MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm December 2020 Full Spoilers!

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

We have the full December 2020 BoxyCharm base box spoilers!

One December variation includes:

  • The Original MakeUp Eraser – The Sponge
  • Elemis – Superfood Glow Priming Moisturizer
  • VISEART – Seamless Eye Primer
  • Huda Beauty – Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette
  • Glamnetic – Lashes + Black Liquid Magnetic Liner

Your December base box may include:

  • The Original MakeUp Eraser – The Sponge
  • butter LONDON – Melt Away Cuticle Exfoliator
  • Tarte – Maneater™ Mascara
  • MAC Cosmetics – Matte Lipstick


  • VISEART – Seamless Eye Primer
  • ICONIC LONDON – Blaze Chaser Face Palette
  • Elemis – Superfood Glow Priming Moisturizer
  • Eloise Beauty – Get Lit Metallic Foiled Liquid Eyeshadow – Pure Gold


  • Artist Couture – Caliente Palette
  • Ofra Cosmetics – Pressed Banana Powder – 10g
  • Alamar Cosmetics – Pero Primero, Primer! Long Wear Sticky Pigment Base
  • Sutra Beauty – Mini Tourmaline Ceramic Curling Iron (3/4″. 19mm)


  • LUXIE – Eyeconic Eye Set – Rose Gold
  • Glamnetic – Babygirl Lashes + Black Liquid Magnetic Liner
  • Glamnetic – Bella Lashes + Black Liquid Magnetic Liner

  • MAC Cosmetics – Lustre Lipstick
  • MAC Cosmetics – Retro Matte Lipstick – Runway Hit
  • Huda Beauty – Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette
  • Spongelle – Body Wash Infused Buffer – Cherry Tonka Musk

  • Persona Cosmetics – Season One Lip Gloss
  • MAC Cosmetics – Cremesheen Lipstick

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular BoxyCharm box is $25 a month:

Now through 12/31, get a FREE Morphe 8S Stellar Impact Highlighter Palette when you start a new BoxyCharm subscription!

Use code BOXYGLITZ to snag this palette with your new BoxyCharm subscription!

This offer is only for new or returning subscribers to the BoxyCharm Base subscription and can be used for the monthly, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month option. 

Check out our reviews of BoxyCharm to learn more!

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyCharm, BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 34 comments

Comments (34)

  1. Last I checked, you can absolutely wear any color eyeshadow, any time of the year.

  2. I decided to give boxycharm another chance to see if I would be happy with what I got and I was surprised and very happy. I got
    #glamnetic babygirl lashes
    #luxie eyeconic eye set
    #tarte maneater mascara
    #huds beauty eyeshadow – ruby
    #mac matte velvet teddy

  3. This was my first month subscribing.

    I literally did not receive a single one of these items.

    Not one.

    Is that normal??

    • Same. I received the palette with the code I input, one add on item I paid for a 4 other items that weren’t listed. I am really confused?

      • Same. Completely random items. No palette other than the promotional add on one.

    • This was the worst Boxy ever!! This is my second box and it was so bad. Another one of those where things had just been thrown in a box without packaging. I received Tarte Mascara (yay), Ofra Banana Power (no), an orange red Mac lipstick (NO, color was awful), the ugliest cheapest Caliente palette and an ugly brown lip gloss. I did not receive one single spoiler. No lashes, no Huda palette, no Elemis. Now I remember why I quit the first time. Looks like one more box and I’m done.

    • What did you end up getting if you don’t mind me asking? It may have been better? lot of times they do a starter box I think too so could have been that and then next month you choose an item and get a base box.

    • The same thing happened to me…I paid for the 3 months base box subscription. The first month was supposed to be the December 2020 box (per my boxycharm account), but all of the items I received were actually leftovers from the November 2020 box. On my account, I can review the December box itself, but I am not able to review any of the products for extra charms because all of the products I received were from November and there is no option to leave a review anymore on those items. I contacted customer support and all they offered me was a $12 add-ons coupon. Ridiculous.

  4. I was worried, but I actually like most of what I got in my first box. As a bonus for signing up, I got the Bakerie Breakfast in Bed palette, which has some gorgeous colors in it!

    I also got:

    The Huda Ruby palette, which I did not expect to like so much

    An actual wearable nude Mac lipstick

    The Glamnetic set (will save for a costume, as they are way over the top for me!)

    The Luxie brushes (I wanted these)

    The Tarte mascara (will wait to try this)

    That aside, I cancelled before getting my box anyway, as it seems costly to take a chance on, after reading about others’ experiences.

  5. Not happy with my box this month. I didn’t get 1 skincare item. Box #51

    Artist couture caliente palette (yuck)
    Glamnetic lashes
    Tarte maneater mascara (yuck)
    Mac cremesheen lipstick fanfare (yuck)
    Butter London cuticle exfoliator (yuck)

    • Same. I hate this box. The lipstick is okay, but I wouldn’t pay more than $8 for it. No skincare even though my preferences are set to ‘mostly skincare.’ I also didn’t get my box until Dec 31st. Worst one of the year.

