Facebook PixelMy Little Mascara Club Review + Coupon - March 2021
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

My Little Mascara Club Review + Coupon

Naomi Pandolfi
ByNaomi PandolfiMar 14, 2021 | 16 comments

My Little Mascara Club is a natural mascara subscription.

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Inside My Little Mascara Club package

About My Little Mascara Club

The Subscription Box: My Little Mascara Club

The Cost: Starting at $9 + $3 Shipping (Free Shipping on orders over $25)

ACTIVE DEAL: Get 15% off your first month!
CODE: MSA15

The Products: 1 product – mascara (add-ons available: mascara shaping combs, mascara corrector swabs, micellar water, and reusable mascara remover wipes!)

Ships to: The U.S. for free.

Good to Know: My Little Mascara Club subscriptions are available for 30, 45, or 60-day shipments.

My Little Mascara Club Review

My Little Mascara Club arrives with an info card that has a quick overview of the products and instructions.

Here's a quick peek at the contents:

The Best Little Mascara Ever: Length + Definition Formula in Luscious Black, 4 ml - Retail Value $15.00 ($12.00 with subscription)

I am beyond thrilled to have the opportunity to try My Little Mascara Club's The Best Little Mascara Ever: Length + Definition Formula in Luscious Black. Their original length and definition mascara is formulated with over 90% natural ingredients and is sweatproof, smudge-proof, smearproof, and long-lasting. I have very sensitive eyes and I can feel my eyes burn a little with some of the harsher mascaras I've tried ... But this applied smoothly, with no clumping and no harsh scent or irritation to my eyes.

I love how full, defined, and striking this mascara makes my lashes. I'm very impressed with this product, and I love how you can set delivery for 30, 45, or 60 days. Let's face it... You're supposed to change your mascara every few months, and I know that I and a majority of mascara lovers out there use the same one for a very long, long, long – YOU SHOULD THROW IT OUT – time.

Here are some before and after shots of The Best Little Mascara Ever: Length + Definition Formula in Luscious Black.

ERASE: Reusable Mascara Remover Wipes, 1 Pair - Retail Value $8.00 ($5.00 with subscription)

I love the idea of reusable makeup removers. Millions of makeup wipes go in the trash every day. These are super fluffy and soft and make saving Mother Earth and staying on a budget feel like a luxury. Whenever I use a makeup wipe, I find myself rubbing harshly on my eye and I always seem to lose a lash or two. With these eraser wipes, all I had to do was gently hold the moistened eraser to my eye for a few seconds before gently wiping away the mascara. It was perfect and definitely ideal for any lash care system. It made removing my mascara a breeze instead of a chore and left behind no weird raccoon-looking smudges under my eyes.

Little Box of Happy Surprise, 1 cookie

Who doesn't love a surprise? This little box is so adorable and looks like a present. When I opened it up, there was an adorable little fortune cookie with a positive inspirational fortune hidden inside. Mine said, "Listen to your heart – it knows your personal path. Live true and real." Just an extra little bonus to brighten your day.

Verdict: I really enjoyed receiving My Little Mascara Club this month. I'm a huge fan of their natural mascara formula and its killer performance. I was able to see a dramatic difference in the fullness and definition of my lashes after applying the mascara, and the curved design of the mascara brush made application easy. The ERASE: Reusable Mascara Remover Wipes worked splendidly. I'm a huge fan and will continue to remove my mascara with them and most likely begin to hoard them. The Little Box of Happy Surprise was just the icing on the cake. This is a practical, useful subscription that I'm going to recommend to all the mascara lovers in my life. With a retail value of $23, you definitely get a deal on your purchase, and I love that you can select the frequency or infrequency with which you'd like to receive your mascara, wipes, and even other accessories.

UPDATEI've been using My Little Mascara Club's The Best Little Mascara Ever: Length + Definition Formula in Luscious Black for two months now, and I've applied the product 28 times and there's still some left. This mascara continues to really make my lashes POP and I've experienced no irritation or sensitivity to the formula.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? You can choose your formula and select the delivery frequency. You can also cancel or adjust your delivery at any time.

