My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

FabFitFun Members Picks Box On Sale Now + FULL SPOILERS!

ByMSAAug 14, 2020 | 59 comments


3.6 overall rating
1080 Ratings | 221 Reviews

The Fall FabFitFun box has sold out so the Members Picks box just launched! And we have the FULL spoilers for the new Members Picks Box!

FYI – If you signed up for a Fall box, you will receive the Fall Box. Seasonal members get to make their choices for the Fall box tomorrow (8/15)! Check out the full Fall box spoilers here.

The Members Picks Box is just for new members that are signing up now.

Whether it’s a must-have serum or a cozy blanket, this box should be at the top of your list. It’s all our members’ most loved products in one box. Think of it as our members sharing the love just for you – all in one box! Oh, and instead of a set curation, new products will be introduced into the box throughout the season so that there’s something for everyone! New members can sign up starting 8/14 to receive their Members Picks Box filled with 8 full-size items (trust us, you won’t regret it). Same great value – just $49.99 for $200+ retail value.

Here are the current customization options.

Here are the items all subscribers get to pick from:


Michael Kors Bedford Travel Passport Wallet OR PJ Salvage Faux Trim Cable Slipper OR Plush Ultra Soft Plaid Scarf OR Pottery Barn Mason Ceramic Diffuser in Solstice

Botkier New York Bond Tote OR Botkier New York Trigger Backpack OR Caravan Diamond Woven Rug OR tarte SEA drink of H2O hydrating boost moisturizer

Amber Sceats Double Coin Necklace OR Gravity Weighted Sleep Mask OR LUMIRA x The Vow by Nicole Trunfio Perfume Oil OR WEI Two-in-One Purify and Glow Mask Collection

Here are the items Select Members (annual subscribers) get to pick from:

Battington Lashes Monroe 3D Silk Lashed + Glue Kit OR IGK Expensive Amia Oil Hi-Shine Topcoat OR Grown Alchemist Hydra Repair Day Cream Camellia & Geranium Blossom OR Touch in SOL No Poreblem Primer

Generation Clay Ultra Violet Brightening Purple Clay Mask OR grace & stella Dr. Pedicure Exfoliating Foot Mask OR Vooray Sidekick Crossbody Bag OR WAY OF WILL Set of 2 Essential Oils – Eucalyptus + Sweet Orange OR Cuccio SomatologyTM CALM + CLEAN Epsom Salt Hand and Body Wash

FabFitFun will choose from the following items for you:

Spongelle Body Wash Buffer in Tea Blossom OR SKIN&CO Roma Truffle Therapy Whipped Cleansing Cream OR Spongelle Boxed Flower in Sugar Dahlia

Lavido Nurturing Hand Cream in Musk, Coconut & Shea Butter OR The Beauty Crop Glow Milk in Blind Date

MakeUp Eraser in Original Pink OR Lapcos Face Masks OR Stone Candles Room Spray in Santal OR MakeupDrop Hybrid Makeup Applicator

What do you think of the spoilers? Are you going to grab a box?

Use coupon code MSA10 to save $10 off your first box! Regularly $49.99 a box.

Check out our FabFitFun reviews and FabFitFun Spoilers to see what you can expect from this subscription!

FabFitFun is a seasonal lifestyle subscription that sends subscribers 8-10 items every season worth over $200. Boxes include amazing products that are trend-savvy ranging from full-size skincare and beauty products, to wellness products, to accessories, to decor and more every season. While some ite... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I contacted FFF today on the status of my Members Picks Box, and was told that my customization didn’t get properly processed, so I would be getting the Winter box instead. I had reactivated my membership specifically to get some of the items from this box. Very frustrated and disappointed. FFF didn’t even contact me to let me know this happened.

Amanda P

Hi! I got this box and several items I received did not match your post. I didn’t get anything in category 4 or 7 and they were replaced with super cheap random items. When I contacted CS they said that items for this box were not guaranteed unless they were customized at checkout.


Well, I’m really excited about my box. I spoke with fff by chat and they were super helpful. I got to personalize 3 items and that’s pretty good for a seasonal subscription.
I left fff but came back for the backpack and other items in box!


The Botkier tote was so incredibly cheap looking and very poorly made. Like a free GWP tote you’d get when buying perfume. Actually, those totes were better than this one. SO disappointed.


Estalyn I agree, talk about overvalued. This tote is very cheaply made. I chose this because I didn’t like the cheesy logo down the straps of the backpack. I wonder now if that is higher quality.


Do you guys know if customization options are all available still?


Hello, i have a trial account but i need to cancel it before they bill the next box because i cant afford it right now. I’ve been trying to do so, but when i click on cancel subscription it takes me back to home page and the trial account is still active. Does anybody knows if theres a problem with the site or about cancelling trial accounts? Thank you


I chatted with FFF and they said it can be cancel immediately after and the only box you will pay for is the Members Picks box. You just need to contact them.


