Facebook PixelMargot Elena Discovery Box Fall 2022 Review + Exclusive MSA Coupon | My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Margot Elena Discovery Box Fall 2022 Review + Exclusive MSA Coupon

Christen Russo
ByChristen RussoSep 15, 2022 | 15 comments

Margot Elena Fall 2022 everything inside the box

The Seasonal Subscription Box from Margot Elena is a quarterly subscription box featuring full-size beauty and lifestyle items. (If you aren't familiar with this brand, it's carried in stores like Anthropologie.)

For $59.99 a quarter + $6.95 shipping (to the contiguous US only), you'll discover the world of All Things Beautiful—this box is filled with over $200 worth of full-sized products curated by the Margot Elena team.

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Opening The Box

 

I still have the feeling of summer in my bones, but I am so ready for the afternoons to cool down like the mornings and evenings have. While I wait, I'm more than happy to have the fall Margot Elena Discovery Box carry the torch toward the most delightfully moody season, when not only the colors become richer all around me, but the changes in the feeling of the air and atmosphere bring a depth to my days. If there's one brand that knows how to capture depth in a bottle, it's Margot Elena. Let's explore how they've painted the upcoming fall season together.

 

Before we jump in, here's a look at the folded info card for this quarter. You can see there are products included from Archive (this is a new one to me!), The Cottage Greenhouse, Infinite She, and Tokyo Milk. The floral illustrations on the card do an amazing job of setting the tone of the scents to come.

Here's What's Inside

Exclusive! Archive Mini Journey Within Body Lotion, 10 oz — Listed Value $24 (Buy the 16.5 oz version for $34)

Margot Elena Fall 2022 Archive lotion

Margot Elena recently introduced a new line, Archive. Their description of the line as a whole is:

Exquisitely tailored & carefully crafted. Take an incredible journey to parts unknown, where past and present blend in this collection of inspired essences.

The label alone is "tailored;" the refined counterpart to the wild designs on TokyoMilk products. The glass bottle that contains this lotion is gorgeous on a countertop or shelf. The scent is simultaneously familiar and fresh, it's floral and powdery without being too bright. The image that comes to mind for me is a really inviting boutique furniture store. Margot Elena carries so many thick, deeply moisturizing creams, but this is a lighter consistency, definitely more in line with a lotion (as the name suggests). Of course, its perfumey fragrance is just as lasting as always. This is really a beautiful scent. To call the bottle "mini" is surprising, but it's a smaller edition of what's available to purchase on their site.

The Cottage Greenhouse Japanese Plum & White Tea Handcreme, 4 oz — Listed Value $26 (Buy the 2 oz travel size for $14)

 

The Cottage Greenhouse is a line that I've often claimed to have more straightforward scents than other Margot Elena lines, and that's certainly true of this Japanese Plum & White Tea cream. To me this is a true floral scent, and one I already know thanks to the jar of whipped body butter that was sent in this box last fall. To be honest, these first two products I've explored in this autumn box are lighter than I was expecting, but as far as floral scents go, this Japanese Plum & White tea is on the richer side. These full-size tubes of handcreme never get old—they're just as wonderful for gifting (I love seeing eyes widen as they're received) as they are keeping in every bag I own.

The Cottage Greenhouse Cucumber & Honey Dry Body Oil, 4 fl oz — Retail Value $28

 

Margot Elena does body oils really well. To reference last fall's box again, they sent a Lollia scent in oil form, and it's the only scented product I've found that works well to hydrate my legs after shaving without burning. I've used it regularly (maybe 1-2 times per week) since then, and I still have a good 2/3 of the bottle left. So I'll have to decide whether I want to gift this new bottle or store it to open next. This one is cucumber-forward with floral notes. It comes off as highly scented when you open the lid, stick your nose up to it, and sniff, but in use it's much lighter.

