MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Too Faced 2020 Cyber Monday Mystery Bag Review

Too Faced 2020 Black Friday Mystery Bag box

Every Cyber Monday, Too Faced releases a Cyber Monday Grab Bag, and it sells out that day.

FYI – This box is no longer available for sale. If you want a reminder when the next one is available, make sure to sign up for the daily MSA newsletter).

Too Faced 2020 Black Friday Mystery Bag packaging

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Too Faced 2020 Black Friday Mystery Bag all items

About This Too Faced Cyber Monday Mystery Grab Bag

The Box: Too Faced Cyber Monday Mystery Grab Bag

The Cost: $42 ($136 Value)

The Products: 5 Products – “MAY contain products for eyes, face, or lips”

Check out our review of the 2018 Too Faced Mystery Bagthe 2017 Too Faced Mystery Bagthe 2016 Too Faced Mystery Bag and the review of the 2015 Too Faced Mystery Box to see what you can expect!

Too Faced Cyber Monday Mystery Grab Bag Review


Too Faced Damn Girl! Mascara , .43 fl oz (full size) – Retail value $26

This is a new mascara from Too Faced; it released in June. Right away, the wand reminded me of their classic Better Than Sex Mascara, but definitely amped up. It’s as if they scaled up the BTS mascara wand because it’s basically the same shape but bigger. It holds a LOT of product on it, but it didn’t seem to clump upon application as long as I swiped excess product off the tip. Unfortunately, the size of the wand just felt pretty clumsy to me and makes it a little more difficult to get the tiny lashes on the inner or outer edges of my lash line. The formula is definitely a solid, opaque black and it coats my lashes quickly and builds well with a second coat. They marketed this as being really revolutionary, but it didn’t blow my mind and I think I prefer a smaller wand. I’ll definitely use it, though.


Too Faced Love Light Prismatic Highlighter in Blinded by the Light, 9g (full size) – Retail value: $30

This is a pretty highlighter! It doesn’t come across as glittery at all. It’s not overpowering – with a fluffy brush, this blends very well! Additionally, it is versatile because you can build it up for some major glow or you can use a light hand for some more natural highlighting.


Rich & Dazzling High-Shine Sparkling Lip Gloss in Sunset Crush, .12 oz (sample size) – Estimated retail value $10.56 (Buy a .25 oz full size for $22)

I was uncertain about this lip gloss initially, because of the high shine and almost holographic shimmer, but it’s actually very pretty! (You’ll see this on my face below.) It comes across more subtle than it looks like it would in the tube, and it isn’t sticky!


Too Faced Damn Girl! Shamelessly Extra Hair Pin Set – Retail value $19

These are swag, I assume, to go with their new mascara. Unfortunately, these are just not my style. They have a good weight to them but I really don’t think my fine, straight hair would have enough texture to keep these in if I tried. Honestly, I don’t see this being a winning item for most people who got this box – I won’t be alone in wishing this was just any kind of cosmetic instead.


Pretty Rich Diamond Light Eyeshadow Palette – Retail value $49 (currently on sale for $29.40)

Here’s the “hero” item of this kit! This eye shadow palette has 16 different shadows with various finishes (glitter, shimmer, and matte). I like the colors a lot! Too Faced generally has very good pigmentation, and that holds up here. There are 4-5 really glittery shades, and most of those feel a little hard to work with. You’ll want to use a primer on your lids to grab the product (Too Faced makes a glitter-specific eye primer) and to apply your foundation/concealer after your eye shadow to avoid having a bunch of glitter on your cheeks. The mattes seem a little powdery, too, so make sure that you tap off excess. Additionally, there are a couple of shadows that are really close to other shadows in the same palette. Honestly, overall, this is not my favorite palette from Too Faced. It’s still decent, though, and has a large number of colors to play with and you can get a lot of different looks out of it. If you like the colors in this palette, I would say it’s a good buy for the sale price that they have it for right now.


Here are swatches of the eye shadows! First, the top 2 rows, then the bottom 2 rows. Also, every Too Faced palette comes with idea cards with step-by-step walkthroughs of a few different looks. These are always helpful! When I worked at Sephora, these booklets were why I always recommended Too Faced palettes to people who were newer to makeup or wanted more confidence to experiment. Plus, they give me new ideas or color combinations I may not have thought to try.


Here, I’m wearing the mascara, lip gloss, eye shadow, and highlighter – admittedly, I used a very light hand with the highlighter and I realize that it really isn’t that noticeable in photos. (Guys, I was timid because it’s been so long since I’ve done a full face including any kind of contour or highlighter thanks to 2020! Haha.) I love the way the lip gloss looks! And for my eyes, I applied Princess Cut (row 2, column 2) all over my lids, Fancy That (row 1, column 3) in my crease, and Oh, That’s Rich (row 3, column 4) on my outer corners. I really like how they look together!

