My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query

Wantable Makeup Reviews

Is Wantable Makeup Right For You?

Updated October 26, 2021

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Wantable Makeup Overview

About the Brand

The Wantable Makeup subscription offers full sized makeup based on your preferences! You can change your makeup preferences anytime, and it's easy to skip a month from your account. Shipping is free to the US. Canada: $6.00 USD United Kingdom: $7.00 USD Australia: $10.00 USD

Key Info

  • Price:$36.00 per month
  • Ships To:US, UK, Australia, and Canada

Wantable Makeup Reviews

Wantable Makeup News

User Reviews

Subscriber Ratings

4.2 overall rating
19
9
3
2
2

Subscriber Reviews

Write A Review
Christina Brewster
Christina Brewster
Feb 15, 2015
I have gotten this box for the past 3 months and really loved 2, but put in a request for a refund/return for my December box ( I think) and am a little disappointed because I put that request in at least 3 weeks ago and have not received my return form yet? I am going to contact customer service tonight and see what the problem is. It is also possible this is an error on my part, I'm not sure. I LOVE that I can return my box and get a refund if I want. I had to change my profile because I was getting alot of weird colors like blue mascara. This is my fault though. I do wear bold colors and and wear dramatic make up and am adventurous as far as color goes, but I do not like colored mascara or colored eyeliner really, which is what I was getting. I do love the quality of items and look forward to this box every month!
Report
Wendy Holt
Wendy Holt
Jan 31, 2015
I received an email from Wantable offering my first box for only $1, and I could not pass that up! I'd been wanting to try this box for a long time, but $40 is a pricy gamble so this was my chance. It shipped quickly and tracking information was provided every step of the way. I received 4 full sized upscale makeup items, and all arrived in perfect condition. (Lip crayon, eyeliner, mineral eye shadow, and mineral loose powder.) All items were *amazing quality. I still think $40 is a high price for items I didn't specifically choose but I think I'll tweak my preferences and try another box.
Report
Lisa
Lisa
Sep 23, 2015
First Wantables box I loved everything. Second the bulkier half is going back. We will see how easy the returns are. Will see how this next month goes if this stays on my subscription list.
Report
Aug 21, 2015
Wantables was my first subscription and I just received my first box. Four excellent full side products. -Model Co. BB Plus cream is my favorite, great color, blends easily, and has a smooth finish, not tacky or hard to smooth on with just enough color to smooth out complexion and still looks natural. -Robanda facial cleaner worked will and left my skin feeling fresh and hydrated. -A foundation brush, seems nice and well made, and personally you can not own too many brushes since they do need to be replaced more often than people think. -And another black eyeliner.
Report
Amy Hoffman
Amy Hoffman
May 17, 2015
I'm in my 5th month of this subscription and while I do like a lot of the items sent, sometimes they really miss the mark. My first box was the best- they took out all the stops and I got 4 fabulous Hugh value items, since then I have received maybe 4 items I wish to keep or use and then swapped the rest. The best thing is that it seems like they do pay attention to special requests. I mentioned that I love coloured mascara and my next box had a blue mascara. Maybe the answer is to redo the style quiz every month and see if that impacts the selection. Also, they say they send 4-5 items, but every box thus far has only been 4.
Report
TexasMama
TexasMama
Mar 21, 2015
I love the ease of returns, makes this one really special although it is a bi pricey, it is worth it!
Report
Gina
Gina
Feb 12, 2015
Just got my first box of Wantable makeup for February! I really, absolutely love it. As a subscriber, I paid $36 and (looking online) got about $70 worth of makeup. Everything was full size and 3/4 items I recceived, I immediately loved! I have heard that 4-5 full items is the norm, so hopefully next month I will be seeing an extra item in the mail. I did have a slight problem with them accepting and charging my card, so I have sent them an email and will see how good their customer service is. In my box: Cara Cosmetics Electra Skin Shimmer, a Lord & Berry Smudgeproof eye pencil, a Tapered Blending Brush from Bodyography, and Bodyography Expressions in 'sleek'. The Bodyography Expressions (eyeshadow?) was off tone for me, but product-wise, the quality was still extraordinary for the amount I paid.
Report
Meagan Kristine Mann
Meagan Kristine Mann
Dec 13, 2014
I have received this box for 3 months now and it has slowly become one of my favorites. It took some tinkering with my quiz settings after the first month (which was unremarkable IMO) but the following 2 months were fantastic. Of all my boxes, Wantable makeup sends me out products that I find myself using daily in my routine (eyebrow pencils, foundation, blush, etc...). It's expensive, but I love it and I think it's worth it. 12/14
Report
Missy Smith
Missy Smith
Nov 19, 2014
Hello! I received an email today saying if I followed the link I could save 50% off my first order. I keep trying the link in my email but it doesn't take off the 50%. Can u please put up another link or something??
Report
 Christine
Christine
Jun 4, 2014
I have received four boxes, each with four products. Of the 16 products, 10 come from 4 companies: ‘Trini Beauty (3 items), Sorme (3 items), Girlactik Beauty (2 items) and Mistrura Beauty (2 items). This is an expensive subscription service and I expect a better variety. None of these products are part of my makeup routine.
Report

The Best Deals Delivered

enter your email for cool stuff

Privacy Notice

About MSA

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. It's our goal to help you discover new and exciting products, serving as a trusted partner in your online shopping experience. Our team is dedicated to providing honest and thorough product reviews, but also empowering the community to learn from each other through trusted reviews of your own. Read our editorial and community guidelines to learn more.