Infinite She Inspired Lip Balm — Retail Value $10

 

I love a good, fat stick of lip balm. That full-lip coverage with one swipe feels so nice going on. With a scent name like Rose Hip and Hibiscus, I was obviously expecting a floral explosion, but in reality this lip balm is so squarely berry-scented to me. I keep coming back to it wondering if this is the time I'll sense the rose or hibiscus, but I am just not catching it. We all know that scents can bring up some serious nostalgia, and I'm transported to the Lip Smacker days—what, 20 years ago? Incredible. This is obviously a classier version of that old lip balm, and with natural ingredients, but I continue to think of Infinite She as being more catered to a younger crowd.

TokyoMilk Black Widow Eau de Parfum, 1.6 fl oz — Retail Value $48

 

I'm so into the spooky black widow spider on the side of this TokyoMilk perfume—what a statement! It's from their TokyoMilk Dark line, which I had yet to explore until now. Here's what they say about Dark:

TokyoMilk Dark is a world where elegant design meets irresistibly daring fragrance & formulas for a provocative collection unlike any other. An intoxicating exploration into the alchemy of allure.

So, how does it smell? Very musky, surprisingly traditional; like a cologne but with a hint of femininity to it. After wearing it for a day, I noticed it maintains its original scent, rather than divulging layers with wear like other TokyoMilk perfumes do. Frankly, I was hoping for something a little more unique, having come to expect weirder things from TokyoMilk—but maybe this perfume is TokyoMilk counterculture in its air of the ordinary. My critique doesn't in any way mean I don't like it. I actually really do, and as with all perfumes from Margot Elena, this one has some great staying power.

TokyoMilk Gin & Rosewater Parfum Crema Délice, 2.5 oz — Retail Value $24

 

Here's another scent I know and love, and despite the grit that might be suggested by the "gin" of Gin & Rosewater, it's actually pretty bright and citrusy. I don't pick up on much floral in this one, but I know it's in there somewhere, making the greater scent the lovely presentation that it is. Remember that Parfum Crema isn't handcreme, and things can get intense if it's used that way!

New! TokyoMilk Follow Your Dreams Candle — Listed Value $24

 

I was so thrilled to find this candle in my box, firstly because candles are always a treat to receive, and this one is a nice, ample size. But also because my four-year-old daughter has incredible enthusiasm over pink and unicorns. The scent is a beautiful blend of mandarin, rose, and more, with a bit of a sugary vibe to it, but very pleasant, and it throws nicely.

TokyoMilk Big Thank You, Bear Hug, and Oh Snap Signature Stationery Greeting Cards — Retail Value $16.50 (sold separately at $5.50 each)

 

This quarter's spread of greeting cards stock my stationery drawer up with a thank you card, a "bear hug" card that could be used for sympathy or just because, and a birthday card. The hippo thank you card and the alligator birthday card are both accented with some glitter. These TokyoMilk cards are cute, but a little mild—I send a lot of mail and like to go a bit bigger with the personality, so I'm hoping we are sent some Infinite She cards in future boxes.

Value - Was This Box Worth It?

The Cost: $59.99 + $6.95 shipping to the contiguous United States.

Value Breakdown: Fall 2022 in the world of the Margot Elena Discovery Box was a mix of products that are new (not yet on the site!), exclusive (sizes you won't find elsewhere), and available for purchase. Due to this mix, I've used a combination of retail values and listed values to determine that everything adds up to $200.50, as indicated in the info card. That's a fantastic value, and higher than last season. There were 8 products in this quarter's box (considering the 3 cards as one), which breaks down to $8.37 per item. That's a huge discount for a spread of products that are of amazing quality. And, the joy that comes from unboxing day is priceless. 

Key Takeaways

Margot Elena Discovery Box was delightful as always. I was expecting the spread for fall to be deeper, bolder, and richer, which isn't exactly how I would characterize the overall curation here, but I'm still in love with what they offered. My top picks for this quarter are the Archive lotion and the TokyoMilk Follow Your Dreams Candle. While I was a little underwhelmed by the Black Widow perfume, I'm still glad to have it in my collection to wear when the mood is right.

Keep track of your subscriptions by adding this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Other Things You Should Know

When is this box available? This box is seasonal, shipping out 4 times a year.

Can I still get this box if I sign up today? Yes, as of the publication of this review, Fall 2022 is still in stock. Order ASAP to receive it, or look forward to the Winter 2022 box, which is estimated to start shipping on December 1.

