My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm September 2021 Box – Full Spoilers

ByMSASep 7, 2021 | 27 comments

4.3 overall rating
1980 Ratings | 226 Reviews

BoxyCharm is an MSA reader favorite because it packs 4 to 5 full-size beauty products into its subscription box for a price that’s hard to beat. Whether you’re on the fence about cashing in or just can’t wait for your next delivery, here’s what’s in store for an August 2021 BoxyCharm delivery.

Drum roll, please … here are the full spoilers for the BoxyCharm September 2021 Base box!

GLAMGLOW YOUTHMUD® Glow Stimulating & Exfoliating Treatment Mask (Retail Value $60.00)

BLINC Glow Getter Face Palette (Retail Value $50.00)

Elaina Badro BabyBlues Set (Retail Value $58.00)

Half Caked Best Friends Forever ‘In Bloom’ + Duo Fiber Brush Set (Retail Value $22.00)

Huda Beauty Demi Matte Cream Lipstick (Retail Value$20.00)

Georgette Klinger Marula Primer (Retail Value $32.00)

DR. BRANDT Triple Antioxidant Eye Cream (Retail Value $46.00)

Saint Luxe Beauty Brow Gel (Retail Value $22.00)

Hip Hop Base Stick | Pinky Rose Cosmetics®

Pinky Rose Cosmetics MULTI-USE MAKEUP BASE STICKS (Retail Value $20.00)

Moisturizing Lipstick | REALHER Makeup

REALHER Moisturizing Lipstick (Retail Value $18.00)

Quick Slick Hair Essence | INH Hair

Insert Name Here Quick Slick Hair Essence (Retail Value $22.00)

Lala's Everyday Mascara – #GIVE THEM LALA BEAUTY

Give Them Lala Beauty Mascara (Retail Value $20.00)


Curious about BoxyCharm and all these choices? Let’s talk about the box …

The box: BoxyCharm Base Box

The price: $25 (valued at $270)

Learn more about BoxyCharm by reading our reviews, and find out why BoxyCharm is an MSA reader favorite.

BoxyCharm ($25 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 4-5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and established brands, with a total retail value of over $100 in every box. The beauty item... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



The glow getter palette was such a letdown:( There was practically no payoff or pigment except for the ugly reddish contour/bronzer. Then a hair slicker wand?!! I also got an eyebrow gel too. Do they think my hair and eyebrows are unruly and out of control? Ugh. What a terrible box:(


I actually got a pretty decent base box…. Glamglow mask. Elemis superfood cleansing balm, la la mascara, the two make up sticks and the blush with the brush set
For $25
So much negativity and complaining and I see the same people every month saying this sucks I am cancelling but every month they are still here complaining. For $25 you can do so much worse.


I signed back up for august because I wanted the free murad moisturizer and I saw the box actually had potential. September box is a buzzkill and I’m ready to dump BC again.


Am I missing something? lol I didnt get any of the thing sshown above. lol


I just opened my box and there is a Manna Kadar setting spray included. So I guess they are just sending out whatever they want.


Have been using the Manna Kadar spray as a body spray. Have gotten so many of them and don’t want anything Manna Kadar going near my face with all the bad ingredients.

Kelly S McElravey

I havent even gotten my box for this month yet. Some months it is as late as the 23rd of the month before I get it.

Angela DeSilva

I’ve gotten mine on the last day of the month before! I still don’t have mine yet one is scheduled for the 27th. I hate FedEx they’re so slow!

Jodi Bone

I’ve been w/Boxycharm since ‘18 & ‘used’ to receive both of my Boxes by 8th every month!! Later I also subscribed my Daughter for Boxy/Premium (so I could keep my Products) We’d receive our Boxys around 6th & then both Premium boxes would come in a day or 2 later, DEF by the 8th! Once IPSY bought/merged w/Boxycharm the Mayhem started!! I’ve contacted BC several times in regards to FACTs: The Addon/Popup Store opens & since we’d NOT Recvd our (4) Boxes?? had’0’ idea IF we wanted &/or Needed to Buy Items NOT Recvd in Boxes. A few times I ordered off Store, then our Boxes would finally appear having SAME Products I JUST ordered from Sales Store. We’ve accumulated TONS of Products which are Not even swatched/opened. Last month I decided to let MY BC Boxes go & then just subscribe to Fashionsta, Belly Bundle (Pregnancy/Baby box)Allure & BEST BOX: “Margot Elena” sub box. For past month(s) Boxycharm will Email me DAILY all Kinds of Freebies & incentives just to resubscribe!! I love Boxycharm & have been soooo tempted!! I will say~IF I ever resubscribe to IPSY? Just shoot me now!! No one deserves the punishmentS IPSY will put one through!! Good Luck on Recving your BC!😃If it’s any consolation your not alone~My daughters’ Premium & Luxe don’t even have tracking # yet😢


I’m been so irritated with Boxy not having spoilers or an app, etc. Then they canceled one item after the next in my pop up order. The final straw was my charms order. I was SO mad- I had bought the Cannuka face cream and 6 weeks went by with no word from them. Of course they took the money that day though! Then I get an email saying they canceled my order and were refunding me- IN CHARMS. If they would have just shipped it when I bought it instead of waiting so long it wouldn’t have been out of stock. The sub box was a whole nother set of issues.. I’m just so done with Boxy at this point. I want to cash out my $50 in charms and be done for good!

