Posted by on in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 60 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have Fall 2017 Limited Edition Box – Spoiler #4

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

We have the latest spoiler for the POPSUGAR Must Have Limited Edition Fall 2017 box! (POPSUGAR sent us this item early so we can answer any questions you might have about it.)

The POPSUGAR Must Have Limited Edition Fall 2017 box will include:

Foreo Luna Play + Facial Cleansers – $39 Value

What do you think of the latest spoiler? 

And in case you missed the previous spoilers:

DANNIJO Dagny Necklace – Retail Value $195

This POPSUGAR-exclusive statement necklace makes any outfit more sophisticated. Pair it with your favorite little black dress for a date or with distressed jeans and your poncho for brunch with the girls.

The necklace is made of steel plated oxidized silver and the gems are made of glass. All DANNIJO Jewelry, including this glam necklace, is produced by responsible manufacturing facilities. 
Here it is on:

I decided to lean into the edgy vibe of this necklace and pair it with a moto hoodie jacket and a casual t-shirt dress.


(Malin + Goetz) Recovery Treatment Oil – Value $82

This luxurious oil will ensure you don’t lose your dewy glow during the cooler months. Apply five to seven drops of the treatment after washing your face to restore moisture. The blend of nine skin-loving oils will keep your skin hydrated and balanced while reducing the appearance of fine lines.

Yes to full-size pricey skin care items!

This oil is lightweight, absorbs quickly, and has a faint, natural scent. It’s pretty much exactly what I look for in a serum/facial oil, so I am very pleased with this spoiler!

The box will also include:

Hat Attack Lightweight Layer Black Poncho – Retail Value $88

When the weather gets a little chilly, this stylish poncho will keep you cozy atop a dress or pair of jeans. The on-trend cover-up can be work off the shoulder or as a boatneck, depending on how you adjust the incredibly soft material.

This is a soft, 100% acrylic knit, that you can wear as a boatneck style, or diagonal.

Here’s how I’m wearing it:

My fall/winter go-to look is: leggings, boots, long-sleeve mini dress, and a vest. I’ve been thinking about getting a poncho and/or a moto jacket for alternative vest options, and I’m digging the poncho look!

And we’re doing something a little different for this spoiler! Several MSA reviewers are modeling it so you can see how it looks with different styles and body types!

From Jess:

I love the lightweight, open knit of this poncho! It makes for a versatile transition piece leading into chillier months (seriously though — is it fall yet?). It’s also awesome that you can throw it on over a tee shirt and jeans for an instantly polished look, and that’s exactly what I did here. Being that I’m currently 27 weeks pregnant, loose and comfy is the name of my game. I finished the look with my favorite suede mules, some bold earrings, and a unique bamboo clutch to make a bit of a statement.

From Anna:

I’m not super into the boho/festival trend. I wanted to create a look that felt more like the countryside of Sweden than the mainstage at Coachella. To do that, I knew I had to match the breeziness of the poncho with something structured, like this striped, collared shirt. The wood-soled platform shoes have a 70s vibe that complements the retro feeling of the poncho, but again, their simplicity and structure saves the look from seeming too hippie for my tastes.

From Nicole:

Ponchos pair incredibly well with jeans and boots for the fall, but I wanted to try to go in a different direction. I paired the poncho for both looks with an effortlessly cool and classic long sleeved striped top. I couldn’t decide what look was my favorite, so I decided to showcase the poncho and my striped top in two different looks. I wanted to bring a pop of color, so I threw in the whole paint can with my golden Eloquii neoprene pencil skirt. I topped off this bold look with knee high black socks and my T.U.K leopard buckled creeper oxfords. You can’t go wrong with leopard print, am I right?

For my second look, I wanted to feel like Iggy Pop if he wanted to go “Search and Destroy” for a haunted hay ride in a cozy poncho. I put on my favorite ASOS Curve spandex black disco pants and my new Torrid boots that have this fantastic stud and chain detail. You won’t be a forgotten boy or girl in that look!

From Sara:

Wow, the open crochet is lightweight, but also surprisingly warm! I love to pair oversized tops with skinny denim or leggings, so this poncho is a match made in heaven with my beloved faux leather leggings from Trunk Club. Since there are no sleeve holes, I decided to shift the poncho a bit to create a boat neckline, rather than a v-neck in the front and back. Combined with a couple neutral textile accessories in my wardrobe, this outfit is full of texture and getting me excited for the cooler weather heading my way!