  6. Does anyone have an active support boxycharm email? Their customer service is not getting back to me on a missing box from last month Amon either email or Instagram…

    • i was missing charms for my november items, i messaged on the boxycharm website, they replied. their email is not monitored. so best way is message on boxybot chat on the website. bot couldnt answer/resolve my question so it forwarded my message to the help center and got a reply within few days.

      • Thank you , I’ll try that 🙂

  7. Mine came today and I got variation 9.

    * Caliente palette
    * Glamnetic Lashes
    * Elemis Glow Priming Moisture
    * Viseart Eye Primer
    * Butter Cuticle Melter

    I was honestly hoping for the purple Huda palette and a Mac lipstick in a wearable color, but that rarely happens for me so I suppose this is a winner. I don’t see myself using the palette, but I’ll use the other stuff. The palette seems nice, just a little loud and orange for me. The peach shimmer looks beautiful though.

  8. One reason I don’t want to sign up is because I don’t want to end up with crap I have no use for like a curling iron 😂. I literally have a buzzed head and no one would even want it in my family

  9. oh Noooooo I thought they only had matte MAC lipsticks, MAC’s mattes are my HG lipstick and one of the few who pass my “has to stay on my face an hour for every dollar I spent on it” rule. But I don’t do shiny lips. Hopefully if I get a MAC lippie it’ll be matte, maybe it’ll even be new to me.

    I snagged a backup Whirl in add-ons since it’s one of my go-tos when I get to wear lipstick, if I end up with a third that won’t be a problem lmao

    • I love your formula to quantify value. My husband has a similar one where he has to use something at many times for each dollar he paid for it. But, with some makeup that would never work (think Tom Ford Quads), but with your formula, I’d be golden with 10-12 uses. I love it!

      Your dream was my reality. I just received the Charlotte Tilbury Mystery Box. I already have and love her lipstick in Walk of Shame AND I have a back up. I got another one in the mystery box along with a broken blush in Walk of Shame. The accidentally sent another WoS lipstick (that makes FOUR) before sending the blush. I’m not mad.

  10. I was going to subscribe for the curling iron, but I missed choice. Shame because the other items aren’t bad. Oh well lol.

  11. Is it me or does that makeup eraser look like a cat toy lol

    • 98% of my sponges end up being cat toys LOL

    • So glad you posted! I just took the sponge out and rolled the pink ball down the hallway, my cat Sacha was on it in an instant!🤣🤣🤣

      • This is cracking me up. I always use my foundation brushes becuase they make my base look perfect but thsi sponge was sooo soft when I got it damp and tried it. I still would neer pay that much for a “cat toy” but I did find it superior to others I have received. I still will never use it though so Blake, looks like you’re getting a new toy when I get home! 😂🐱‍👤

  12. How are these options better than what Luxe is rolling out this month?

    • I was thinking the same thing. I just opened my luxe box and i was like “huh”, how come i didn’t get a glamnetic lashes?.

      • Same, girl, same.

  13. Typical Boxy… advertise the beautiful Huda & Artist Couture eyeshadow palettes everywhere, then throw in an alternate face palette you might get instead.

    I hope those that get them actually want them instead of the colorful eye palettes. 🤞

  14. They always have couple great products. Everytime I sign up I get a box of junk.( I’ve signed up for multiple month 4 different times.) Nothing Boxy can do to ever get me to sign up again.

    • Yep, happened to me too, bait and switch! The only the Premium box with the Fenty crossover didn’t do that because of limited variation

    • Thats exactly why I canceled Boxy like 8 months ago and everytime I see spoilers I feel even better about that decision. They always advertise great products at first but when the full spoilers come out its like 3 great products and the rest are a bunch of fillers. Only certain people get the great products and everyone else gets boxes full of fillers. I’ll never subscribe to Boxy again. Even Premium wasn’t worth it, its slightly better than the base box but not enough to make it worth the price. I’ll stick with Ipsy, I’ve had the regular GB for two years now and GBP for one year and while every once and a while I get a dud 95% of the time I’m really happy with what they send me. GBP is great and im always happy with what I get especially now that you get to choose 3 products every month

  15. Weren’t these December boxes supposed to be holiday sparkle?

    • “Bubbles & Glitz”

    • Pay no attention to the “theme”, the products never match the theme with Boxy lol

    • There is no excuse for them to send anyone that Caliente palette right now. The web page for the company’s ad copy for it says, “get ready to feel the summer fantasy!” They put this in a December box and sent it to where I’ve already had snow. And it’s a lousy palette. The mattes are pigments that I swatched hours ago and they stain so bad. The orange color would be good as a blaze orange shade for those who go deer hunting. I would have loved the teased Huda palette, just like last month I would have loved the teased ND palette. They are becoming such a consistent disappoinment after so many years that I’m ready to be done with them.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.