Fall has been a difficult season for me this year, but my day was instantly brightened when I spotted the Alltrue Fall 2025 box waiting on my doorstep. I couldn’t wait to dive in and see everything inside!
Alltrue is a quarterly subscription that offers a customizable selection of socially conscious lifestyle products. While I received a curated box, this season’s choices were plentiful—there truly seemed to be something for everyone. Perfectly aligned with the cozy spirit of fall, I was eager to discover what was in store!
ACTIVE DEAL: Limited Time Only! $15 off of your first Alltrue box
CODE: MSA15OFF
The Cost: $79.95 per quarter + free shipping within the contiguous USA ($7.95 shipping Canada, Hawaii, Alaska, and US Territories), or $69.95 per box when you sign up for an annual subscription.
This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the editorial guidelines to learn more about how we review boxes.)
How does Alltrue work?
Each Alltrue box contains 6-8 products. There are different levels of customization available to their annual and seasonal subscribers.
From Alltrue:
Every seasonal box includes 6-8 sustainable, full size products, at sample size prices — and annual members get to customize the products that go in each box!
As a reviewer, I have previously been able to customize all tiers of this box, but this season I received a curated box.
The booklet that came with the box included a couple of articles, a list of the tiered items for the fall season, and a recipe. I enjoyed flipping through it while sipping my morning coffee and immediately started craving the focaccia with roasted squash and herbs. I actually sold all of my butternut squash this year, but I saved the recipe for future use!
What's Inside The Alltrue Box?
This season, there were three tiers of items to choose from, along with three additional selections. Everything was packaged neatly and arrived in perfect condition—I couldn’t wait to dig in!
Category 1
Coalatree - Nomad Packable Duffel - Retail Value $50
In the first category, there were eight different options, with retail values ranging from $30 to $160. As I mentioned above, I received a curated box, so I didn’t get to choose—but I did end up with one of the lower-priced items. The $50 packable duffel bag I received is made by a reputable brand and is considered eco-friendly. Constructed from reinforced nylon, this 22-liter bag folds neatly into its own pocket and is perfect to keep in my car for storage, shopping trips, or overnight stays. Overall, I think the quality and size are decent, though the $50 price point feels a bit steep. Honestly, though, had I been given a choice, I probably would have picked the duffel anyway, as it’s the item best suited to my current season of life.
Category 2
Dime Sunglasses - Retail Value $60
In the second category, there were five options to choose from, with values ranging from $40 to $60. Once again, I didn’t get to make my own selection this season, but I did receive the highest-value item—a pair of Dime sunglasses. These cat-eye glasses feature a tan plastic frame with polarized lenses. The quality is impressive; they’re well made, with sturdy, thick arms that feel comfortable to wear. Channeling a vintage 1950s–1960s vibe, these sunnies were a fun addition to my accessory collection, and I was happy to stash them in my car for bright, sunny mornings.
I’ve never tried a cat-eye style of sunglasses before, but I think I’m a fan! The tan frames actually complemented my face shape nicely and made me feel pretty chic. If they’d been white, I totally would’ve felt like Wendy Peffercorn from The Sandlot—but this is a close second! I’ll definitely have to pair these with a red lippie for that classic, retro look.
Category 3
Bamboozle Measuring Cup & Spoon Set - Retail Value $28
The third category also included five different options: Sea Salt Shimmer Spray, a Pickleball Set, Measuring Cups, Roll-On Perfume, and Bombas Socks. Had I been given the choice, I would have picked the measuring set—and that’s exactly what I received! I love this eco-friendly bamboo fiber set; the neutral colors are gorgeous, and the quality is excellent. I’d been limping along with an old set, so this was a really nice upgrade, and they work beautifully. Easy to wash and attached with a ball chain, they stay together nicely and store well. Overall, I’m extremely impressed!
While I’d already sold all of our squash, I still had a few pie pumpkins left—so we made a pie! My new set of measuring cups was a hit, and I was so happy to have received them.
Wander Beauty - Volumizing Mascara - Retail Value $26
The next item I received wasn’t listed in the booklet, but it was mentioned on the page with the QR code that can be scanned for more information about the other three products. I received the Wander Beauty Volumizing Mascara and absolutely love it—the rich black hue, waterproof formula, and clump- and smudge-free finish are fantastic. This brand also steers clear of parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrance, and mineral oil. I also really like the fluffy brush and found that the formula wears beautifully throughout the day.
Here you can see the Wander Beauty mascara after a full day of wear—with absolutely no touch-ups! I love this smudge-proof formula.
Earth Harbor Mermaid Milk Moisturizer - Retail Value $23.99
The next item I received was a moisturizer from Earth Harbor called “Mermaid Milk.” It has a lovely consistency and was a refreshing addition to my skincare routine. Featuring spirulina and matcha, which help boost skin radiance and health, this cream wears beautifully under makeup and doesn’t leave a greasy feel. I’ve been using a bit of tretinoin lately, which has made my skin extra dry, and this moisturizer has really brought it back to life. I’m absolutely loving this inclusion!
Alltrue Ceramic Bud Vase - Retail Value $20
The last item I received for the Fall Alltrue season was a small ceramic bud vase. As a gardener, I really appreciate this inclusion, though I felt it would have been better suited for the spring or summer season rather than fall. Since we just plowed under our garden, I didn’t have any buds to test in the vase, but I can already see how useful it will be come mid-May. The color and design are lovely, and I enjoy this style of vase for displaying broken-stemmed flowers—though the timing feels a bit off.
Value - Was This Box Worth It?
The Cost: $79.95 per quarter + free shipping within the contiguous USA ($7.95 shipping Canada, Hawaii, Alaska, and US Territories), or $69.95 per box when you sign up for an annual subscription.
The Alltrue Fall 2025 Box contains six items. The subscription claims a value of up to $250+ per box. The items I selected totaled around $210 based on retail prices I found online, which is a bit lower than the stated value. I suspect that Alltrue may use slightly inflated pricing on their website to reach that $250 estimate.
While I know many subscribers are still apprehensive after the chaos that previously surrounded this subscription, (they definitely have reason to be), it seems things have been fairly stable over the past couple of years. With a great variety of items I was impressed by the quality and selection I received. My favorite items were the duffel bag, measuring cups, mascara, and moisturizing cream—but honestly, I use everything almost daily, which, to me, is pretty amazing.
To Wrap Up:
Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes, this box is still available.
What do you think of the Fall 2025 Box? Click below to write a review!
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.