What do you think of the first spoiler? Is it helpful to see the spoiler modeled this way?

More info on this box:

The Box: POPSUGAR Must Have Limited Edition Fall 2017Box

The Cost: $100

The Products: “Filled with over $450 worth of gorgeous Fall fashion, beauty, and home accessories, this box is full of items that will have you feeling stylish and cozy all Fall long.”

If you want an email alert when this box is available for sale (or when spoilers are released), make sure to sign up for News and Spoilers alerts at the end of this post!

Are you going to grab a Limited Edition Fall Box box? Check out my review of the 2016 POPSUGAR Fall Box, and my review of the 2015 POPSUGAR Fall Box to see what has been in past boxes!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I absolutely LOVE the hat attack shawl (so soft) and the sweet/sour glasses (cute!). I’m gonna give the face cleansers a try but haven’t yet. The rest was just ok. But honestly the shawl and glasses made it worth buying and it was fun going through everything!

  2. How about some beat heatsets? Those would be awesome in a summer or fall box! And very gift able.

    • Last year’s Fall LE box included headphones.

  3. How many Foreo’s does a girl need anyway? I have the big pink one a mini travel blue one.. and now this?? Ugh.. big big miss for me! Bummer..

  4. Feeling very disappointed that I got this. Already have the Foreo, as does everyone, I think.

    • I don’t have one! I wish it were full sized but this is going to be a way to try it. Plus it will be good for travel.

  5. I am sooooo glad I didn’t buy this. The fact that they have released so many spoilers says nobody buys these boxes of overpriced junk sight unseen anymore. The poncho is straight up hideous. The necklace is old lady tacky and beyond gross. Another overpriced face oil. And another Foreo Play. Score-jk it’s a total fail. Why anyone keeps buying these is beyond me.

  6. I just received a tracking email for this box from PSMH but it’s different than the normal tracking and isn’t showing up in my FedEx app. Have they changed their shipping? It still shows that it will be coming from Gilroy, CA. I’m excited that it’s already shipping because I thought we had another week or so to wait!

    To clarify the email itself looks the same as always but once you click on the tracking link it appears different than in the past or atleast it does to me

    • Same here!

      • Got my notice but it will take 10 to 14 days before I get mine.

        It is time to reveal it all!

      • Can you tell which service it is shipping through? It doesn’t appear to be FedEx like normal

        • It looks like it’s USPS

          • Ok thanks

          • Hi my tracking notice is FedEx.. I’m on the east coast not sure if that matters

  7. I am loving this so much more than their LE Summer box. This spoiler put me over the edge and I just bought it! I don’t even care what the other items are because I’m so happy with these and see myself getting a ton of use out of them all…. love the poncho instead of the typical scarf for fall! Excited to see what else is in the box though.

  8. So….I don’t mean to be negative. I know everyone has different tastes. But, lately I have been feeling like PS is approaching these boxes with an attitude of “What can we obtain affordably to put in these boxes?” (think: Henri Bendel umbrella which was a free GWP from October last year) rather than “what is a MUST HAVE that we can affordably source for this box” I get that they are a business and what not, but I have just been feeling a little too much bargain-basement vibe lately. I don’t mean offense to anyone who loves the box, I’m just commenting on an overall trend I am seeing.

    It makes me sad because I literally ADORE Popsugar. They could sell a box full of tax bills and I would buy it. Lol. I buy every single one with no spoiler because I am that much of a fan haha. I just hope they aren’t having financial trouble or something.

    Zoe is absolutely knocking it out of the park lately, though!

    • I totally agree…..

    • I agree. When I first started subscribing to PS a little over two years ago, I enjoyed receiving new brands and the latest styles. For example, in one of my first boxes, I received a scarf, a style that I later saw all over the place for fall fashion. It does worry me when I start to see PS offering the same stuff included in other subs – the Foreo Play, the Seven Husbands book, Nicely Noted cards, etc. But…on the other hand maybe I just have too many subs. I do wonder if this is what happened to LLB though. It was my favorite sub ever :/

      • LBB was awesome! I wonder how Dan Murrilo is. I wish someone would do a similar version of LBB. It had so many fans….

