Facebook PixelThe Crafter's Box Subscription Review - September 2020 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Crafter’s Box Subscription Review – September 2020

Krista Moore
ByKrista MooreOct 3, 2020 | 16 comments

The Crafter's Box
4 overall rating
1 Ratings | 0 Reviews

The Crafter's Box is a monthly maker subscription box:

As a member of The Crafter's Box, we'll send a lovingly kitted box of tools and materials to your doorstep on a monthly basis. Each month we feature a new expert maker and that maker has built for us a unique, grown-up, on-trend project that reflects their artistic style. In addition to the monthly box, our featured maker has created an educational, digital workshop to teach their crafting medium and to offer their tips and tricks.

The best part of this model is the ability to revisit workshops in the future to create again and again. Happy making!

The Crafter's Box offers three different subscription models:

  • Individual Membership: $65 per month for a kit of curated tools and materials + a new digital workshop by the featured maker
  • Crafter's Night: $60 per person (minimum of 3 people necessary) per month for a group kit of the curated tools and materials sent to one host + individual video access for each person
  • Video-Only Access: $20 per month for access to the digital workshop created by the featured maker (no tools or materials included)

This review is of the Individual Membership for $65 per month. 

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

About The Crafter's Box

The Subscription Box: The Crafter's Box 

The Cost: $65 per month + free US shipping (other plans available from $20 per month)

ACTIVE DEAL: Get 25% off your first box!

The Products: A shipped kit of curated tools and materials + a new digital workshop by the featured maker of the month

Ships to: The US for free and internationally for varying rates

Good to Know: Membership enrollment is open between the 10th - 20th of each month. Subscriptions automatically renew on the 15th. Projects are designed to be for ages 18+.

The Crafter's Box September 2020 Review

The Crafter's Box seems to be what my crafting subscription box dreams are made of! Each month they feature a different, unique craft that is designed with the crafty adult in mind. The items you get to create are thoughtfully curated and created with high-end materials so that your finished products are modern and luxe.

Let's take a look inside September's box - the craft this month is Tiled Blok Print with Gradation!

We received two info cards this month. They detail information on what's included in the box, as well as a short bio on the featured maker this month, Mindy Schumacher of Follysome Prints. I have a vague memory of doing some sort of block printing in art class as an elementary student, but I haven't experimented with a craft like this since then, so I was excited to jump in and start creating! The idea is that you create a design that is repeated many times over your surface. The neat twist of the project this month is that you get to create a custom ombré effect by making a gradation with your colors.

Now, onto the items!

4" x 6" Speedball Carving Block - Estimated Retail Value $6.00 (a 2-pack retails for $12.00 here)

First up is the carving block that we will use to stamp our design onto our fabric. It's made of a pink acrylic material that is flexible but has a decent heft to it. The block comes in a 4x6" size, but we will have to trim it down to create a 4x4" square for our project.

Ergonomic White Birch + Steel 4mm V Tool - Estimated Retail Value $19.00 (this is a custom-made tool that is not sold separately, but an expansion pack of 2 additional carvers retails here for $38.00)

The carving tool is very well made and fits so nicely in your hand! This is what we will use to create the design on the stamping block, and it was designed just for this box. The V tip came packaged with a protective rubber coating, which was nice because the tip of the V is quite sharp.

Speedball 4" Rubber BrayerRetail Value $11.16

Next up is the rubber brayer, which is a rubber wheel that we will use to roll the paint onto our block. The wheel part is 4" wide, which is perfect to use with our 4x4" square design.

Acrylic Inking Plate 

We also received a 4x6" piece of acrylic plastic to use for our paint mixing surface. As you can see, my cat was very interested in licking the glass after I unwrapped it! She always likes to photobomb while I'm taking photos for my reviews, and after a kind reader commented that they wanted to see more cat photos, I left this one in for you here!

Speedball Fabric and Paper Ink in White, Blue, and Black - Estimated Retail Value $14.00 (a trio of other colors can be found here)

The star of the show - the paint! We received three standard colors - white, blue, and black - that we can mix to create our custom color gradient. This is a special paint that is colorfast on fabric, and it's specifically made for block printing.

25" x 25" Silk Scarf - Estimated Retail Value $17.14 (a 35" x 35" silk scarf sells here for $24.00)

The project featured for the craft this month is a silk scarf that we get to print on. The scarf is 100% crepe silk and a creamy white color. It came with pretty firm creases and wrinkles in it, but I used a wrinkle release spray and my steam iron and they came right out.

Plastic Ruler

We also received a plastic ruler to use when creating our design. Not much to say about this item - it's a pretty basic ruler! It is nice of the box to include this in case we didn't already have one.

Soft Pencil and Mix Sticks 

This pencil contains super-soft lead so that it transfers easily from our drawn design to the stamping block. The mix sticks are for mixing our custom paint color blend.