Did you ever find out if you can cancel it? I was wondering the same thing.


Hi everyone! The Members Picks Box is designed to introduce new members to a special curation of some of our favorite products. It has replaced what was previously known as the Editors Box, offered in-between seasons. Whether it’s the latest trends, brands you know and love, or rediscovering popular items from the past, this box can be customized for everyone, and we will be continually introducing new items to it. Existing members can purchase an extra Member Picks Box in our shop, and new members can get it when you join now at

Please keep in mind, our usual shipping time frame still stands for these boxes. Boxes can take up to one month from sign-up to process and an additional 7-10 business days to be delivered domestically. We are still working on getting our Fall boxes shipped for our Select members and Member Picks boxes will begin shipping after our Select members.

If you have any additional questions or concerns, feel free to reach out to our Customer Care team at and we will be happy to answer any other questions for you! Xo


I ordered the Editor’s box on July 2, 2020. It was called the Editor’s box and now it showing up as the Member’s picks box. I know what three items I picked, (a facebook ad I clicked on gave 3 options but I am now an annual member). One item I picked they ran out of and I was give a $10 credit, the cooler and spray are the ones I’m concerned they are going to do a bate and switch on. I will not be very unhappy if that happens. If my box ever ships will I be able to see on my account what I will be getting for this members pick box (most of those items I received when I was a previous member are being shown above)? The one item that I wanted that made me sign back up they ran out of.
For the fall box I picked 5 items and did add ons so I know that box will be late shipping. I have friends that have already received their boxes but they didn’t shop in the sale or do add ons. I do understand the slow shipping right now.


This is a massively confusing post – poorly worded and disorganized. The regular Fall box has already closed. I’m a yearly member. I already got charged for my add on item and am expecting shipment any day now.

This member’s choice box may be available as an additional box, but is it?? I just looked and nothing has changed except that add on’s have opened again.

In the future MSA, please get all your facts straight and make sure you posting is accurate.


I agree. I’m a quarterly member, and I never had the option of a Michael Kors option, any of the other options shown. Is this a different box?


Mary, this post has nothing to do with the Fall box. This post is letting people who are not already subscribed to FFF know that the Fall box is sold out, so if they subscribe they will get the box pictured above instead. Not really sure what’s so confusing about that.


An email was sent for this box. In the email a link was included that you can click to make the selections.


Seasonal members get to pick now, so customization is only closed for annual. This is saying this specific box is available for people just signing up for FabFitFun now and not members who already have the subscription. Also, a few people have stated in the comments that this box is apparently available in fff’s shop. Hope you get it if you want it! 🙂


This box is in their online shop for all members not just new ones. And the slippers and oil are not an option. Just so you know. Annual members can customize categories 4-5 but you have to go on online and chat with customer service to do it.


I was just sent a starter box. Within minutes I got an email asking if I wanted this box. I said yep and then went into chat and they let me customize it right then. I would go into chat if you’re a member and ask for this version. Two fragrant items!! I am excited!

Valerie M

Does anyone know what time seasonal members can choose their items? Also, is everything available or are some choices sold out? Thank you for the help!


FabFitFun, please, please fix your website. For the last half hour, I’ve been trying to buy a $200 gift care without luck. The link takes me to my account without any section/area to purchase gift card. On top of that, besides gift card, there is no other way to gift a subscription.

I do not have a new email (not associated with account) to buy gift card.


There is not one single thing that appeals to me. A bunch of leftovers/rejects, ugh. And that coin necklace – as cheap as it looks in photos, it’s 100 times cheaper in person. My 10-year-old niece wouldn’t be caught dead wearing it. Everything is so … CHEAP. RV is beyond meaningless.


Well it’s supposed to be repeats on this box it’s like, “member favorites” or whatever they’re calling it.

Also for the record I love that coin necklace and wear it almost daily and get lots of compliments on it. *shrug


I like the necklace, I thought it was cute. Why would a 10 year old be given this anyways?


So this is a today only option? Too bad. I was definitely going to sub next Wednesday. I pretty much have something I love in every category except for the lashes but my BFF loves them if thats what I get.


It’s not just for a day, it’s their in-between season box so it will be available for awhile, but they will be rotating different items in/out.


I was going to sign up for another box for the PJ Salvage Faux Trim Cable Slipper. However, looks they are OOS already. In the shop, it shows
Choice 1 : Plush Ultra Soft Plaid Scarf OR Michael Kors Bedford Travel Passport Wallet OR Pottery Barn Mason Diffuser in Solstice
Choice 2: Caravan Diamond Woven Rug OR tarte™ SEA drink of H2O hydrating boost moisturizer OR Botkier New York Bond Tote OR Botkier New York Trigger Backpack
Choice 3: Gravity Weighted Sleep Mask OR WEI™ Two-in-One Purify and Glow Mask Collection OR Amber Sceats™ Double Coin Necklace.
Their Instagram post states “ instead of a set curation, new products will be introduced into the box throughout the season”


Exactly. I am so very glad I have canceled.


