MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

butter LONDON Feel Good Beauty Box Review – November 2019

butter LONDON is a makeup company that started exclusively with nail polish before branching out to eye, lip, and face products, too.

They recently offered a Feel Good Beauty Box that is still available for purchase!

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out our review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

About this Beauty Box

The Box: butter LONDON Feel Good Beauty Box

The Cost: $60 + free shipping

The Products: “This Feel Good Beauty bombshell features 10 full-size mystery products, including bestsellers and customer favorites! Whether you desire new nail lacquer colors, shimmering eyeshadow, matte eyeliner, or glowy highlighter— this box has it all! Overall, 10 beauty products to make you feel good, a $160 value for 60% off! While supplies last.”

Ships to: The US only

November 2019 butter LONDON Feel Good Beauty Box Review


Matte Liquid Liner in British Racing Green, Full-Size! – Retail Value $20

First off, I would just like to say thank you to butter LONDON for sending a shade other than black! This green eyeliner is a fun change from the typical black, and the felt tip gave me great control over lining my eyes. 


Glazen™ Eye Gloss in Spark, 5.5 g – Full-Size! Retail Value $24

I have fallen in love with this eyeshadow. It takes some work because of the jelly-like consistency, but a tiny bit on a stiff eyeshadow brush is more than enough to give me a gorgeously pigmented metallic eyeshadow. I’ve worn this multiple times as the only shadow on my lids since receiving it, and you can’t even tell that I’ve consumed any from the jar. Plus, it has great staying power and I had no issues with creasing. 


On the Glow Pen in White Gold, Full-Size! – Retail Value $12

This is a neat concept- it is slim and portable, and when you go to use it you find a domed sponge applicator nestled into the end of the tube that contains the light gold highlighter. This is more for targeting specific areas to highlight (like the inner corners, brow bone, or cupids bow) compared to giving your face an all-over glow, but it is perfect for travel when you consider the amount of space a brush and highlighter would normally take up.

Here are the swatches. From top to bottom we have the eyeliner, highlighter, and eye gloss.


Come To Bed Red Nail Lacquer, 0.4 oz – Retail Value $15

I think this is the third time I’ve received this classic red shade in a butter LONDON Mystery Box. While I love the mystery, this brand has a gorgeous array of colors that I wish would give Come To Bed Red a break. That being said, this has a great formula and is perfectly smooth and opaque in two coats. 


Minted Nail Lacquer, 0.4 oz – Retail Value $15 (currently on sale for $12)

This is described as a soft teal cream that definitely leans more traditionally minty than teal to me. Like all of the butter LONDON creme polishes, this has a great formula and smooth application.


Kip Nail Lacquer, 0.4 oz – Estimated Value $15

Is this grey? Is this blue? I can’t tell for sure since this shade is no longer sold on the butter LONDON website. I will say that it’s lovely, and it’s a shade I will put away until spring comes because it is a great pastel shade that’s a cross between a light sky blue and a grey that is neutral while still being different from a regular nude polish. 


Supernova Glazen™ Peel-Off Glitter Mini Nail Lacquer, 0.2 oz – Retail Value $12

This is a peel-off glitter nail polish that is supposed to solve the issue of how hard glitter nail polish is to remove: Since I have had gel nail polish over acrylics for years, this nail polish didn’t quite work for me (you’re supposed to use it without a base coat). That being said, I tried this sparkly silver glitter on my non-adorned toenails, and after a day of wear, I really was able to just peel it off my big toe!


Glitz Glazen™ Peel-Off Glitter Mini Nail Lacquer, 0.2 oz – Retail Value $12

This has the same innovative peel-off formula, only in a light pink glitter shade. It’s lovely, and if you want to wear it for longer than a day or two you can just use it with a top and base coat and it’ll perform like a regular glitter polish. 


Bang On! Patent Shine 10X Nail Lacquer, 0.4 oz – Retail Value $18

This is from butter LONDON’s patent shine product line, and I do think this deep teal creme shade had an especially shiny finish. 


24K Crushed Diamonds Patent Shine 10X™ Nail Lacquer, 0.4 oz – Retail Value $18

This is also from the patent shine line, and it is a gold glitter made with crushed diamond powder to add additional shine. I couldn’t tell from the website if this actually includes 24 karat gold (I own a few genuine gold flake top coats), but this is quite pretty and adds a lovely bit of festivity to your mani.

Here is the overcoat over all of the non-glitter shades from the box.

The Verdict: butter LONDON promised full-size products that include best-sellers and customer favorites, and I definitely think they delivered. This box contained a good mix of glitter polishes and non-glitters, and even though I couldn’t find Kip on the website, none of these products felt like unwanted products haphazardly put together and then called a mystery box. I calculated a total value of $161, which is more than $100 over the cost of the box, too. 

To Wrap Up:

Can you get this box if you sign up today? Yes, this box is still available!

Value Breakdown: This box costs $60 which means you are paying approximately the following per item:

  • Eyeliner: $7.45
  • Eye gloss: $8.94
  • Highlighter: $4.47
  • Come to bed red:  $5.59
  • Minted: $5.59
  • Kip: $5.59
  • Supernova: $4.47
  • Glitz: $4.47
  • Bang On!: $6.71
  • 24K Overcoat: $6.71

Check out the and best beauty and skincare subscription boxes of 2019 for more box options!

What do you think of the butter LONDON Feel Good Beauty Box?

Written by Jessica Hapak

Jessica Hapak

I am a staunch believer that pineapple doesn’t belong on pizza and when I’m not working as a family law attorney I enjoy hiking the Louisiana trails (alligator sightings are a favorite!) or relaxing with Duchess, my cat. I’m a sucker for anything labeled a mystery box and I’ve never met a bath bomb I didn’t like.

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Butter London Reviews, Mystery Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: butter london | 14 comments

Comments (14)

  1. I thought you were going to model the eye makeup for us. That green liner is so pretty and the shadow looks interesting!

  2. This looks better than their past mystery boxes to me!

    • You snooze you loose I guess. It’s saying sold out.

      • In no small part due to this review, I bet, haha. Great job!

      • I know I was thinking that. I don’t know how many people subscribe to MSA, but it did make me wonder…did the buyers here just make them sell out? One would think! But it makes all the reviews that much more pressing, if you want a box, get it now 😂

  3. What happened to this brand? It used to be everywhere and now the price is lower and it’s almost non-existent

  4. I like the crushed diamonds for something different. Green eyeliner looks grand. Too bad I can’t wear that with green eyes.

    • Hi Jody, agree that the green eyeliner looks fantastic. As a fellow green-eyed gal I think it would probably look wonderful on you!

  5. It was a great box and well worth the money/. I always love their mystery boxes!

  6. Anyone know if everyone gets the exact same items?

    • Omgosh, wondering the same as I am about to order just hoping I’ll get this same (or close) box! That eyeliner is GORGEOUS and the polishes are all so pretty. Not a dud to be found!

      • Agreed, Lori! If I knew the box would be exactly the same…. Oh it’s hard to resist! All of the products and colors are right up my alley, and that doesn’t happen too often

      • Mine was exactly the same, the highlighter was a different shade though. Everything else, exactly the same.

      • Thank you for the info! I just ordered it based on how amazing the gold eye color looks in the photos here, and I hadn’t even considered that I might get a different shade!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.