will probably use everything aside from the foundation and maybe the purple lipstick, but honestly this was such a good value with the coupon.
Reply
carol
Sounds like there was a lot of variation! I like that. Mine had liquid lipstick in Fifth Ave (gold), Ever Green eyeliner (green!), ICE eyeshadow in Go Black, the Magic Roulette Concealer (with purple, green, yellow, etc.), and blush/bronzer in Format. And of course, the lanyard. And the bag.
I have some research to do!
Reply
Ann
Not too bad, I got:
Bag: meh
Lanyard: who cares
Mini highlighter refill in Rodeo Drive
Eyeshadow refill in Iron
Full size Blush/Bronzer in Format
Three long lasting liquid lipsticks in: Fantasia, Queens & Wonderland
Reply
Marie
I got the bag, lanyard, liquid lipstick in Las Vegas (lilac color), liquid lipstick in Emerald City (a triple chrome metallic red, gold, green), lip liner in Savage Red, mini godet of Rodeo Drive highlighter, full size blush/bronzer in Format (came broken) and a loose pigment eyeshadow in Blue Jeans.
Reply
Lisa
I love Emerald City I bought it at Ulta Cyber Monday. It looks so stunning over brown or mauve lipsticks. I get so many compliments.
Reply
Marie
Lisa,
Thanks for the tip!
marinekid
Not a great result for me. Bag, lanyard, fix line eyeliner gel in white rabbit, oil free dual foundation in color 44 (too dark for me), liquid lipstick in Cape Town and format blush/bronzer. Oh well.
Reply
PudgeKat
I got the exact same except for the lipgloss in Bordeaux (dark purple). Basically a waste because everything was an unwearable color for me (blues, purples, too dark foundation powder, white eyeliner). I have a natural simple look so prefer neutrals, majorly disappointing and hope I can get rid of these things through swap!
Reply
Sam
I got the same plus a purple eyeliner and mini-highlighter, super bummer as I was hoping for more lip items. But I still think it’s a good buy as I can use most of the products.
Reply
Angela
Liz- can you please put this on swaps? Thank you!
Reply
Liz Cadman
Yes! We’ll add it!
Reply
Frances
Liz – do you know when the box will be added to swaps?
Michele
I am sorry there are some who did not get good bags. I loved mine and thought of ordering another one but not sure I want to risk it based on other reviews.
I got:
make up bag – I really like this because it is a larger bag than Ipsy and I can really use it
lanyard
green eyeliner – forest green color
highlighter – really pretty
bronzer – a little dark for me but so pretty!
powder in light – my color! Whooo!
Lip color in a pretty coral shade that I would not have bought but love
Coral blush – I usually use pinks but this went really well with the lip color and green eyeliner
I am just ecstatic – best mystery deal I have done! So tempted to get another, but I don’t think they could beat what I got so I might just stop while I am ahead! I have never tried this brand but loved everything I received. I love trying new brands and this was an easy way for me to sample their products.
Reply
h
Not worth 107 bucks!!
Blush in Format $15
Eyeliner in Dark brown $9
Mini Rodeo drive pan $15
Perfecting Sponge $10
Key ring
Bag
I know it said 5 products worth 107. I wrote them. worth 18 but not worth what it said
Reply
Jill
Mine came, it’s not what I was expecting but I can’t conplain for 28 bucks. I got a pan of beautiful highlighter, the format blush/bronzer, a pan of eyeshadow, the white eyeliner, two lippies (ultimate red and Cape Town [a purple]) he lanyard and the bag
Reply
Tanya M.
Good hint the code sioeednworking. Whew!!
Reply
Tanya M.
Good thing the code stopped working …some of the bags are great! I wish my boss would stop interrupting me when I am on this site. Lol
Reply
Tanya M.
Tank goodness the code stopped working … watching those YouTube veideos made me weak! Lol
Reply
Beccah
My bag was not good. I can’t use anything. 2 lipsticks in bright red and metallic purple. Lip gloss in orchid. Cream foundation in 28 dark. Lip Liner spicy and a broken blush/bronzer.
Reply
Ami
I got my mystery bag! It had two liquid lipsticks, a beautiful red and a metallic orange-red, two lipliners, a brown and a pink, one full sized bronzer/blusher, a keychain, and a face mask! not to mention the purse, I was very pleased with what I got for under $20!
Reply
Beth C
I just got mine this morning! It was perfect for me!
I got the bag and lanyard
Full size blush/bronzer in format
Mini highlighter godet in rodeo
Full size eyeshadow (in case with mirror) in champagne
Makeup sponge
Liquid lipstick in Santa Ana- red
Liquid lipstick in Napa valley – a fun metallic purple
Reply
Gina
I got mine today and wasn’t the best, got the bag, lanyard , blush/bronzer, 2 liquid lipsticks in ultimate red and emerald city a red lip liner, a pan of slate eye shadow and loose mineral eye shadow in blue jeans. Kinda bummed but you get what ya get with the mystery bags, I don’t think I’ll buy again.
Lindsey
I got mine this morning! It included the bag and lanyard along with:
*Perfecting Puff makeup sponge
* Full size Blush/Bronzer in Format
*Full size highlighter in Blind the Haters
*mini pan of Rodeo Drive highlighter
* Liquid Lipstick in Plumas
* Eyeliner in Ever Green
Overall I am really happy with what I got for only $18.50!
Reply
Leona
We are bag twins! The only difference is my liquid lip is Mocha! Pretty impressed for only $18.50!
Lisa
I got mine too!! I was shocked because I was never sent tracking until it arrived!! I got a lanyard, liquid lipstick in ultimate red, lip gloss in orchid, brown lip pencil in baby doll, blush/bronzer in Format, eye shadow in plastic which a shimmer white so I am using as highlight it comes in a compartment with a mirror., and a tiny eye shadow godet in vanilla which is a french vanilla color. That is only thing I didn’t like but I tend to forget about things I stick in z palette anyway.
Reply
Linda
I got the bag, the lanyard, 2 liquid lipsticks, in wonderland light purple and ultimate red, blush/in format, 2 eye shadows in the godet style in pink petal and vanilla and fixline eyeliner gel in white rabbit. I will use everything but the white eyeliner and the lanyard. Would do this again worth the money.
Trish
I’d love to see you review this bag. Aside from incompatible shades for my personal taste, I love everything I have from OFRA Cosmetics.
Reply
Anne
I’m a sucker for a good mystery deal. I would like to see it reviewed–even if this bag isn’t available any more, a review lets us know what we might expect from the brand. Like how I know not to get mystery boxes from the company that only sent My Little Pony lipglosses.
Reply
Michele
Truth! Never again for them!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.