Yeah , I wish I could have skipped, I rather have gotten this box I stead of the fall box. I got the annual so I thought I was stick with it until someone told me I could have skipped, so that just makes me more upset with fff. I’ve been with them for over three years now and it’s gotten really bad over this last year… smh, what a sham

Nicole trombley

WOW…Those are not the choices that were advertised before apparently the annual members chose all the “good” products and we are left with the crap…they should make all the items available to all subscribers. Total B.S …BYE FELICIA


Hi Nicole!

If you signed up when the fall box was available, you get to choose from the fall box items. The customization for seasonal members opens tomorrow and that will be for the fall box items. This box and these selections are only if you are subscribing as a new member today. Hope that helps! Thanks!


I’m a new seasonal member, who signed up specifically for fall to get the serum. I also like
some of the other category options. i read that the serum sold out, as did one of my other picks, when the annual subscribers made their selections. The advertising is incredibly misleading, and I canceled immediately. I’m still out $40, and will probably give everything away. I’d live to have the $40 to put towards one of Dermstore’s curated boxes.


Can you clarify if this is the box/set of choices current seasonal members will be getting?? It’s confusing because the choice window for existing seasonal members hasn’t even opened yet. It would be wrong if it sold out before it was actually available to seasonal members, right?!


Hi Katie!

The customization for seasonal members opens tomorrow and that will be for the Fall Box items. This is just the box you would get if you were signing up as a new subscriber today. Hope that helps! Thanks!


Oh no, I was holding off til tomorrow to make sure the Scarfigan was still available before subscribing. Oh well, hope I’ll get to swap for it or snag it off eBay.


Ah, this explains when I tried to sign up for the FFF Fall box last night, it told me I would be receiving the “members pick box” (which I stupidly thought meant the regular box) instead. Glad I didn’t hit the checkout button, but bummed about missing out on the canisters and basket.


I am a seasonal subscriber and found out last week that canisters are “sold out”.


Jessica, my experience with FFF is that they hold onto a certain amount of stock of choice items for seasonal subscribers. When people said the canisters were “sold out,” what they meant was that annual subscribers could not add them on as an additional item. You should still be able to choose them as a seasonal subscriber.


Welp. Guess I missed out on picking up the second box I was going to order. My annual box is on the way, though, and it’s probably better that I only got one box anyway.


Hey! If you’re already a member you can likely buy an uncustomized Fall box for $39.99 in the add on sale coming up for all members 😎🙂.


At the moment, the extra fall boxes in the add on sale is sold out. But if you “favorite” them, they come back into stock as people drop them from their carts.


The warehouse is still full of leftovers, huh?

Can’t call it members picks. This is the stuff that members didn’t pick.


Especially the glow milk that no one wants, lol.


LOL!! Good one!


I’m still just so bummed they changed the cardboard boxes. To me those were an extra $10 value right there since I used them for storage. But the new ones look less sturdy and aren’t reversible so I can’t hide the ugly shipping label and inevitable scratches.

Less and less into FFF lately


Oh my gosh thank you for posting this! I feel like such a dork but I had not even realized these boxes were reversible. I just thought there were two box designs available and you got one or the other randomly HAHA!


Is this the new editor’s box? Why change the name to something needlessly confusing?


Does this replace the editors box?


The passport holder is a really silly option right now. It’s like HELLO there’s a pandemic! No one is traveling right now!!


My Mother in law was staying with us before the pandemic and couldn’t fly home. It’s been a long 10 months. Finally flights opened from Ny to Brazil and what sold me on this box was the passport holder. I’m surprising her with her ticket home in this holder. 😄 it’s a win win.


Have you seen the movie “Breaking Away?” Everyone needs a passport holder. There might be a new girl at the A&P.

You Might Also Like

Net-A-Porter 2021 Advent Calendar Spoilers
Net-A-Porter 2021 Advent Calendar Spoilers
September 7, 2021
Open Call: We’re Looking for Volunteers to Help Review a Meal Kit!
Open Call: We’re Looking for Volunteers to Help Review a Meal Kit!
September 7, 2021
Add to Cart?: Help Us Decide What New Beauty Products to Review!
Add to Cart?: Help Us Decide What New Beauty Products to Review!
September 16, 2021
BoxyCharm September 2021 Box – Full Spoilers
BoxyCharm September 2021 Box – Full Spoilers
September 7, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.