Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
UPDATE - Yosef recently made a correction to this spoiler. You will receive one of the palettes in the premium box but these are not the choice items. The choice item has not been revealed yet. BoxyCharm Premium choice will now open on 11/18 instead of 11/14.
What do you think of the spoilers? Which palette do you want?
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
OHHHH I NEED that Too Faced one!!! Cmon Boxy, bring it to mamma!
Reply
Dani G.
I really hope this is for January. I’ve been wanting that palette but I know I won’t be off the waitlist for December. Unfortunately I was a few hours late catching the announcement and signing up. I might not even make it off by January considering lots of people said they signed up immediately and didn’t get off the waitlist.
Reply
Stacey Clay
We were supposed to be able to choose a product today at 3:00 but I haven’t gotten the email yet. Has anyone else not gotten it?
Reply
Cylie
I feel like I’m the only one that I thinks this – but damn that Storybook Cosmetics palette is so boring looking. Unless there’s some amazing stuff in this box I’m taking myself off the waitlist because I definitely don’t need or want that palette.
Reply
Megan W
Whelp server crashed at 0919 am. That was a fun 15 mintues….
Reply
Heather K
I love all of my Too Faced pallets! I sometimes forget to put the glitters and shimmers on with my finger instead of a brush because they work WAY better that way, but I still love them none the less!!!
Reply
Regina
I been wanting to try a palette by storybook, yay ! Now I can without having to pay full price. After I see their performance then I can decide if the rest are worth investing in. I love sub boxes for this reason alone.
Reply
Carol
Oooh, now this might get me to resubscribe lol. I’ve been wanting this palette for a bit.
Reply
Regina
This is exciting to me, I love toofaced
Reply
Jacki
Is choice still happening as scheduled?
Reply
Jacki
Looks like they slid choice for premium to Monday November 18. That could change again since they have boxycharm choice and popup currently scheduled for tomorrow
Reply
Carla
pop up still not open
Reply
LaylaB
They posted to their IG stories….now they are saying update will come tomorrow at 9am est
Reply
Regina
Well, that’s fun! I hope the too faced is for January also!
Reply
Yessy
Is anyone having issues with the pop up? I tried and I’m suppose to access but it’s not working? I’m wondering if anyone else got access with no problem. Thanks
Reply
Morgan
People crash it opening in new tabs, new windows, hitting refresh over and over and over again to try to force into a transaction. It basically creates traffic that is 10 times higher than the actual number of users….so sites like this that announce openings of stores cant even have their host fix a problem bc of the sheer number of hits per second.
This is why I don’t sit there are hit refresh like an angry ape every time Ipsy or Boxy or FFF have these sales. If we all did that it would be a different story.
Reply
Kenley
Someone posted that they have postponed it until tomorrow due to continued site issues.
Reply
Ashlee
They’ve delayed it again until tomorrow. The next announcement about it will be at 9am EST tomorrow/Wednesday, but that’s just an announcement, not when it opened.
Reply
Beccah
Not working for me either. Still says upgrade!
Reply
Beccah
Popup is still not working! Says to upgrade!
Reply
Jana
Yep – mine too!
Reply
Tiina
I would be very very excited for the Too Faced palette. It is the only palette I would be interested in this. So exciting!
Reply
Ashlee
Same!! I don’t care for the other two, totally want the Too Faced!
Reply
Roxann
What about regular boxy? Everything now focuses on premium and luxe. What about us regular subs?
Reply
Jackie
There are spoilers for regular subs as well. There are two storybook palettes, it is in a different posting.
amarante
If these are choices, they are so NOT comparable as I really wanted the Storybook palette because it is utterly unique.
The other palettes include a not very well received palette Treasures palette and a run of the mill Two Faced Palette.
I am not ordinarily one to vent if I get one versus the other – e.g. wouldn’t care if I got Treasures versus the other but the Storybook line is completely different
Reply
Jackie
I think you get the storybook if you do not have luxe. If you have luxe, then you will get it in there. So essentially everyone getting luxe or premium will get the storybook, or so I’ve heard it explained.
Reply
rsb
Idk where to put this but where is the POPUP! What happened?? I was so looking forward to the Sa͏l͏e because those were some great prices. I’m so disappointed. Boxy what is going on with you? I want my pop up sale!!!
SquirrelyGirl
Pretty sure that this MIGHT be for January, not December. At least that’s what the groups were speculating
Reply
Bonnie
That would be so great. I don’t want to have to choose between these palettes – I want them all!
Reply
Jamey
Agreed!!! I want all 3!!! I collect and love full eyeshadow pallettes I love playing in new formulas and if I know I like them and they work for me, I buy more from the line…(I’ve now spent THOUSANDS on natasha denona pallettes thanks to 1 “morganna” single from allure box this past year) … so excited to try the storybook and the dose pallette. I liked their mates, but will be nice to try some shimmers …i have a few two faced pallettes and like them, but I’m curious about the “pineapple ” line, since two face is so hit or miss these days!!
Super excited for this!!!
Misha
I saw something where Too Faced palette my be in January boxy premium.
I just hope it’s not a unicorn product.
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
I was just typing the same thing lol
Reply
Jackie
I love the sparkles 🙂 3 eyeshadow palettes as spoilers though – wow, hopefully there will be some skincare 🙂
Reply
Marie
Whichever month it’s coming in I really hope I get that Too Faced palette.
Reply
Salena
So if the too faced ends up being an alternate to the other two eyeshadow palettes then only those who don’t choose on 11/14 have a chance to get it. Kinda sucks if you think about it.
I like the fairy tale book one just because it looks cute but I’m honestly not excited for any of these. More excited for boxyluxe 🤷🏻♀️
Reply
Jackie
It was said that the other two palettes are not choices as previously spoiled, so not completely sure. Guess we’ll find out soon what the choices are.
Reply
Salena
Where was that said 🧐? The above article said that the dose palette and the Storybook Cosmetics palette were choices for premium members.
Elizabeth
Wait really? I’m so confused… so what is actually the choice?
Christa H
Ok Boxy! I need that Too Faced Palm Springs palette please!!! 🙌👍❤Wowzers! What a spoiler!!! 👀😳
Reply
Penny Walker
That makes 2 of us. I absolutely love the colors, now just need to get off the waitlist…grrr
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.