Facebook PixelThe Crafter's Box ‘Handmade Paper’ Review – April 2021
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Crafter’s Box ‘Handmade Paper’ Review – April 2021

Erin Pullmann
ByErin PullmannMay 12, 2021 | 9 comments

Crafter Box April Box Contents

The Crafter's Box
4 overall rating
1 Ratings | 0 Reviews

The Crafter's Box is an artisan craft subscription box that features a different, unique craft each month that is designed with the crafty adult in mind. The boxes are thoughtfully curated with high-end materials so that your finished products are modern and luxe. There's also an accompanying video workshop led by the featured artist that introduces you to the craft and provides you with detailed instructions to complete the project.

Subscribers get first access to new workshops for $65 per month, and the remaining workshops are later available to purchase in The Crafter's Box marketplace for $75. So, members save $10 and are guaranteed to receive the newest workshop.

This review is of the Crafter’s Box Handmade Paper workshop. 

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Crafter Box Handmade Paper Open Box

About The Crafter's Box

The Subscription Box: The Crafter's Box 

The Cost: $65.00 per month + free U.S. shipping (save with longer subscriptions)

ACTIVE DEAL: Get 25% off your first box!

The Products: A shipped kit of curated tools and materials + a new digital workshop by the featured maker of the month

Ships to: The U.S. for free and internationally for varying rates

Good to Know: The month's featured project is announced on the 1st and subscribers have until the 8th to pause, skip, or swap that month. Projects are designed to be for ages 18+.

The Crafter's Box "Handmade Paper" Review

Let's take a look inside this box curated for April -- the craft featured is making handmade paper!


We received a folded info card this month detailing information on what's included in the box, as well as a short bio on the featured maker this month, mixed media artist Rae Samuels of Sweet Lotus Co. For this workshop, Rae walks us through the process of creating handmade paper.

Now, onto the items!


Arnold Grummer Pour Handmold and Deckle (5.5" x 8.5") – Retail Value $39.90

This beautiful wood handmold and deckle will be used to turn mushy pulp into paper! It's the kind of tool that makes you feel like you've accomplished something by learning to use it. If you really enjoy making paper and want to make a new hobby of it, this is a sturdy, high-quality tool that you will get a lot of use out of.

Medium Paper Press Bar (2.5" x 6")

This bar will be used in pressing and drying your paper. When you're done, it will also make a great paperweight!


Medium Couch Sheets (6" x 9") - Retail value of comparable product $6.99 on Amazon)

After coming out of the mold, your homemade paper will dry on these sheets. You can only use them once, so if you want to keep making paper, you'll have to pick up more elsewhere.


Dried Rose Petals 

This is the fun part! We'll use these fragrant dried rose petals to embellish our paper.


Other Materials

The rest of the materials and tools we received include a microfiber cloth, clothespins, a sponge, and 3 feet of 12-ply cotton which will all be used during the pressing and drying process. The 20lb Hammermill printer paper and brown paper bag are what we'll use to make our pulp. Additional tools that you'll need to have on hand include a square or rectangular tub with a flat bottom (at least 6.5" x 10"), mixing bowls, a 1/2 cup measuring scoop and a small blender or immersion blender. I'd also recommend having towels on hand because there's a good chance you'll be spilling some water.

In addition to the tools and materials in this kit, our workshop also includes a digital workshop valued at $25.00 (this is the video access only price).

Now, let's make some paper!


The first step is to make pulp. Rip up your printer paper and brown paper bag into small pieces and soak it in warm water for at least 30 minutes (but preferably overnight for a softer end product). When you're ready to start the project, blend the paper into pulp using a small smoothie blender or an immersion blender. The consistency should be oatmeal-like but you can leave it a little chunkier for a more rustic look. Be sure to wash all the paper out of your blender right away so it doesn't dry in there!


Next, we form the paper. Submerge your handmold in a tub of water (I didn't have a tub in the right size and had to use a roasting pan) and then add 1/2 cup of pulp. Pick up the mold and let the water fall out. If you notice any transparent areas in the mold, add a little more pulp and repeat the process.


After removing the handmold from the water, open it, remove the paper (keep it stuck to the plastic sheet), and add the wire cover sheet. Now you'll take turns using the sponge, presser bar, and microfiber cloth to remove as much water as you can. Once you've completed this process, lay a couching sheet on the table and flip the paper over onto it. Now you're ready to hang it up to dry for 12 hours using the string and clothespins. If you don't have that much time to dry it, Rae shows you a quicker drying method using an iron in the video.

Once you've gotten a handle on the process, it's time to experiment with embellishments! This looks fancy but doesn't add that much work to the process. Just grab some rose petals and sprinkle them in with your pulp.


In the tutorial, Rae shows us how to make paper embellished with rose petals as well as some gold mica flakes. As a fan of all things sparkly, I really wish the mica had been included in the box! Luckily, I had a similar product at home to experiment with. I decided to try out a sheet of brown paper with both copper flakes and rose petals.


