MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Knit Picks “Fan Favorites” Box Review – September 2019


KnitPicks Review September 2019 closed box

Knit Picks is an online yarn and knitting supply company that specializes in providing high-quality materials at a reasonable price. They also launched a line of monthly subscription boxes featuring their products!

The options for boxes are as follows:

  • Skill Builder: $48.00 per month, for yarn, knitting needles, instructional materials, and other knitting supplies. This box focuses on teaching you something new each month!
  • Sock Yarn: $48.00 per month, for 2 skeins of sock-weight yarn, a sock pattern book, a shawl or accessory pattern, and knitting goodies (needles, accessories, stitch markers, pins, etc.)
  • Fan Favorites: $48.00 per month, for a surprise assortment of yarn, needles, and tools that are either brand new to the shop or products that are best sellers.
  • Crochet Lover: $27.00 per month, for at least 150g of yarn, a crochet pattern or book, and crochet goodies (hooks, tools, etc.)
  • Sock Labs: $27.00 per month, for 2 limited-edition hand-painted skeins of yarn and one pattern

KnitPicks Review September 2019 open box

This review is of the Fan Favorites box, $48.00 per month. Want to see a different Knit Picks box reviewed? Let us know by voting in the comments below!

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

KnitPicks Review September 2019 all items

About Knit Picks

The Subscription Box: Knit Picks Fan Favorites Box

The Cost: $48.00 per month + free US shipping (other plans available starting from $27.00, and save with longer subscription plans)

The Products: A surprise assortment of yarn, patterns, knitting needles and tools, and fun extras

Ships to: The US for free and worldwide for varying rates

Knit Picks Fan Favorites September 2019 Review

Knit Picks is a fantastic online store for knitters and crocheters, and it’s always been one of my favorite places to shop for yarn and tools! They recently launched a line of subscription boxes that feature different products from their in-house yarn and pattern lines. 

KnitPicks Review July 2019 info card two front

KnitPicks Review September 2019 front of card

A card is included in the box that details the contents of this month’s Fan Favorites Box. The description reads:

Our latest collection, Spectrum: A Colorwork Collection in Palette, is guaranteed to satisfy your need for engaging knits. There are a few beginner-friendy patterns included to help get you started on your stranded knitting journey, as well as enough of our colorwork superstar yarn, Palette, to make the Color Shock Hat!

KnitPicks June 2019 card two

There was a second card in the box that goes into more detail on each of the different boxes available. MSA plans to review a different box type from Knit Picks each month, and we are leaving the choice up to you! Please let us know in the comments below which box type you’d like to see reviewed for October!

Now, onto the good stuff – the yarn!


Knit Picks Palette Yarn in colors “Majestic,” “Cream,” and “Cyan” – Retail Value $11.37 ($3.79 per skein)

The box included three colors of Knit Picks’ Palette yarn line, which is their yarn specifically developed for stranded colorwork. We received a bright purple, cream, and bright blue. The yarn is fingering weight and contains 231 yards in 50 grams, and it is 100% Peruvian Highland wool. I like that this yarn comes in 50 gram balls (instead of the traditional 100g skein), because for a lot of colorwork patterns you only need small amounts of lots of different colors of yarn.

Peruvian Highland wool isn’t known for being the softest yarn in the world, and this yarn definitely feels more rustic than a lot of the merino wool or wool blends I’m used to working with. That said, it has a really great “stickiness” where the strands of the fibers want to hold together really well. This wooly feeling is ideal for stranded colorwork (or Fair Isle) knitting, and I was excited to try this yarn out!


Spectrum: A Colorwork Collection in Palette book – Retail Value $29.99 (currently on sale for $17.99)

The box included a new pattern book by Knit Picks, called Spectrum. It features 11 patterns all made out of their Palette yarn, and has items such as scarves, hats, and sweaters. I appreciate that this book doesn’t go overboard on showing multiple versions of the same colorwork charts in different color combinations like previous pattern books I’ve received from Knit Picks have. There is only one color variation per pattern shown, but as you can see from the page detailing all of the different colorways available, the possibilities are endless! I’m already planning a Flurries scarf in different shades of taupe and brown – there are so many lovely neutrals included in this collection, as well as lots of fun bright colors.

The book also has a fairly large intro section on colorwork knitting techniques, and I found it to be thorough and well-written. If you are new to colorwork knitting or if this is a technique you have been wanting to try, I think this book would be a great resource for you!


Soak Wash in Ravelry Unleash, 8 oz. – Retail Value $16.00

I love that we received a full-size bottle of Soak! Soak Wash is my absolute favorite product for washing my hand-knits, and I can always use more of it. Soak is biodegradable, phosphate-free, dye-free, and non-toxic. You can use it for handwashing, or I have used it in my washing machine when I wash my delicate store-bought sweaters or dresses.

I was especially excited to get this limited-edition scent, called “Unleash,” that was released as a celebration of the online knitting community Ravelry’s 10-year anniversary. Unleash has a light, fruity scent that I really like. I blocked a couple of sweaters with it, and I really like how light the scent is – it’s very subtle compared to some of the other Soak scents I’ve used, and I appreciate that!


