Facebook PixelMarshmallow of the Month Club Review - October 2020 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Marshmallow of the Month Club Review – October 2020

Haley Faye
ByHaley FayeNov 2, 2020 | 11 comments

Marhsmallow Of The Month October 2020 box

Marshmallow of the Month Club
0 overall rating
0 Ratings | 0 Reviews

Marshmallow of the Month Club is a monthly subscription that delivers gourmet marshmallows made with all-natural ingredients (and fish-based gelatins so they're pescatarian-friendly), plus homemade graham crackers and some kind of chocolatey treat.

Marhsmallow Of The Month October 2020 inside box

When you sign up, you also get to choose if you prefer cocoa, tea, or coffee for included hot beverages, as well as allergy-accommodating options.

Marhsmallow Of The Month October 2020 packaging

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Marhsmallow Of The Month October 2020 all items

About Marshmallow of the Month Club

The Box: Marshmallow of the Month Club

The Cost: $25/month & free shipping, save with longer-term subscriptions

ACTIVE DEAL: Save 5% off your first box with a 3 or 6-month subscription

The Products: Every month includes half a dozen flavored gourmet marshmallows, different homemade graham crackers, some form of chocolate, a drink packet, and another small treat.

Ships to: The U.S.

Marshmallow of the Month Club Subscription October 2020 Review

First things first: I am obsessed with this packaging! It is so cute! It's a 4x4 cardstock box with pieces that make it look like a s'more! And they wrapped it in fake web and spiders this month for Halloween. Brilliant. Topping off the pleasant surprises is an info card personalized with my name.


The info card explains the flavor of the month: apple marshmallows made with caramelized sugar and a hint of applewood smoked salt. The card also explains that they sent a mini skewer to roast the marshmallows over the caramel praline scented candle they included for indoor s'mores. (Note: toasting a marshmallow over a scented candle is not something I would recommend nor be comfortable doing, but I'll explain that later.)


Caramel Apple Marshmallows

Starting with, of course, the star of the box! These caramel apple marshmallows are made with a short, easy-to-read, all-natural ingredients list. They're also made with fish gelatin so that they're pescatarian friendly. They have more of a bite/chew to them than typical store-bought marshmallows, but they're still fluffy and airy.  The flavor comes through well, too, with the apple cider, caramelized sugar, and applewood smoked sea salt. They're good!


Maple Apple Spiced Graham Crackers

Graham crackers are my fave! I had high expectations for these. I like them, but they didn't wow me. They are really, really crunchy. The flavor is good, but I don't think there's any way these would lend themselves well to s'mores because the marshmallow would smush down too much because the cookies are so hard. But, on their own, they still tasted good.

Marhsmallow Of The Month October 2020 cookie marshmallow sandwich

Marhsmallow Of The Month October 2020 candle and stick

Mini Skewer

Caramel Praline Tea Light

This is the candle and the skewer the info card mentioned earlier. They're adorable, and the candle smells really good. However, I really don't think it's the best idea for them to suggest toasting a marshmallow over it. Scented candles produce chemical fumes when burned and also soot, and these things would make the marshmallow taste pretty bad because it would absorb all of those concentrated things. Also? Probably not the safest idea. Everything that comes up from searching online says not to. I'll still use the little tea candle on its own, but I'll choose my oven to toast the marshmallows. (If you have a gas stove, just toast marshmallows over a burner! It's one of my favorite things!)



These are a tasty extra treat! I'm not generally a huge fan of caramels on their own but these were buttery and smooth and tasted good. My husband liked them, too.


Dillettante Ephemere Dark Chocolate Truffle Cremes - Buy a 10 oz box for $12.57

Oh, my WORD. These chocolate truffles are insane. They're definitely gourmet, and they just totally melt in your mouth. These are delicious and I am actually planning to order a full box as a Christmas present to myself!


