Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Omg thank you!!! Some people seem so darn entitled its sickening. We pay $21 a month for 5 full sized products. I look at it as we only pay $4.20 per item. You will never find a better deal than that! Im in my 2nd year with boxy and yeah I may not always get the variation I’m hoping for, but as a single mom of 2, I can’t go out and buy the latest and greatest products. I am very grateful that boxy has helped me grow my collection without breaking the bank and I’ve found some amazing products and brands I can’t afford to go out and buy myself. To those who do nothing but complain, cancel your subscription and let someone else have your spot that will appreciate it!
Reply
Not spolied
Some people are so spoiled sounding. Sorry to offend but these boxes are awesome especially for people who can’t afford to buy these products full price. 21 a month is very affordable and you get full size products. People bashing on the items makes other people feel that they’re wrong for liking them. Palettes are something I personally never get tired of. I can depot and share them with my sister who can’t even afford the sub. So freedom of speech go ahead but be grateful y’all can afford to complain.
Reply
Stephanie
Yes, yes, yes! I LOVE Boxycharm, and the value is astounding!
Reply
Redhed36
You think these comments are bad check out the Fitfabfun comments. LOL. I just hope I don’t get the mostly empty Ofra item only because I don’t want to have to come up with extra money to buy the pieces to fill it. It would be mainly useless to me. I think a lot of the issues are that people have been receiving this box and likely multiple others for so long the mystery and excitement is gone. They tend to push similar products each month and I think people are on product overload. I am new to the sub box world and I still get super excited with every box, well minus an issue I had with a Blessbox, but they rectified that.
Reply
Hallie
I got the ofra palette and it saves money in the long run. Mac eyeshadows are $6 for the magnetic refill pans. You can pick any colors and create a palette of colors you may not have in a palette. The blush pans are $17 which isn’t bad considering many high end brands charge @ $30 because of packaging. Plus, even if not mac, you can de-pot eyeshadow or whatever and pop it in there and brands like colorpop and makeup geek have good prices for refill pans. I hope this helps you 🙂 I only have 4 shadows, a highlighter and a blush in there right now. I add as I need them.
Anya
Im kind of conflicted with the look of this palette….3 of the shades in the top row look THE EXACT SAME, and the bottom left and bottom right colors also look super similar. Would this palette even be worth it??
Reply
MistyO
Boxycharm has done it again.!!! I absolutely love this monthly sub box.!!!! Can’t wait for March’s box and we just started February.! Lol
Reply
Amy
I have tons of palattes and still want more 💖 A girl can never have to many choices 😂
Reply
Taylor
I’m thinking about canceling. I can’t rememebr the last time a box got me legitimately excited. Usually I only like one product and give the rest away. The Allure Box is so much better, and I don’t know if I need both.
Reply
Britney
I’m a minority here, I know. But I am tired of palettes every single month. I actually cancelled because I’m in palette overload.
Reply
Kenetrice Jones
That’s great. All of you who are sick of receiving palettes should cancel your subscription. There are far too many people on the waitlist for these boxes to go to waste. If you’ve gotten all you could ever need from Boxy, please cancel if you haven’t already. Let someone more excited and grateful enjoy it. 😉
Reply
annika
I agree and also why are the palettes same brand PUR? I only have been subbing for a month and I am already tired of this brand.
Reply
Debora Espinosa
1 month? that means u’ve received one box…..
Jessica
Ditto!!! And I never wear lipstick so I have lots of product I need to trade because I don’t use eyeshadow or lipstick.
Reply
Carrie
Yup me too!
Reply
Estrellita
agreed, its worse when you can’t even sell/swap them because they sell on ebay for 5-8bucks and there are so many on the swap site. I cancelled too. Will be back when the palettes and highlighters are not in every single box:/
Reply
Caro
Same here!!!! Im tired of them.
Reply
Bonnie
Imagine if there weren’t spoilers and everyone just had to wait and see what was in the box? I love reading these too, but I do think seeing all these spoilers cause a lot of anger, frustration, and obsession with getting this month but not that month, and how can I time it so I get March but don’t get February etc. Wouldn’t it be easier to just buy the stuff if it’s causing so much angst?
Reply
Annabella
Where is the Like button when you need it?
Reply
jessica
hahaa right, i usually check the spoilers the day my Package is out for Delivery ! Since i get notifications about my Deliveries & i do still get excited & i love the products (ive read these comments of ppl complaining about the products ) but i wonder if it would be different not having spoilers available, some of these commets deserve a like or helpful button , some deserve a NOT HELPFUL lol
Victoria
I’m just frustrated I’m not off the waitlist only. I love getting new products I normally would not buy for myself. I’m a makeup junkie 😂 I want it if it sparkles and is pretty even if I won’t use it . I always do makeovers on friends/family as well so I enjoy everything I receive in my sub boxes. For some it’s good for others, not so good I think lol. Like I said I’ve been watching these boxes spoilers and what others get for months now and loved every box every month so figured yep this sub is for me especially being full sized products, I even enjoy my ipsy, not too big on birch box.