  9. This is my favorite post. My initial reaction was “eww, a poncho?” But each of you make it look stylish and sassy! Love that idea!

    • I’m usually not a poncho person (lol) but I absolutely love this one!

  10. I will purchase if it goes on sale; love pretty much everything in it.

  11. Why did I buy this box at full price……??
    Sorry for the negative again, but it seems like the fall LE is doomed to have steep discount after it starts shipping.
    4 spoiler items out and the box still not sold out.
    I always have this weird impression that psmh’s le boxes are very sought after (probably cuz of the target colab box I was never able to snag one before they decided not to do it anymore).
    If you don’t buy it in time, you might miss it.
    But since this year’s resort, and then the twice summer box 50% sale. It just seems like there’s a pattern starting to form.
    I’ll probably be super pixxed if later the fall box does go deep discount, since I don’t really like the box so far (personal preference).
    Really hope psmh will have a better market strategy for holiday boxes… It really kind of sxxks when you buy a box for $100, then 1-2 weeks later, everyone else is getting it half price…

    • I feel like am in your same boat. I bought it at full price based on liking the first spoiler. I haven’t liked any of the subsequent spoilers. And now, on top of that, I already have the Foreo. So it’s a duplicate item for me. I am feeling very disappointed.

      If this box goes on sale, especially for a deep discount, I think I will never buy another PopSugar box again (LE or regular). It’s just too risky of a game to play – sure, you might wind up with a wonderful box that is a steal at full price, but, you also might wind up with a bunch of useless or junky items AT FULL PRICE. It seems like a bait and switch. The couple boxes I don’t grab (in the span of 2-3 years) wind up being fantastic and sold out, but the many boxes I do grab wind up being a bunch of fluff.

    • I feel that the reason that these boxes do not sell out anymore has to do with everybody waiting for that “deep discount: that they plan on seeing. So I pay over $100 (I pay tax) and then it goes on sale for half price 2 weeks after I receive my box? What motivation do I have to buy a box at full price? None! My box arrives next week and I wonder if they will reveal the rest of the box or not.

      Bottom line: I am going to be VERY annoyed if this box goes for half price in a few weeks Annoyed enough to never buy more PS boxes. I need to cut down on sub boxes anyway. I like what is in this box way more than the RZ one. RZ is sliding downhill fast as far as quality is concerned. I am beginning to think the sub box trend will end within the next few years.

  12. I would love this box!

  13. I received one of these in a
    $15 Allure box last year so I’d expect this to be Full Size Rechargeable in a LE box 😑

    • Me too…..they need to step it up. I see these in advent calendars as well. The company (Luneo Play) gave/sold at a VERY low cost to endorse their larger product so it doesn’t look good to have the small, throw away version.

  14. I think the box is awesome! Don’t understand why everyone is complaining!

    • Shrug. I like it too 🙂

  15. I passed on the Foreo in the August BF, so at first I was excited to see it offered elsewhere.

    Then I realised it was in THIS box 😕

    Ugh. As I’ve always said, if you miss something in 1 box, just wait. It will come around again in another sub.

    I would never pay $100, but I’d buy for a steep discount.

  16. Yawn to this spoiler…have 2 of these…it’s a great box, but waiting for the deep discount that will come soon here.

  17. I like the spoilers so far, but I am easy to please. I appreciate that there is not much duplication between this box and the Fall BOS. I got both, and am happy with both.

  18. How many more items will be in the box? Is this the majority of the box?

    • 2 more items!

  19. I LOVE that you had women of different shapes and sizes model for us! Thank you! 💖

  20. FOUR spoilers? Has PS ever released this many for an LE box before? FFF released all but two of the fall box items as spoilers also. The only motivation for doing this, as far as I can tell, is declining sales. I understand some people are more likely to risk their money if they know they like most of the items, but I’m the exact opposite. You could say sub boxes are my preferred form of gambling. The surprise is half the appeal! If I bought this box not knowing what was in it, I’d be happy with it. I would use or gift everything. But I have a similar black shawl and a similar necklace, I need to use the face oils I currently have, and I received a Foreo Play in BeautyFix already. So now that I know what’s going to be in the box, it’s much easier to talk myself out of spending money on it.

