MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Love Goodly Subscription Box Review – April / May 2017


Love Goodly is a vegan subscription box that sends a mix of beauty, wellness and lifestyle items every other month.

FYI – For this box, I worked with Love Goodly to select one of the brands featured in the box: One Love Organics. (They are one of my all time favorite luxe, natural beauty brands.) So, I went into this review already knowing I’m a fan of one of the products – because I picked it! Please keep that in mind when reading the review. 


This box was sent to us for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)


The Subscription Box: Love Goodly

The Cost: $29.95 a box

COUPON: Use code LOVEMSA5 to save $5 off your first box!

The Products: LOVE GOODLY sends a mix of beauty and skincare products and samples, wellness products, healthy snacks and eco style or home accessories. All products are vegan and cruelty-free!

Ships to: US only

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wish list!

Check out all of my Love Goodly reviews!


Each box comes with an info card detailing the items included.


And I’m super excited about this box because I got to pick one of the brands included!


Now, onto the items!



One Love Organics Love Springs Eternal Youth Preservation Serum – FULL SIZE! Value $75


I got to work with Love Goodly for this box, and One Love Organics was my brand pick! I love One Love Organic formulas – they are ingredient-conscious and smell lovely. (And they are a splurge beauty brand for me – so I was thrilled to see this $75 serum in a $30 box!)


This serum scent reminds me of the paperwhite narcissus flower! I’ve been using it as my nighttime serum for the past few weeks, and I love how soft it makes my skin feel. I put the recommended 3-5 pumps onto my skin, so it takes a while to absorb – fine by me for a night serum. (And it has been very gentle on my skin.)

(Subscribers will receive this unless they opted the Vitamin C Body Polish – one of my all time favorite products!)


100% Pure Maracuja Mascara in Black Tea – FULL SIZE! Value $25


I love the 100% Pure Blueberry mascara for a natural look mascara (it smells like blueberries), so I was excited to try this one. I am not a fan of the Black Tea scent on this one, but the formula itself is what I expected – it made my lashes very dark, and provided good length and lash separation. (This isn’t going to be a high-impact big-volume mascara, but I like it for an easy every day look.)


100% Pure Bright Eyes Mask – Value $7

These eye masks are infused with organic aloe, organic matcha tea, and organic green coffee to help brighten and de-puff the skin under your eyes. Admittedly, I never see much of a difference in my skin after using these eye masks. (I have dark under eye circles, but no under eye bags.)

But, I can confirm that these are very refreshing.!(I recommend putting them in the fridge before using them for extra cooling!)


PureSol Bamboo Charcoal Konjac Cleansing Sponge – Value $13


I’ve tried konjac sponges before for my face, but this is my first body konjac sponge!


If you aren’t familiar with these type of sponges, they arrive dry/stiff, then you wet them before use. When you’re done, squeeze out the excess water and let it dry on the included hook.


It’s a great tool for a very gentle exfoliation. I’m going to use this in place of my regular body scrubs when I’m wearing self tanner – it will keep my tan looking even without rubbing everything off!


Lastly, this box included a coupon card for $10 off your first order at Juice Served Here.

Verdict: This box has a value of about $120! I think that’s fantastic for a $30 vegan lifestyle box! I’m biased for picking the One Love Organics product, but it’s definitely my favorite item in the box!

What do you think of the April/May Love Goodly box?

(Also good to know – with each box and purchase, Love Goodly donates a portion of the proceeds to these charities).

Love Goodly

How do subscribers rate Love Goodly?

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about Love Goodly!

Enable notifications () to get the latest Love Goodly spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Love Goodly Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, Vegan Subscription Boxes| Tags: love goodly | 32 comments

Comments (32)

  1. This box really looks amazing! I wish we had a similar box here in Denmark!

  2. Glad I stumbled upon this review. I am going to give the box a try in my attempt of purchasing only green beauty products. It is encouraging to read there are real people in customer service to contact as well.

  3. Looks like this box is available as a stand alone purchase as their earth box for $35, plus an earth day tote. Tempted to get another!

    • That’s a great idea, worth it for the serum alone!

  4. I’m very pleased with this! The serum made me resubscribe (thanks, Liz!) and I will use everything else in the box – that’s a win in my book! I’m very proud my myself for going spoiler free after the OLO spoiler!

  5. The products speak for themselves and they are amazing! So, if I saw it on another site with someone who didn’t help curate the box (1 item), I’d still try it out. Thanks, Liz!!

  6. I can’t wait to get my box! I usually don’t look at spoilers, but I couldn’t help this one. I will use everything! I wonder if the mascara will also help lashes grow quicker and fuller with all the amazing ingredients?