ACTIVE DEAL: Get 15% off your first month!
CODE: MSA15

Value Breakdown: At $17 for this subscription, here’s what you are paying approximately per item:

  • Mascara: $11.09
  • Erase Wipes: $5.91

Alternatively, each item in this box has an average cost of $8.50.

Check out our other favorite beauty subscription boxes!

Keep track of your subscriptions by adding this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Do you have a favorite from this month's My Little Mascara Club?

Starting at $9.00
Active Deal
Get 15% off your first month!
Use Coupon Code MSA15
Subscribe Now
"Tired of clumpy mascara? Join the club! Meet the little mascara everyone is subscribing to, exclusively at My Little Mascara Club. Seriously smudge proof, packed with clean ingredients, and just the right size for you to always have a fresh, clump-free mascara. Delivered! We are 100% Vegan + C... read more.
Naomi Pandolfi
Naomi Pandolfi

Naomi Pandolfi is a skincare obsessed subscription box junkie who is always on the hunt for the best curl defining cream. She is a producer and contributing writer at several online publications, including MSA, The Knockturnal, and Hey Beauti Magazine. Naomi is also the Head of Development at Starfury Productions and is dedicated to helping Black, minority, and underrepresented creators develop and sell projects.


Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

16 comments

Rena

When I read the title of mascara club, I immediately thought…wait, are they doing April Fool’s early this year?! 🤣

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jody

Glad you reviewed it. I don’t think it is for me.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Pink5

I got that set and was severely underwhelmed.

The mascara was clumpy and did not perform. The remover pads recommended a specific brand (Fresh) which is not included.

And while the fortune cookie is a cute inclusion, mine was tasteless and the fortune was dumb.

Unless you go through buckets of mascara every month and are never home, I cannot recommend.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Lorif631

As soon as I see “Made in China” I’m out.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Julia

I don’t see volume. The “before” and “after” photos differ in the tint/color of the lashes. The mascara did not add volume.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Pink5

This version is not a volumizing mascara. There is a separate formula that is supposed to add volume, but I am not certain if it’s available yet.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Cindy

Huh? Just last month I received two sample sizes of Lancôme Idole free in the mail just for asking, and last week the new Benefit Magnetic – no sub, just free samples. Not to mention samples of high end mascaras are always available at Sephora either free or for 100 points. Why would anyone pay for mascara samples?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kat

where are you asking for these free samples? seems like they be a bit stingy with them considering the times

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jackie

I really appreciate the through review but – wow, this seems really expensive for a sample sized mascara, 2 reusable cotton rounds, and a fortune cookie. I completely agree that people use mascara for way too long, but travel-sized mascaras are abundant in sub boxes and free as GWP often.

Maybe it’s great mascara, but the value really doesn’t seem there for me.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Naomi Pandolfi

Oh yeah, I agree Jackie, if you receive MANY subscription boxes this may not be the service for you. I always try and review as if I don’t receive the multiple boxes that I do. I think someone who likes their staple products delivered right to their door as they need them would enjoy a subscription like this.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Pam

I agree, the value isn’t there. And it’s hard to pay for something oversaturated in other boxes.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Snow

This is a really nice review. I like the concept of receiving a new, well performing mascara a set amount of time. Unfortunately I am swimming in mascara. I also like to “cocktail” my mascara and experiment with different formulas and brushes. Hands down, mascara is my most loved (and needed) makeup item with lipstick a super close second.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Naomi Pandolfi

Mascara “Cocktail” I love it lol! I find that the wand and brush matter the most for me. The formula can be awesome but if the brush isn’t on point I’ll still get goopy clumps or thick tarantula leg lashes.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Stephanie

I’m swimming in mascara too! Even though I dread receiving them in sub boxes it’s been nice trying out all the different brands and tossing them fairly quickly. This mascara looks nice but unfortunately, I don’t use made in China products, especially around my eyes.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jenz42

Love the review! I tried this as well and found the mascaras to both be really irritating to my eyes. But the wipes are fantastic and the micellar remover is amazing!! My eyes are just stupid-picky.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Naomi Pandolfi

Yikes! Eyes are super delicate. Oh yeah I was impressed with the wipes! They remove product so throughly.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike