Facebook PixelThe 18 Best Horror Subscription Boxes of 2020 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The 13 Best Horror Subscription Boxes of 2021

April Stettner
ByApril StettnerOct 29, 2021 | 0 comments

Whether you're a year-round Halloween person or a fan of all things spooky and mystical, you've come to the right place. This list of horror subscriptions will fuel your fear with horror collectibles, t-shirts, thriller novels, mystical tales, and so much more. No matter if you're looking to add a little 'boo' to your beauty routine or seeking a serious scare, you'll find something to shock you in this article. Enter if you dare...

Best Horror Subscription Boxes for Fear and Fun

1. Horror Pack

Horror Pack January 2019 - Contents

Image from our review.

Cost: Starts at$29.99 per month for a 4 Blu-Ray disc plan. Save with longer subscriptions. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save $3 off your first month!
CODE: HORRORPACKMSA

Why we love it: Horror Pack seeks to fill your movie collection with Blu-Rays of must-see horror movies. Every shipment includes a limited edition title, and often, they'll send more recent titles and retro movies, too—some delightfully campy, others all-out terrifying. 

Check out our Horror Pack details and reviews for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US for free, Canada for $6.00, and worldwide for $18.00.

2. Hunt A Killer

Hunt A Killer Episode 2 June 2017 - 0001

Image from our review.

Cost: $30 per month. Save with longer subscriptions. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Limited Time Only! Use code MSA25 to get 25% off your first box
CODE: MSA25

Why we love it: If true crime horror is more your speed, you've got to try Hunt A Killer! This immersive subscription plan puts you on the trail of a serial killer, helping a detective sort through evidence, case files, autopsy results, audio files, and more. Use your own cunning, share the game with friends and family, or join up with the Hunt A Killer community to solve the case. 

Check out our Hunt A Killer details and reviews for more information on subscribing. Ships worldwide (with free shipping to the US).

3. My Thrill Club

My Thrill Club

Image from our review.

Cost: $18.99 per month. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: 15% off your first order. No coupon needed - just use this link.

Why we love it: Explore the full spectrum of suspense with this book and movie subscription! My Thrill Club sends subscribers two new hardcover books and an eBook from your chosen genre each month. Choose from crime and mystery, thriller and espionage, horror, or a mix of all. My Thrill Club is a great way for horror lovers to reread classics and discover new authors in the genre. You might just get a surprise in your shipment, too! (Think DVDs and more.)

Check out our My Thrill Club reviews and details for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US and Canada.

4. Creepy Crate

April_May Creepy Crate All the Goodies

Image from our review.

Cost: $39.99 every other month + free US shipping. Save with longer subscriptions. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save $5 off your first box!
CODE: CREEPYMSA

Why we love it: Creepy Crate is a bi-monthly horror subscription that fills all the dark corners of your home with delightfully dreadful collectibles, clothes, accessories, books, and other items. You may see Michael Myers or Nell Crane pop up on mugs or posters, while other boxes might contain general themes such as witches, curses, and more.

Check out our Creepy Crate details and reviews for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US for free, worldwide for an additional cost.

5. Loot Fright

Cost: $34.99 per month + shipping. Subscribe here!

Why we love it: Loot Fright Gives you a surprise mix of horror collectibles, apparel, and more from classic and current franchises delivered to your chamber door every other month!  This month's crate theme is "Enter Blumhouse" masters of movie horror. And they're bringing their spine-tingling tales to Loot Fright. Enter Blumhouse with exclusive collectibles and gear from Happy Death Day, The Invisible Man, The Purge, and more! Are you scared yet?

Check out our Loot Fright details and reviews for more information on subscribing. Ships worldwide.

6. and The Story Begins

Read our review of the October and the Story Begins box!

Image from our review.

Cost: $17.95 per month. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save 25% off your subscription!
CODE: SPRING25

Why we love it: and the Story Begins sends you two books per month in genres of your choosing, including horror and mystery/thriller. The books from this subscription are new, thoughtfully chosen, and wrapped and shipped in 100% recycled material. 

Check out our and The Story Begins details for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US and Canada.

7. ZChest

Image from our review.

Cost: $30 per month. Save with longer subscriptions. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save 5% off your first box
CODE: WELIV

Why we love it: ZChest is filled with up to 8 zombie-themed items such as toys, collectibles, movies, music, posters, hats, socks, shirts, and more! The quirky and creepy items you get in this subscription are perfect for fans of zombie lore.

Check out our ZChest details and reviews for more information on subscribing. Ships worldwide.

8. Cosy Killer

Cost: £25 (approx. $34.45 ) per month. Subscribe here!

Why We Love It: CosyKiller is a year-long murder mystery adventure, delivered to your doorstep each month. Packed with clues, keepsakes, ciphers, and mementos you need to review and unravel. CosyKiller is like an Agatha Christie novel where you play Miss Marple – no conclusions are drawn, and the puzzling and detection is up to you!

Check out Cosy Killers FAQ to learn more

9. Skulls Unlimited BoneBox

Image via Cratejoy.

Cost: $24.99. Subscribe here!

Why We Love It: Skulls Unlimited is the world's leading supplier of osteological specimens. Each #BoneBox subscription includes a mystery skull, collectible animal trading cards, a unique animal or art item, and of course related promotions and exclusive discounts! Items in the BoneBox will always be natural bone animal products, never replica. Past boxes have included skulls, teeth, bacula, claws, and other osteological items.

Check out our Skulls Unlimited details to learn more. Due to wildlife export restrictions, the BoneBox is only available to the lower 48 States, Alaska, and Hawaii (no U.S. territories). 

10. Wizarding World

Cost: $39.99 + shipping bi-monthly. Save with a longer subscription. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save 10% off any length subscription, or $3 off month-to-month
CODE: ADDICTION or SAVE3

Why We Love It: This one's for the Harry Potter fans! While not exactly a box of horror, we couldn't leave ol' Potter off the list of mystical, right? Show off your Hogwarts house pride with a surprise mix of unique and officially licensed Wizarding World collectibles, apparel, figures and more delivered to your door every other month. Past box items have included character-themed bobble heads, keychains, t-shirts, scarves, wands, and more.

Check out our Wizarding World details and reviews to learn more.

11. Cryptid Crate

Image via Cratejoy.

Cost: $43.99 per month + shipping. Subscribe here!

Why we love it: Cryptid Crate is a monthly subscription filled with various cryptozoology and paranormal-themed items to wear, display and collect. Expect a carefully curated package filled with 4-7 creeptastic pieces from indie makers and artisans pertaining to bigfoot, sasquatch, UFOs, ghosts, and other cryptid and mysterious creatures. Items include paranormal wall art and home decor, t-shirts, collectibles, books and films, accessories, and much more!

Ships worldwide from the United States except for the United Kingdom.

12. Parcel of Terror

Image via Cryptocurium.

Cost: $40 per month. Subscribe here!

Why we love it: The Parcel of Terror sends you a monthly collection of handmade horror items, such as pins, wall plaques, magnets, and more. Parcel of Terror boxes cover a wide range of horror themes, like slasher flicks, Halloween, cryptozoology, and other spooky subjects.

Check out our Parcel of Terror details for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US only, for free.

13. NME Box

Image via Cratejoy.

Cost: $64.99 per month. Subscribe here!

Why we love it: Get a great new makeup experience every month with NME Box. If you love getting creative with your makeup or following makeup tutorials, then this one-of-a-kind subscription is for you. Boxes are packed with everything from palettes to prosthetics to wigs to help you make picture-worthy looks. Create a character. Learn new skills. Who will you create?!

Ships worldwide from the United States.

 


Want more scary-good subscriptions? Check out these pop culture subscription boxes!

 

April Stettner
April Stettner
April is a freelance writer with a borderline unhealthy obsession with all things beauty and 90’s pop culture. When she isn’t beach hopping with her dog Wyatt, she's interviewing female entrepreneurs in Charleston, SC.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.