Verdict: All in all, I’m quite happy with this year’s Too Faced Cyber Monday Mystery Bag! I generally love Too Faced cosmetics, so I knew this would be a pretty safe bet for me. The only downsides for me, really, are the fact that the overall style of the design aesthetic is not one I would naturally gravitate towards, and the hairpins are a bit of a letdown, personally. Even if I liked them, my hair is just not the right type to hold them. That being said, the entire box costs $42, and the palette alone sells for $49. So it’s like you could look at it as buying a decent palette (or the palette’s sale price + the travel-sized lip gloss) and getting some nice full-sized extras! The total value adds up to $134.56, which is the promised retail value.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, this box is now sold out, but sign up for our newsletter to know when the next box becomes available next Black Friday!

Value Breakdown: At $42 for this box, here’s what you are paying approximately per item:

  • Mascara: $8.11
  • Highlighter: $9.36
  • Lip Gloss: $3.30
  • Hair Pins: $5.93
  • Eye Palette: $15.29

What did you think about the Too Faced 2020 Cyber Monday Mystery Box this year? Which product are you most (or even least) excited about?

Written by Haley Faye

Haley Faye

Haley Faye first discovered the wonderful world of subscription boxes in 2012 and began writing for MSA in 2014. Over the years, she has found many subscriptions to love. Now a mom of three, her favorite boxes are ones that dress her kids, help her get organized, feed her family, send her snacks, and offer educational fun for her children.

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: too faced | 26 comments

Comments (26)

  1. Haha I’m down for sell mine off, I don’t do hair pins 🙈

  2. I will happily sell all of the contents, hair pins included!

  3. That lip gloss is so pretty!

  4. If anyone wants to sell their box let me know.

    • I haven’t opened a single product and would be glad to sell you the whole box!

      • I’ll take it

  5. Haley you are stunning as usual.

    • Oh, thank you so much! <3 You're so kind. Thanks for reading!!

  6. You do such a nice job and look so good doing it!!!

    • Thank you, Annette! 😀

  7. I will sell mine.

    • Reply to Dani

  8. I’d recently gotten The Halloween Laura Geller mystery box (two actually, a 10pc and 7pc, did end up with a few repeats between them) when this came out, so didn’t grab it, but I did have some FOMO and wondered if I’d regret not getting it! I do like Too Faced, it was one of the first brands I was really into when I first got into make-up. I’m glad I didn’t get this – the palette and lip gloss would have been nice, but I don’t wear cursewords in my hair, lol. Also I don’t wear mascara much.

    So it’s good I went with the Geller box. It didn’t have an eyeshadow palette, but was over $200 in value and had this very cool “Shades of Mauve” face palette in it that can be used for lip/cheek/eye. Now that I’m in my late thirties, different brands are better for my skin – TooFaced doesn’t work as well for me as it used to, though I still wear some of the eyeshadows (Socialite is so gorgeous.)

    • “I don’t wear curse words in my hair” is hilarious. I agree, those pins are incredibly tacky.

      I rarely do make up mystery boxes any more because I don’t deviate my look. But I absolutely love reading these reviews 👍

  9. You look great!

    I wanted that palette forever and finally bought it a few months back when it was discounted as part of a bundle for like $28. I read bad reviews of it, but didn’t listen. I absolutely hate it and have barely used it. The shades are great, but the formula is so bad. I haven’t tried the mascara and lip gloss yet.

  10. This is the first eyeshadow palette I’ve seen all year that is NOT loaded with oranges. What a great bunch of WEARABLE colors!

  11. Haley, your makeup look is LOVELY! Great job with the eye shadow choices and execution in particular. SO pretty!

    • Aw, thank you so much Sara! <3 Thanks for reading!

  12. I love that mascara (and it looks great on you!), but you’re right, it takes me forever to apply because I am trying not to bump my eyelids with the huge applicator.

  13. Haley — your makeup looks fantastic! I love your eyeshadow and that gloss!

    • Thank you, Victoria! 🙂

  14. I love your beauty reviews, Haley! I wish you did all of them!!!

    • Jen, that is so sweet. Thank you and thanks for reading!!

  15. I might be the only one but I’m obsessed with those hair pins!!! If anyone wants to sell theirs, let me know!

    • I feel the same way. I could really used those hair pins!

      • My box was missing both the mascara and the hair pins. Needless to say I was disappointed!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.