Mountain High Premium Hot Chocolate Packet - Buy a 100-packet box for $29.99

I'm happy with another very simple ingredient list! Sugar, milk, cocoa, and salt is how I make my mom's hot chocolate from scratch, so I'm happy with this too. This hot chocolate was more milk chocolate, and not too intense or dark, but it was a tasty warm-up drink.


Okay, so they said to make s'mores with the box contents, so I had to try it! I used the broiler in my oven to make these. The chocolate was super melty and the marshmallows definitely toasted! These were really messy (I was right about the crackers being too hard for the perfect s'more) but they were tasty. This time I preferred the items as they were, straight out of the packages, but it was still delicious either way.

The Verdict: I actually had packages of gourmet marshmallows as favors at my wedding and I really loved those, so I knew I had to grab this subscription! My first month was a pure delight to open. Everything was a fantastic treat, and the chocolates were incredible (I have more in my cart as we speak). The simple and natural ingredients were really appreciated, and the packaging really impressed me, too. I can't wait to see future boxes! 

To Wrap Up:

Can you get this box if you sign up today? No, if you order now your next box should be their November box!

Value Breakdown: Because the marshmallows and graham crackers are homemade just for this subscription, it's hard to really nail down a specific value that you get out of this box. If you're looking specifically at just "how many marshmallows, graham crackers, and hot cocoa packets can I get for $25?" then this box probably falls short. But what I'm really getting out of this box is the fun and uniqueness of the artisan marshmallows, homemade graham crackers (which are also different flavors month to month), the quality of the ingredients, and the overall experience, too. This was a delight in the mail, and I can especially see it being a cute gift to send to someone.

Check out all of chocolate and sweets subscription boxes in the Food Subscription Box List!

What do you think of the October Marshmallow of the Month Club?

Starting at $20.99
Active Deal
Save 5% off your first box with a 3 or 6-month subscription
Use Coupon Code METIME
Subscribe Now

"Our marshmallows are made with all-natural ingredients and colors to infuse flavor and brighten each batch. Our marshmallows are made using fish-based gelatin, perfect for pescatarians! Treat yourself with our egg free and corn syrup free marshmallows. Our guilt-free confections are perfect for ... read more.

Haley Faye
Haley Faye
Haley Faye first discovered the wonderful world of subscription boxes in 2012 and began writing for MSA in 2014. Over the years, she has found many subscriptions to love. Now a mom of three, her favorite boxes are ones that dress her kids, help her get organized, feed her family, send her snacks, and offer educational fun for her children.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I just gifted myself six months of these adorable boxes!

Reply ButtonReply


Just got my November box. Packaged very nicely. I won’t give away the surprise for those who haven’t received theirs yet but I am delighted with the contents. The flavors of the marshmallows and the grahams crackers are so creative! I’m also enjoying all the extra gifts and the scent of the candle is divine.

Reply ButtonReply


This looks so good! Love well made marshmallows plus the accoutrements are so cool. Just subscribed

Reply ButtonReply


I have had this box countless times! It’s such a good buy! I love the different flavors each month, definitely will buy more!

Reply ButtonReply

Hallie Gottlieb

I thought what? Marshmallows. Then i saw how cute it was packed and how tasty they sounded. Now i am tempted

Reply ButtonReply


So excited to see this sub reviewed! Been eyeing it for a while!

Reply ButtonReply


So excited to see this sub reviewed! Been eyeing it for a while!

Reply ButtonReply


Such a thoughtful and well crafted subscription!

Reply ButtonReply


this looks adorable, but I’m allergic to fish! darn pescatarians 😛

Reply ButtonReply


I’m a vegetarian who can’t stomach meat or gelatin at this point, we can suffer together and watch this amazing sub with jealousy!

Reply ButtonReply

Doxy Mama

Add me to the pity party. Fish gelatin? In a sweet treat??? 🤢🤮 I don’t eat animals, but even if I did I don’t think I could stomach fish gelatin. I buy vegan marshmallows called Dandies. I get them on Amazon and yes, they’re over-priced, but they are SO good!!!
There really isn’t any real need for gelatin at all.