Facebook Pixel
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our Subscription Box Favorites for September 2019! | MSA
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Our Subscription Box Favorites for September 2019!

Megan K.
ByMegan K.Nov 2, 2019 | 8 comments

Welcome to our monthly post highlighting our favorite discoveries from a variety of women's, beauty, and even dog subscription boxes! Here are our favorite items from the past month:

Marne's Favorite:

Barebones Ultimate Tool with sheath

The Item: Barebones Ultimate Tool with Sheath 

The Cost: $50.00

From: Bespoke Post

Why I love it: I've never owned anything as badass as this tool! I can't wait to use it while camping this fall!

Read more reviews by Marne!

Ragan's Favorite:

Meowbox September 2019 - Furrst Place Medal TopMeowbox September 2019 - Sneaky 2 Top

The Item: Furrst Place Medal

The Cost: $5

From: meowbox

Why I love it: Many times, I just choose the item that my cats had the most fun with. This month, it was this medal. Sneaky was particularly amusing -- I put it around her neck and she wrestled with it.

Read more reviews by Ragan!

Megan's Favorite:

The Item: The Hundredth Acre Night-Blooming Jasmine Candle

The Cost: $25.00

From: California Found

Why I love it: What a swoon-worthy candle! It smells like a summer night, heavy with jasmine in the air. I am going to be waiting for summer until it comes back around, but for now, this candle will have to be my escape from the cold winter months to come.

Read more reviews by Megan!

Brandi's Favorite:

The Item: Pura Vida Bracelet Pack - The Celestial Set

The Cost: Retail Value $14.95

From: Pura Vida Bracelet Club

Why I love it: I have been wearing this set of bracelets ever since I first received it! They are the perfect fall set to me with their neutral colors, the gold accents, and that sparkly druzy stone. I really love the phases of the moon bracelet and how unique it is! They all just go so well with one another or individually if you choose. Plus I have always been a fan of how charitable this company is as well as the fact that these wax-coated string bracelets can be worn all the time and they really do hold up well over time!

Read more reviews by Brandi!

Becca's Favorite:

Bolzano Subscription Box September 2019 - Purse Front TopBolzano Subscription Box September 2019 - Purse Held With Two Short Handles Front

The Item: Bolzano Gabriela Bag

The Cost: $198

From: Bolzano Lux

Why I love it: Mustard yellow is a hot color this fall, and this purse delivers!!! This faux leather purse is incredibly soft, and very well made; the zipper glides like a dream, and the stitching is perfection. I love the color and the design, and that it holds everything I need plus more! My favorite part is the silver signature "B" keychain which stands for "Bolzano" but is also perfect for "Becca!" I have been using this all month, and have gotten tons of compliments!

Read more reviews by Becca!

Christen's Favorite: 

The Item: Heroclip Small

The Cost: $17.95

From: Cairn

Why I love it: This snazzy carabiner is small but mighty! As a mama who loves the outdoors, it has practically provided me the extra hand I'm always wishing for. It's amazing for quickly clipping my keys, diaper bag, water bottle, or about a million other things to my belt loop or stroller handle!

Read more reviews by Christen!

Jessica's Favorite: 

Birchbox mask rubber 1

The Item: Dr. Jart+ Bright Lover Rubber Mask 

The Cost: $12

From: Birchbox Your Mask Match

Check our Birchbox Coupon List to get the most up-to-date coupon!

Why I love it: This mask is fun! The rubber part of the mask is cooling like a hydrogel mask, and the ampoule you apply before the rubber mask is so hydrating to my skin. This is expensive for a single-use mask, but I loved it.

Read more reviews by Jessica!

Shatae's Favorite

Keto Krate September 2019 - High Key Mini Cookies Front

The Item: High Key Mini Cookies - Chocolate Chip, 2.25 oz

The Cost: Buy a 3 pack for $13.97

From: Keto Krate

Why I love it: These guilt-free chocolate chip mini cookies are made with all-natural ingredients and are low-carb and gluten-free. I love the texture and the phenomenal taste of these cookies. They have a shortbread-like texture with the perfect crumble. They don't taste at all like a low carb snack. I loved them and so did my husband and the kids.

Read more reviews by Shatae!