Check out all of our Margot Elena Discovery Box reviews!

What do you think of the Margot Elena Discovery Box

Christen Russo
Christen Russo

Hi there, I'm Christen! I've been writing with MSA since 2017. I am all sorts of things: a writer, a mother, an outdoors-lover, a low-maintenance self-carer, and general hungry person.

You'll find me collecting stationery and squirreling away stickers, riding bikes and swimming with my family, creating outfits in earth tones and flowy silhouettes that make me feel amazing, wearing big earrings, drinking beer and asking my husband to feed me harmonies to sing, taking my vitamins, living for live music, roping everyone into a craft, being human and vulnerable, and celebrating the phenomenon of being alive.


Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

15 comments

sparker

This is only my third box, but it had a lot less “wow” for me than the previous two. That said, I loved the Tokyomilk scents, and since I can only go through so much lotion, I am happy to have some products to gift for the holidays. The candle scent wasn’t bad, but it’s just not for me, so I’ll pass it along!

I was really surprised with the black widow perfume. It was not at all what I expected, its very charming and pleasant, and I’ve been wearing it daily!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Caligirl

I am not sad I missed this. I have been subscribed since the 1st box. I miss the special one of a kind items. Will subscribe again just need to years of stash.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kelly

I adore this box and will definitely use all these items. I do wonder why they have a Tokyo Milk spray perfume AND a Tokyo Milk cream perfume again – a combo which they also had in the last box. I would have liked to see a body cream or bath product this time instead of the cream – which lasts forever.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Christen

I agree that these items last so long that it’s crucial for a product-type switch-up quarter to quarter. Otherwise new items end up sitting in a storage basket somewhere for months!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

SBR

I am using my solid lotion perfume before bed 🤣. It smells good and relaxes me, but two should still last forever. I might use it on my cuticles or something.

Like This CommentLike

Anita F

I received my box and am very happy with it but it’s only my third box. The lotion bottle is actually quite large and everything smells wonderful- especially the candle and the crème perfume. I love the little cards too!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Vicki

I’ve gotten this box for a few years now, and unfortunately I’m not super impressed by this one. I’ve already gotten note cards multiple times…I’d like to see a fun surprise item for the home, like a beautiful kitchen towel or tote bag. This was done occasionally in previous years and I miss the element of surprise.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Christen

I, too, am getting a little tired of the same note cards quarter after quarter. As a stationery fanatic I’d be game to just have a switch-up of card style (like I said in the review), but a surprise home item would be even better!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

SBR

I would love a home item instead of the cards. Luckily, my 13yo loves the cards and is able to use most as birthday cards for her friends. I believe they all have been blank inside which gives her more room to do artwork for her friends!

Like This CommentLike

Rebecca

Margot Elena boxes are consistently amazing. The variety of products, the quality and the lovely presentation make this one a big winner in the sub box world. The lotion in a 10 oz bottle is certainly not a sample size. While not currently available on the website, this may be a product they are considering offering in a smaller size, like the dry body oil which comes in 4 oz and 8 oz. I find Margot Elena’s curations to be a fabulous value and a great gift to myself.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

mia

What’s with the smaller size body lotion? This box is supposed to be full size only. Ten ounce is still a big bottle of lotion, but it’s not even available on their website. It’s like they made a smaller one just for their sub box.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Alice

Mia, I agree. I wrote a longer comment yesterday, but MSA didn’t publish it for some reason (?).

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Alice

Right?! I don’t sub to ME; however, all companies believe we are too stupid to notice product sizes in any genre.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Christen

Hey, Alice! I have no idea why this happened but something in our system triggered the need for me (as the author) to approve your comment, which is not the norm, and I didn’t see the notification until a few days later. I’m definitely not trying to gaslight you, I promise! Sorry about that!

Like This CommentLike

Alice

Note to anyone reading: This comment says ‘a day ago’; however, MSA didn’t publish it until a few moments ago AFTER I wrote the other reply to Mia, mentioning my missing comment. Gaslight, anyone?!

Like This CommentLike