Jodi Bone

I’m with you on the Charm room!! I had SOO many charms & actually caught the Charm room open. I ordered ‘something’ obviously not worth remembering AND these Cute/Awesome Water Bottles for my Daughter. When I ordered using these Charms~ my Daughter was in her 1ST month of Pregnancy & Desperately needed Water Bottles. Last month I let MY Base, Premium & Luxe Boxes go after Computer wouldn’t let me change my Debit Card & for once Boxycharm CS didn’t help me. Since I subscribed & paid for My Daughters Boxycharm I can still shop Addons/Popup & enjoyed having Extra $$ in my Bank Acct. Since I let my (3) Boxes go??… Boxycharm Emails DAILY w/Deals & Finally fixed my Accounting Page. I Recvd an Email wanting to know IF certain Issues were addressed satisfactory for Me. The Issue regarding NOT recving my Charm room order was FINALLY addressed LAST Week..those Water Bottles I didn’t receive?? Boxycharm gave me $2 credit back (seriously??!) in Charm points..that’d probably be a ‘little’ beneficial IF I was still a charmer!! Remember I ordered Charm Items in my Daughter first Month of Pregnancy?? She’s in last week of her 8TH Month~due ANY Day/week now. So that’s the time frame of giving Boxycharm enough time to Mail out for anyone’s reference. Good Luck Ladies! I subscribed to “Margot Elena” & SOOO Happy!! You ladies need to check that SUB Box out!! TRUST ME 🤗


They did the same with the charm room to me too. And didnt bother to say anything, and I had to send 3 message. Ipsycharm is going down hill


I finally decided to reactivate. I miss the sales and the free gifts actually interested me. Most of these spoilers are alright for me. I don’t want anything Real Her. Not interested in the Half Caked stuff and the base sticks are actually retailed at $10 on the company website and $8 at Forever 21. I don’t tend to approve of obviously inflated prices being in my boxes. Otherwise I’m good with these and hopefully won’t end up with the couple of things I don’t want.


The retail value of the Pinky Rose base sticks is correct. It’s a set of 2 sold for $20.


I found NOT expecting anything good in the box, I am pleasantly surprised time and time again, month after month.

When I fixated and obsessed I didn’t get what I wanted. Now that I just focus on the surprise of opening it, Boxy has been good to me.

Ya’ll might not agree, but this works for me.


I agree. Like I said above, for $25 I’m pretty happy. I spend that on a takeout order. People need to see the glass half full….

Angela DeSilva

Both boxy and Ipsy are sending all garbage this month I’m so done!!! I’d rather spend my money elsewhere and pick my own makeup!! Canceling all three subscriptions for both.


I agree. My ipsy plus was about the same RV as my Ipsy regular this month for some reason. Im still favouring Ipsy on the sheer fact that I can pick 3 of the 5 though so I KNOW I will actually use a majority.. Boxy is just a shot in the dark for the same price. The only thing appealing anymore about Boxy is the FFF type sales they have so I can start collecting Christmas gifts.. after that I’m done with Boxy.


Things I want: glamglow, Dr. Brandt. Things I’ll get: Brush set (I think there’s a rule that everyone needs a new set every month) brow gel (I have microblading and they know it), black mascara, lipstick in the closest shade to “corpse” they can find and base sticks that are off by a minimum of three shades.


I thought that was just my crappy luck, Rebecca! Know what looks horrible on me with my blonde hair, even more blonde brows and lashes, and fair skin with pink undertones?? Anything brown. And what do I usually end up with? Yep – neutrals in all shades of brown. Nothing quite like a super nude lipstick to make my lips disappear completely from my face! And the brushes…..I’ve given away/gifted complete sets and I still have more than I can ever remember. Of course, Ipsy sends me a new single brush almost every single month too – never a big, fluffy powder or fan brush either…..always a highlight brush or a shadow blender (along with yet another neutral/brown single shadow. Incidentally, if anyone needs a liquid eyeliner, I’m totally your girl!!!


I’ll take your liquid liner and give you the endless fake lashes and lipsticks I get when I wear neither lol.


Haha…whenever I see something in the spoilers reveal that I actually, truly want, my first thought is always “too bad I won’t get it”.

Jess B

I mean even if you cancel the resubscribe free gifts aren’t good anymore!! lol


Time to cancel basebox for me. They went downhill.


Boxycharm is so bad anymore.


Not excited for September’s box.


Remember the good ole days when BC was exciting?
MSA, there is another error in your narrative.

You Might Also Like

Sugarfina 2021 Santa’s Workshop Advent Calendar: Available Now
Sugarfina 2021 Santa’s Workshop Advent Calendar: Available Now
September 23, 2021
Confessions of a Swapper: NatlovesMelody
Confessions of a Swapper: NatlovesMelody
September 22, 2021
AIA Beauty Bundle: October 2021 Box Will Feature Full-Size ColourPop Products
AIA Beauty Bundle: October 2021 Box Will Feature Full-Size ColourPop Products
September 17, 2021
GlossyBox Subscription September 2021 Review + Coupon
GlossyBox Subscription September 2021 Review + Coupon
September 22, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.