Abby's Favorite:

The Item: Pet Qwerks Krinkle & Squeak Newspaper Dog Toy

The Cost:$4.84

From: Dapper Dog

Why I love it: I had plans for this newspaper toy while reviewing, and now that I've set them into action, Murray just can't get enough! When he is getting restless, aka being needy or acting like a brat, Ryan and I started burying a treat inside the middle of this toy, and Murray goes wild! It keeps him entertained anywhere from 10-30 minutes, and it is really fun to watch him try to uncover his reward.

Read more reviews by Abby!

Haley's Favorite:

Panda Crate Bond With Me Box milestone pillow and card

The Item: Panda Crate Milestone Pillow and Cards

The Cost: N/A

From: Panda Crate by KiwiCo

Why I love it: This pillow is something I can see being super easy to remember to use and keep easily on hand. It features a clear window for the milestone cards to slip into and you can keep them all in there and just put the right one in front so you never lose any! I definitely have to point out that my favorite part of the way they designed these cards is that the backs of them have spaces for you to write out stats and favorites of your baby! I really love this because it’s simple and uncomplicated and I’ll already have them in hand when snapping the picture really quick. I have a really nice baby book for my first, and I don’t think I really even used it at all. I can keep up with these cards, though!

Read more reviews by Haley!

Nicole's Favorite:

Stitch Fix Plus September 2018 Box 0015

The Item: Dorothy Faux Leather Textured Skirt by Eloquii x R29

The Cost: $69.95

From: Stitch Fix

Why I love it: This skirt is incredibly unique! The reptilian, textured, shiny, patent leather-like material is reminiscent of skirts I would ogle when I was a teen in the '90s. This piece is so versatile! Pair it with your fave vintage band shirt for a dreamy rock'n'roller look or a pussybow blouse, knee-high boots, and oversized round sunglasses for a look '70s Brigitte Bardot would drool over! You will slay no matter how you style it!

Read more reviews by Nicole!

What do you think of our favorites for September? And what were your favorite discoveries?

Megan K.
Megan K.
I love natural/vegan beauty products, Korean skincare, unique jewelry, and weird candies from far away places. When I am not waiting for my next exciting box you can find me painting or taking photographs of interesting people. I never leave home without pug hair somewhere on my shirt and a bold lipstick on my smile.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

8 comments

Darlene

What a gorgeous calico cat! 😍

Reply ButtonReply

Beth

After reading Maren’s review of the tool I got one. It will be great for working in the garden, but wow. I wasn’t prepared for how massive it is! Definitely a serious tool!

Reply ButtonReply

Marne Orenich

You ain’t kiddin’!! I hope it works well for you, Beth!!

Reply ButtonReply

Joy B.

Nicole I think I missed that review by you. You look totally awesome in this entire outfit. Love it!

I’m new to this website and subscription boxes in general. (Well three months new) This is the first time I’ve seen this “favorites” feature and I love it!

So far I’ve signed up for Ipsy (having no luck with it), Birchbox (love it), Sephora play (one month so far and I liked it), Scentbird (my favorite hands down), Allure (love it), Pet treater (cat edition), and Sunday Riley(haven’t received yet but signed up because I loved the review so I know I’ll be happy).

I tried Dia & Co. but cancelled before my first box shipped due to customer service. I plan on trying several more subscriptions in the upcoming months. Thank you guys for your reviews, they are so fun to read and I have a brand new addiction now!

The only thing I’m lacking that I really want is a bath box! Any suggestions from readers or reviewers would be appreciated!

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica Hapak

Hey Joy! Welcome to the addiction! Depending on the type of bath box you’re looking for use the search feature to check out my previous reviews of Bath Blessing, Lavish, Bath Bevy, and Fortune Cookie Soap.

Thanks for reading!

Reply ButtonReply

Beth

No ideas on bath boxes, but you certainly are jumping into to sub boxes with both feet! That’s quite a starter list. Enjoy!

Reply ButtonReply

Jody

Brandi, I love my bracelets as well. I keep mixing with the Nov. set and last year’s Oct. spider web! I love black and dark colors!

Reply ButtonReply

Brandi D.

Ooh I’m sure it looks great with the spider web! I missed out on that one!

Reply ButtonReply