Pastel Yarn Hank Enamel Stitch Markers – Retail Value $14.99

How adorable are these stitch markers?! There are five in the set, and they are all different pastel colors of a skein of yarn. The packaging was interesting, as the stitch markers were not assembled onto their pins when they came. It gave me the idea that if you wanted to, these skeins would make a very fun set of earrings or a necklace! I absolutely love the sparkle in these pins, and they make a great beginning-of-round stitch marker.

I was really drawn to the Churchyard Railing hat in the pattern book – I just love the detailing in the crown decreases. I decided to use my yarn to make this hat, and I’ll alternate between the purple and blue colors for stripes throughout.


Here’s my progress so far! When I do colorwork I use both hands, keeping one color in my left and one color in my right. I didn’t realize this technique had a specific name, but according to this pattern book, this is called Scandinavian knitting. I love being able to knit this way because it gives me enough mental challenge to be engaging (plus it uses both sides of your brain!), but the rhythmic stitch counts make it a relaxing knit at the same time. Let me know in the comments below if you like to knit colorwork as well!

Verdict: I thought this was a great Fan Favorites box! I liked that the yarn we received went along with the pattern book, and the stitch markers and Soak wash were great extras that I know I’ll get a lot of use out of. For $48.00, we received three skeins of yarn, a pattern book, a set of enamel stitch markers, and a bottle of Soak Wash for a total retail value of $72.35. Knit Picks advertises the boxes as having a $60 value, and most of their boxes are right around that mark, so this month’s box has a higher value than usual, which is great! If you know you are a fan of Knit Picks products, or you want to try new yarn and knitting/crochet items at a discounted price, I think this box has a great value!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes, if you sign up before October 15th, you will get the September 2019 box—but act fast.

Value Breakdown: At $48.00, here’s approximately what you are paying for each item:

  • Knit Picks Palette yarn – $7.54 ($2.51 per skein)
  • Spectrum pattern book – $19.90
  • Soak Wash – $10.62
  • Stitch Markers – $9.94

Check out all of our Knit Picks reviews and the best arts & crafts subscription boxes of 2019!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you think of the September 2019 Knit Picks Fan Favorites Box

My Subscription Addiction is planning to review each of the box types on a rotating basis, and we are letting YOU choose which one we review next. Leave a comment below on which box you would like to see reviewed next month: the Fan Favorites box, the Skill Builder box, the Sock Yarn box, the Crochet Lover box, or the Sock Labs box! Thank you!

Knit Picks

How do subscribers rate Knit Picks?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

per month
Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about Knit Picks!

Enable notifications (On switch) to get the latest Knit Picks spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Krista Moore

Krista Moore

Krista entered the subscription box world through beauty boxes and quickly became hooked on boxes! She loves knitting, crocheting, all things crafty, and her cat! Her favorite boxes are KnitCrate, Allure Beauty Box, and FabFitFun.

Posted in Craft Subscription Boxes, Knit Picks Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: knit picks | 8 comments

Comments (8)

  1. I’d love to see the skill builder box reviewed!

    • Thanks for the vote! We have reviewed skill builder in the past but can definitely review it again if you are interested! 🙂

  2. I’ll have to tell my mom about this subscription! I don’t know if she has heard of Knit Picks either, but my mom and sister are both incredible knitters and I’m curious if they’d be interested in this box. The only reason they wouldn’t is the sheer fact that they are up to their eyeballs in yarn. I happen to live right Nextdoor to ok of the best yarn shops in The Twin Cities so, I’m never quite sure if they are actually coming to visit me. 😂 those stitch markers are absolutely adorable and I really want to find those to buy as stocking stuffers for them! So super cute! I’m a huge fan of anything mini and in any form. Thanks for your review and your knitting is just beautiful.

    • Thank you so much for the comment, Katie! I bet your mom and sister would love this box! I like the Fan Favorites box the best out of the offerings from KnitPicks because they send more than just yarn – I always get really useful tools and fun surprises like the adorable stitch markers! I have more yarn than I know what to do with, though, and I feel like I can always use more!! Most knitters would probably agree with me 🙂

  3. Great review!!!!!!

    FYI — I’m not sure people will get the September box if they sign up now. I REALLY loved your review and the hat from the August box, so I signed up before 9/15 in hopes of getting the box for that. Instead, I received the same September box you reviewed here. Not sure if that is the typical experience or if they were just out of the August box.

    Not sure which pattern I’m gonna knit from that book. I like so many of them!!!!!!

    • Hi, Tam – oh no!! I’m sorry you didn’t get the August box like you had thought. Did you write in to customer service to find out the reasoning? I would guess that the August box was perhaps sold out but I don’t know the answer to that. I hope you still like this box! So many fun patterns this time!

  4. The hat looks great. You are so talented! I’ve been knitting for almost twenty years and color work seems too intimidating still.

    Always love your reviews.

    • Thank you for the kind comment! Colorwork opens up so many possibilities in knitting – I encourage you to try it! Starting with a hat is a great first step! 🙂

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.