Butcher Paper

We received a large sheet of white butcher paper to protect our workstation while we are stamping - always a good thing to have on hand!


I always talk about this with The Crafter's Box, but it's always true - they send absolutely everything you need to create the craft that month. This month was no exception, as we received three sheets of white printer paper to draw our design on. In my opinion, this is a little bit overkill, but I do appreciate the thoughtfulness of making sure we are all set up to go with the craft.

Now, let's get block printing!

The first step was to draw out the design for the block. Mindy walks you through exactly how she created the sample pattern, and I liked it so much that I just copied exactly what she did. You start with a grid of half-inch squares and then draw concentric squares inside of them. However, she freehanded the petal shapes, and I borrowed a tip I learned from the Sashiko Embroidery video from The Crafter's Box March 2020 - I used the rim of a drinking glass to trace my curved line so that each one was identical to the next.

Next, I prepped my pink block by trimming 2" off of one long side to create a 4 x 4" square. I then transferred my drawn design to the block by flipping the paper over onto it and pressing down, which transferred the pencil marks over. The block material picked up the pencil very easily, so this was not difficult to do at all.

Before I attempted to start carving my actual design, I practiced with the carving tool on the trimmed off extra piece of block. It took a few practice lines before the movement became natural, but then it was pretty easy to use. The handle of the carving tool has a curve on one side so that it fits really easily into the palm of your hand. After practicing a few curved lines, I felt ready to go onto the real thing.

The process of carving the design was a slow one, as I wanted to make sure I had each line perfect before moving onto the next. I found it fairly easy to follow the design, but it was tough around the edges (where we were carving away the corners by the petal shapes), and also where two lines intersected. Once I was finished, though, I was pleased with the result of my design.

Next came the fun part - mixing colors! Mindy walks you through how she gets her favorite dusty blue color for your custom main color, but I wanted something that was a little bit grayer and less blue. To achieve that I simply used less blue paint in my original mix. To get the gradient effect, you then put pure white and pure black on either side of your custom color, and roll away. After a few seconds of rolling up and down on these three patches of color, an ombré effect starts to occur - so pretty!

Mindy recommended doing a couple practice stamps on paper before starting to stamp onto the silk scarf. She said that the first few stamps don't turn out the best, as the stamp has to fully absorb the paint for a clean transfer of paint. Transfering the paint from the acrylic to the stamp was not difficult - you just picked up paint on the roller brayer and then rolled it onto the stamp.

Next, it was time to get moving on my scarf! I really loved the gradient effect of swapping between the light and dark edges of my stamp, but it was important to remember which direction I rolled the paint on each time so that they didn't get contaminated between stamps. I found that it was hard to get the same level of intensity of paint with each stamp, no matter how consistent I was trying to be. I also found that my paint dried out pretty quickly (within 5-10 minutes), so I had to keep adding more white and black paint to the edges of my acrylic as I stamped. It was also hard to keep the silk perfectly flat and smooth, and that meant that some of my stamps were a little bit offset from the one next to it. Overall though, the process was very easy to follow and worked just like the video tutorial said it would. These small complaints I have are just my perfectionist side coming through!

Here's what my scarf looked like once I finished completely stamping it! I was very frustrated with my project towards the end, as I ran out of my main custom color paint just before I was completely done. As you can see in the close-up picture, the second row from the left is much lighter than the surrounding squares - this is where I was running out of paint and struggling to make it work.

I ended up realizing that I needed to mix more custom color, and that's what I used for the three squares on the far left column that look darker than the rest of the scarf. In-person, the difference is far less of a contrast than it shows up in these pictures, but it still doesn't look perfect in person either. But oh well, it's a handmade project and these little imperfections are what make everyone's project unique! Once you are wearing the scarf or have it tied around something, no one will ever notice that a couple of the stamps are a slightly different color than the rest of them!

Here is my finished scarf! I love the gradient of the light to dark in each row - I think it makes the print look really cool. I didn't get as much white or super light color as Mindy's original project did, but I still love how mine turned out. I tied it around the handle of a plain black purse (bonus points if you recognize which Fall subscription box this came in!) and I think the scarf really livens up the purse! It's such a fun accessory to personalize with, and I was very proud that I stuck through a new-to-me craft and came out with a finished product at the end.

Verdict: The Crafter's Box is usually my favorite box I get each month, and this box was no exception. While I wasn't the best at block printing right away, the project was fun to create and I love my finished scarf. I really enjoyed mixing my own colors, and I plan to experiment more with my leftover paint in the future! The presentation is lovely, and I thought it was great how the box includes absolutely everything you need to do the project. I like that The Crafter's Box showcases more unique types of crafts than a lot of other craft subscription boxes, and I love that I was able to experiment with a new craft to me. I also really appreciate the modern, upscale vibe that I get from this box - it feels like I'm making and creating for a purpose, rather than just crafting to craft.