  7. I had skipped the last box and forgot to skip this one. It just charged me yesterday, pretty excited about my mistake 🙂

  8. I had been in the market for a new face serum, especially since wanting to switch to natural/organic skincare and I am so excited for this box! I am so excited to try the serum! I chose the mascara in brown and am looking forward to that as well. I read it smells a bit like chocolate 🙂

    • How did you select a mascara color? I just signed up and don’t see where to do it.

      • There was an email link in the spoiler post about the mascara. I just emailed and asked for brown rather than black.

      • You email them directly and a real person responds. Search for the spoiler, it has the email.

      • Thanks ladies!

  9. What a fantastic box! If it’s still available I want it so bad. Every product is amazing. The konjac sponge is great and I go through those often. I also love One Love Organics. So indulgent! What a wonderfully curated box 🙂

    • Oooooh it looks like it is still available!!!

  10. Yay, so excited I choose this box over a couple others I was considering that were a bit less. I really like the products and think I will use all of them. 😉

  11. I realize you noted this in your review, but reviewing a box you helped curate is a bit of a conflict of interest.

    • Fair point. Since I didn’t pick out all the items, but just selected one of the brands for this box, I hadn’t originally thought of it that way, but I totally see your view.

      I’ll add a note in bold to the beginning of the review to call it out more. Let me know if you have any other suggestions, and thank you for the feedback!

    • I don’t understand your point. What is a ‘bit’ of a conflict of interest? Liz chose one item and was clear about that in her previous spoiler as well. People can now decide to purchase (or not) based on the items and this full review lets us know what’s in the box. Regardless of any collaboration, the first two spoiler items alone convinced me to sub. The value now that I see everything included is outstanding!

    • How does this create a conflict of interest? Its very clearly noted…and she only chose 1 brand/item. Like the poster above me said, its your choice whether you want to buy the box or not. This box has been on my radar for a while, i may just jump on it now because every item looks great! And i wont lie, that serum is swaying me.

      • It’s a conflict of interest because she’s reviewing a box she helped curate. And yeah it’s in the disclaimer but it’s still a conflict of interest. It’s like if an actor reviewed his own movie, or an author reviewed her own book.

        It’s Liz’s website and she can run it however she likes. But, there is an inherent bias in this review. Not just because she chose the brand but because it appears she has a working relationship with the company that makes this box. So this isn’t a review, it’s more like an advertisement. At least to me it makes the review less trustworthy.

        Everyone is free to get the box if they want. It makes no difference to me one way or the other.

      • These are to a great extent advertising. These types of sites are well compensated most every time each of us receives a delightful box of goodies for pennies on the dollar. And kudos to them, for turning a fun hobby into a very lucrative career, albeit one with the potential longevity of a major league sports star.

      • She picked one item that went into the box. To me, it’s no different from one of the 5th Avenue Style boxes (or Golden Tote for that matter) where the customer gets to pick one item, and the rest are a mystery. She very clearly spelled out her involvement in the beginning of the review.

      • Cookie, your comment is really unhelpful and petty. A beauty box is not the same as a movie nor a book, but authors do book tours and actors do interviews to promote their work, so your point is still wasted. Indicating that she shouldn’t share her opinion because she co-curated is absolutely absurd. Her excitement to share the products and excitement about participating in the curation are more than justified – it’s clearly passion, not just advertising. All of the brands included are amazing, and from reading the comments, that is unanimously evident, regardless of Liz.

      • Cookie, you speak like an auditor. I agree, the independence has to be in fact and appearance (per AICPA :).

      • Ha ha! Coming from a former auditor, your comment made me chuckle 😀

      • Good points Cookie – I agree. Much of the “reviews” are promos. But I like this site anyway to see the boxes.

      • She is reviewing a product she did not create – so I trust her review. If the item was not quality, she would not have selected it for the box.

        Plus – Why wouldn’t you advertise a box you helped curate on your own website?

  12. Oh my – this looks fantabulous! I’m glad I didn’t hesitate to sign up for Love Goodly (my very first one!) when I saw the spoiler #1. I’ve been meaning to get the body konjac sponge from Julep, but now I know I don’t have to! And, of course, super excited about the serum … Great job Liz 😍

  13. Thank you for this awesome review, Liz! I like this box much more than my first one in Feb!

  14. Yay!
    I’m so excited to get this box! I pretty much signed up immediately after reading the OLO spoiler (thank you so much Liz! 😉 )

    • Awesome! Hope you love the box, Randi! 🙂

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


Never miss another deal

Sign up for our newsletter for exclusive discounts, news and more