Reply
Harshada Sant
Hi I just got off waitlist today. I am not really into sparkly products, which is kinda the Feb theme. So if you want I can give you the entire Feb box when I get it.
Kearstin
I am a sucker for any spoilers but I think you’re right. If we didn’t have this site or any kind of spoilers, we’d be happy with either box most likely and wouldn’t even realize that someone else got something that we wanted, etc. We are so stuck on instant gratification whether it’s a box, a spoiler, or whatever!
Reply
Moi
Just subbed and on wait list. How long is it? I’m kinda hoping for a Feb box but if I miss March I’ll be crushed 😭😭
Reply
Kenetrice Jones
It just depends. Some people only spend a couple weeks on there and some people spend months on there. I personally was only on the waitlist for 2 weeks but I’ve seen people complaining on their instagram about being on the waitlist for 2 to 3 months already. So it varies from person to person. I hope you get the March box though.
Reply
queene731
I was on it for a month so you should get the March box, unless they have a waitlist overload due to this spoiler.
Reply
Jackie
Oh wow this palette is gorgeous! I hope its the same formula as the Soiree Diaries we got a few months back!
Reply
Julie
Man, I haven’t even received my February box and there’s already March spoilers!
Reply
Heather S.
Same here!!! Was hoping it would of came today.
Reply
Katie
I so hope I’m off the wait list for this palette 🙂
Reply
Barb
I didn’t want the February box so I cancelled, but when I saw this palette, I reactivated to see if maybe I would get off the list in March. I got off the waitlist overnight and the Feb box has shipped my way. Oh, well. The waitlist is apparently short right now.
Reply
Heather
If you get the highlighter palette and don’t want it, I’ll buy the box from you! Just post under March spoilers. Thanks, Heather H.
Reply
Jocelyn
I don’t want the February box either.. I only signed up again today hoping for this palette in the March box.. so I hope I get off the waitlist for that.. but if they send me the February box I’m not going to be happy.
Reply
Victoria
This is frustrating I subscribed right at the end of January and I’m still on the waitlist and I so wanted the February box. I was watching Boxycharm spoilers for months before I decided to subscribe to them! Hoping they remove me ASAP from the waitlist
Reply
Harshada Sant
Hi I just got off waitlist today. I am not really into sparkly products, which is kinda the Feb theme. So if you want I can give you the entire Feb box when I get it.
Heather
Me too! “Subbed” in Jan but still waitlisted. 🙁
Kim
I wish boxy wld let us pause even if ur only allowed say 4x per year. Im with u wasnt excited for this box at all. But next month looks promising.
Reply
Lisa
Man, I’m jealous! I signed up on January 25 and I’m still on the waitlist. I was subscribed from September through November, so I’m familiar with how the waitlist works for the most part, but it seems wonky now. I didn’t think there was much of a waitlist, because in January lots of people were getting off in 3 days or so. I don’t want January, so I waited until the end of the month to resubscribe and now I’m still waiting.
Reply
Redhed36
Can Liz or whoever confirm this is not a variant item? I seen comments on other threads where the March spoiler is actually a variant and they are not happy. Lol
Reply
WB
The February box has a palette that is a variation…the box will have a Naked Cosmetics palette or an Ofra pop up palette. The Pur palette above will be in all the March boxes.
Reply
Xani
The statement from the ceo specifically said “all charmers will receive…” so I think we’re good.
Reply
Lori
Love it! Can’t wait to play with the colors!! I may be older but I love all the pretty colors
😍😊💖🙌⭐⭐❤️
Reply
Iggy'sRock
Who cares your age! Color is beautiful. Where would you want! There is too much blah in the world as is.
Reply
Toni
Love 💕 it, can’t wait to get it
Reply
Kristin Tanner
I wish Too Faced would do a palette with them and I would love to see some too faced items in my box
Reply
amy
this is beautiful!!! i am also hoping that we will get that CRAYOLA palette in the next few months . but i think the palette is to big to fit in a boxycharm box so probably not, but still i can dream
Reply
Christine
Awesome PUR palette! Thank you, Boxy Charm!
Reply
Jessica
Love PUR, excited for some pops of color, but three of those colors look identical to me.
Reply
Christine
I think one is a matte light peach, one a matte slightly darker peach and one a peach shimmer.
Reply
Jessica
You have better eyes than I do! I’m hoping the variation will be more noticeable in person.
Bella01
That’s one gorgeous Palette!
Reply
T.Marie
Love, love, love!
Reply
Nancyisshopping
I love it!! I’m looking forward to it!
Reply
RoguesEn3D
This is why I got into makeup sub boxes. Fun, colorful cosmetics and staples; familiar brands and new ones to experience. A highlighter and pretty brushes for January, now a lovely palette from PUR. Many thanks to BC and PUR.
Reply
heather
Woo Hoo!! Pretty, pretty, pretty!!! Love the colors, and that it’s a dependable brand, not another crown, or wonky ‘off’ brand!!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.