For $65, we received tools and supplies to make a block-printed silk scarf. The box has a very careful curation and extremely well-made video tutorial content. The video tutorial was so well done and very in-depth, and I really enjoyed learning tips and tricks on how to get the best final products.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, you will receive the November 2020 box (if you sign up between October 10th - 20th). However, this exact box will be available in the marketplace here after October 1st.

ACTIVE DEAL: Get 25% off your first box!

Check out our other reviews of The Crafter's Box and the top-rated craft subscription boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you think of The Crafter's Box for September 2020? Let us know in the comments!

Starting at $65.00
Active Deal
Get 25% off your first box!
Subscribe Now
The Crafter's Box is a membership community for those that love to make. Monthly we send a curated box of specialized tools & carefully sourced materials (everything needed) to build a beautiful, grownup craft project and to master a new artistic technique. Our projects are hosted by an expert a... read more.
Krista Moore
Krista Moore
Krista entered the subscription box world through beauty boxes and quickly became hooked on boxes! She loves knitting, crocheting, all things crafty, and her cat! Her favorite boxes are KnitCrate, Allure Beauty Box, and FabFitFun.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Ack, flashbacks to cutting myself with one of those V tools in middle school art class. And just letting the blood drip to the floor as we had been warned that they were sharp and we should be very careful so I was afraid to say anything.
Nice work on the project, though!

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

Haha oh no!! The video tutorial had quite a few warnings about those sharp points! That’s neat that you got to try this type of craft in school!

Reply ButtonReply

Hallie Gottlieb

what a fantastic review! This looks daunting so a step by step helps. I could see where i would get a little ocd too. I’m harder on myself. Yours turned out beautiful on that FFF bag 😉

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

Thank you so much! I was fighting against my perfectionist nature for sure with this one 😉 But in the end, it gets bunched up and you can’t tell at all that there are small imperfections! Also, you’re the winner for knowing where my bag came from haha!

Reply ButtonReply


Great review, I skipped this box. It does look like fun though. Would carefully attaching the scarf to a blocking mat help? or a yoga mat? to keep it flatter? I really don’t know but just thought about it when reading through.

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

That’s a really good idea! I would be afraid of the ink seeping through to whatever was beneath you, but I bet you could pin both the butcher paper and the scarf to something to keep it flat while you’re working.

Reply ButtonReply


This turned out so beautiful.

I love all MSA reviews, but my favorites are where y’all create something beautiful!

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

Thank you! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply


I love reading the reviews for this box. The projects are not basic at all and look like a challenge. You truly learn how to do something you likely have never done before. I personally love that they include every single thing because while I have stuff like printer paper, it is so nice when you can just have it all ready to go. I wish I could subscribe to this and maybe one day, but I’m just swamped with work and it would forever stay in my “want to do” pile. I am living vicariously through these reviews though and I always start every review thinking “Wow, that looks hard” and ending with “But the instructions are thorough and the projects are unique and interesting!”

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

I’m so glad that you enjoy the reviews! I always feel the same way when I open up the box – “oh wow, this is going to be difficult! I bet my project won’t turn out well at all.” but then they really do walk you through it step by step. Work can be so busy, but the good thing to remember is that with most of these projects you don’t have to complete them all in one sitting. I typically try to since I want to get the review out to you as quickly as I can, but you can always work on your project a little bit here and there when you have pockets of time, especially for projects like weaving or embroidering!

Reply ButtonReply


A silk scarf that size should cost around $8. Check Dharma Trading for more, if you want to keep making scarves!
Block printing is so gorgeous, and has such a long history, what a cool project!

Just one thing- please don’t use wrinkly release spray or anything like it on a surface you are about to dye or paint! It can affect the fabric’s ability to take color. It seems to be fine for this, your finished piece is beautiful, but I’d just use an iron with a press cloth next time.

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

Thanks for the tip! I was wondering about the spray as well, but from my research, it appeared that once the fabric had dried it would be good to go for dyeing. But I have to admit that I didn’t look into it too much! It wasn’t ironing out at all before I used it, and I didn’t want to start printing on top of wrinkles.

Reply ButtonReply


Love this craft! I had no idea what it was so it was fun reading through each section and seeing the pictures all of the way to the end when we got to see your gorgeous finished scarf. I love the way it looks tied to your bag, I’m not a big scarf wearer but I do love them as accessories like that. Also, love the kitty photobomb! The realness of it is just so amazing and relatable. Great review!

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

Thank you so much for the kind comment! I love taking you guys along the journey with me 🙂 I agree, I don’t wear silk scarves around my neck much, but love it as an accessory on a purse!

Reply ButtonReply


Wow! That’s awesome. Your scarf turned out amazing!!

Reply ButtonReply

Krista Moore

Thank you!

Reply ButtonReply