  21. Blahhh. I really wish I’d held off on this box. I have a feeling it’s going to be deeply discounted. It’s not that the products aren’t nice, they’re just not for me (mostly because i have too many subscriptions). This will be my 3rd Foreo mini, and the necklace is very similar to the one in the Rachel Zoe winter box (plus, I like that one better). The facial oil I can use, but ponchos like that just aren’t my style and nothing about it looks high end. I think for $100 price point, the Zoe Box of Style blows PSMH LE boxes away, for curation and luxury.

  22. I super love everything except the poncho. I will probably buy once full spoiler is up.

  23. I find this to be a disappointing spoiler. In a box like this, it should be a full size Foreo, not the Play.

    Anyway, I already have a Play and never use it, so it doesn’t appeal to me.

    The only thing I really like in this box is the necklace. I’ll probably try to swap for it. If the box (shockingly) goes on sale, maybe I’ll buy it. I kinda like the poncho, not not enough to actively pursue it.

    • Tamara, I completely agree. I’d expect a $100 LE box to include the full-size, rechargeable. I already received the Play in BeautyFix, which is a $25 box!

  24. I love this box – but these always seem to go on sale so I shall wait!

  25. I’m excited for this one! I’m most excited for the poncho and face oil, which more than pays for the box. Not sure about the necklace, but I’ll try it on when it gets here. If I don’t love it, I’ve already got a gift recipient in mind. I’ll probably gift this Foreo since I have one, but even then I still think this box is worth it!

  26. I love everything so far. I may have to buy a second box. If they go on sale, I will definitely get another one. There are so many great items I can use for gifts.

  27. Why are there 2 skin items AGAIN in a Pop Sugar box? Ugh, I have a Luna Plays I already do not use from other sub boxes. I have Beauty Fix and Allure for skin items. I regret purchasing this. How is this box a “Fall Style Kit” with 2 facial items in it? I hope we get a very nice lux fall stylish candle for the home or this box is being swapped or sold 🙂

  28. I have been curious about the Luna but being a Clarisonic fan could not justify the cost. It is nice to have one to try. I just wish PS would release entire box content!

    p.s. These do not recharge.

  29. I don’t think I would buy this even at a discount. The items are nice enough but nothing that really attracts me. Hopefully the winter on will be more my style!

  30. Liz, is the necklace good quality/ well-made? Thanks! 🙂

  31. I keep hoping they will spoil something that I “must have” – I love the necklace but already have two sparkly statement necklaces I rarely wear, I worry the poncho will look aging on me, I already have two nice bottles of facial oil to use up, and I’m happy with my current cleansing plan. If the box sticks around long enough to go on sale I’ll probably grab one though. This will be the first Fall box I’ve missed in a while.

  32. Not my style this year. I think the necklace is kind of pretty, but none of the other products are good fits for me.

  33. So far I’m only keeping the poncho and swapping or trying to swap everything else.

  34. I wish someone would include a full size Foreo but the box really looks great.

  35. Okay, so that’s 4 items worth $404. Typically there are 6 items in a PS box so that means that the last two items probably have a RV of around $50. At these point why not just spoil the entire box? One of the last two items is a snack/food item and it would be nice to have a pop of fall color – maybe a nail polish? Or will it be a home item? I’m not planning on buying this box but I’m looking forward to the full reveal.

    • …. truly, why not spoil the entire box at this point?? …. “hero” items are all out – ?? 🙁

  36. I was on the edge but now I am sold – I just bought one. I can’t wait to see what the final item(s) in the box are – sounds like $45 left in value

  37. This is shaping up to be a nice box but I’m still not ready to pull the trigger. I really wish the necklace was more my style!! $404 in spoilers so far–looks like the last two fall boxes included six items, so possibly two items left and not much RV to get to the promised $450. Wonder what else will be included…and if I’ll totally regret not purchasing!

  38. ……. I’m looking at the whole – it’s really quite good, even though I can’t possibly “rock” that necklace or poncho – I’ve got two great skin care items – a poncho to gift and am relatively sure I have a good swap in place for the necklace ………. PSMH really does a great job!! 🙂

  39. love! Have been using one from beauty fix and love it! It may not be rechargeable but can’t wait for my second one!

  40. I’m surprised that Foreo is popping up quite often in subscription boxes lately.

  41. I am totally digging this box! Fall never lets me down!!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!