When I woke up the next morning, the paper was dry. It didn't look as smooth or perfectly shaped as Rae's, but I thought it was pretty good for a first try. Next time I might focus on making a smoother pulp to see if that helps.


One of the fun parts of this project was that once the paper was dry, I got to use it to create more crafts! Since I didn't think the paper was smooth enough to write on, I decorated it with stickers from my personal collection to create a birthday card and a little motivational poster to hang on my wall.


Verdict: My first project from The Crafter's Box was fun, accessible, and something I will get use out of. One great thing about this particular project is that you can easily keep going with it without having to spend a lot of money on additional supplies. I would love to master this skill and make some beautiful paper to use in gifts next Christmas.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, you'll receive May's box but you can purchase this workshop individually for $75.

ACTIVE DEAL: Get 25% off your first box!

Value Breakdown: The value of just the handmold and video workshop is $64.50, which is basically the cost of the entire box for subscribers. While most of the items in this box were everyday objects you may already have around the house, you're still getting a great value and will have most of what you need to keep developing your new skill.

Check out our other reviews of The Crafter's Box and the top-rated craft subscription boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you think of The Crafter's Box "Handmade Paper"? What are you going to do with your paper? Let us know in the comments!

Starting at $65.00
Active Deal
Get 25% off your first box!
Subscribe Now
The Crafter's Box is a membership community for those that love to make. Monthly we send a curated box of specialized tools & carefully sourced materials (everything needed) to build a beautiful, grownup craft project and to master a new artistic technique. Our projects are hosted by an expert a... read more.
Erin Pullmann
Erin Pullmann
When Erin finds a new box she loves, she wants the world to share her joy, especially if it includes something sparkly. Her non-subscription addictions include knitting, reading, baking, running and dancing with her husband and daughter.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I’ve been making paper like crazy since I got this box. I keep grabbing random paper to experiment with wherever I can, like the yellow and white printed paper our local breakmakers wrap the loaves in and tissue paper from orders. I just started a whole batch with brown packing paper from my Amazon orders and some taupe mica flakes I bought. I found it’s really nice to make a whole batch using the same ‘recipe’ if you want to make a larger craft with it. I’m working on making custom covers for notebooks/journals to give to friends. I opted to use our immersion blender, we usually just use it for soups or salad dressing, so if the blades dull a little it’s less of a big deal.

Reply ButtonReply


I just watched through “Ascendance of a Bookworm” and I really want to make paper now – haven’t done it since an elementary school project where we made paper from old jean scraps. This would be really fun.

Reply ButtonReply


I haven’t had the chance to try out papermaking – waiting to pick up an old, unused food processor from my parents – but I’m looking forward to it. I used to make handmade books as a hobby, and I’m hoping to pick it back up with some beautiful handmade paper!

Also quite looking forward to May’s cross stitch workshop; I picked up cross stitch during quarona, but it’s been slow-going and I’ll be happy to get some pointers. I’m glad I dumped most of my beauty subs and picked this one up instead.

Reply ButtonReply


I love the look of those copper flakes! You don’t even need the rose petals in that one – just the combo of the brown paper and the copper flakes is beautiful.

I skipped the paper they included in the kit and opted for tissue paper instead and I was really pleased with how mine came out. I can definitely write on mine – maybe a function of the tissue paper being easier to make into really fine pulp – and I got a beautiful deckle edge. I used a lot of white tissue paper, and also pulped a piece of purple tissue paper (thanks, tarte!) and blended some dots of purple in with a mostly white base. It made a marbled effect that I liked, although I’ll admit that I was going for a purple edge and it turned into marbling when I realized that my first pull had holes in it, so I had to mix the pulp up more than I intended to get it to work.

I’m looking forward to making more sheets, and I appreciated that after some crafts that really take a long time to do we got a box that was a little easier this month, but with tools we can keep reusing to do the same project many more times.

Reply ButtonReply

Erin Pullmann

Ooh, I love the purple tissue paper idea! I save my paper from tarte, too!

Reply ButtonReply

Erin Pullmann

Love the idea of using purple tissue paper! I save my paper from tarte, too! And I will definitely try a sheet of brown paper with just the copper flakes!

Reply ButtonReply


Using tissue paper is a great idea! I have a bunch of pink tissue paper from a recent Ulta purchase, I’m definitely going to try making a sheet with that.

Reply ButtonReply


although i am usually a fan of crafters box, I think it is incredibly irresponsible of them to (a) expect that you to have a blender or smoothie maker, and (b) assume that you would be willing to use it for crafts.

unless you are using food-grade paper, you have no guarantee as to how it has been processed or what is in it. Seriously. look up “paper chemicals” on wikipedia!

If paper making is your thing, be safe – get a $10 blender from goodwill and reserve it for crafting.

Reply ButtonReply


They did offer an immersion blender as an add-on and mentioned in the description for the workshop that a blender or food processor was a recommended tool. I agree that implying it’s okay to use the same blender/processor for food and for papermaking is somewhat careless.

Reply ButtonReply